Brightsurf Science News and Current Science News Events
 

View Larger Image

Your Inner Fish: A Journey into the 3.5-Billion-Year History of the Human Body


by Neil Shubin

List Price: $24.00
Price: $16.32
You Save: $7.68 (32%)
Available: Usually ships in 24 hours
Sales Rank: 1454
Studio: Pantheon
Binding: Hardcover
Number Of Pages: 240
Publication Date: January 15, 2008
Publisher: Pantheon


EDITORIAL REVIEWS

Product Description
Why do we look the way we do? What does the human hand have in common with the wing of a fly? Are breasts, sweat glands, and scales connected in some way? To better understand the inner workings of our bodies and to trace the origins of many of today's most common diseases, we have to turn to unexpected sources: worms, flies, and even fish.

Neil Shubin, a leading paleontologist and professor of anatomy who discovered Tiktaalik—the "missing link" that made headlines around the world in April 2006—tells the story of evolution by tracing the organs of the human body back millions of years, long before the first creatures walked the earth. By examining fossils and DNA, Shubin shows us that our hands actually resemble fish fins, our head is organized like that of a long-extinct jawless fish, and major parts of our genome look and function like those of worms and bacteria.

Shubin makes us see ourselves and our world in a completely new light. Your Inner Fish is science writing at its finest—enlightening, accessible, and told with irresistible enthusiasm.

Amazon.com
Oliver Sacks on Your Inner Fish
Since the 1970 publication of Migraine, neurologist Oliver Sacks's unusual and fascinating case histories of "differently brained" people and phenomena--a surgeon with Tourette's syndrome, a community of people born totally colorblind, musical hallucinations, to name a few--have been marked by extraordinary compassion and humanity, focusing on the patient as much as the condition. His books include The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, Awakenings (which inspired the Oscar-nominated film), and 2007's Musicophilia. He lives in New York City, where he is Professor of Clinical Neurology at Columbia University.

Your Inner Fish is my favorite sort of book--an intelligent, exhilarating, and compelling scientific adventure story, one which will change forever how you understand what it means to be human.

The field of evolutionary biology is just beginning an exciting new age of discovery, and Neil Shubin's research expeditions around the world have redefined the way we now look at the origins of mammals, frogs, crocodiles, tetrapods, and sarcopterygian fish--and thus the way we look at the descent of humankind. One of Shubin's groundbreaking discoveries, only a year and a half ago, was the unearthing of a fish with elbows and a neck, a long-sought evolutionary "missing link" between creatures of the sea and land-dwellers.

My own mother was a surgeon and a comparative anatomist, and she drummed it into me, and into all of her students, that our own anatomy is unintelligible without a knowledge of its evolutionary origins and precursors. The human body becomes infinitely fascinating with such knowledge, which Shubin provides here with grace and clarity. Your Inner Fish shows us how, like the fish with elbows, we carry the whole history of evolution within our own bodies, and how the human genome links us with the rest of life on earth.

Shubin is not only a distinguished scientist, but a wonderfully lucid and elegant writer; he is an irrepressibly enthusiastic teacher whose humor and intelligence and spellbinding narrative make this book an absolute delight. Your Inner Fish is not only a great read; it marks the debut of a science writer of the first rank.

(Photo © Elena Seibert)

A Note from Author Neil Shubin

This book grew out of an extraordinary circumstance in my life. On account of faculty departures, I ended up directing the human anatomy course at the University of Chicago medical school. Anatomy is the course during which nervous first-year medical students dissect human cadavers while learning the names and organization of most of the organs, holes, nerves, and vessels in the body. This is their grand entrance to the world of medicine, a formative experience on their path to becoming physicians. At first glance, you couldn't have imagined a worse candidate for the job of training the next generation of doctors: I'm a fish paleontologist.

It turns out that being a paleontologist is a huge advantage in teaching human anatomy. Why? The best roadmaps to human bodies lie in the bodies of other animals. The simplest way to teach students the nerves in the human head is to show them the state of affairs in sharks. The easiest roadmap to their limbs lies in fish. Reptiles are a real help with the structure of the brain. The reason is that the bodies of these creatures are simpler versions of ours.

During the summer of my second year leading the course, working in the Arctic, my colleagues and I discovered fossil fish that gave us powerful new insights into the invasion of land by fish over 375 million years ago. That discovery and my foray into teaching human anatomy led me to a profound connection. That connection became this book.

Click on thumbnails for larger images

The crew removing the first Tiktaalik in 2004
Ted Daeschler and Neil Shubin propecting for new sites (Credit: Andrew Gillis)
The valley where Tiktaalik was discovered (credit: Ted Daeschler, Academy of Natural Sciences)

The models of Tiktaalik being constructed for exhibition (Tyler Keillor, University of Chicago)
Me with one of the models (John Weinstein, Field Museum)








CUSTOMER REVIEWS (Average Customer Rating: 4.5 based on 69 reviews)

In the shallows of evolutionary theory  
It does not take a trained eye to see that there are basic similarities between animals -- this is, after all what allows humans to "play" horses and dragons and cats with just a wee bit of makeup and costuming. Most mammals, birds, lizards, fish and even insects have a head, a body and various appendages stick out for locomotion, manipulation and catching prey. But are these similarities just apparent, or do they go deeper?

Biologist Neil Shubin documents the fascinating truth that human beings (and birds, bees, etc.) share fundamental body patterns with each other. And that these patterns are well-nigh ubiquitous. Shubin examines the common animal limb pattern: one upper bone, connected to two lower bones, connected to blobs of wrist bones, connected to a number of elongated digits. To make a bat wing, lengthen the digits and cover them with skin. To make a horse hoof, elongate the middle finger and fused the others into a solid mass. But our similarities go much deeper, and Shubin provides a fascinating tour through the world of embryology. It's here that scientists have discovered, by painstaking trial and error, the chemical messengers that form our bodies from formless blobs of cells. He discusses the Hox gene (found in humans, mice, fruit lies and much animal life) that programs an embryo's head-to-tail features. He shows how distance from ZPA (a patch of organizing tissue) determines the length of fingers, turning some into pinkies and some into thumbs.

The book is interesting, often exhilarating, and hard to put down. What's neat is the glimpse we get into the toilsome work of the scientists who collect, prepare and analyze fossils. It takes years of work, sharp eyes, luck and a knack for puzzle solving to piece together, say, the story of how mammals developed precise chewing - an ability that reptiles do not have. A tiny tooth found on a beach in Nova Scotia can fill in the gaps of how and when the transition from reptile-style toothedness and mammal-style dentition came about.

I had only two criticisms. Unlike Stephen Jay Gould, who tends to write far above the heads of intelligent readers, Shubin tends to write down a bit. Unlike Gould, Shubin avoids scientific jargon, to a degree that is curious. Secondly, he leaves some rather large gaps in his tale. While it is interesting that animals tend to have the same skeletal limb structure, why did they adopt this structure? Is the one bone/two bone/blobs/digits model the only one that works out of water? And why/how did the creatures begin to move in the direction of limbedness? In the ongoing debate between evolution and creationism, such insights would have helped answer the nagging questions that even proponents of evolution have about the mechanisms behind it.

Still, "Your Inner Fish" is an accessible and informative read about the personal process of collecting bones and the intriguing conclusions that science has made about our relationship with all (and I mean all!) animal life. The next time you listen to the radio, thank the ancient fish whose jawbones evolved into the bones of your ears. And give a thought to box jellies, with whom we share the basic mechanisms of sight.
September 02, 2008

Your Inner Fish Review  
Written in an informal, but informative style, "Your Inner Fish" communicates the relationships between living organisms and the coping strategies involved in the adaptation to a changing environment. This book was a joy to read.
August 29, 2008

Good, but not splendid  
Neil Shubin, codiscoverer of the Tiktaalit, shows in this book that to become a human you must first become a fish. Its a wonderful argument against the notion of `intelligent design'. Or would you call a car manufacturer intelligent who makes a Mercedes by first building a wooden coach? Nevertheless there is an unwholesome streak of creationism and anti-darwinism in Shubins otherwise lucid descriptions, a streak which seems to belong to US-American culture like Samba belongs to Brazil. For example, he criticizes Haeckels `ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny' understanding of the way evolution shows up in embryos when Haeckel "would compare a human embryo to an adult fish". But any changes in the features of an embryo - like going from fish to human - require the action of natural selection to have acted once. Now, natural selection operates on the reproduction success of an animal, and that means adults. Therefore, for any developmental stage of an embryo, there must have existed an adult creature that had evolved just to this stage; and when you trace the embryonic development, a fossil must exist at every level that had achieved just this stage. To understand the embyro, you need to understand Natural selection, which means you must understand the reproduction success of the adult. It does not suffice to compare the embryos of different species - their "blueprints" ; Shubin just loves to talk all the time about "blueprints", which is a typical design term. Tracing embryos runs parallel to tracing the fossils of adults.
For another example, look at the way he describes the recent research situation when it was found that "in many single-celled animals, much of the molecular machinery for cell adhesion, interaction, and so on is just not there", which "would seem to support the notion that the genes that help cells unite to make bodies arose together with the origin of bodies. And at first glance, it seems to make sense that the tools to build bodies should arise in lockstep with the bodies themselves." This idea makes sense, yes - if you are a creationist. If you think like Haeckel, this is nonsense because for selection to produce bodies there must have been a single cell animal with all the needed machinery existing. And as Shubin beautifully narrates, just such an animal turned up : the choanoflagellates.
Science has been kind to Haeckel, contrary to what Shubin asserts in the book.
Despite my reservations, I highly recommend his book because of Shubins genuine enthusiasm for his subject, and the wealth of new results that he presents. If it had more of Dawkins and much less Gould in it, it would have been splendid. The pictures are as miserable as I have come to expect nowadays in good books about science.

August 28, 2008

The Story of Fossils and Geneology  
Through extensive fossil records and geneology, Mr. Shubin takes the reader through the development of single celled organisms (bacteria), multi-cell (jellyfish), bodies (worms), skull (fish), hands and feet (reptiles), three-boned middle ear (mammals), and finally, bipedal with large brain (humans).

We have in us anatomical design improvements that can take us only so far from our water borne ancestors. Mr. Shubin asserts if humans were designed from scratch, "we would not have to suffer everything from hemorrhoids to cancer."

If, like me, you have always wondered why the male scrotum tucks close to the body in chilly weather, "Your Inner Fish" is an excellent source.

Curiously, Mr. Shubin made no mention of how a Cro-Magnon was able to win the U.S. presidency twice; in 2000 and 2004.
August 24, 2008

chordate anatomy made bearable, even interesting  
I am enjoying reading this, 30 years after taking a course covering much of the portion of the book I have so far completed. The authors enthusiasm for the subject and articulate writing style would make this a good read for anyone with out a lot of biology background who wants to have a better understanding of form and function and how it came to be.
August 18, 2008


SIMILAR PRODUCTS

Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why It Matters
by Donald R. Prothero
by Carl Buell

Relics of Eden: The Powerful Evidence of Evolution in Human DNA
by Daniel J. Fairbanks

The Making of the Fittest: DNA and the Ultimate Forensic Record of Evolution
by Sean B. Carroll

The Oxford Book of Modern Science Writing
by Richard Dawkins

Only a Theory: Evolution and the Battle for America's Soul
by Kenneth R. Miller

© 2008 BrightSurf.com