Brightsurf Science News and Current Science News Events
 

View Larger Image

Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems


by Stephen T. Thornton, Jerry B. Marion

List Price: $202.95
Price: $162.36
You Save: $40.59 (20%)
Available: Usually ships in 1 to 3 weeks
Sales Rank: 14178
Studio: Brooks Cole
Binding: Hardcover
Number Of Pages: 672
Publication Date: July 07, 2003
Publisher: Brooks Cole


EDITORIAL REVIEWS

Product Description
This best-selling classical mechanics text, written for the advanced undergraduate one- or two-semester course, provides a complete account of the classical mechanics of particles, systems of particles, and rigid bodies. Vector calculus is used extensively to explore topics.The Lagrangian formulation of mechanics is introduced early to show its powerful problem solving ability.. Modern notation and terminology are used throughout in support of the text's objective: to facilitate students' transition to advanced physics and the mathematical formalism needed for the quantum theory of physics. CLASSICAL DYNAMICS OF PARTICLES AND SYSTEMS can easily be used for a one- or two-semester course, depending on the instructor's choice of topics.


CUSTOMER REVIEWS (Average Customer Rating: 2.5 based on 49 reviews)

Like so many other science books, not worth the money  
I used this book as a physics undergrad in the mid '90s. Like so many others on this site, my copy of M&T split in half before the semester was even half over. I'd sure love my $80 back plus interest...

I thought some of the later chapters were quite good -- particularly the one on Lagrangian dynamics -- but the first few chapters didn't strike me as particularly well written. More than a decade later, I can still recall a problem in Chapter 2 that wasn't even remotely covered anywhere in the chapter itself. It somehow managed to survive to the 4th edition, and I'd be willing to bet it's in the 5th as well.

There were lots of things I liked about Marion and Thornton, but generally speaking, if students are expected to plunk down this kind of money for texts on fairly venerable topics, the content should be QA-tested, and the book itself should be reasonably well-constructed.
June 20, 2008

Great Reference text  
Pros: Great reference text. The examples are clear and there are generally a lot of them. The notation is generally very readable.


Cons: The price. As with almost any physics text, this one is most easily understood if you can compare it to another book of the same level (might I recommend Taylor?) However, the price of this book makes that impractical at best.

This book is a good text. It is one of the first books that physics students encounter after their introductory courses which makes for a very challenging semester. I think that may be why it has recieved so many poor reviews. . .
May 21, 2008

Best option for sophmore-level mechanis  
I use this text in my spring sophomore-level mechanics class. There are no perfect texts for this level, but this is the best one out there. The book does assume that you either have a solid base of mathematics or are willing to learn during the course. That's typical in a physics class; you learn mathematics while learning physics, and so its a good introduction to the style of more advanced physics classes. While the chapter on nonlinearity doesn't fit well with the other chapters, and I wish Lagrangian's were moved later in the text, its still a better choice then most other texts for most students. Less mathematically prepared students could use Taylor's text, for example, and more mathematically prepared students should use Goldstein and landau, but this book aims at the middle of lower division physics majors.
January 11, 2008

Fantastic Textbook  
I really like this book a lot. I never went to class for both quarters of my upper-division undergraduate mechanics class, and instead read Thornton and Marion religiously. I've heard friends express their dislike for it, but I think it is very clear and provides excellent perspective and insight. It is very mathematically rigorous, which I appreciate but others may not. The proofs given are typically very readable, although I often skipped over the sort of "obvious" things that the book shows in exquisite detail. Lots of great sections and topics, much interesting material covered, in addition to the basics. Highly recommended.
October 28, 2007

it gets the job done  
it starts off well enough, but the chaos chapter is terrible. I did use multiple sources while i was taking an analytic mechanics course. The best part of the book is the well assorted bunch of problems.
October 10, 2007


SIMILAR PRODUCTS

Introduction to Electrodynamics (3rd Edition)
by David J. Griffiths

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics (2nd Edition)
by David J. Griffiths

Mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences
by Mary L. Boas

Classic Dynamics of Particles and Systems: Student Solutions Manual
by Stephen T. Thornton

Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems/Students Solution Manual
by Jerry B. Marion

© 2008 BrightSurf.com