Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 

View Larger Image

Dominance by Design: Technological Imperatives and America's Civilizing Mission


by Michael Adas

List Price: $29.95
Price: $23.96
You Save: $5.99 (20%)
Available: Usually ships in 24 hours
Sales Rank: 833863
Studio: Belknap Press
Binding: Hardcover
Number Of Pages: 480
Publication Date: January 20, 2006
Publisher: Belknap Press


EDITORIAL REVIEWS

Product Description

Long before the United States became a major force in global affairs, Americans believed in their superiority over others due to their inventiveness, productivity, and economic and social well-being. U.S. expansionists assumed a mandate to “civilize” non-Western peoples by demanding submission to American technological prowess and design. As an integral part of America’s national identity and sense of itself in the world, this civilizing mission provided the rationale to displace the Indians from much of our continent, to build an island empire in the Pacific and Caribbean, and to promote unilateral—at times military—interventionism throughout Asia. In our age of “smart bombs” and mobile warfare, technological aptitude remains preeminent in validating America’s global mission.

Michael Adas brilliantly pursues the history of this mission through America's foreign relations over nearly four centuries from North America to the Philippines, Vietnam, and the Persian Gulf. The belief that it is our right and destiny to remake foreign societies in our image has endured from the early decades of colonization to our current crusade to implant American-style democracy in the Muslim Middle East.

Dominance by Design explores the critical ways in which technological superiority has undergirded the U.S.’s policies of unilateralism, preemption, and interventionism in foreign affairs and raised us from an impoverished frontier nation to a global power. Challenging the long-held assumptions and imperatives that sustain the civilizing mission, Adas gives us an essential guide to America’s past and present role in the world as well as cautionary lessons for the future.

(20070301)


CUSTOMER REVIEWS (Average Customer Rating: 2.5 based on 2 reviews)

Does not accomplish what it sets out to do  
This book attempts to look at the course of American history from the colonial days through the gulf war. There are times when this book comes close to achieving its goal but most of the time it is a very general overview that is lacking in points. The technology described does not seem to relate to what the author wants to talk about and the argument comes out fairly week. This is a book that should be able to hold the readers interest with how fascinating an idea of how technology made America a superpower. While this premise is true it is not shown through this book. Furthermore there are severe typos that actually make it hard to understand at times.

The second half of the book is where the argument really begins to fall apart. The analysis of Vietnam comes close to understanding how unprepared the United States was for guerilla warfare but Adas demonstrates ignorance of the larger issues of the cold war. The entire buildup under Reagan is absent from the book. The place where the book should really have stopped was at the analysis of the Gulf War. There is no understanding of the global oil market and it actually went as far to state that Saddam improved condition of Iraq for the people there. While ignoring death camps for Kurds and mass graves were occurring we see Saddam in a supposed good light. The terrorist attacks on the United States are even worse in their portrayal. The understanding of response to Bin Laden and his lack of research on the 1990's terrorist attacks is abysmal. Please see the 9/11 commission report for an actual understanding of how terrorism was evolving in the 1990's. This book is barely worth one star. Just disappointing.

April 15, 2007

Just not iconoclastic enough for my tastes.  
I found myself reading this book surprisingly quickly. It isn't ponderous or soaked with tendentious prose. The subject matter of the book, how America harnessed technology and technology mindfulness to shape and force through domestic and foreign policy initiatives, is tackled with encyclopaediac zeal. All in all the blend of history, politcs and science/technology makes for a potentially absorbing read, so why did I find it a bit deadening? It has all the right components and should have grabbed me by the ankles and swung me around but it didn't.

Despite the technical qualities of the content, it contains two flaws. In the first instance it is repetitive. The first hint that this could be a problem is found in the first chapter discussing Admiral Perry's 'opening' mission to Japan. The reader is drilled into learning that Perry believed US technology would overawe the Japanese, etc. The vignettes are meant to illustrate the tehnological fascinations of US society and policy makers. The proposition is repeated on nearly every page of the chapter, and this tendency to drill home points persists throughout the book. Strangely, it did seem at times as if I had revisited a boyhood encyclopaedia.

The book also steers clear of trenchant political analysis of the motivating investment forces of the various actors and their political agendas. This is a great pity as the material is more than ready for political mastication, irrespective of conservative or liberal preferences. If I was asked to sum up my main disappointment, it is the absence of iconoclasm. The chapters are crying out for a good old fashioned dollop of humbug from time to time.

I 'got through' this book more under the traditional obligation to finish a book once one has started it than out of any deep sense of enjoyment. The scholarship is impressive. it may well suit professional historians in that genre more than a wider milieu. A book to contrast this one with is 'Irresistible Empire' which is a bit more worldly in my opinion and makes may of the same points, especially regarding Europe, with greater finesse.
December 23, 2006


SIMILAR PRODUCTS

Machines As the Measure of Men: Science, Technology, and Ideologies of Western Dominance (Cornell Studies in Comparative History)
by Michael Adas

Does Technology Drive History? The Dilemma of Technological Determinism
by Merritt Roe Smith, Leo Marx

America Calling: A Social History of the Telephone to 1940
by Claude S. Fischer

The Tools of Empire: Technology and European Imperialism in the Nineteenth Century
by Daniel R. Headrick

Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (The Institution for Social and Policy St)
by James C. Scott

© 2008 BrightSurf.com