| View Larger Image | Medicare Meets Mephistopheles | Paperbackby David Hyman (Author)
| List Price: | $9.95 | | | Available: | Usually ships in 24 hours |
| | Binding: | Paperback | | Publisher: | Cato Institute | | Page Count: | 100 Pages | | Publication Date: | September 25, 2006 | | Sales Rank: | 855,658th |
|
EDITORIAL REVIEWS |
Product Description
Let's say you're the devil, and you want to corrupt the American republic. How would you go about it? According to David Hyman, you might create something like Medicare, the federal health care program for the elderly. Hyman submits that Medicare may be the greatest trick the devil ever played. Medicare feeds on the avarice of doctors and other providers, turns seniors into health care gluttons, and makes regions of the United States green with envy over the dollars showered on other regions. The program exploits the sloth of government officials to increase the tax burden on workers and drag down the quality of care for seniors. Medicare makes Democrats lust for socialized medicine, while its imperviousness to reform makes Republicans angrier and angrier. Most of all, Medicare allows its ideological supporters to bleat and preen their way to the heights of moral vanity. In the style of C.S. Lewis' The Screwtape Letters, Hyman writes that Medicare has freed the self-interest of these mortals from its natural restraints. As a result, the seven deadly sins have blossomed. With epic political battles over Medicare and the future of limited government looming just over the horizon, Hyman uses satire to cast a critical eye on this mediocre government program. |
CUSTOMER REVIEWS (Average Customer Rating: 4.5 based on 5 reviews)
|
Two for the writing, zero for choosing to ignore the obvious by roustabout (oakland, ca)  2 Stars
May 30, 2009
I see the Cato true believers think this is a wonderful book. And it is well-written, so long as one is prepared to ignore the elephant in the room: How much would it cost to provide healthcare to this, or any, population under a Cato-endorsed program?
Until the day when I see the Cato institute suggest that corporations should not have individual rights as do people under the Constitution, and in particular that their accounting should be open to public scrutiny by anyone for any reason rather than shielded by the fourth and fifth amendments, I will know that Cato is still uninterested in free markets. Free markets cannot exist without transparent access to information.
In the specific case, we could compare the cost of providing care to those 65 and over via Medicare, a single-payer program with good enough reimbursement rates that health plans actively recruit new Medicare enrollees, with the costs of providing health care to the 55-65 year old population who are working within the marketplace for insurance. In order to make the comparison, we would need to have accurate information from three large groups of players whose real accounts are currently invisible to us: the insurers, the hospitals and the pharmaceutical industry.
To the extent that aggregate date exist, they indicate that 55-65 year olds pay far more per capita for healthcare than Medicare will pay per capita on their behalf once they are eligible; that even with that disproportionate cost, a large fraction have no access to insurance and another large fraction have very high co-payment rates for physician visits, inpatient care and medicines.
There are two large economic reasons for this; one, the private insurers are not in a position to negotiate rates as effectively as Medicare is due to simple economies of scale and two, the private insurers have no real incentive to negotiate rates. No one sees their true costs and in the current system everyone is rewarded for padding the costs - hospitals, drug companies and insurers.
What Cato is not answering in its book is the obvious question: How much will health care cost in the absence of Medicare? If the invisible hand of the free market would truly drive costs down, why are the insurance and pharms industries squealing so loudly about letting a government-backed plan compete against them?
20 years ago, Harry and Louise told us the market was a better solution to the problem of healthcare. In that 20 years, neither industry nor the Republican-dominated Congress have changed or innovated anything substantial in the way of improving access to care.
Guys, you've had two decades to do something believable here. Step aside, give a different approach a chance.
| |
Concise, witty, readable Satanic endorsement of Medicare by Richard Gibson (Woodland Hills, CA)  5 Stars
May 24, 2009
This relatively short book is in the form of a long memo from an underling demon to Satan, complementing him on the great success of his plan to use Medicare to destroy the American Republic. After giving a brief history of Medicare, he examines the program from the perspective of how it works with the seven deadly sins and how it undermines American virtue.
The presentation is in the superficial form of satire. It is not satire. It is dead serious. And it is very effective. Not only does it present a great deal of material quickly an effectively, but, by putting it into a moral context, it really cuts to the heart of why huge government programs such as Medicare are so bad for the country.
An accomplished performance by an unaplogetic conservative. Easy to read and well worth reading.
| |
Very entertaining! by Dr. John A. Hamel V (Kensington, MD USA) 5 Stars
April 28, 2008
This book is really a satire against Medicare. It is written from the perspective of one of the Devil's executives. This executive writes a memo (essentially the whole book) to his boss (The Devil) about how well Medicare is working out in their malevolent plan. I considered it very entertaining reading.
| |
The devil made me do it. by Lloyd Hyman (La Grange, IL) 5 Stars
January 03, 2007
Professor David Hyman has used the seven deadly sins to serve up an easy to read description of the Medicare mess. His satirical approach is both amusing and on target. I think this small volume is required reading for both the layman and the expert. The book supplies a historical perspective, and provides a useful focus on the Medicare problem areas. I think this focus and fact driven perspective is essential, if the nation is to make any progress confounding Mephistopheles.
| |
In using satire as a vehicle for analysis, Hyman provides a biting analysis easy to digest. by Midwest Book Review (Oregon, WI USA) 5 Stars
December 11, 2006
No ordinary survey, MEDICARE MEETS MEPHISTOPHELES takes the form of allegory, and is written as a memorandum from an underling demon to the devil himself. Devilish details demonstrate Medicare's pitfalls and the foundations that only undermine honesty and encourage greed and profiteering. In using satire as a vehicle for analysis, Hyman provides a biting analysis easy to digest.
Diane C. Donovan
California Bookwatch
| |
SIMILAR PRODUCTS |
| Crisis of Abundance: Rethinking How We Pay for Health Care
by Arnold Kling (Author)
America's health care troubles stem largely from a great success: Modern medicine can do much more today than in the past. The problem is how to pay for it. In easy to understand prose, MIT-trained economist Arnold Kling explains better ways of financing health care by relying less on government and more on private savings and insurance. A must-read for health care reformers.
| 
| Healthy Competition, Second Edition: What's Holding Back Health Care and How to Free It,
by Michael F. Cannon (Author)
Government control has driven health care costs sky-high at the same time that it has reduced the quality of care. As America's health care system cries out for reform, should policymakers embrace even more government planning, or should they fight for more individual freedom? In this updated edition of their 2005 book, the authors tackle proposals that would let government manage even more of America's health care sector. The continuing problem of ever-rising health care costs makes this book...
| 
| False Alarm: Why the Greatest Threat to Social Security and Medicare Is the Campaign to "Save" Them (Century Foundation Book)
by Joseph White (Author)
For anyone seriously interested in the debate about Social Security. With the aging of the U.S. population, there is much speculation about the future of the Social Security and Medicare programs. Will they be able to provide for the increasing number of elderly people? And, if they can, will their cost endanger the federal budget and the economy? Vocal segments of society are calling for radical reform of these programs. In False Alarm: Why the Greatest Threat to Social Security and...
| 
| Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer
by Shannon Brownlee (Author)
“My choice for the economics book of the year…it’s the best description I have yet read of a huge economic problem that we know how to solve—but is so often misunderstood.”—David Leonhardt, New York Times Our health care is staggeringly expensive, yet one in six Americans has no health insurance. We have some of the most skilled physicians in the world, yet one hundred thousand patients die each year from medical errors. In this gripping, eye-opening book, award-winning...
| 
| The Cure: How Capitalism Can Save American Health Care
by David Gratzer (Author)
Drawing on personal experience in both the Canadian and U.S. systems, Dr. Gratzer shows how paternalistic government involvement in the health care system has multiplied inefficiencies, discouraged innovation, and punished patients. The Cure offers a detailed and practical approach to putting individuals back in charge. With an introduction by Milton Friedman, The Cure will be required reading for anyone who wants to know what is really wrong with the modern health care system.
|
|
|
