Egg-sharing does not damage a donor's own chance of a baby say UK researchersOctober 27, 2003Women who take part in egg sharing programmes run by fertility clinics are not compromising their chance of having a baby by donating some of their eggs, according to UK research published today (Thursday 30 October) in Europe's leading reproductive medicine journal Human Reproduction[1]. The Lister Fertility Clinic in London, a private clinic that has been running a formal egg sharing scheme since January 1998[2], has evaluated 276 egg sharing cycles involving 192 women who agreed to share their eggs, 274 recipient cycles involving 246 women who received eggs and 1,098 non-sharing standard IVF or ICSI cycles involving 718 women. The participants were divided into three groups - egg sharers, non-egg sharers aged under 36 and recipients. The researchers evaluated the doses and duration of drugs needed for ovarian stimulation, the numbers of eggs collected and donated, and the fertilisation, pregnancy and live birth rates. Clinic director and research team leader, Mr Hossam I Abdalla, said: "We found no statistically significant difference in the three groups. The egg sharers achieved a pregnancy rate of 42% and a live birth rate of 33%, the non-egg sharers achieved a pregnancy rate of 40% and a live birth rate of 30.9%, and the recipients achieved a pregnancy rate of 41.4% and a live birth rate of 28.6%." The number of eggs collected, the number of mature follicles and the amount of stimulating hormone (gonadotrophin) used was not significantly different between the egg sharing women and the non-egg sharing women. In addition, the average number of embryos transferred and the mean numbers of eggs allocated between egg sharers and recipients was not statistically different. "Up to now, there has been no research in the UK carried out with large numbers of patients to ensure that the egg sharing programme is not detrimental to egg sharers and/or to the outcome of recipients' treatment compared with standard IVF or ICSI," said Mr Abdalla. An important additional finding was that there was no evidence to back up a theoretical risk that the donors may have an increased chance of the potentially dangerous condition of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome - a condition where the ovaries go into overdrive and produce too many follicles and eggs as a result of the hormones given to prepare them for fertility treatment. "The premise was that to have enough eggs for egg sharing, doctors may over stimulate the donors' ovaries," said Mr Abdalla. "But, we provided the donors with the standard drug regimen given to all IVF patients of a similar age and there was no increased incidence of ovarian hyperstimulation, of drug dosage or of the numbers of eggs produced compared with standard IVF patients." He said that two previous studies had demonstrated lower pregnancy rates, but they had a smaller number of patients and there may have been a slight bias towards recipients in egg allocation. The present study had insisted that donors had at least the first four eggs so that there was a decent number of eggs for the donor's own treatment. "Our view is that for successful egg sharing the sharer should always be given priority and have the first call on her eggs without any undue pressure. I believe that is the primary reason for the success of our programme." Mr Abdalla said that egg sharing was a constructive way of solving the problem of shortage of eggs. So, it was a reassuring finding that patients who took part in a programme and provided a valuable source of donor eggs were not compromising their own chances or putting themselves at risk of additional complications. However, he said that for egg sharing to be successful it was essential that the programme gave the women taking part all the advice and support that is provided for fertility patients and that donors always had priority in terms of their treatment and the first call on their eggs. A study examining the psychological and emotional impact of the programme was also under way. "We need to know how a patient would feel if they did not fall pregnant and the recipient does, or vice-versa. There is potential here for joy, happiness, sadness and other emotions. So, it is particularly important to follow these patients up and we are currently providing an extensive questionnaire to all of our egg sharers." The results of this study should be available next year. [1] Does egg-sharing compromise the chance of donors or recipients achieving a live birth? Human Reproduction. Vol 18. No. 11. pp 2363-2367. [2] The Lister Fertility Clinic has been providing egg donation since 1988 with sporadic cases of egg sharing. A pilot group on egg sharing started in July 1997 and the programme was properly established from January 1998. About 5% of the clinics total cycles of assisted conception involve egg sharing. Egg sharers get reduced cost cycles. The only charge is £500 towards medications. The recipients do not pay for the donor's treatment, but pay overall charges similar to the cost of an IVF cycle. So effectively, two patients are treated for the cost of one treatment cycle. There is no obligation between the sharer and the recipient. The sharer can withdraw at any time and has primary claim on her eggs without extra cost. The egg sharer who is unsuccessful in conceiving, can try up 3 times, sometimes more. According to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) 45 out of the UK's 95 fertility treatment centres have egg sharing programmes. MW Communications |
|||||||||||||||||||||
| Related Fertility Current Events and Fertility News Articles ORNL, Los Alamos pioneer new approach to assist scientists, farmers Sustainable farming, initially adopted to preserve soil quality for future generations, may also play a role in maintaining a healthy climate, according to researchers at the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge and Los Alamos national laboratories. Fertility procedures need not delay breast cancer treatment for younger women A new study published in the November issue of the Journal of the American College of Surgeons shows that breast cancer patients under 40 years old who undergo fertility preservation do not face a significant delay in the treatment of their disease when their care is coordinated in a timely fashion. For young boys with cancer, testicular tissue banking may be option to preserve fertility For parents of children with cancer, the hopeful news is that pediatric survival rates have steadily improved for decades. Among the bad news-treatments that enable survival often cause infertility. European Urology: Male factor infertility associated with comorbidities The December issue of European Urology, the official journal of the European Association of Urology, features an article entitled 'Are Infertile Men Less Healthy than Fertile Men? Nitrogen loss threatens desert plant life, study shows As the climate gets warmer, arid soils lose nitrogen as gas, reports a new Cornell study. That could lead to deserts with even less plant life than they sustain today, say the researchers. Hybrid bluegrasses analyzed for use in transition zone The transition zone can be one of the most challenging places to maintain high-quality turfgrass; changeable growing conditions in these regions often prove too hot for some grasses and too cold for others. Finding turfgrass that thrives in these challenging environments can be perplexing for turf management professionals and homeowners alike. Teen girls diagnosed with STI more likely to seek treatment for partners after watching video A study at Johns Hopkins Children's Center found that girls diagnosed with pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) who watched a short educational video were three times more likely to discuss their condition with their partners and to ensure partner treatment than girls diagnosed and treated without seeing the film. Wolves, moose and biodiversity: An unexpected connection Moose eat plants; wolves kill moose. What difference does this classic predator-prey interaction make to biodiversity? Fetal study highlights impact of stress on male fertility Exposure to a combination of excess stress hormones and chemicals while in the womb could affect a man's fertility in later life, a study suggests. IVF insurance coverage yields fewer multiple births, Yale researchers find The proportion of in vitro fertilization (IVF) multiple births was lower in the eight states that provide insurance coverage for couples seeking IVF treatment, primarily due to fewer embryos transferred per cycle. More Fertility Current Events and Fertility News Articles |
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||