RSS Feeds

Earth Science

Space Science

Life Science

Fields of Scientific Study

Nanotechnology

Cancer

Definitions of The Fields of Scientific Study

Research Supports Abstinence as Healthy Goal for Teenagers but Critiques

January 06, 2006

While few Americans remain abstinent until marriage and most initiate sexual intercourse as adolescents, abstinence from sexual intercourse is an important behavioral strategy for preventing human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), other sexually transmitted infections (STIs), and unintended pregnancy among adolescents, according to the report, Abstinence and Abstinence-Only Education: A Review of U.S. Policies and Programs. The paper also notes that while there is broad support for abstinence as a necessary and appropriate part of sex education, controversy arises when abstinence is the sole choice for teenagers. John Santelli, MD, MPH, professor and chair, Heilbrunn Department of Clinical Population and Family Health, Mailman School of Public Health, and p rofessor of Clinical Pediatrics, Columbia University is the lead author of the report, published in the January issue of the Journal of Adolescent Health.

The paper supports abstinence from sexual intercourse as "a healthy choice for teenagers" but critiques government policies and programs that promote abstinence-only or abstinence until marriage as the only prevention message for teenagers. According to the report, abstinence as the sole option for adolescents is scientifically and ethically problematic and should be abandoned as a basis for health policy and programs.

"Abstinence is a very healthy choice for teenagers-but sex education for teenagers needs to give teenagers all the facts - all the medically accurate information they need to protect themselves, " said Dr. Santelli. "While abstinence from sexual intercourse is theoretically fully protective from pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections, in actual practice, abstinence often is not maintained which leaves teenagers vulnerable to pregnancy and STIs." Recent data indicate the median age at first intercourse for women is 17.4 years, while the median age at first marriage is 25.3 years.

The report recommends that efforts to promote abstinence should be based on sound science. Drawing a distinction between abstinence as a behavior and abstinence-only programs, the paper concludes there is no evidence base for providing "abstinence only" or "abstinence until marriage" messages as a sole option for teenagers. In reviewing scientific literature, the report finds abstinence-only programs demonstrate little evidence of efficacy in delaying initiation of sexual intercourse. Conversely, efforts to promote abstinence as part of comprehensive reproductive health promotion programs, which provide information about contraceptive options and protection from STIs, have successfully delayed initiation of sexual intercourse.

The review of U.S. policies and programs also finds ethical problems with abstinence-only programs, because they provide misinformation to teenagers and withhold information needed to make informed choices. "Typically, abstinence-only education programs provide incomplete and/or misleading information about contraceptives, or no contraceptive information at all. In many communities, abstinence-only education has replaced comprehensive sexuality education," observes Dr. Santelli. According to the paper, federally funded abstinence until marriage programs neglect and stigmatize gay and lesbian youth. These programs also neglect real health needs for contraception and STI testing among sexually experienced youth, putting these youth at increased risk for unintended pregnancy and STIs, including HIV.

A copy of the complete findings can be found at http://journals.elsevierhealth.com/periodicals/jah

Dr. Santelli also was the lead author on a position paper on Abstinence-Only Education Policies and Programs: A Position Paper of the Society for Adolescent Medicine which also was published in the January 2006 Journal of Adolescent Health. The paper includes specific recommendations from The Society for Adolescent Medicine, a multidisciplinary organization committed to improving the physical and psychosocial health and well-being of all adolescents through advocacy, clinical care, health promotion, health service delivery, professional development, and research. The complete findings can be viewed at http://www.adolescenthealth.org/PositionPapers.htm

Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health

Related Abstinence Current Events and Abstinence News Articles

Abstinence Current Events and Abstinence News RSS

Teen girls diagnosed with STI more likely to seek treatment for partners after watching video
A study at Johns Hopkins Children's Center found that girls diagnosed with pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) who watched a short educational video were three times more likely to discuss their condition with their partners and to ensure partner treatment than girls diagnosed and treated without seeing the film.

Crushing cigarettes in a virtual reality environment reduces tobacco addiction
Smokers who crushed computer-simulated cigarettes as part of a psychosocial treatment program in a virtual reality environment had significantly reduced nicotine dependence and higher rates of tobacco abstinence than smokers participating in the same program who grasped a computer-simulated ball.

Proactive, personalized telephone counseling can help teen smokers to quit
Personalized, proactive telephone counseling centered on motivational interviewing and cognitive behavioral skills training has been found to favorably impact quit rates among teen smokers, according to a pair of studies published online October 12 in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

Teen smoking-cessation trial first to achieve significant quit rates
For the first time, researchers at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center have demonstrated that it is possible to successfully recruit and retain a large number of adolescent smokers from the general population into a smoking intervention study and, through personalized, proactive telephone counseling, significantly impact rates of six-month continuous quitting.

Alcoholism's effect on sleep persists during long periods of sobriety
A study in the Oct.1 issue of the journal Sleep shows that long-term alcoholism affects sleep even after long periods of abstinence, and the pattern of this effect is similar in both men and women.

Researchers explore long-term adolescent vulnerability to drugs
As part of efforts to understand drug abuse, Georgia State University researchers are finding that adolescent rats appear to be less vulnerable to the long-term effects of withdrawal and relapse in certain types of drug use than rats that take the drugs in adulthood.

Doctors Fear Asking Mentally Ill to Quit Smoking
People with mental illnesses such as depression and anxiety are the heaviest smokers in the country, but their doctors are afraid to ask them to quit. They assume that if their patients try to quit smoking, their mental disorders will get worse.

Study finds US prison system falls short in treating drug addiction
Almost a quarter of a million individuals addicted to heroin are incarcerated in the United States each year. However, many prison systems across the country still do not offer medical treatment for heroin and opiate addiction, despite the demonstrated social, medical and economic benefits of opiate replacement therapy (ORT).

Low-income kids report first sexual intercourse at 12 years old in new ISU study
As a new mother herself, Brenda Lohman admits to being shocked by the results of a new study she co-authored. It found that among nearly 1,000 low-income families in three major cities, one in four children between the ages of 11 and 16 reported having sex, with their first sexual intercourse experience occurring at the average age of 12.77.

Pre-cessation patch doubles quit success rate: Researchers call for labeling changes
Using a nicotine patch before quitting smoking can double success rates, according to Duke University Medical Center researchers. They say their latest data suggest changes should be made to nicotine patch labeling.

More Abstinence Current Events and Abstinence News Articles

	Abstinence: Members of Overeaters Anonymous Share Their Experience, Strength, and Hope by Overeaters Anonymous (Author)
	Sex Smart: 501 Reasons to Hold Off on Sex: A Sexuality Resource for Teenagers by Susan Pogany (Author) Written by a medical science journalist and parent, this book provides straightforward answers to hundreds of questions teens have about sex and relationships.
	Abstinence makes the heart grow fonder Long Sleeve T-shirt Large White by Shop Zeus
	The Abstinence Teacher by Tom Perrotta (Author) Stonewood Heights is the perfect place to raise kids. It’s got the proverbial good schools, solid values and a healthy real estate market. It’s the kind of place where parents are involved in their children’s lives, where no opportunity for enrichment goes unexplored. Ruth Ramsey is the human sexuality teacher at the local high school. She believes that “pleasure is good, shame is bad, and knowledge is power.” Ruth’s younger daughter’s soccer coach is Tim Mason, a former stoner and rocker whose response to hitting rock bottom was to reach out and be saved. Tim belongs to The Tabernacle, an evangelical Christian church that doesn’t approve of Ruth’s style of teaching. And Ruth in turn doesn’t applaud The Tabernacle’s mission to take its message...
	Teen Abstinence Sometimes teenagers think having sex is the answer but it's really the problem. And, more and more teenagers are just saying no. There are plenty of reasons, emotional spiritual and biological. On this edition of American Family we'll find out why more teenagers are choosing abstinence.
	The Power of Abstinence by Kristine Napier (Author) Citing a rise in sexual abstinence among American teens, a guide for parents offers practical advice on how to encourage young people to postpone sexual activity and nurture a healthy self image.
	Abstinence Starring: Dr. Jocelyn Elders Directed By: Star Price, Scott Firestone, Chip Selby Also With: Star Price (Writer), Joshua E. Kessler (Producer), Patti Duce (Producer), Aaron Yampolski (Producer), Lee Mortimer (Producer), Diana Marcketta (Producer), Alex Walton (Producer), Penn Jillette (Writer), Teller (Writer), Steve Melcher (Writer), Jon Hotchkiss (Writer), Michael Goudeau (Writer)
	Feu d'abstinence Suarez (Primary Contributor)
	Why Abstinence? [VHS] To have sex, or not to have sex? This is the question that troubles Twenty-first Century teens. While media messages seem to constantly proclaim that everyone everywhere is sexually active, this is simply not the case. It’s true that a lot of teens have given in to the pressure to have sex, but many have later regretted doing so. Wiser young people are deciding to put off sexual relationships until they are more mature, at which time they’ll be better able to deal with the emotional commitment that should accompany intimacy. Learn about the benefits of abstinence and make decisions about sex that are based upon careful considerations. When you spend time thinking about sexual intimacy before you’re confronted with the temptation to dive into such a relationship, you’ll be a...
	Win This War by Chuck Dennie; downhere; Mike Weaver; Michael O'Brien; Matthew West; Lee Spoken; By The Tree & Aaron Blanton