Email a Friend
Printer Friendly
Slashdot It!
Submit to Reddit
Add to Facebook

National study finds no effect from reducing total dietary fat

February 08, 2006

Despite findings being announced this week that a low-fat diet introduced in the middle-age years didn't reduce the risk of breast cancer, heart disease, stroke or colon cancer, one of the researchers says people still need to focus on the types of fat they eat. The national diet study of almost 50,000 healthy postmenopausal women was part of the massive Women's Health Initiative (WHI) study.

The hypothesis that low-fat diets could help reduce the risk of certain diseases had been assumed, but never tested. But, do the findings mean that what we eat doesn't matter?

"Nutrition knowledge has progressed dramatically since the study began," said Mara Vitolins, Dr.Ph., associate professor of public health sciences at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center. "Today, we know that reducing total fat may not be enough - we need to focus on the types of fat we eat."

Vitolins, a registered dietician, is an author on the three papers that report the results in the Feb. 8 edition of the Journal of the American Medical Association. Wake Forest was a Vanguard Center, one of 16 university sites chosen to launch the WHI.

The study compared a group of women who followed their normal eating patterns with a group who followed a study diet designed to reduce total fat. At the end of the first year, the low-fat diet group was consuming about 24 percent of calories from fat, compared to 35 percent in the normal-diet group.

At the end of the study's sixth year, the low-fat diet group consumed about 29 percent of calories from fat, compared to 37 percent in the normal-diet group. The low-fat diet group also increased their consumption of vegetables, fruits and grains.

Researchers found no difference between the two groups in terms of risk of breast cancer, colon cancer, heart disease or stroke.

Vitolins said one explanation for the results is that the low-fat diet was designed to reduce total fat and didn't make a distinction between good fats, such as those found in nuts, fish, and vegetables oils, and bad fats, such as the saturated fat in meats and the trans fat used in baked goods and potato chips.

"The study was testing the belief that lowering total fat would reduce the risk of cancer," said Vitolins. "Since the study began, we've learned a lot more about how the types of fats we consume make a difference."

Vitolins and others said the study's findings should not change recommendations for staying healthy.

"The results of this study do not change established recommendations on disease prevention," said National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Director Elizabeth G. Nabel, M.D., in an NIH press release. "Women should continue to get regular mammograms and screenings for colorectal cancer, and work with their doctors to reduce their risks for heart disease including following a diet low in saturated fat, trans fat and cholesterol."

Current dietary guidelines call for keeping saturated fats to less than 10 percent of calories, with most fats coming from fish, nuts and vegetable oils. They also call for limiting levels of trans fat. Vitolins said that only recently has trans fat become recognized as harmful - it must now be listed on food labels.

Vitolins also said it's important to remember that participants began the low-fat diet later in life. Women were 50 to 79 years old when the study began and were followed for an average of 8.1 years.

"Our diets start when we are born and it makes sense that what you eat over a lifetime will make a difference," she said.

About 3,300 women in the Piedmont Triad were participants in the Women's Health Initiative, according to local principal investigator Denise E. Bonds, M.D., M.P.H., assistant professor of public health sciences at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center. Of those, 988 participated in the diet study, which was one of three WHI trials. The other trials evaluated hormone therapy and the effects of calcium and vitamin D on prevention of osteoporosis-related bone fractures and colon cancer.

Nationally, the WHI enrolled 157,000 women between 50 and 79 years old at 40 clinical centers, making it the largest clinical trial ever undertaken in the United States.

Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center

Related Dietary Fat Current Events and Dietary Fat News Articles

Dietary Fat Current Events and Dietary Fat News RSS

Olive-oil enriched diet helps breast cancer survivors lose more weight
Researchers from The Miriam Hospital have found that olive oil may offer another potential health benefit - it produces greater weight loss in breast cancer survivors compared to a more traditional low-fat diet.

New study finds attending Weight Watchers meetings helps reduce the risk for type 2 diabetes
The 57 million Americans currently living with "pre-diabetes" could benefit from a group weight loss program, like Weight Watchers, according to a new study published in this month's American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine.

High-fat meals a no-no for asthma patients
People with asthma may be well-advised to avoid heavy, high-fat meals, according to new research. Individuals with asthma who consumed a high-fat meal showed increased airway inflammation just hours after the binge, according to Australian researchers who conducted the study. The high fat meal also appeared to inhibit the response to the asthma reliever medication Ventolin (albuterol).

Trans fats linked to increased endometriosis risk and omega-3-rich food linked to lower risk
Women whose diets are rich in foods containing Omega-3 oils might be less likely to develop endometriosis, while those whose diets are heavily laden with trans fats might be more likely to develop the debilitating condition, new research published today (Wednesday 24 March) suggests.

Study results leave search for new diabetes and heart disease treatments unresolved
Treatment with the anti-hypertensive drug valsartan (Diovan) led to a modest reduction in the development of type 2 diabetes but did not significantly reduce cardiovascular events in patients with impaired glucose tolerance, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center and the University of Oxford.

Total fat, trans fat linked to higher incidence of ischemic stroke
Post-menopausal women who reported consuming the most daily dietary fat had a 40 percent higher incidence of clot-caused strokes compared to women who ate the least amount, according to research presented at the American Stroke Association's International Stroke Conference 2010.

Gladstone scientists identify target that may reduce complications of obesity
Although obesity is a risk factor for diabetes and coronary heart disease worldwide, only some obese individuals go on to develop these metabolic complications, while others are relatively protected. Defining these protective factors could help scientists prevent disease in the wider population.

Latest epidemic? High cholesterol, obesity in fruit flies
How do fruit flies get high cholesterol and become obese? The same way as people do - by eating a diet that's too rich in fats.

Scientists find obesity alone does not cause arthritis in animals
The link between obesity and osteoarthritis may be more than just the wear and tear on the skeleton caused by added weight.

Gladstone scientists reveal key enzyme in fat absorption
Scientists at the Gladstone Institutes of Cardiovascular Disease (GICD) have found that a key enzyme involved in absorbing fat may also be a key to reducing it.

More Dietary Fat Current Events and Dietary Fat News Articles

	The Fats of Life: Essential Fatty Acids in Health and Disease by Glen D. Lawrence (Author) The Fats of Life delineates the importance of essential fatty acids, with a focus on distinctions between omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acid variants. Lawrence addresses in detail the capacity for polyunsaturated fatty acids to influence asthma, atherosclerosis, heart disease, inflammation, cancer, and immunity.
	Irwin Naturals Green Tea Fat Metabolizer Dietary Supplement Liquid Gel Caps, 75-Count Bottles (Pack of 2) by Irwin Naturals Green Tea Fat Metabolizer┐ combines a highly concentrated form of green tea extract with a powerful blend of natural herbal boosters and nutrients that, when used with a reduced calorie diet and exercise plan, can help:
	Modern Dietary Fat Intakes in Disease Promotion by Humana Press The industrial and agricultural revolutions have dramatically changed our lifestyles including where we get foods and what we eat. Modern diets have moved away from a close association with historically beneficial foods and diets towards foods and diets with increased fats and contaminants and with much lower intakes of fruits and vegetables. Modern Dietary Fat Intakes in Disease Promotion focuses on the scientific evidence that define such risks in modern diets with the consequences of increased illness, cancer and disease. There is also an emphasis on methods to reverse negative components of modern diets for health improvement. The volume is divided into six sections. The first section focuses on the behavioral aspects of eating and is followed by sections on fats, obesity and...
	Madi K's Whole Natural Almonds, 11-Ounce Pouches (Pack of 4) by Madi K's Madi K's family grown Whole Natural Almonds are brought to you from tree to mouth. The Nonpareil Almond is natural, nutritional, and considered to be the finest tasting, most expensive variety of almond grown in California. It's light color, smooth skin and tasty flavor delivers a quality savory nutritional snack with zero trans fat and zero cholesterol. A one ounce single serving makes the ideal daily snack portion! Madi K's is owned by almond farmers now in their third generation who have been farming for over four decades. Madi K's maintains the highest quality standards in our three state-of-the-art facilities in Southern California where we emulate family values consisting of trust, integrity, pride of ownership and passion for our delicious and healthy almond products. All Madi...
	Relacore - Help Prevent Stress Related Abdominal Fat, 72 caps,(CRC) by Relacore Relacore - Help Prevent Stress Related Abdominal Fat capsules controls belly fat. It increase energy stress reducer/mood elevator. It helps prevent stress-related abdominal fat. Use it with any diet or exercise program.
	Dinex International Inc Tan Low Fat Dietary Tray Cards - Large by Dinex International, Inc Dietary Tray CardsColorful Tray Cards insure accuracy and communicate special diet information Specifications:Type: Low Fat DietSize: Large (3-1/2" x 2-5/8")Color: TanCase of 500.Other cards pictured are sold separately. Room service cards\|tray label\|meal delivery labels\|hospital tray cards\|nursing home tray cards\|institutional tray card Home
	Dietary Management of Fat and Cholesterol (Video Counseling Library, Cardiology) Also With: Milner-Fenwick (Primary Contributor) This video explains how HDL, LDL, saturated fats, andunsaturated fats affect the body, and the importance ofreducing cholesterol levels. Viewers learn American Heart Association based diet strategies for healthier foods, howto read labels, and how to prepare foods.
	`Pelouze Portion-Control Scale Model #YG-1000R by Scales---Body-Fat Use for dietary portion control * Easy to read dial * Large red hairline pointer for accuracy * Zero adjustment knob below platform * Weight capacity: 1000 g x 5 g * 1 Year Warranty * Shipping Carton Size: 16 L x 12 W x 10 H
	Carb-Ease TM by AdvoCare Carb-Ease® supplement helps prevent the breakdown of carbohydrates by inhibiting the digestive enzymes used to break them down.* The body must break down starches and other complex carbohydrates (polysaccharides) into smaller, more usable forms (monosaccharides). Once broken down, the simple glucose molecules can then be transported across the intestinal wall into the bloodstream. Carb-Ease contains herbal extracts and other ingredients such as L-arabinose that help inhibit the breakdown of selected complex carbohydrate molecules so that the body is less likely to absorb them.* Furthermore, Carb-Ease contains additional ingredients, including dry bean extract and gymnema, that help reduce your cravings for sweets and helps inhibit the absorption of some carbohydrates before they can be...
	Super Fat Burner Support Weight Loss 90 Capsules Dietary Supplement by vitabase Are you feeling the need for some extra assistance as you lose those extra pounds? Weight loss is very likely the most effective and fastest way to boost the quality of your health. After you have lost some weight, you will see the benefits of lower blood pressure, increased energy, improved mobility, lower blood sugar levels, better sleep and much more. A healthy diet and exercise are both required in order to effectively lose weight, but often people need a higher metabolism in order to boost their ability to take off unwanted pounds. Vitabase Super Fat Burner is a powerful, natural combination of minerals, vitamins, amino acids, herbs and essential fatty acids that help to increase metabolism and boost weight loss.