 |
|
Hysterectomy type makes little difference in later sexual function
May 15, 2006Women who undergo a total hysterectomy, in which both the uterus and the cervix are removed, are no more likely to experience sexual difficulties or urinary or bowel problems after surgery than women who have only their uterus removed, a new review has found.
This finding contradicts perceptions among some women and physicians that retaining the cervix is preferable or even necessary to pelvic function.
Total hysterectomy is a slightly more complex and lengthy operation, but the likelihood of ongoing menstrual bleeding after surgery is increased with subtotal hysterectomy.
"Women considering surgery will have to balance the supposed advantages of a less complicated surgery with a risk of cyclical bleeding after subtotal hysterectomy," said lead author Anne Lethaby of the University of Auckland in New Zealand. "The review did not find any other differences."
The review appears in the current issue of The Cochrane Library, a publication of The Cochrane Collaboration, an international organization that evaluates research in all aspects of health care. Systematic reviews draw evidence-based conclusions about medical practice after considering both the content and quality of existing trials on a topic.
The rationale for the review, according to the authors, was to compare the safety and effectiveness of subtotal and total hysterectomy and to evaluate the perception that total hysterectomy could increase the risk of urinary incontinence, bowel problems and reduced sexual pleasure.
The reviewers identified three randomized controlled trials enrolling a total of 733 women that compared subtotal and total hysterectomy for noncancerous conditions. The most common reasons for hysterectomy in these trials were fibroids and heavy menstrual bleeding.
There was no evidence in these trials that total hysterectomy increased the risk of urinary or bowel problems. In the two years following surgery, women receiving a total hysterectomy were no more likely to suffer from urinary incontinence, increased urinary frequency or constipation than women who underwent subtotal hysterectomy.
They also found no evidence from these trials that removal of the cervix impaired sexual function. Satisfaction with sex, prevalence of painful intercourse and rates of sexual problems in the year or two following surgery did not differ significantly according to the type of hysterectomy.
"Early studies taught that subtotal hysterectomy was better than total hysterectomy in terms of sexual function, urinary function, and GI function, but these studies were not well done," said Howard Sharp, M.D., of the University of Utah School of Medicine. "Now that we've had a few studies that have been done with a much higher degree of scientific rigor, they're showing us that there's really no difference in terms of these outcomes."
The reviewers did find that women having total hysterectomy had a greater risk of fever during surgery. Operating time was about 11 minutes shorter for subtotal hysterectomy in the two trials that measured this, and women who underwent subtotal hysterectomy in these studies also lost less blood, on average, than women having total hysterectomy. However, there was no significant difference in the need for blood transfusions according to type of surgery.
"An 11-minute difference in the operating room is statistically significant, but I think it's clinically irrelevant," said Sharp. "And while we would all like to hang on to every drop of blood we can get, what really matters to me is whether I have to transfuse a patient."
Another potential disadvantage of total hysterectomy, an increased risk of vaginal vault prolapse, was not confirmed in the review. The authors noted that to assess this risk properly, longer follow-up of trials would be needed.
One significant difference of possible relevance to some women was the greater likelihood of ongoing cyclical vaginal bleeding with subtotal hysterectomy. Almost 12 percent of women having subtotal hysterectomy were experiencing ongoing bleeding one year after surgery was completed, compared to fewer than 1 percent of women having total hysterectomy.
"I've had patients who have had cyclical bleeding after subtotal hysterectomy, but most patients state that it's just a nuisance issue," said Sharp. "However, if definitive treatment is what they want, I make sure that I counsel them about the potential for post-hysterectomy spotting with subtotal hysterectomy."
According to Lethaby, the review cannot be considered definitive, due to the small number of studies that have compared total and subtotal hysterectomy and the fact that fewer than a thousand women were enrolled.
"While the risks and benefits are clear in the review, more research is required before we can be confident of the findings," she said.
Center for the Advancement of Health
"Women considering surgery will have to balance the supposed advantages of a less complicated surgery with a risk of cyclical bleeding after subtotal hysterectomy," said lead author Anne Lethaby of the University of Auckland in New Zealand. "The review did not find any other differences."
The review appears in the current issue of The Cochrane Library, a publication of The Cochrane Collaboration, an international organization that evaluates research in all aspects of health care. Systematic reviews draw evidence-based conclusions about medical practice after considering both the content and quality of existing trials on a topic.
The rationale for the review, according to the authors, was to compare the safety and effectiveness of subtotal and total hysterectomy and to evaluate the perception that total hysterectomy could increase the risk of urinary incontinence, bowel problems and reduced sexual pleasure.
The reviewers identified three randomized controlled trials enrolling a total of 733 women that compared subtotal and total hysterectomy for noncancerous conditions. The most common reasons for hysterectomy in these trials were fibroids and heavy menstrual bleeding.
There was no evidence in these trials that total hysterectomy increased the risk of urinary or bowel problems. In the two years following surgery, women receiving a total hysterectomy were no more likely to suffer from urinary incontinence, increased urinary frequency or constipation than women who underwent subtotal hysterectomy.
They also found no evidence from these trials that removal of the cervix impaired sexual function. Satisfaction with sex, prevalence of painful intercourse and rates of sexual problems in the year or two following surgery did not differ significantly according to the type of hysterectomy.
"Early studies taught that subtotal hysterectomy was better than total hysterectomy in terms of sexual function, urinary function, and GI function, but these studies were not well done," said Howard Sharp, M.D., of the University of Utah School of Medicine. "Now that we've had a few studies that have been done with a much higher degree of scientific rigor, they're showing us that there's really no difference in terms of these outcomes."
The reviewers did find that women having total hysterectomy had a greater risk of fever during surgery. Operating time was about 11 minutes shorter for subtotal hysterectomy in the two trials that measured this, and women who underwent subtotal hysterectomy in these studies also lost less blood, on average, than women having total hysterectomy. However, there was no significant difference in the need for blood transfusions according to type of surgery.
"An 11-minute difference in the operating room is statistically significant, but I think it's clinically irrelevant," said Sharp. "And while we would all like to hang on to every drop of blood we can get, what really matters to me is whether I have to transfuse a patient."
Another potential disadvantage of total hysterectomy, an increased risk of vaginal vault prolapse, was not confirmed in the review. The authors noted that to assess this risk properly, longer follow-up of trials would be needed.
One significant difference of possible relevance to some women was the greater likelihood of ongoing cyclical vaginal bleeding with subtotal hysterectomy. Almost 12 percent of women having subtotal hysterectomy were experiencing ongoing bleeding one year after surgery was completed, compared to fewer than 1 percent of women having total hysterectomy.
"I've had patients who have had cyclical bleeding after subtotal hysterectomy, but most patients state that it's just a nuisance issue," said Sharp. "However, if definitive treatment is what they want, I make sure that I counsel them about the potential for post-hysterectomy spotting with subtotal hysterectomy."
According to Lethaby, the review cannot be considered definitive, due to the small number of studies that have compared total and subtotal hysterectomy and the fact that fewer than a thousand women were enrolled.
"While the risks and benefits are clear in the review, more research is required before we can be confident of the findings," she said.
Center for the Advancement of Health
Hysterectomy Current Events and Hysterectomy News RSSMayo researchers find robotic repair for vaginal prolapse has significant benefits
New Mayo Clinic research has found that robotic surgery for vaginal prolapse dramatically reduces patient hospital stay and recovery time.
Hormone mix could cut breast cancer risk and treat symptoms of menopause
The right combination of estrogen and a selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM), which blocks the effects of estrogen in breast tissue, could relieve menopause symptoms and cut breast cancer risk.
Interventional radiology treatment for uterine fibroids: Safe, nonsurgical option
Uterine fibroid embolization-a minimally invasive interventional radiology treatment for women that cuts off blood flow to painful fibroids to kill the tumors-is highlighted as an appropriate treatment for women in a Clinical Therapeutics article in the Aug. 13 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.
Young early stage ovarian cancer patients can preserve fertility
A new study finds that young women with early-stage ovarian cancer can preserve future fertility by keeping at least one ovary or the uterus without increasing the risk of dying from the disease.
Ovary removal may increase lung cancer risk
Women who have premature menopause because of medical interventions are at an increased risk of developing lung cancer, according to a new study published in the International Journal of Cancer.
2 reproductive factors are important predictors of death from ovarian cancer
Researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found that survival among women with ovarian cancer is influenced by age of menarche and total number of lifetime ovulatory cycles.
Uterus sparing surgery is a safe and effective treatment for pelvic organ prolapse
Researchers presented data at the 104th Annual Scientific Meeting of the American Urological Association (AUA) showing that uterus sparing surgery is an effective and safe treatment for women who want to preserve the integrity of vaginal function after pelvic organ prolapse.
First successful transvaginal nephrectomy performed using advanced surgical concepts' tri-port
r. Rene Sotelo is pleased to announce the world's first successful live human transvaginal nephrectomy using the Tri-port multi-channel port supplied by Advanced Surgical Concepts Ltd.
Women's Cancer Outcome Improved by Surgical Evaluation
Many women scheduled to undergo hysterectomy for pre-cancerous cell changes actually need a more comprehensive surgery, something they should discuss with a gynecologic oncologist, say researchers at the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB).
Study Shows Younger Women With Endometrial Cancer Can Safely Keep Ovaries, Avoid Early Menopause
In the largest study to date on the safety of ovarian preservation in women aged 45 and younger who were surgically treated for early-stage endometrial cancer, researchers have found that there is no survival benefit associated with surgical removal of the ovaries, compared to women whose ovaries were left intact.
More Hysterectomy Current Events and Hysterectomy News Articles
 |
The Essential Guide to Hysterectomy by Lauren F. Streicher (Author) In clear, conversational language, Dr. Lauren Streicher discusses everything a woman needs to know to make informed choices about this often-controversial subject, including emotions and sex after surgery, hormone replacement, and much more. |
 |
Through the Land of Hyster: The Hyster Sisters Guide by Kathy Kelley (Author) This book contains pre-op and post-op information, checklists, helpful hints for recovery and more. Advise given in the book is shared as a form of sisterly advice and women to women support. "Bedtime Stories for Hyster Sisters" are included to add to the sisterly charm of this book. This book reflects the solid information along with a bit of humor known at the Hyster Sisters website. |
 |
The H Word: The diagnostic studies to evaluate symptoms, alternatives in treatment, and coping with the aftereffects of hysterectomy. by Nora W. Coffey (Author), Rick Schweikert (Author) THE H WORD discusses the common reasons hysterectomy is recommended, the diagnostic studies that should be performed to obtain a diagnosis, alternatives in treatment, and strategies to help women cope with the lifelong aftereffects of removal of the uterus and ovaries. It revolutionizes our understanding of female anatomy and the important lifelong functions of the female organs, while revealing a solution to the complex problem of hysterectomy performed without the information that is necessary for informed consent. The HERS Foundation¹s 51-city, 51-week Protest & Play tour provides the backdrop for THE H WORD, which takes an unflinching look at the environment of hysterectomy in America. THE H WORD empowers women with information that gynecology doesn¹t want you to know about 100... |
 |
101 Handy Hints for a Happy Hysterectomy by Linda Parkinson-Hardman (Author) hysterectomy, menopause, hrt, fibroids, endometriosis |
 |
The Woman's Guide to Hysterectomy: Expectations and Options by Adelaide Haas (Author), Susan L. Puretz (Author) Hysterectomy is performed more than any other surgical procedure for women, with the exception of the cesarean section. Authors Adelaide Haas and Susan L. Puretz, both professors in the field of health, have experienced hysterectomy firsthand. Dismayed by the limited information available to them, they collaborated on this comprehensive book about a critically important subject for women. THE WOMAN’S GUIDE TO HYSTERECTOMY addresses common fears, expectations, and questions regarding such issues as what to ask your doctor, second opinions, preparations for surgery, sex and sexuality after surgery, and life after hysterectomy. Encouraging all women to become more actively involved in their own healthcare, this book is a practical catalog of the latest medical information and provides... |
 |
Your Guide to Hysterectomy, Ovary Removal, & Hormone Replacement: What All Women Need to Know by Elizabeth L. Plourde (Author) Combining personal stories of women's surgical experiences with the most recent medical data, this book offers a unique exploration into the issues surrounding hysterectomy, ovary removal, and hormone replacement. This book provides much needed information to clarify the confusion around HRT since the WHI study was released in July 2002. Women do not need to suffer needlessly. Well-documented with scientific references, it argues against the common belief that women's reproductive organs are dispensable after their childbearing years and looks at the full impact of reproductive organ removal on women's health. Detailed information on the side effects that can arise from these surgeries is provided, including high blood pressure, heart disease, osteoporosis, depression, fibromyalgia,... |
 |
The Hysterectomy Hoax: The Truth About Why Many Hysterectomies Are Unnecessary and How to Avoid Them, 3rd Edition by Stanley West MD (Author), Paula Dranov (Author) While more than 600,000 hysterectomies are performed each year in the United States, 90 percent of them are unwarranted. This vital health guide offers women the information they need to empower themselves in making critical health decisions. For example, surgery can often do more harm than good and may pose needless risks, except in situations involving a life-threatening illness such as cancer. However, surgeons often rely on hysterectomies as a panacea for everything from premenstrual syndrome to uterine fibroids. An important step in bridging the communication gap between patient and physician are the specific questions in this book for women to ask their doctors. Included is information about various gynecological conditions with suggestions for alternative treatments, such as... |
 |
So You're Having a Hysterectomy by Togas Tulandi (Author), Barbara Levy (Author) Everything women need to know to face surgery with confidence This book puts women facing a hysterectomy firmly in the driver’s seat, explaining the procedure as well as alternative therapies in step-by-step detail. Real-life patient stories, extensive self-help sections, and detailed illustrations take the mystery out of doctor visits and operating room procedures. The book also includes a directory of resources, a guide to complementary therapies, and a diary to help people keep track of treatment and recovery. Togas Tulandi, MD, is Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at McGill University and recognized worldwide as a leader in women’s health. Barbara R. Levy, MD, is Assistant Clinical Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the University of Washington School of... |
 |
Do You Really Need Surgery?: A Sensible Guide to Hysterectomy and Other Procedures for Women by Michele C., MD Moore (Author) The authors also help the patient through the post-operative phase, revealing what to expect, how to make the recovery easier, and how to take care of yourself after the surgery. |
 |
Hysterectomy? The Best or Worst Thing That Ever Happened to Me?: A Collection of Women's Personal Experiences by Elizabeth L. Plourde (Author) Consumer text provides invaluable insights into the variable effects reproductive organ surgery has on the body. Discusses personal experiences in a variety of scenarios, including complete hysterectomy, hysterectomy with one and two ovaries removed, tubal ligation, and resolution without surgery. This powerful, insightful book offers in-depth information about the benefits and risks of hysterectomies through the personal accounts of women who have undergone the procedure. Every year, one million women face the decision of whether to have a hysterectomy. Two-thirds of the women who elect to have the procedure are glad that they did. The other third, however, experience unexpected consequences, including changes in sexual desire. This book reveals the real stories behind what most... |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |