 |
|
Ancient raindrops reveal the origins of California's Sierra Nevada range
July 07, 2006One of the longest ongoing controversies in Earth science concerns the age of California's Sierra Nevada, the tallest mountain range in the continental United States and site of Yosemite National Park, Lake Tahoe and other scenic wonders.
"The debate falls into two camps," said C. Page Chamberlain, professor of geological and environmental sciences at Stanford University. "One is that the mountains rose from sea level in the last 3 to 5 million years, which is very recent on a geologic time scale. The other group suggests a much more ancient origin going back 60 million years or so."
Now, in a study published in the July 7 edition of the journal Science, Chamberlain and Stanford colleagues Andreas Mulch and Stephan A. Graham present strong evidence that the Sierra Nevada range has stood tall—7,200 feet (2,200 meters) or higher—for at least 40 million years.
"An elevation profile drawn across the northern Sierra Nevada 40 to 50 million years ago would not look much different than today's profile," said Graham, the Welton Joseph and Maud L'Anphere Crook Professor of Applied Earth Science at Stanford.
"Those mountains probably have persisted since the Mesozoic Era—more than 65 million years ago—until today," Chamberlain added. Back then, according to many scientists, California was split by an ancient subduction zone—a region of constant geologic upheaval, where a plunging oceanic tectonic plate continuously pushed the continental North American plate higher and higher to create the Sierra Nevada range.
This version of events is in sharp conflict with the "recent uplift" scenario, which argues that the Sierra rose from sea level to 7,200 feet about 3 million to 5 million years ago after an enormous block of the Earth's crust broke off and fell into the mantle. According to this hypothesis, the crust was then replaced by hot, buoyant mantle material that eventually raised the mountains. Although the Science study found no evidence to support this scenario, data revealed that a modest uplift of 1,100 to 2,000 feet (350 to 600 meters) did occur as recently as 3 million years ago.
The Stanford team obtained their results by conducting a chemical analysis of ancient raindrops unearthed in the Sierra during the California Gold Rush. In addition to providing important insights for geoscientists, the authors say their findings could lead to more accurate assessments of global climate change.
"If you want to make a climate model and project out into the future, you need to test your model by running it back in time and seeing how it matches similar climate histories in the past," Chamberlain said.
"Determining when the mountains rose is an important question, because the effect of a relatively tall range on precipitation and climate is very significant," said Mulch, a postdoctoral scholar in Stanford's Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences and lead author of the study. "Making the mountains twice as high would therefore make the impact twice as large."
Heavy raindrops
To determine when the Sierra rose to its current height, the scientists used an increasingly popular research tool that combines geology and chemistry to create a record of prehistoric rainfall patterns dating back millions of years. This technique relies on the fact that in nature, hydrogen and other atoms occur in different sizes called isotopes. Deuterium, for example, is a slightly heavier form of hydrogen, and drops of rainwater that contain deuterium isotopes often fall at lower elevations.
"If you have a cloud coming in and dropping out water, as it climbs the mountain its preference is to first drop the heavy water that's rich in deuterium," Chamberlain said. "As you go up in elevation, the raindrops become lighter and lighter. Therefore, the rainwater becomes gradually depleted of deuterium the higher up the mountain range it falls."
Over time, some raindrops are incorporated into molecules of clay and other minerals that form on the ground. These clays provide scientists with a geologic record of ancient precipitation, which can then be compared with samples of modern precipitation collected at the same altitude. If the comparison reveals similar isotopic ratios, then the elevation of the mountain must have been similar in ancient and modern times.
"Determining the height of a now-eroded mountain range has remained frustrating and elusive," said Graham. "Relating the isotopic composition of ancient rainfall to minerals formed in ancient soils provides a powerful way to infer those paleoelevations and is creating a burgeoning set of data from the Himalayas and Tibet, the Andes and now the Sierra Nevada."
Gold Rush diggings
In the study, the Stanford team compared modern rainfall with prehistoric samples dating back to the Eocene epoch 40 million to 50 million years ago. Soil and rocks from the Eocene often are buried deep underground. But in the mid-1800s, gold prospectors began using hydraulic mining to expose gold-bearing gravels along two major Sierra rivers, the Yuba and the American. Using powerful water canons, the miners "cut away half a mountain in a few minutes [and] changed entire landscapes," wrote historian Joseph H. Jackson.
Hydraulic mining caused severe environmental damage and exposed tons of ancient rocks and minerals that can still be seen today. "If you go up along the Yuba and American rivers east of Sacramento, you'll see the gold diggings," Chamberlain said. "They were mining river gravels that were deposited 45 to 48 million years ago. When these deposits formed, they underwent intense chemical weathering that turned them into clay minerals."
Embedded in the crystalline structure of these soft clays is a continuous record of Eocene precipitation along the western flank of the Sierra Nevada—a record that would have remained locked underground if not for the destructive pursuit of gold 150 years ago.
"If you can follow the river up to what you think was its crest, then you can use the hydrogen-deuterium isotopes in the clay minerals to reconstruct the topography of the mountain, which is what we did," Chamberlain said.
During the study, the Stanford team collected dozens of clay samples from 15 sites along the two rivers—old Sierra mining camps with colorful names like Orleans Flat and You Bet Diggings.
"The highest sampling elevation was about 5,500 feet [1,700 meters] going down to about 980 feet [300 meters] to where the ocean shoreline was roughly 40 million years ago," Mulch said. "I then analyzed the clay minerals in the lab to get an idea of what the isotopic composition of the water was at that time."
When Mulch compared ancient raindrops in the clays with modern precipitation samples, he discovered a remarkable similarity: In both cases, deuterium levels gradually decreased from the lowest-elevation collection site to the highest—a strong indication the topography of the Sierra had changed little since the Eocene epoch. "With these data, we've been able to extend the record back and say, 'We think these mountains were high 40 to 50 million years ago and did not rise from sea level in the last 3 to 5 million years,"' Chamberlain said.
However, isotope analysis also revealed that the mountains have not remained entirely static. "There is no question that 3 or so million years ago there was some kind of uplift, but no higher than 2,000 feet [600 meters]," Mulch said.
"The cool part is that it's the gold mines and these gold-bearing gravels that are telling us this," Chamberlain added.
Besides isotopic data, Mulch points to other geological evidence that the Sierra range is really tens of millions of years old.
"I'm not emotionally attached to one side of the debate or the other, because obviously I could live with mountains being young or old," he said. "But if you look at these rivers and what they deposited in the riverbeds, the boulders that they transported can be as large as a basketball or even larger. There's no way for me to understand how you could do this if the gradient was that of a meandering river in a flat landscape. This is what mountain rivers do: They transport big boulders. That's what we see in the Himalayas and the Andes, and that's what we're not seeing in the Mississippi or Missouri rivers. They just transport very fine material and not house-sized boulders."
Climate change
The Stanford team has begun extending the technique beyond California. "We're trying to unravel a picture of how all of western North America looked through time in terms of its topography," Chamberlain said. "The Sierra is one piece of the puzzle. What seems to be emerging is that the Great Basin, which includes much of Nevada and Utah, was a large plateau that basically collapsed. So the crest of the Sierra was once the edge of a plateau, similar to the Himalayas and the Tibetan highlands. Can we prove that? We think we're getting close."
Solving these geologic puzzles also has significant implications for modeling global climate change, past and future, he said.
"There are basically six large mountain ranges climatologists need to know the history of—western North America, the Himalayas, Antarctica, Greenland, the spine down Africa and the Andes," Chamberlain noted. "To get an idea of what's going to happen if carbon dioxide levels double in the future, you'd have to go back 20 or 30 million years in time. If you knew what the topography of these six mountain ranges was then, you could include that in your computer models and see how they respond when you double the carbon dioxide."
Stanford University
"An elevation profile drawn across the northern Sierra Nevada 40 to 50 million years ago would not look much different than today's profile," said Graham, the Welton Joseph and Maud L'Anphere Crook Professor of Applied Earth Science at Stanford.
"Those mountains probably have persisted since the Mesozoic Era—more than 65 million years ago—until today," Chamberlain added. Back then, according to many scientists, California was split by an ancient subduction zone—a region of constant geologic upheaval, where a plunging oceanic tectonic plate continuously pushed the continental North American plate higher and higher to create the Sierra Nevada range.
This version of events is in sharp conflict with the "recent uplift" scenario, which argues that the Sierra rose from sea level to 7,200 feet about 3 million to 5 million years ago after an enormous block of the Earth's crust broke off and fell into the mantle. According to this hypothesis, the crust was then replaced by hot, buoyant mantle material that eventually raised the mountains. Although the Science study found no evidence to support this scenario, data revealed that a modest uplift of 1,100 to 2,000 feet (350 to 600 meters) did occur as recently as 3 million years ago.
The Stanford team obtained their results by conducting a chemical analysis of ancient raindrops unearthed in the Sierra during the California Gold Rush. In addition to providing important insights for geoscientists, the authors say their findings could lead to more accurate assessments of global climate change.
"If you want to make a climate model and project out into the future, you need to test your model by running it back in time and seeing how it matches similar climate histories in the past," Chamberlain said.
"Determining when the mountains rose is an important question, because the effect of a relatively tall range on precipitation and climate is very significant," said Mulch, a postdoctoral scholar in Stanford's Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences and lead author of the study. "Making the mountains twice as high would therefore make the impact twice as large."
Heavy raindrops
To determine when the Sierra rose to its current height, the scientists used an increasingly popular research tool that combines geology and chemistry to create a record of prehistoric rainfall patterns dating back millions of years. This technique relies on the fact that in nature, hydrogen and other atoms occur in different sizes called isotopes. Deuterium, for example, is a slightly heavier form of hydrogen, and drops of rainwater that contain deuterium isotopes often fall at lower elevations.
"If you have a cloud coming in and dropping out water, as it climbs the mountain its preference is to first drop the heavy water that's rich in deuterium," Chamberlain said. "As you go up in elevation, the raindrops become lighter and lighter. Therefore, the rainwater becomes gradually depleted of deuterium the higher up the mountain range it falls."
Over time, some raindrops are incorporated into molecules of clay and other minerals that form on the ground. These clays provide scientists with a geologic record of ancient precipitation, which can then be compared with samples of modern precipitation collected at the same altitude. If the comparison reveals similar isotopic ratios, then the elevation of the mountain must have been similar in ancient and modern times.
"Determining the height of a now-eroded mountain range has remained frustrating and elusive," said Graham. "Relating the isotopic composition of ancient rainfall to minerals formed in ancient soils provides a powerful way to infer those paleoelevations and is creating a burgeoning set of data from the Himalayas and Tibet, the Andes and now the Sierra Nevada."
Gold Rush diggings
In the study, the Stanford team compared modern rainfall with prehistoric samples dating back to the Eocene epoch 40 million to 50 million years ago. Soil and rocks from the Eocene often are buried deep underground. But in the mid-1800s, gold prospectors began using hydraulic mining to expose gold-bearing gravels along two major Sierra rivers, the Yuba and the American. Using powerful water canons, the miners "cut away half a mountain in a few minutes [and] changed entire landscapes," wrote historian Joseph H. Jackson.
Hydraulic mining caused severe environmental damage and exposed tons of ancient rocks and minerals that can still be seen today. "If you go up along the Yuba and American rivers east of Sacramento, you'll see the gold diggings," Chamberlain said. "They were mining river gravels that were deposited 45 to 48 million years ago. When these deposits formed, they underwent intense chemical weathering that turned them into clay minerals."
Embedded in the crystalline structure of these soft clays is a continuous record of Eocene precipitation along the western flank of the Sierra Nevada—a record that would have remained locked underground if not for the destructive pursuit of gold 150 years ago.
"If you can follow the river up to what you think was its crest, then you can use the hydrogen-deuterium isotopes in the clay minerals to reconstruct the topography of the mountain, which is what we did," Chamberlain said.
During the study, the Stanford team collected dozens of clay samples from 15 sites along the two rivers—old Sierra mining camps with colorful names like Orleans Flat and You Bet Diggings.
"The highest sampling elevation was about 5,500 feet [1,700 meters] going down to about 980 feet [300 meters] to where the ocean shoreline was roughly 40 million years ago," Mulch said. "I then analyzed the clay minerals in the lab to get an idea of what the isotopic composition of the water was at that time."
When Mulch compared ancient raindrops in the clays with modern precipitation samples, he discovered a remarkable similarity: In both cases, deuterium levels gradually decreased from the lowest-elevation collection site to the highest—a strong indication the topography of the Sierra had changed little since the Eocene epoch. "With these data, we've been able to extend the record back and say, 'We think these mountains were high 40 to 50 million years ago and did not rise from sea level in the last 3 to 5 million years,"' Chamberlain said.
However, isotope analysis also revealed that the mountains have not remained entirely static. "There is no question that 3 or so million years ago there was some kind of uplift, but no higher than 2,000 feet [600 meters]," Mulch said.
"The cool part is that it's the gold mines and these gold-bearing gravels that are telling us this," Chamberlain added.
Besides isotopic data, Mulch points to other geological evidence that the Sierra range is really tens of millions of years old.
"I'm not emotionally attached to one side of the debate or the other, because obviously I could live with mountains being young or old," he said. "But if you look at these rivers and what they deposited in the riverbeds, the boulders that they transported can be as large as a basketball or even larger. There's no way for me to understand how you could do this if the gradient was that of a meandering river in a flat landscape. This is what mountain rivers do: They transport big boulders. That's what we see in the Himalayas and the Andes, and that's what we're not seeing in the Mississippi or Missouri rivers. They just transport very fine material and not house-sized boulders."
Climate change
The Stanford team has begun extending the technique beyond California. "We're trying to unravel a picture of how all of western North America looked through time in terms of its topography," Chamberlain said. "The Sierra is one piece of the puzzle. What seems to be emerging is that the Great Basin, which includes much of Nevada and Utah, was a large plateau that basically collapsed. So the crest of the Sierra was once the edge of a plateau, similar to the Himalayas and the Tibetan highlands. Can we prove that? We think we're getting close."
Solving these geologic puzzles also has significant implications for modeling global climate change, past and future, he said.
"There are basically six large mountain ranges climatologists need to know the history of—western North America, the Himalayas, Antarctica, Greenland, the spine down Africa and the Andes," Chamberlain noted. "To get an idea of what's going to happen if carbon dioxide levels double in the future, you'd have to go back 20 or 30 million years in time. If you knew what the topography of these six mountain ranges was then, you could include that in your computer models and see how they respond when you double the carbon dioxide."
Stanford University
Sierra Nevada Current Events and Sierra Nevada News RSSCave Study Links Climate Change to California Droughts
California experienced centuries-long droughts in the past 20,000 years that coincided with the thawing of ice caps in the Arctic.
Small rodents encourage the formation of scrubland in Spain
After two years of research over five degraded landscapes in the National Park of Sierra Nevada (Granada), scientists have established for the first time that field mice base their diet on holm oak and pine seeds, causing a deterioration of the habitats and an extension of scrubland in the forests.
Pacific Northwest forests could store more carbon, help address greenhouse issues
The forests of the Pacific Northwest hold significant potential to increase carbon storage and help mitigate greenhouse gas emissions in coming years, a recent study concludes, if they are managed primarily for that purpose through timber harvest reductions and increased rotation ages.
Bone bed tells of life along California's ancient coastline
In the famed Sharktooth Hill Bone Bed near Bakersfield, Calif., shark teeth as big as a hand and weighing a pound each, intermixed with copious bones from extinct seals and whales, seem to tell of a 15-million-year-old killing ground.
Scripps Studies Offer New Picture of Lake Tahoe's Earthquake Potential
For more than a decade, scientists at Scripps Institution of Oceanography at UC San Diego have been unraveling the history of fault ruptures below the cobalt blue waters of Lake Tahoe one earthquake at a time.
Origins of wolverine in California genetically verified
A wolverine first photographed by a remote-controlled camera on the Tahoe National Forest in February 2008 is most closely related to Rocky Mountain populations, according to a team of 10 federal, state and university scientists.
Study assesses impact of fish stocking on aquatic insects
The impact fish stocking has on aquatic insects in mountain lakes can be rapidly reversed by removing non-native trout, according to a study completed by U.S. Forest Service and University of California, Davis, scientists.
Charcoal evidence tracks climate changes in Younger Dryas
A new study reports that charcoal particles left by wildfires in sediments of 35 North American lake beds don't readily support the theory that comets exploding over the continent 12,900 years ago sparked a cooling period known as the Younger Dryas.
Dirty snow causes early runoff in Cascades, Rockies
Soot from pollution causes winter snowpacks to warm, shrink and warm some more. This continuous cycle sends snowmelt streaming down mountains as much as a month early, a new study finds.
Climate change effects on imperiled Sierra frog examined
Climate change can have significant impacts on high-elevation lakes and imperiled Sierra Nevada Yellow-legged frogs that depend upon them, according to U.S. Forest Service and University of California, Berkeley, scientists.
More Sierra Nevada Current Events and Sierra Nevada News Articles
 |
The Laws Field Guide to the Sierra Nevada (California Academy of Sciences) (California Academy of Sciences) by John Muir Laws (Author), John Muir Laws (Illustrator) With more than 2,800 original watercolor illustrations, John Muir Laws has masterfully catalogued over 1,700 species of Sierra trees, wildflowers, ferns, fungi, lichens, fish, reptiles, amphibians, birds, mammals, insects, and other small animals. The guide is designed for quick and easy use in the field. Color tabs and a unique system of keys and organization assist in the quick identification of the living things encountered along the trail, while Laws s illustrations capture the feeling of plants and animals with detail critical for their classification. |
 |
Hand Made Vintage Style SIERRA NEVADA PALE ALE Beer Can Belt Buckle by BeerCanBucklesCom Its a rough job, but each beer must be consumed before the process of making these belts begins! |
|
Sierra Nevada Mustard Gift Set! by Sierra Nevada Sierra Nevada Mustards are award winners. First Place winners at the Napa Valley Mustard Festival, these delicious mustards are made with real Sierra Nevada beers. Great gift, great price. | |
 |
History of the Sierra Nevada by Francis P. Farquhar (Author) From the time it was sighted by Spanish explorers in the eighteenth century through the creation of the John Muir trail, the building of the Hetch Hetchy Dam, and the founding of the Sierra Club, the great snowy range of California has provided fulfillment to generations of trappers, immigrants, engineers, naturalists, and tourists. Now a mountaineering classic, this pioneering book was the first to synthesize into a single, riveting narrative all of the varied aspects of human endeavor related to the history of the Sierra Nevada. Thoroughly illustrated with photographs, drawings, and maps, the book continues to be indispensable for any lover of the high country. |
 |
Sierra Nevada Log Cabin Fireplace DVD Starring: Apple Wood Directed By: West Coast MEDiA;Inc. On a beautiful winter day, deep within the Sierra Nevada mountains, there is a special feeling that you’ll have when you’re inside a rustic log cabin.
Imagine for a moment the wonderful aroma of a hearty meal simmering on the stove, a comfortable sofa beside a bear skin rug and of course the crackling fireplace.
With this DVD you’ll come as close as possible to experencing the relaxing pleasures of a log cabin in the mountains. Just insert the disc into your player and sit back to enjoy endless hours of a continuous real wood burning crackling fireplace.
Sierra Nevada Log Cabin Fireplace has been beautifully recorded on location with natural sounds (no music) using professional broadcast television equipment and Nikon optics. This "drop and play" DVD is... |
 |
SIERRA NEVADA EMBOSSED METAL SIGN NEW!!! SIERRA NEVADA EMBOSSED METAL SIGN, THIS BEAUTIFUL METAL SIGN IS THE PERFECT ADDITION TO YOUR BAR.... |
 |
Great American Puzzle Factory Hotel Sierra Nevada 1000 Piece Puzzle by Great American Puzzle Factory Hotel Sierra, Nevada Jigsaw Puzzle High definition photographer Louis Cantillo photographed the alfresco dining area at a popular hotel, bringing in to focus its brilliantly painted walls, charming ceramic tiles, colorful plantings and fresh white linens. It is now the subject of a picturesque photo-puzzle that armchair travelers will enjoy more and more with every puzzle piece they put in place. 1000 Pieces 19.25" X 26.5" Ages 12+ |
 |
Sierra Nevada in California Places Art Poster Print by Albert Bierstadt, 36x26 by Art.com Art.com is the world's largest retailer of art prints, posters, photographs, and framed artwork. With our huge selection of over 400,000 prints, you'll easily find the perfect piece for your home, office, or classroom. Our art is printed on quality paper. When you order framed artwork, the piece is built by our team of in-house professionals. Visit our Amazon store today at www.amazon.com/artdotcom to find Special Offers and search for products based on 'Artist Name' and 'Subject Categories' such as Movie, Music, Vintage, TV, Children, Travel, Kitchen, Museum Art, Animals, Floral, Motivational, and Sports. Art.com is dedicated to providing you with high quality products and service by offering you 100% satisfaction guaranteed. We ship internationally to over 80 countries. Decorate your... |
|
National Geographic Sierra Nevada Trails Illustrated Explorer by National Geographic Trails Illustrated Sierra Nevada Explorer contains 10 Trails Illustrated maps seamlessly stitched together, covering over 10,000 square miles of the most popular recreation sites in the Sierras. Includes: Lake Tahoe Basin, Yosemite National Park, Sequoia/Kings Canyon National Park, Pacific Crest Trail, John Muir Trail, Rubicon Trail, Tahoe Rim Trail, and more… Trails Illustrated Sierra Nevada Explorer Software combines our easy-to-use TOPO! software, with our award winning Trails Illustrated maps, giving you the best tool for printing accurate trail maps at home. Each Trails Illustrated map National Geographic creates undergoes a rigorous editorial process to ensure that it is the most accurate trail map available. Cartographers work directly with local land managers to pinpoint the... | |
 |
Sierra Nevada 2010 Wall Calendar by Browntrout The Sierra Nevada landscape encompasses a huge expanse of unspoiled scenery that is truly awe-inspiring. These majestic mountains and the stunning valleys rank high among nature's blessings. Such pristine natural beauty inspires and enlightens one's mind and spirit. Marvel at the great Sierra Nevada in this thrilling wall calendar. |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |