Analysis of Spanish flu cases in 1918-1920 suggests transfusions might help in bird flu pandemic

August 30, 2006

Transfusions with blood products taken from people who had recovered from Spanish influenza may have reduced risk for death and improved symptoms of hospitalized patients who contracted Spanish influenza complicated by pneumonia. Early treatment was superior to later treatment.

Researchers studied medical literature published shortly after the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic and found eight relevant studies.

Similar transfusions might be useful in treating victims of a bird flu pandemic, especially in light of the problems with existing vaccines and treatments, say authors of the Spanish flu study. They say that a single recovering bird-flu patient could donate "a weekly volume of plasma sufficient to treat multiple patients with H5N1 influenza."

The article "Convalescent Blood Products for Spanish Influenza Pneumonia: A Future H5N1 Treatment?" will be published in the Oct. 17, 2006, print edition of Annals of Internal Medicine and is available at http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/full/0000605-200610170-00139v1. An accompanying editorial is available at http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/full/0000605-200610170-00140v1.

Spanish flu (H1N1) and bird flu (H5N1) are subtypes of influenza A virus. The Spanish flu pandemic in 1918 to 1920 killed between 20 million and 100 million people worldwide.

The World Health Organization (WHO) says that a bird-flu pandemic is a serious possibility today. As of August 24, 2006, 241 cases of confirmed avian flu A/(H5N1) have been reported to WHO, resulting in 141 deaths.

WHO says H5N1 virus is widespread in birds, particularly poultry which seems to be the source of the Asian infections. Widespread prevalence of the virus in birds increases the chance of transmission from bird to human. When human cases become transmissible from human to human, a flu epidemic begins. If it is virulent, it will spread fast. If there are no effective antiviral drugs available, it will spread faster.

WHO says the world is not prepared to handle a bird-flu pandemic. Vaccines to prevent the particular flu strain of the pandemic will take time to manufacture and distribute after the first outbreaks.

Current recommended treatment is hospitalization and treatment with an antiviral drug, but studies of bird flu outbreaks in Asia have found that 30 percent to 80 percent of patients treated this way have died.

And WHO says the manufacturer of the most currently used drug (oseltamavir) does not have capacity to fill existing orders immediately. During an epidemic, antiviral agents, antibiotics and other medications may be rationed or not available to the most severely ill patients.

The WHO says that most developing countries will have no access to vaccines and antiviral drugs throughout a pandemic.

So the authors of the Spanish flu study believe blood product therapy has promising implications for the current situation.

The study has important limitations: the number of studies was small, the number of patients was small, and assignment to treatment or controls was not random, blinded or placebo-controlled; dosages and definitions were not standardized; disruptions caused by World War I probably affected medical personnel available to record data as well as exacerbated the spread of the disease; and wartime censorship may have affected publication of existing research. (The name "Spanish flu" came from the fact that Spain was not a partner in World War I and its press was freer to report details of the pandemic than press in combatant countries who did not want reveal information about deaths and sickness to enemies.)

The authors call for convening a body of experts "to consider H5N1 plasma therapy and to make recommendations for a research strategy and possibly treatment guidelines if therapy is required before the research is completed."

John J. Treanor, MD, says, in an accompanying editorial, that the idea that "passive serotherapy" might be useful in treating H5N1 virus infection has precedence in other viral diseases such as chicken pox, rabies and hepatitis A and B.

Treanor, of the infectious disease division of the University of Rochester Medical Center, identifies concerns with logistics, such as the ability to obtain, classify and prepare the blood materials in the midst of an outbreak, and missing information, such as whether people who recover from H5N1 infection actually develop high levels of an antibody or what is the most effective level of antibody or appropriate dose of plasma needed to achieve success in infected patients.

"Although many logistical hurdles exist, controlled clinical studies done now will probably pay a considerable dividend when the pandemic begins," Treanor says. "We can, should, and must explore these issues about serotherapy now, in advance of the pandemic."

American College of Physicians

---

---

	The Great Influenza: The Story of the Deadliest Pandemic in History by John M. Barry (Author) At the height of WWI, history’s most lethal influenza virus erupted in an army camp in Kansas, moved east with American troops, then exploded, killing as many as 100 million people worldwide. It killed more people in twenty-four months than AIDS killed in twenty-four years, more in a year than the Black Death killed in a century. But this was not the Middle Ages, and 1918 marked the first collision of science and epidemic disease. Magisterial in its breadth of perspective and depth of research and now revised to reflect the growing danger of the avian flu, The Great Influenza is ultimately a tale of triumph amid tragedy, which provides us with a precise and sobering model as we confront the epidemics looming on our own horizon. John M. Barry has written a new afterword for this edition...
	A Cruel Wind: Pandemic Flu in America 1918-1920 by Dorothy A. Pettit (Author) The flu pandemic that began in 1918 touched with illness virtually every family in America. It was a devastating time, far overshadowing the carnage of World War I as the pandemic killed more people in less time than any disease before or since. With 25% to 30% of the worlds population having clinically apparent illnesses and a mortality rate of 2.5% - 5%, it is believed that more than 675,000 Americans were among the 50-100 million that died worldwide. Because many experts believe that it is not a matter of if the world will encounter another 1918-like flu pandemic, but when, this social history of the pandemic should be considered essential reading for students, public health officials, doctors, nurses, journalists, and those in government office, interested in learning what workedand...
	Purple Death : The Mysterious Flu of 1918 by David Getz (Author), Peter McCarty (Illustrator) It was the worst epidemic in this country's history, and the search for its cause is still one of science's most urgent quests. It was 1918, the last year of World War 1. Thousands of men lived in the crowded army training camps that were scattered all across the United States. That spring, a strange flu struck the soldiers at a camp in the Midwest. Healthy young men went to the hospital complaining of sore throats and fevers. Within hours they had suffocated, their skin taking on a terrible purplish hue. The devastating flu spread like wildfire across the country, infecting soldiers and civilians alike. It killed more than half a million people in a matter of months, then disappeared as suddenly as it had come. To this day, no one knows what caused a common flu to...
	October Mourning: A Novel of the 1918 Spanish Flu Pandemic (Autographed) by James Rada Jr. (Author) In the midst of a World War, the true enemy was unseen. It came with a handshake or a breath and it left behind 40 million dead. In October 1918, World War I was winding down, but the world had yet to face the deadliest killer known. Spanish Flu would devastate the world. In Cumberland, Maryland, Dr. Alan Keener, a young doctor fresh from medical school, suspects the flu has reached Allegany County. He wants to take steps to prevent its spread, but he is met with resistance from old-school doctors who believe that the flu’s deadliness is overblown and easily treated. They soon learn differently as the flu begins to spread throughout the county. No one is safe from its effects. A street preacher named Kolas aids the flu’s spread....
	America's Forgotten Pandemic: The Influenza of 1918 by Alfred W. Crosby (Author) Between August 1918 and March 1919 the Spanish influenza spread worldwide, claiming over 25 million lives, more people than those perished in the fighting of the First World War. It proved fatal to at least a half-million Americans. Yet, the Spanish flu pandemic is largely forgotten today. In this vivid narrative, Alfred W. Crosby recounts the course of the pandemic during the panic-stricken months of 1918 and 1919, measures its impact on American society, and probes the curious loss of national memory of this cataclysmic event. In a new edition, with a new preface discussing the recent outbreaks of diseases, including the Asian flu and the SARS epidemic, America's Forgotten Pandemic remains both prescient and relevant. Alfred W. Crosby is a Professor Emeritus in American Studies,...
	Flu : The Story Of The Great Influenza Pandemic by Gina Kolata (Author) A scientific history of the Great Flu Epidemic of 1918, which killed at least 40 million people. The author details the science and latest understanding of flu, examines the chances of a great epidemic recurring and explores what can be done to prevent it.
	Dance with a Spanish Lady by eQuality Publishing On September 18, 1918, Dr. Nicholas Wareing attends an autopsy at Camp Upton Army Training Camp on a young private who has died from the influenza pandemic. As he leaves the camp to bike the three miles to Upton Train Station, he gets very ill with the grippe himself.
	The Children Set at the height of the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic, "The Children" was the lead story in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine's 70th Anniversary issue (September/October 2011). From "The Children": "The death wagon had turned onto her street. Ella knew, from nights watching through the attic window, that two men in rubber boots would climb from the wagon's benchlike seat. As their horses stomped and fussed, they'd bend over her. From above, she'd look like a rolled carpet or bundle of bedding. Each would pick up one end, then they'd stagger to the open back of the wagon. With a practiced swing or two, they'd hoist her onto the stack. Men had been doing this since the middle ages. And how was 1918 different than 1318? People were dragged away to prison for...
	Death And The Spanish Lady (An Eleanor Jones Mystery) by Pulp Fiction Press Melbourne, 1919. Death upon death. Nurses returned from the Great War are once again risking their lives, this time putting themselves in the firing line of a deadly disease: the Spanish ‘Flu. On the frontline is Sister Eleanor Jones. Her family torn by death and shell shock, Eleanor does what she can for the sick, among them the likeable Jimmy Cotton, in the temporary hospital hastily set up in the grand Melbourne Exhibition Building. But there is one death she cannot prevent. A death unlike all the others on the makeshift ward. Poison. Hiding behind the gauze masks designed to stop infection, someone is intent on adding to the death toll. When Jimmy Cotton disappears, Eleanor cannot help...
	Enza It is a time of innocence and prosperity. The Women’s Suffrage Movement gains more attention with each passing day. All across the country housewives and young ladies harbor hope that they might finally win the right to vote. Patriotism is at its peak as the war to end all wars rages an ocean away. On the homefront, in a small town in Michigan, life is being lived out like the pages of a Mark Twain novel. Until an unseen enemy, deadlier than any human adversary, threatens Mankind’s very existence. Elliot Owens – The only thing in the world that matters to Elliot is his wife and their five children, and he will do everything in his power to protect them. Daniel Pullman – When his plans to join the Army are dashed following an injury, meeting the...