 |
|
Researchers cast doubt on hypothesis that stigma fuels HIV epidemic
October 31, 2006The dominant view in the public health community is that the stigma of being HIV positive fuels the HIV epidemic, and yet there is a lack of evidence to support this view, say two researchers in a provocative essay in PLoS Medicine.
In a 2002 report, UNAIDS declared that the stigma associated with HIV was one of the "greatest barriers" to preventing new HIV infections and alleviating the impact of the disease. The standard argument for the link between HIV stigma and the global HIV epidemic, say Daniel Reidpath (Brunel University, UK) and Kit Yee Chan (Deakin University, Australia) is that stigma undermines HIV prevention efforts by making a person afraid to engage in safe behavior or seek testing for fear that these acts would themselves raise suspicion in the minds of others about the person's HIV status.
Reidpath and Chan say that there is no good evidence to support this argument. "To establish a causal link between HIV stigma and epidemic progression," they say, "requires longitudinal data on rates of infection and levels of HIV stigma. Weaker, but nonetheless potentially persuasive, evidence could also be found in an observed correlation between levels of HIV-related stigma and rates of HIV infection across contexts-such as between countries. Currently, no such evidence is available."
An alternative hypothesis, they say, is that stigma may in fact help to slow the epidemic. "It is plausible," they say, "that a social control mechanism, such as stigma, could reduce opportunities for contact between high- and low-risk groups."
"In writing this essay," say the authors, "our aim was neither to diminish the suffering of people living with AIDS in the eyes of the reader nor to advocate for the use of HIV stigma as a mechanism to control the spread of the epidemic. Our objective was to draw attention to the lack of evidence supporting the current dominant view on the relationship between stigma and the global spread of HIV."
Citation: Reidpath D, Chan KY (2006) HIV, sigma, and rates of infection: A rumor without evidence. PLoS Med 3(10): e435.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0030435
Public Library of Science
An alternative hypothesis, they say, is that stigma may in fact help to slow the epidemic. "It is plausible," they say, "that a social control mechanism, such as stigma, could reduce opportunities for contact between high- and low-risk groups."
"In writing this essay," say the authors, "our aim was neither to diminish the suffering of people living with AIDS in the eyes of the reader nor to advocate for the use of HIV stigma as a mechanism to control the spread of the epidemic. Our objective was to draw attention to the lack of evidence supporting the current dominant view on the relationship between stigma and the global spread of HIV."
Citation: Reidpath D, Chan KY (2006) HIV, sigma, and rates of infection: A rumor without evidence. PLoS Med 3(10): e435.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0030435
Public Library of Science
HIV Epidemic Current Events and HIV Epidemic News RSSUrbanization in Africa at dawn of 20th century marked outbreak of HIV
New research indicates that the most pervasive global strain of HIV began spreading among humans between 1884 and 1924, suggesting that growing urbanization in colonial Africa set the stage for the HIV/AIDS pandemic.
Climate change threats to HIV rates
Social factors, including economic pressures caused by climate change, could lead to an increase in HIV infection rates world-wide, warns a leading researcher from the University of New South Wales (UNSW).
U of M researchers develop new online tool in fight against spread of HIV
A new Web-based software program is the latest tool University of Minnesota researchers are using to help fight the spread of HIV. A multidisciplinary team of researchers led by Joseph Konstan, a professor in computer science and engineering, and B. R. Simon Rosser, a professor in the School of Public Health, are embarking on a clinical trial this month to test a software program that aims to reduce risk-taking behavior associated with the spread of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections.
Different HIV rates among gay men and straight people not fully explained by sexual behavior
Differences in sexual behaviours do not fully explain why the US HIV epidemic affects gay men so much more than straight men and women, claims research published ahead of print in the journal Sexually Transmitted Infections.
High-risk behaviors could lead to HIV epidemic in Afghanistan
In a report that is among the first to describe the prevalence of HIV and Hepatitis B and C viruses in Afghanistan, a researcher from the University of California, San Diego (UCSD) School of Medicine voiced concerns that increasing injection drug use and accompanying high-risk behavior could lead to an HIV epidemic in Afghanistan.
Male circumcision for HIV prevention and more
Three clinical trials in Africa found that adult male circumcision reduced the risk of men acquiring HIV infection from heterosexual sex by 51-60%.
Heavy drinking can hasten the progression of the simian immunodeficiency virus disease
Alcohol abuse can impair a person's immune system, leading to infections like pneumonia. Alcohol abuse is also more common among individuals already infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) than among the population as a whole.
How HIV 'exhausts' killer T cells
American and South African scientists working at the epicenter of the AIDS epidemic in South Africa have discovered how the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) "exhausts" killer T cells that would otherwise attack the virus.
Researchers seek to solve mystery of natural HIV control
An international, multi-institutional research consortium is seeking to discover how a few HIV-infected individuals are naturally able to suppress replication of the virus.
AIDS research agenda proposed
In an Editorial Review published in the current issue of AIDS (2006,20,7, 1-5), HIV researchers from Argentina, Australia, South Africa, and the United States address the challenging question of the impact of major social, ecological, political, economic, biomedical, viral, and other changes on the HIV epidemic and the world's ability to respond.
More HIV Epidemic Current Events and HIV Epidemic News Articles
 | In the Shadow of the Epidemic: Being HIV-Negative in the Age of AIDS (Series Q) by Walt Odets For gay men who are HIV-negative in a community devastated by AIDS, survival may be a matter of grief, guilt, anxiety, and isolation. In the Shadow of the Epidemic is a passionate and intimate look at the emotional and psychological impact of AIDS on the lives of the survivors of the epidemic, those who must face on a regular basis the death of friends and, in some cases, the decimation of their... |
 | Dawning Answers: How the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Has Helped to Strengthen Public Health (Medicine) Dawning Answers charts the legacy of the global HIV/AIDS epidemic to the theory and practice of public health. Richly detailed chapters describe how advances in techniques and startegies to monitor health events, develop public policy, set funding priorities, mobilize communities, support the adoption of safer behaviors, ensure access to needed prevention and treatment services, and involve... |
| When Communities Assess their AIDS Epidemics: Results of Rapid Assessment of HIV/AIDS in Eleven U.S. Cities by Benjamin Bowser iWhen Communities Assess their AIDS Epidemicsi is a detailed ethnographic description of the AIDS epidemic in ten U.S. cities and the U.S. Virgin... | |
 | Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic by Neill McKee, Jane Bertrand, Antje Becker-Benton This book promotes the use of strategic communication to fight against the HIV/AIDS epidemic. Focusing on strategic communication for positive and measurable behaviour change, the authors elaborate on a wide range of issues including: the importance of advocacy and community mobilization; comprehensive approaches to prevention and the use of communication in reducing stigma; communication... |
 | Women, Families and HIV/AIDS: A Sociological Perspective on the Epidemic in America by Carole A. Campbell Carole Campbell examines the position of women in the AIDS epidemic (women living with HIV, and women caring for HIV-infected family members) in a sociocultural context. Campbell draws a connection among women's risk of AIDS, gender roles (particularly adolescent gender role socialization), and male sexual behavior, demonstrating that efforts to contain the spread of the disease to females must... |
 | Scientific Errors and Controversies in the U.S. HIV/AIDS Epidemic: How They Slowed Advances and Were Resolved by Scott D. Holmberg Our understanding, prevention, and treatment of HIV have made remarkable strides in the past two decades, but the way has not been smooth or straight. Part history, part narrative, and mainly "scientific autopsy," this book is an insider's account of the errors, controversies, and corrections that have marked the first 25 years of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in the United States. The author discusses... |
 | Encyclopedia of AIDS: A Social, Political, Cultural, and Scientific Record of the HIV Epidemic by Raymond Smith The Encyclopedia of AIDS covers all major aspects of the first 15 years of the AIDS epidemic, including the breakthroughs in treatment announced at the International AIDS Conference in July 1996. The encyclopedia provides extensive coverage of major topics in eight areas: basic science and epidemiology; transmission and prevention; pathology and treatment; impacted populations; policy and law;... |
 | AIDS, Identity, and Community: The HIV Epidemic and Lesbians and Gay Men (Psychological Perspectives on Lesbian & Gay Issues) "HIV alters the lives of anyone that it touches, whether they are gay or straight. This book looks at all of the aspects of how HIV/AIDS has altered the lives of those it touches. . . . The titles of the 12 chapters give an excellent overview of what is covered in these extremely well-written reports. . . . This is a must-read book for everyone. It should be in all libraries, including school... |
 | Deterministic And Stochastic Models Of Aids Epidemics And Hiv Infections With Intervention by Tan Wai-Yuan; Hulin Wu With contributions from an international team of leading researchers, the book pulls together updated research results in the area of HIV/AIDS modeling to provide readers with the latest information in the field. Topics covered include: AIDS epidemic models; vaccine models; models for HIV/cell dynamics and interactions; cellular kinetics; viral dynamics with antiviral treatments; modeling of drug... |
 | Organizing Aids: Workplace and Organizational Responses to the HIV/AIDS Epidemic (Social Aspects of Aids) by David Goss It has been estimated that 90% of those who are HIV positive are in employment. This text provides a historical and international review of the theoretical and practical issues which bear upon organisational responses to... |
| © 2008 BrightSurf.com |