Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later
Slashdot It! Slashdot Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later
Submit to Reddit Submit Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later to Reddit
Reading: Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money laterTwitter This Reading: Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money laterTwitter Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later
Add to Facebook Add Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later to Facebook

Cost-benefit analysis: Combo treatment costs more, saves money later

November 08, 2006

From a health insurer's perspective, the most effective cancer treatment may also be the most cost-effective, according to a new study sponsored by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG 91-11).

Compared to higher-priced combination treatments, the least expensive, single-modality cancer treatment may cost more in the long run because of the costs associated with treating complications and recurrence of cancer, said lead author Andre A. Konski, M.D., M.B.A., M.A., a radiation oncologist and director of clinical research in Fox Chase Cancer Center's radiation oncology department. Konski presented the results today at the 48th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology in Philadelphia.




The study examined costs for patients with Medicare insurance who had taken part in an RTOG clinical trial, #9111, for locally advanced laryngeal cancer between 1991 and 1996. That randomized phase III trial was designed to compare three treatment regimens-two combining radiation therapy and chemotherapy and one using only radiation therapy.

"In overall survival rates, there was no significant difference among the three treatment arms," Konski pointed out. "However, patients receiving induction chemotherapy as well as radiation or concurrent chemo-radiation therapy had better outcomes in terms of disease-free survival, local and regional control and preservation of their larynx.

"In our subsequent economic analysis," Konski explained, "these better outcomes translated into significant savings of dollars that were spent on treating patients for complications and recurrences that occurred with the less effective therapy of radiation by itself."

The specific aim of the new RTOG cost-benefit analysis was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the combination chemotherapy and radiation treatments compared to radiation therapy alone as viewed from the payer's perspective. Of the 547 patients who took part in RTOG 9111, Medicare cost data and clinical outcomes for 47 months were available for 66 patients.

Data included Medicare Part A and Part B costs from all providers-inpatient, outpatient, skilled nursing facility, home health care, hospice and physicians. The RTOG researchers calculated expected costs for the 47-month period for each arm of the trial, based on average estimates of survival probabilities and mean monthly costs for each month.

Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were calculated as savings per life year in terms of overall survival and in terms of disease-free life years. Calculations were in 1996 dollars with the standard annual discount rate of 3 percent.

"Although radiation alone costs less in and of itself, the expected mean 47-month cost of that treatment was $57,357-compared to the two treatment arms that included chemotherapy," Konski said. "Concurrent chemo-radiation cost a little more $57,870, and represented an incremental increase of $697 per life year of overall survival and $2,048 per disease-free life year."

"Induction chemotherapy plus radiation therapy was the most cost-effective," Konski concluded. "At a 47-month cost of $49,018, this treatment saved $7,031 per disease free and $9336 per life year of total survival.\\\

Fox Chase Cancer Center





Science News and Science Current Events Tag Cloud
This tag cloud is a visual representation of term frequencies of random science news topics with common terms grouped together and emphasized by their display size.
Hormone Therapy   Hibernation   Drugs   Insomnia   Pneumococcal Disease   Hypoxia   Atmosphere   Liver Transplant   Drug Addiction   Medication   Snowmelt   Psychotherapy   Signaling Pathway   Alcohol Addiction   Delirium   Angiogenesis   Diabetes   Second-hand Smoke   Fruit Flies   Gecko   Selenium   Lead Exposure   Organic Matter   Brain Imaging   Cervical Cancer  
Related Cancer Treatment Current Events and Cancer Treatment News Articles Cancer Treatment Current Events and Cancer Treatment News RSS Cancer Treatment Current Events and Cancer Treatment News RSS
Study shows PET can measure effectiveness of novel breast cancer treatment
A new study published in the July issue of The Journal of Nuclear Medicine shows that positron emission tomography (PET) scans in mice can be used to determine whether a novel type of breast cancer treatment is working as intended.

Cancer survivors at greater risk of birth complications; special monitoring needed
Survivors of childhood cancer run particular risks when pregnant and should be closely monitored.

BRIT1 allows DNA repair teams access to damaged sites
Like a mechanic popping the hood of a car to get at a faulty engine, a tumor-suppressing protein allows cellular repair mechanisms to pounce on damaged DNA by overcoming a barrier to DNA access.

NIST discovers how strain at grain boundaries suppresses high-temperature superconductivity
Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) have discovered that a reduction in mechanical strain at the boundaries of crystal grains can significantly improve the performance of high-temperature superconductors (HTS).

UCF researcher's nanoparticles could someday lead to end of chemotherapy
Nanoparticles specially engineered by University of Central Florida Assistant Professor J. Manuel Perez and his colleagues could someday target and destroy tumors, sparing patients from toxic, whole-body chemotherapies.

Novel light-sensitive compounds show promise for cancer therapy
Chemists at the University of California, Santa Cruz, have developed novel compounds that show promise for photodynamic cancer therapy, which uses light-activated drugs to kill tumor cells.

New Approach for Treating Recurrent Prostate Cancer on the Horizon
A new study shows that an alpha-particle emitting radiopeptide-radioactive material bound to a synthetic peptide, a component of protein-is effective for treating prostate cancer in mice.

Many breast cancer patients take high doses of antioxidants despite possible consequences
A new study finds that many women with breast cancer take antioxidant supplements while undergoing cancer treatment, even though the consequences of doing so are unknown.

Defeating nicotine's double role in lung cancer
A lung cancer treatment that inhibits nicotine receptors was shown to double survival time in mice, according to Italian researchers.

Many breast cancer patients take high doses of antioxidants despite possible consequences
A new study finds that many women with breast cancer take antioxidant supplements while undergoing cancer treatment, even though the consequences of doing so are unknown.
More Cancer Treatment Current Events and Cancer Treatment News Articles
Outsmart Your Cancer: Alternative Non-Toxic Treatments That Work

Outsmart Your Cancer: Alternative Non-Toxic Treatments That Work
by Tanya Harter Pierce (Author)

When you "OUTSMART" your cancer, only the cancer cells die - not your healthy cells! In writing "Outsmart Your Cancer: Alternative Non-Toxic Treatments That Work", Tanya Harter Pierce interviewed scores of people who outsmarted their cancer and went on to live normal healthy lives. Read their real-life stories and how they completely recovered from lung, breast, prostate, colon, kidney, brain, bone, pancreatic, lymphatic, and other types of cancer using non-toxic approaches! In an easy-to-understand conversational style, this book also explains the sound scientific reasons for the successes of alternative cancer therapies.

After Cancer Treatment: Heal Faster, Better, Stronger

After Cancer Treatment: Heal Faster, Better, Stronger
by The Johns Hopkins University Press

At age 36, Julie Silver was enjoying an exciting career as a physician at the Harvard Medical School and a rewarding personal life as a mother, wife, and award-winning writer. But she had the sense that something was wrong. Two years and multiple doctors later, she was diagnosed with the breast cancer she had suspected all along and was catapulted into the role of cancer patient.

Like many cancer patients who experience serious side effects from treatment, Dr. Silver emerged from therapy feeling not better, but exhausted and physically devastated. As she worked to heal herself, she became determined to write a book to help others recover after cancer treatment.

Here Dr. Silver shares her own cancer journey and offers a step-by-step plan for physical healing, including...

Breast Cancer: Risks and Prevention, Diagnosis & Treatments

Breast Cancer: Risks and Prevention, Diagnosis & Treatments

What are the risk factors for breast cancer and what decisions will a woman need to make on the basis of an abnormal mammogram result or a diagnosis of breast cancer?

This product is manufactured on demand using DVD-R recordable media. Amazon.com's standard return policy will apply.

Relaxation, Imagery and Meditation: Healing Practices to Complement Cancer Treatment

Relaxation, Imagery and Meditation: Healing Practices to Complement Cancer Treatment
by Carolyn McManus



Hypnosis Support for Cancer Treatment

Hypnosis Support for Cancer Treatment
by Gwen Randall-Young



After Cancer Treatment: Heal Faster, Better, Stronger (A Johns Hopkins Press Health Book)

After Cancer Treatment: Heal Faster, Better, Stronger (A Johns Hopkins Press Health Book)
by Julie K. Silver MD (Author)

At age 36, Julie Silver was enjoying an exciting career as a physician at the Harvard Medical School and a rewarding personal life as a mother, wife, and award-winning writer. But she had the sense that something was wrong. Two years and multiple doctors later, she was diagnosed with the breast cancer she had suspected all along and was catapulted into the role of cancer patient.

Like many cancer patients who experience serious side effects from treatment, Dr. Silver emerged from therapy feeling not better, but exhausted and physically devastated. As she worked to heal herself, she became determined to write a book to help others recover after cancer treatment.

Here Dr. Silver shares her own cancer journey and offers a step-by-step plan for physical healing, including...

  Options in the Treatment of Breast Cancer [VHS]
Starring: B. Elliot Grysen M.D. J.D.
Directed By: B. Elliot Grysen M.D. J.D.
Also With: B. Elliot Grysen M.D. J.D. (Primary Contributor)

This video production is based on the counseling sessions used by Dr. Mark Campbell to explain to his patients what breast cancer treatment options are available. These sessions have been widely acclaimed by patients and cancer support groups and now have been recorded and edited to present the same information to other patients and their families.

Chem / Rad Support - Two for one Sale! Dr. Kang's formula to counteract the side effects of chemotherapy and radiation therapy in the treatment of cancer. Limited time offer.

Chem / Rad Support - Two for one Sale! Dr. Kang's formula to counteract the side effects of chemotherapy and radiation therapy in the treatment of cancer. Limited time offer.
by Trilight,Inc.

The Western scientific treatments of choice for cancer include surgery, chemotherapy and radiation. The side-effects of chemotherapy and radiation include extreme fatigue, loss of appetite, nausea and vomiting. This formula in part targets these side effects and helps the patient endure the treatment as well as recover from the side-effects as quickly as possible. A second aspect of this formula addresses the immune system. From the Western scientific perspective the part of the immune system that targets cancer includes the activation of T cytotoxic cells (T killer cells). These cells are activated by the immune system and have receptors specific for cancer cells. Once activated T cytotoxic cells lyse tumor cells as well as individual cancer cells that have metasta.

This TCM...

Maximum Intenational Maximize Graviola 750, 750mg Graviola, 100 Veggie Caps

Maximum Intenational Maximize Graviola 750, 750mg Graviola, 100 Veggie Caps
by Maximum International

Having attracted worldwide interest as an inhibitor of malignant cell growth, this remarkable Amazonian herb has been studied in more than 20 laboratory tests for its anti-tumor and cell protective qualities. The best Graviola on the market. Maximum Int'l. is the company with the most potent products available. Lab tested to make sure the ingredients are of the most superior quality and highes quality raw materials available. This product is manufactured in an FDA inspected and GMP certified facility. Quality is guaranteed.

Breast Cancer: Treatment

Breast Cancer: Treatment
by GeneEd E-Learning

Breast cancer is the most common form of cancer in North American women. Although the incidence of breast cancer has been increasing every year, early screening programs in some countries have reduced the number of deaths caused by breast cancer. This course introduces the indicators used to determine patient prognosis, discusses the treatments available to breast cancer patients, and explains how certain treatments are applicable to specific stages of breast cancer. eTextBooks from GeneEd are self-paced, multimedia courses designed for nurses (RNs), doctors (MDs and PhDs), clinical research associates (CRAs and monitors), clinical research coordinators (CRCs), investigators, researchers, other healthcare professionals, and patients. Accreditation: GeneEd designates this educational...

© 2009 BrightSurf.com