First molecular simulation of a long DNA strand shows unexpected flexibility

RSS Feeds

Virginia Tech researchers used novel methodology and the university's System X supercomputer to carry out what is probably the first simulation that explores full range of motions of a DNA strand of 147 base pairs, the length that is required to form the fundamental unit of DNA packing in the living cells - the nucleosome. Contrary to a long-held belief that DNA is hard to bend, the simulation shows in crisp atomic detail that DNA is considerably more flexible than commonly thought.

The research is published in the December issue of the Biophysical Journal, in the article "A Computational Study of Nucleosomal DNA Flexibility," by Jory Zmuda Ruscio of Leesburg, Va., a Ph.D. student in the Genetics, Bioinformatics and Computational Biology Program at Virginia Tech, and Alexey Onufriev of Blacksburg, assistant professor of computer sciences and physics at Virginia Tech. They have been invited to do a platform presentation at the 51st Biophysical Society Annual Meeting in Baltimore in March.

There is about 12 feet of DNA in a human cell but it is packaged into nucleosomes - lengths of 147 base pairs each wrapped around eight special proteins. A nucleosome looks kind of like the lumpy beginning of a rubber-band ball. Or maybe more like a lumpy worm coil. Uncoiled, the worm wiggles, flexes, and even kinks, according to a simulation performed on System X.

As we know from watching forensic detective shows on TV, the DNA in all of an individual's cells is identical. The DNA in fingernail cells is exactly the same as in muscle. Yet the cells are different. "This is because, roughly speaking, the DNA in different cell types is packed differently and the complexes it forms with the surrounding proteins are in different positions, so only the relevant part of the code can be read at a time," said Onufriev. "Although nobody knows exactly how it happens, you can imagine reading only what you can see on a part of a crumpled newspaper."

The traditional view is that DNA is relatively rigid and that considerable energy is required when it needs to be bent to form protein-DNA complexes. However, recent experiments (Nature, Aug. 17, 2006) have begun to challenge that view. "The famous double-helix may be much more flexible than previously thought," said Onufriev.

The Virginia Tech research responded to this debate. Using 128 of System X's 1,100 processors, the research resulted in a System X movie revealing DNA wiggling like a worm, showing greater flexibility than expected from the traditional view. The DNA packing in the nucleosome is also found to be surprisingly loose. "The implication is that it may not cost much energy to bend the DNA - even to bend sharply," said Onufriev.

The methodology that is making it possible is based on the so-called "implicit solvent" approach being developed by Onufriev. "Biology does not happen in a vacuum," he said. "We are 75 percent water, and the effect of the water environment must be taken into account when studying biomolecules."

Previous simulations were often slowed because they accounted for the water that is present in living systems. For instance, in early studies of protein folding, only a few percent of the computing effort was being spent on the activity of the protein while the rest accounted for the activity of the surrounding fluids. The "implicit solvent" approach accounts for the role of water on average, but the movements of individual water molecules are not predicted, freeing computation capacity for simulation of whatever protein is being studied.

"Experiment cannot always probe atomic detail of living molecules because they are too small and often move too fast, said Onufriev. "But we can combine computational power with good algorithms to simulate these motions at high (atom-scale) resolution.

"It is an exciting time to do molecular modeling," he said. "The computing power and the methodology have come to the point that we can begin to fully probe biology on timescales very relevant to living things - such as DNA packing."

Virginia Tech's System X supercomputer was critical to this research, he said. "It was the combination of its sheer compute power with the algorithmic advantages that made it possible to run molecular simulations on that scale."

So far, the Virginia Tech research team addressed the question of how flexible the DNA is, which is only a small piece of the "second part of the genetic code" puzzle, Onufriev said. "However, this small piece should pave the way to addressing bigger questions, such as 'Exactly how is the tightly packed genetic content read by cellular machines"'"

"Atomic level simulations can complement experimentation and narrow competing theories," said Onufriev. "For systems as large as the nucleosome, simulations using virtual water may be the only practical way to estimate the stability of various confirmations," he said.

How DNA bends and flexes is critical for many cellular processes including cell differentiation and DNA replication. Although also observed in recent experiments, this unusual DNA flexibility is still unexplained. "Now seeing that DNA is not as hard to bend may lead to radical changes in our perspective," said Onufriev. "We are using these detailed pictures to see exactly how DNA bends and to understand the details of the mechanism behind it, something that is very hard or impossible to do experimentally.\\\

Virginia Tech