 |
|
Second SPORT Study Shows Surgery Advantage for Spinal Stenosis and Slipped Vertebra
May 31, 2007Dartmouth-led Study Results Show Clear Surgery Advantage
Hanover, NH - In one of the three most common back conditions for which patients seek treatment, surgery proved to have substantially better results than non-surgical remedies, according to Dartmouth-led research published in the May 31 New England Journal of Medicine. The paper is the second in a series detailing the findings of the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial (SPORT), a seven-year, $21 million national study funded by the National Institutes of Health.
In cases of degenerative spondylolisthesis with spinal stenosis, a condition that affects six times as many women as men and is especially prevalent among African-American women, surgery was twice as effective as non-surgical approaches in reducing pain and restoring functionality for patients.
This publication follows the release of earlier SPORT findings in November, which looked at patients seeking treatment for disk herniation with sciatica. For that condition, the difference in outcomes between the surgical and non-operative groups was less.
"The SPORT study was undertaken with one purpose in mind: to give physicians and patients solid information that would allow them to make informed choices when faced with a decision of how to treat their back condition," said lead author Dr. James N. Weinstein, professor and chair of orthopaedics at Dartmouth Medical School and Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center.
Although back surgeries are among the most common surgical procedures performed in the United States, until SPORT, there had been only a few very small controlled trials to gauge their effectiveness.
Degenerative spondylolisthesis (DS) is the forward slippage of one lumbar vertebra on the one below it. It generally occurs after age 50. It is not clear why it occurs more often in African-American women. Although DS alone generally causes no symptoms, in some cases it can result in spinal stenosis--narrowing of the spinal canal which causes pressure on the nerves--resulting in significant pain in the legs that is worsened by simply taking a walk.
SPORT followed 601 patients diagnosed with DS and symptomatic spinal stenosis. Of those, 372 received surgery within two years and 235 remained non-operative. Two years after enrollment in the trial, while non-operative patients reported only modest improvement in their condition, patients who had surgery reported significantly reduced pain and improved functionality. Surgical patients saw relief from symptoms fairly quickly, reporting major improvements as early as six weeks after their operation.
Non-operative treatments included physical therapy, steroid injections, and medicines to relieve pain. Surgery involved relieving pressure on the nerves through removal of bone and soft tissue in a procedure called a decompressive laminectomy.
"As a surgeon, it's very important to me that I have evidence that I can share with my patients as they are trying to decide how to proceed with treatment," Weinstein said. "Up until now, we suspected surgery produced better results, but we had little objective data to support that. With the results of this study, we can now discuss much more fully the surgical and non-surgical options available to our patients so that they can make an informed choice."
Although the study was designed to look at a randomized and an observational cohort, fully 40 percent of participants who had been randomized changed their minds after enrollment in the trial and switched to the other group, i.e. choosing to have surgery after being randomized to the non-operative group, or deciding to proceed non-surgically after being randomized to the surgical group. As a result of the substantial crossover between surgical and non-surgical groups in the randomized cohort, the authors chose to publish the results based on what treatment was actually received in each group. While this is not a randomized comparison, the analysis carefully controlled for differences that existed between the two groups at the outset.
The third major SPORT study, on the effectiveness of surgery vs. non-surgical options for spinal stenosis without any spondylolisthesis, is expected to be released later this year. Additional papers based on the wealth of data gathered from the entire SPORT process will be published over the next several months.
Co-authors on the DS article were Jon D. Lurie MD MS; Tor Tosteson ScD; Brett Hanscom MS; Anna N.A. Tosteson ScD; Emily A. Blood MS; Nancy J.O. Birkmeyer PhD; Alan S. Hilibrand MD; Harry N. Herkowitz MD; Frank P. Cammisa MD; Todd Albert MD; Sanford E. Emery MD MBA; Lawrence G. Lenke MD; William A. Abdu MD MS; Michael Longley MD; Thomas J. Errico MD; and Serena Hu MD.
Centers enrolling patients in the study in addition to Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center were: Wm. Beaumont Hospital, Royal Ok, MI; Emory University, Atlanta; NYU/Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York; Hospital for Special Surgery, New York; Kaiser Permanente, Oakland, CA; Nebraska Foundation for Spinal Research, Omaha; Rothman Institute at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, Philadelphia; Rush Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center, Chicago; University of California, San Francisco; University Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western Reserve University, OH; Washington University, St. Louis; Maine Spine and Rehabilitation, Scarborough.
For more information, go to: http://www.dartmouth.edu/sport-trial
Dartmouth Medical School
This publication follows the release of earlier SPORT findings in November, which looked at patients seeking treatment for disk herniation with sciatica. For that condition, the difference in outcomes between the surgical and non-operative groups was less.
"The SPORT study was undertaken with one purpose in mind: to give physicians and patients solid information that would allow them to make informed choices when faced with a decision of how to treat their back condition," said lead author Dr. James N. Weinstein, professor and chair of orthopaedics at Dartmouth Medical School and Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center.
Although back surgeries are among the most common surgical procedures performed in the United States, until SPORT, there had been only a few very small controlled trials to gauge their effectiveness.
Degenerative spondylolisthesis (DS) is the forward slippage of one lumbar vertebra on the one below it. It generally occurs after age 50. It is not clear why it occurs more often in African-American women. Although DS alone generally causes no symptoms, in some cases it can result in spinal stenosis--narrowing of the spinal canal which causes pressure on the nerves--resulting in significant pain in the legs that is worsened by simply taking a walk.
SPORT followed 601 patients diagnosed with DS and symptomatic spinal stenosis. Of those, 372 received surgery within two years and 235 remained non-operative. Two years after enrollment in the trial, while non-operative patients reported only modest improvement in their condition, patients who had surgery reported significantly reduced pain and improved functionality. Surgical patients saw relief from symptoms fairly quickly, reporting major improvements as early as six weeks after their operation.
Non-operative treatments included physical therapy, steroid injections, and medicines to relieve pain. Surgery involved relieving pressure on the nerves through removal of bone and soft tissue in a procedure called a decompressive laminectomy.
"As a surgeon, it's very important to me that I have evidence that I can share with my patients as they are trying to decide how to proceed with treatment," Weinstein said. "Up until now, we suspected surgery produced better results, but we had little objective data to support that. With the results of this study, we can now discuss much more fully the surgical and non-surgical options available to our patients so that they can make an informed choice."
Although the study was designed to look at a randomized and an observational cohort, fully 40 percent of participants who had been randomized changed their minds after enrollment in the trial and switched to the other group, i.e. choosing to have surgery after being randomized to the non-operative group, or deciding to proceed non-surgically after being randomized to the surgical group. As a result of the substantial crossover between surgical and non-surgical groups in the randomized cohort, the authors chose to publish the results based on what treatment was actually received in each group. While this is not a randomized comparison, the analysis carefully controlled for differences that existed between the two groups at the outset.
The third major SPORT study, on the effectiveness of surgery vs. non-surgical options for spinal stenosis without any spondylolisthesis, is expected to be released later this year. Additional papers based on the wealth of data gathered from the entire SPORT process will be published over the next several months.
Co-authors on the DS article were Jon D. Lurie MD MS; Tor Tosteson ScD; Brett Hanscom MS; Anna N.A. Tosteson ScD; Emily A. Blood MS; Nancy J.O. Birkmeyer PhD; Alan S. Hilibrand MD; Harry N. Herkowitz MD; Frank P. Cammisa MD; Todd Albert MD; Sanford E. Emery MD MBA; Lawrence G. Lenke MD; William A. Abdu MD MS; Michael Longley MD; Thomas J. Errico MD; and Serena Hu MD.
Centers enrolling patients in the study in addition to Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center were: Wm. Beaumont Hospital, Royal Ok, MI; Emory University, Atlanta; NYU/Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York; Hospital for Special Surgery, New York; Kaiser Permanente, Oakland, CA; Nebraska Foundation for Spinal Research, Omaha; Rothman Institute at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, Philadelphia; Rush Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center, Chicago; University of California, San Francisco; University Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western Reserve University, OH; Washington University, St. Louis; Maine Spine and Rehabilitation, Scarborough.
For more information, go to: http://www.dartmouth.edu/sport-trial
Dartmouth Medical School
American Pain Society's low back guideline expanded to cover interventional procedures
For low-back pain patients and their doctors, the American Pain Society, www.ampainsoc.org, said today it is expanding its evidence-based, clinical practice guideline on diagnosis and treatment of chronic low back pain to include recommendations on surgery and other interventional treatments.
Study Find Spine Surgery Yield Greater Benefits over Nonsurgical Treatments
A research study by orthopedic spine, back and neck surgeon at Rush University Medical Center Dr. Howard An and colleagues found that patients who underwent surgery for spinal stenosis showed significantly more improvement in all primary outcomes than did patients who were treated nonsurgically.
New Treatment Guidelines For Low Back Pain
A summary of evidence on the diagnosis and treatment of low-back pain has prompted the American Pain Society (ASP) and the American College of Physicians (ACP) to issue a new treatment guideline.
Elderly spinal cord injuries increase five-fold in 30 years, Jefferson neurosurgeons find
The number of spinal cord injuries among senior citizens (age 70 and above) has increased five times in the past 30 years, as compared with younger spinal cord injury patients, researchers at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital and Jefferson's Regional Spinal Cord Injury Center of the Delaware Valley recently reported.
Spacer insertion may offer less invasive option for lumbar problems
Implanting a small spacer between lumbar vertebrae during a procedure called interspinous process decompression may be an effective and minimally invasive way to treat spinal stenosis, according to a new report.
More Spinal Stenosis Current Events and Spinal Stenosis News Articles
 | Conquer Back and Neck Pain: Walk It Off! A Spine Doctor'sProven Solutions For Finding Relief Without Pills or Surgery by Mark Brown Every human being suffers from back pain at some point in life. In an effort to find relief, people turn to a wide variety of treatments, and to doctors who will prescribe narcotic painkillers. What they don t realize is that many of these treatments -- especially narcotic drugs -- actually interfere with their body s own ability to heal and overcome pain. When these treatments fail to help, they... |
 | The Official Patient's Sourcebook on Spinal Stenosis This book has been created for patients who have decided to make education and research an integral part of the treatment process. Although it also gives information useful to doctors, caregivers and other health professionals, it tells patients where and how to look for information covering virtually all topics related to spinal stenosis (also Cervical Spinal Stenosis; Degenerative Lumbar Spinal... |
 | Lumbar Spinal Stenosis Centenary Clinic, Antwerp, Belgium. Comprehensive and illustrated text presenting basic sciences, clinical presentation, physiopathology, and diagnosis, to conservative and surgical treatment modalities. Also discusses economic and ethical considerations and management of LSS. For clinicians, researchers, and manipulation therapists. DNLM: Spinal... |
 | 21st Century Complete Medical Guide to Spinal Cord Diseases, Injuries, and Spinal Stenosis: Authoritative Government Documents, Clinical References, and ... for Patients and Physicians (CD-ROM) by PM Medical Health News This up-to-date electronic book on CD-ROM provides the best collection available anywhere of official Federal government information and documents on the subject of spinal cord disorders. This CD-ROM uses next-generation search technology that allows complete indexing and makes all files on the disc fully searchable. For patients, practical information is provided in clearly written patient... |
| Lumbar Spinal Stenosis by Gunnar B. J. Andersson, Thomas W. McNeill | |
 | Spinal Stenosis - A Medical Dictionary, Bibliography, and Annotated Research Guide to Internet References by ICON Health Publications In March 2001, the National Institutes of Health issued the following warning: "The number of Web sites offering health-related resources grows every day. Many sites provide valuable information, while others may have information that is unreliable or misleading." Furthermore, because of the rapid increase in Internet-based information, many hours can be wasted searching, selecting, and... |
| CLINICAL ORTHOPAEDICS AND RELATED RESEARCH NUMBER 115 MARCH APRIL 1976 SPINAL STENOSIS by J.B. Lipppincott | |
| Gale Encyclopedia of Medicine: Spinal stenosis by John T. Lohr PhD The article is excerpted from Gale Encyclopedia of Medicine. Consult the second edition of this authoritative, comprehensive, in-depth medical guide for information on more than 1,700 medical topics in language accessible to adult laypersons. Presented in a single alphabetical sequence, articles range in length from one or two paragraphs for minor topics, to several pages or more for major... | |
| Neurapraxia, "stingers," and spinal stenosis in athletes.(Featured CME Topic: Sports Medicine): An article from: Southern Medical Journal by Steve Page, Jeffrey A. Guy This digital document is an article from Southern Medical Journal, published by Southern Medical Association on August 1, 2004. The length of the article is 2652 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.Citation... | |
| Lumbar Spinal Stenosis by Thomas W. McNeill |
| © 2008 BrightSurf.com |