 |
|
Pioneering study catalogs ethical issues of scientific research in developing world
September 11, 2007The first comprehensive examination of the ethical, social and cultural (ESC) challenges faced by major science programs in developing countries has identified a complex assortment of issues with the potential to slow critical global health research if left unaddressed.
The findings are published in this week's PLoS Medicine.
The challenges range from problems such as government corruption to questions surrounding community and public engagement, cultural acceptability, and gender.
Professor Peter Singer (Senior Scientist, McLaughlin-Rotman Centre for Global Health, University of Toronto) and colleagues conducted 70 interviews with academics, government officials, and NGO and private sector experts from developing countries. The study team pinpointed 13 ESC issues of concern for major science programs, including:
* community engagement-developing world experts stressed the need for researchers to create opportunities to listen to and understand the concerns and interests of the communities in which they work
* cultural acceptability- the experts identified several examples of technologies now in development that could face cultural barriers, including intravaginal and aerosolized vaccines and nutritionally enhanced foods that look different from traditional varieties
* gender-in many developing countries, according to the experts interviewed, culturally-ingrained discrimination limits women's opportunities to make contributions in science and health and advocate for their needs
* affordability-many new technologies will need to be donated or heavily subsidized to reach those in need, many of them living on less than a dollar a day
* corruption and poor governance-some developing world experts said that with the power to approve new technologies resting solely with governments and little transparency in those approval processes, political considerations often trump public health care.
"Concurrent with the rapid growth of scientific research in developing countries, there are more reports of projects that face challenges related to ethical, cultural and social concerns," said Professor Singer. "Our goal was to anticipate issues that could be faced by such programs and try to prevent them as this important work moves forward."
The McLaughlin-Rotman Centre team has supplemented its ESC investigation with three separate reports, also published in PLoS Medicine. The first discusses the team's work as an ESC Advisory Service to the Grand Challenges in Global Health (GCGH) Initiative (http://www.gcgh.org/channels/gcgh), funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which offered 44 grants totaling $450 million for a broad range of innovative research projects involving scientists in 33 countries. The second and third papers focus on engaging communities and civil society organizations (CSOs) in biomedical research in developing countries.
"This is the first time ethical, social, and cultural counsel has been engaged on a large scale to provide advice in a systematic way on these issues in a developing world context," says study co-author Dr. Jerome Singh of Centre for the AIDS Program of Research (CAPRISA) in Durban, South Africa, and a co-leader of the GCGH ESC advisory service.
Public Library of Science
Professor Peter Singer (Senior Scientist, McLaughlin-Rotman Centre for Global Health, University of Toronto) and colleagues conducted 70 interviews with academics, government officials, and NGO and private sector experts from developing countries. The study team pinpointed 13 ESC issues of concern for major science programs, including:
* community engagement-developing world experts stressed the need for researchers to create opportunities to listen to and understand the concerns and interests of the communities in which they work
* cultural acceptability- the experts identified several examples of technologies now in development that could face cultural barriers, including intravaginal and aerosolized vaccines and nutritionally enhanced foods that look different from traditional varieties
* gender-in many developing countries, according to the experts interviewed, culturally-ingrained discrimination limits women's opportunities to make contributions in science and health and advocate for their needs
* affordability-many new technologies will need to be donated or heavily subsidized to reach those in need, many of them living on less than a dollar a day
* corruption and poor governance-some developing world experts said that with the power to approve new technologies resting solely with governments and little transparency in those approval processes, political considerations often trump public health care.
"Concurrent with the rapid growth of scientific research in developing countries, there are more reports of projects that face challenges related to ethical, cultural and social concerns," said Professor Singer. "Our goal was to anticipate issues that could be faced by such programs and try to prevent them as this important work moves forward."
The McLaughlin-Rotman Centre team has supplemented its ESC investigation with three separate reports, also published in PLoS Medicine. The first discusses the team's work as an ESC Advisory Service to the Grand Challenges in Global Health (GCGH) Initiative (http://www.gcgh.org/channels/gcgh), funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which offered 44 grants totaling $450 million for a broad range of innovative research projects involving scientists in 33 countries. The second and third papers focus on engaging communities and civil society organizations (CSOs) in biomedical research in developing countries.
"This is the first time ethical, social, and cultural counsel has been engaged on a large scale to provide advice in a systematic way on these issues in a developing world context," says study co-author Dr. Jerome Singh of Centre for the AIDS Program of Research (CAPRISA) in Durban, South Africa, and a co-leader of the GCGH ESC advisory service.
Public Library of Science
Scientific Research Current Events and Scientific Research News RSSGulf War research panel finds 1 in 4 veterans suffers from illness caused by toxic exposure
At least one in four of the 697,000 U.S. veterans of the 1991 Gulf War suffer from Gulf War illness, a condition caused by exposure to toxic chemicals, including pesticides and a drug administered to protect troops against nerve gas, and no effective treatments have yet been found, a federal panel of scientific experts and veterans concludes in a landmark report released Monday.
'Arid aquaculture' among livelihoods promoted to relieve worsening pressure on world's drylands
"Arid aquaculture" using ponds filled with salty, undrinkable water for fish production is one of several options experts have proven to be an effective potential alternative livelihood for people living in desertified parts of the world's expanding drylands.
New small-scale generator produces alternating current by stretching zinc oxide wires
Researchers have developed a new type of small-scale electric power generator able to produce alternating current through the cyclical stretching and releasing of zinc oxide wires encapsulated in a flexible plastic substrate with two ends bonded.
Proteomics Study Yields Clues As To How Tuberculosis Might Be Thwarting The Immune System
A link between the immune system and the self-cleaning system by which biological cells rid themselves of obsolete or toxic parts may one day yield new weapons in the fight against tuberculosis and other deadly infectious diseases.
Coral reefs found growing in cold, deep ocean
Imagine descending in a submarine to the ice-cold, ink-black depths of the ocean, 800 metres under the surface of the Atlantic.
Solar Power Game-Changer: "Near Perfect" Absorption of Sunlight, From All Angles
Researchers at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute have discovered and demonstrated a new method for overcoming two major hurdles facing solar energy.
Extinct sabertooth cats were social, found strength in numbers, study shows
The sabertooth cat (Smilodon fatalis), one of the most iconic extinct mammal species, was likely to be a social animal, living and hunting like lions today, according to new scientific research. The species is famous for its extremely long canine teeth, which reached up to seven inches in length and extended below the lower jaw.
K-State physics lab becoming a frontrunner in ultrafast laser research
For decades, the J.R. Macdonald Laboratory at Kansas State University has been known worldwide as a center for atomic collision physics using particle accelerators. Now, researchers at the lab are working toward making it known for ultrafast laser science.
News Bits About Qubits: Scientists Store and Retrieve Data Inside an Atom
Another step towards quantum computing - the Holy Grail of data processing and storage - was achieved when an international team of scientists that included researchers with the U.S. Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) were able to successfully store and retrieve information using the nucleus of an atom.
Secret Lives of Catalysts Revealed
The first-ever glimpse of nanoscale catalysts in action could lead to improved pollution control and fuel cell technologies. Scientists from the U.S. Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory observed catalysts restructuring themselves in response to various gases swirling around them, like a chameleon changing its color to match its surroundings.
More Scientific Research Current Events and Scientific Research News Articles
 | Scientific Research in Education by Richard J. Shavelson Researchers, historians, and philosophers of science have debated the nature of scientific research in education for more than 100 years. Recent enthusiasm for "evidence-based" policy and practice in education - now codified in the federal law that authorizes the bulk of elementary and secondary education programs - have brought a new sense of urgency to understanding the ways in which the basic... |
 | Scientific Method for Ecological Research by E. David Ford Scientists tend to take the thought processes that drive their research for granted, often learning them indirectly by observing their supervisors and colleagues. This book emphasizes the advantages of being explicit about these thought processes and aims to help those undertaking ecological research to develop a critical attitude to approaching a scientific problem and constructing a procedure... |
 | Managing Scientists: Leadership Strategies in Scientific Research by Alice M. Sapienza This updated edition provides managers with a practical guide focused on the particular management needs for research and development in biotechnology and pharmaceutical industries. It offers a way to improve the quality of interactions and creativity output in R&D, with real life case studies to illustrate key... |
| Tactics of scientific research;: Evaluating experimental data in psychology by Murray Sidman | |
 | An Introduction to Scientific Research by E. Bright Wilson Noted scientist's exceptionally clear, pragmatic guide to principles and procedures useful in a wide range of sciences. Design of experiments and apparatus; classification, sampling and measurement; analysis of experimental data; errors of measurement; probability, randomness and logic; much more. Indispensable for any researcher. 1952 edition. 49... |
 | Homosexuality: The Use of Scientific Research in the Church's Moral Debate by Stanton L. Jones, Mark A. Yarhouse [] How prevalent is homosexuality? [] What causes it? [] Is it a psychopathology? [] Can it be changed? Questions like these often accompany discussions of homosexual behavior. For answers we naturally look to scientific studies. But what does the scientific research actually show? More important, what place should this research have in shaping the church's response? Stanton Jones and... |
 | Advancing Scientific Research in Education by Committee on Research in Education, National Research Council Transforming education into an evidence-based field depends in no small part on a strong base of scientific knowledge to inform educational policy and... |
 | The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes: Volume 1: Philosophical Papers (Philosophical Papers Volume I) by Imre Lakatos Imre Lakatos' philosophical and scientific papers are published here in two volumes. Volume I brings together his very influential but scattered papers on the philosophy of the physical sciences, and includes one important unpublished essay on the effect of Newton's scientific achievement. Volume II presents his work on the philosophy of mathematics (much of it unpublished), together with some... |
 | Scientific Research on the Sculptural Arts of Asia: Proceedings of the Third Forbes by Janet Douglas Scientific investigations presented in this book include studies of Southeast Asian jade, Chinese bronzes, Mongolian deer stones, Japanese polychrome sculpture, and others and help us learn more about why, where, and how these works were made as well as... |
 | Scientific Integrity: Text and Cases in Responsible Conduct of Research by Francis L. Macrina "Scientific Integrity: Text and Cases in Responsible Conduct of Research, Third Edition", presents an important revision of a best-selling text in the expanding field of responsible conduct of research training. This book presents the core topics for graduate and postdoctoral trainees and professional researchers on the principles of scientific integrity. It contains highly relevant interactive... |
| © 2008 BrightSurf.com |