 |
|
Call for closer examination of 'brain death' as the end of life
September 12, 2007The medical diagnosis of brain death is at odds with our traditional view of when death actually occurs, says a leading academic speaking at an international conference on Death, dying & disposal in Bath today (Wednesday 12 September 2007).
Whilst a diagnosis of brain death is made using factors including fixed and dilated pupils, lack of eye movement, absence of respiratory reflexes, the social understanding of death is that it occurs when the heart stops beating.
This makes decisions that often follow brain death, such as organ removal and the cessation of life support, potentially unsettling for the bereaved, says Professor Allan Kellehear from the Centre for Death & Society at the University of Bath.
He is calling for organ removal and cessation of life support to become social decisions, rather than purely medical ones, and for more research to be carried out into the social impact of brain death and its implications.
"Forty years ago, being dead used to be very simple - it was the point at which your heart stopped beating," said Professor Kellehear.
"Now death itself has been complicated by the fact that we can keep alive people who are brain dead almost indefinitely.
"Brain death is the point at which doctors can switch off machines or begin harvesting organs, but, to relatives, being brain dead is not the same as being a corpse.
"Corpses are not warm, they are not pink, they do not move, they are not pregnant - but a person who is brain dead can be all of these things.
"To all appearances, there is little difference between a person who is brain dead and a person who is asleep.
"At the same time we ask people if it is OK to remove a beating heart or other living organ from their loved one.
"It is further complicated by the fact that one in one thousand people who are brain dead survive when the machines are switched off.
"If it is your daughter lying there, your idea of a remote chance is very different from that of your daughter's doctor.
"The situation at present is that these decisions are based on medical information alone.
"I would argue that these should be social decisions. To better inform these decisions, we need a closer look at the social implications of brain death.
"At present, this understanding is totally lacking from the medical literature on this topic."
University of Bath
He is calling for organ removal and cessation of life support to become social decisions, rather than purely medical ones, and for more research to be carried out into the social impact of brain death and its implications.
"Forty years ago, being dead used to be very simple - it was the point at which your heart stopped beating," said Professor Kellehear.
"Now death itself has been complicated by the fact that we can keep alive people who are brain dead almost indefinitely.
"Brain death is the point at which doctors can switch off machines or begin harvesting organs, but, to relatives, being brain dead is not the same as being a corpse.
"Corpses are not warm, they are not pink, they do not move, they are not pregnant - but a person who is brain dead can be all of these things.
"To all appearances, there is little difference between a person who is brain dead and a person who is asleep.
"At the same time we ask people if it is OK to remove a beating heart or other living organ from their loved one.
"It is further complicated by the fact that one in one thousand people who are brain dead survive when the machines are switched off.
"If it is your daughter lying there, your idea of a remote chance is very different from that of your daughter's doctor.
"The situation at present is that these decisions are based on medical information alone.
"I would argue that these should be social decisions. To better inform these decisions, we need a closer look at the social implications of brain death.
"At present, this understanding is totally lacking from the medical literature on this topic."
University of Bath
Study finds significant differences in protocols hospitals use to determine brain death
A survey of some of the top hospitals in the country has found that protocols followed to determine brain death differ significantly among those institutions.
Kidney donation after cardiac death may expand donor pool, research shows
New research at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center suggests that transplanting kidneys from donors who died after cardiac arrest - which used to be considered taboo - offers a promising approach to increase the donor pool.
Heat-related deaths in middle, high school football players spikes in 2006
Every year, Fred Mueller compiles a sports list, but unlike popular pre-season picks or a glamorous hot-recruit sheet, nobody envies him this task. Some years the list is longer than others, but, Mueller said, there's no reason any kid should be on it.
Mayo Clinic develops new coma measurement system
Mayo Clinic neurologists have created the first new, reliable and easy-to-use clinical tool in 30 years for measuring coma depth, a proposed replacement for the Glasgow Coma Scale.
More Brain Death Current Events and Brain Death News Articles
 | Stress, the Aging Brain, and the Mechanisms of Neuron Death (Bradford Books) by Robert M. Sapolsky Honorable Mention in the category of Biological Sciences, 1992 Professional/Scholarly Publishing Annual Awards Competition presented by the Association of American Publishers, Inc. Looking beyond the now widely recognized relationships between stress and physical illness, this accessible and engagingly written book suggests that stress and stress-related hormones can also endanger the brain.... |
 | Beyond the Brain: Birth, Death, and Transendence in Psychotherapy (Suny Series, Transpersonal & Humanistic Psychology) by Stanislav Grof Beyond the Brain seriously challenges the existing neurophysiological models of the brain. After three decades of extensive research on those non-ordinary states of consciousness induced by psychedelic drugs and by other means, Grof concludes that our present scientific world view is as inadequate as many of its historical predecessors. In this pioneering work, he proposes a new model of the... |
 | Medicine, Miracles, and Manifestations: A Doctor's Journey Through the Worlds of Divine Intervention, Near-death Experiences, and Universal Energy by John L. Turner "I admire Dr. Turner for having the courage to share his life and truths with us. I truly recommend this book to every health professional and those willing to open their minds and accept the true nature of life. You will be touched by the stories he shares; his book can help you open your mind and become aware of new and exciting aspects of true healing and curing."--Dr. Bernie Siegel, author of... |
 | Brain Death: A Reappraisal by C. Machado This text is intended to provide an overview of brain death. The topics explored in this book are the concept and historical approach of human death, clinical examinations of brain-dead patients, ancillary tests in coma and brain death, bioethical discussions of brain death and its relationship with some consciousness disturbances, and the legal considerations of human death.... |
 | A Matter of Life and Death: The Brain Revealed by the Mind of Michael Powell by Diane Broadbent Friedman Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger collaborated in the creation of many remarkable British films including "The Red Shoes," "The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp," and "A Canterbury Tale." While film scholars have known that Powell and Pressburger valued accuracy to enhance the power of their stories, a complete analysis of the neurological basis of one of their most memorable films, "A Matter... |
 | Beyond Brain Death: The Case Against Brain Based Criteria for Human Death (Philosophy and Medicine) Beyond Brain Death offers a provocative challenge to one of the most widely accepted conclusions of contemporary bioethics: the position that brain death marks the death of the human person. Eleven chapters by physicians, philosophers, and theologians present the case against brain-based criteria for human death. Each author believes that this position calls into question the moral... |
 | Persons, Humanity, and the Definition of Death by John P. Lizza In this riveting and timely work, John P. Lizza presents the first comprehensive analysis of personhood and humanity in the context of defining death. Rejecting the common assumption that human or personal death is simply a biological phenomenon for biologists or physicians to define, Lizza argues that the definition of death is also a matter for metaphysical reflection, moral choice, and... |
 | Brain Death by Eelco FM Wijdicks This volume thoroughly reviews the currently accepted methods and criteria for the diagnosis of brain death and discusses its legal, ethical, religious, and philosophical aspects. The book provides much-needed guidance for all practitioners who treat patients with catastrophic neurologic disorders evolving to brain death. Noted experts examine the complexities and potential pitfalls of clinical... |
 | Death: Beyond Whole-Brain Criteria (Philosophy and Medicine) |
| The choking game.(Behavioral Consult)(incidence of deaths and brain injuries from fainting games): An article from: Pediatric News by Michael S. Jellinek This digital document is an article from Pediatric News, published by Thomson Gale on November 1, 2006. The length of the article is 1012 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.Citation DetailsTitle: The... |
| © 2008 BrightSurf.com |