Vitamin E trials 'fatally flawed'

September 24, 2007

CORVALLIS, Ore. - Generations of studies on vitamin E may be largely meaningless, scientists say, because new research has demonstrated that the levels of this micronutrient necessary to reduce oxidative stress are far higher than those that have been commonly used in clinical trials.

In a new study and commentary in Free Radical Biology and Medicine, researchers concluded that the levels of vitamin E necessary to reduce oxidative stress - as measured by accepted biomarkers of lipid peroxidation - are about 1,600 to 3,200 I.U. daily, or four to eight times higher than those used in almost all past clinical trials.

This could help explain the inconsistent results of many vitamin E trials for its value in preventing or treating cardiovascular disease, said Balz Frei, professor and director of the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University, and co-author of the new commentary along with Jeffrey Blumberg, at the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University.

"The methodology used in almost all past clinical trials of vitamin E has been fatally flawed," said Frei, one of the world's leading experts on antioxidants and disease. "These trials supposedly addressed the hypothesis that reducing oxidative stress could reduce cardiovascular disease. But oxidative stress was never measured in these trials, and therefore we don't know whether it was actually reduced or not. The hypothesis was never really tested."

The level of vitamin E that clearly can be shown to reduce oxidative stress, new research is showing, is far higher than the level that could be obtained in any diet, and is also above the "tolerable upper intake level" outlined by the Institute of Medicine, which is 1,000 I.U. a day. OSU researchers are not yet recommending that people should routinely take such high levels, but they do say that controlled clinical trials studying this issue should be aware of the latest findings and seriously consider using much higher vitamin E supplement levels in their studies.

In lab, animal or human studies, there's evidence that vitamin E can reduce oxidative stress, inhibit formation of atherosclerotic lesions, slow aortic thickening, lower inflammation, and reduce platelet adhesion. Some human studies using lower levels of vitamin E supplements, such as 100 to 400 I.U. a day, have shown benefits in reducing cardiovascular disease risk, and others have not. An underlying assumption was that these levels were more than adequate to reduce oxidative stress, since they far exceeded the "recommended dietary allowance" or RDA for the vitamin, a level adequate to prevent deficiency disease.

"What's now clear is that the amount of vitamin E than can conclusively be shown to reduce oxidative stress is higher than we realized," Frei said. "And almost none of the studies done with vitamin E actually measured the beginning level or reduction of oxidative stress."

Proper studies of vitamin E, researchers say, must be done carefully and take into account the newest findings about this micronutrient. It's now known that natural forms of the vitamin are far more readily absorbed than synthetic types. It's also been discovered that supplements taken without a fat-containing meal are largely useless, because in the absence of dietary fat vitamin E is not absorbed.

Some clinical trials may wish to study the long term effect of vitamins on healthy individuals. But if a clinical trial seeks to learn the value of reducing oxidative stress, they should select patients in advance for those who have high, measurable oxidative stress - often people who are older or have a range of heart disease risk factors, such as obesity, poor diet, hypertension or other problems. Cognizance should also be taken of people with health issues that may further increase their vitamin needs, such as smokers.

"A pill count simply isn't enough to determine the value of vitamin E," Frei said. "We need to select people for trials properly, make sure they are taking the right form of the vitamin, at the right levels and at the right time, and then verify the metabolic results with laboratory testing."

"Only when we do these studies right will we answer questions about the value of vitamin E in addressing cardiovascular disease," he said. "So far we've been flying blind."

A parallel, Frei said, would be presuming to test the value of a statin drug, which lowers cholesterol, without ever measuring cholesterol levels in the test subjects, neither at the beginning nor at the end of the study. Such trials would be ridiculed in the science community.

So far, that's the way vitamin E has been studied.

The use and intake of vitamins, experts say, has traditionally been thought of in terms of overt deficiency - for example, not enough vitamin C causes scurvy. Much less research has been done on the levels that can help create optimum health. The issue is of special importance with modern populations that have very different diets, activity levels and increased lifespan, and are dying from much different causes - predominantly heart disease and cancer - than people of past generations.

Oregon State University

---

---

	The Vitamin E Factor: The Miraculous Antioxidant for the Prevention and Treatment of Heart Disease, Cancer, and Aging by Andreas Papas (Author) It is too early to conclude that vitamin E has all the beneficial effects attributed to it, but even if only 25% of current expectations were to be fulfilled, vitamin E would become an important weapon against a range of chronic diseases. The book is not simply scientific and education but also a please to read.Dimitrios Trichopoulos, MDVincent L. Gregory Professor of Cancer Prevention and Professor of Epidemiology, Harvard School of Public Health
	The Antioxidant Miracle: Put Lipoic Acid, Pycnogenol, and Vitamins E and C to Work for You by Lester Packer (Author), Carol Colman (Author) Imagine there was an easy way you could keep your heart strong, your mind sharp, and your body youthful. Imagine this program could keep you young, improve your sex life, prevent cancer and heart disease, and keep your skin supple and wrinkle-free. And perhaps best of all, imagine this was something readily available at your local drugstore or natural food store. These and other benefits are the miraculous results of antioxidants. Lester Packer is the world's foremost authority on these natural healers. In The Antioxidant Miracle, he explains for the first time exactly how you can design a practical, personalized antioxidant program for disease prevention and optimal wellness. The Antioxidant Miracle is the first popular book to reveal the full range of healing benefits of lipoic...
	Curing the Incurable: Vitamin C, Infectious Diseases, and Toxins by Thomas E. Levy (Author) New
	Vitamins to Avoid (Natural Health) Vitamins to Avoid teaches you the natural vitamins you should not take to avoid developing adverse effects depending on your pre-existing medical conditions, concurrent medications and any other medical therapy you may be receiving. Topics covered include: 1.Vitamin A This chapter discusses the patient factors, medical conditions, medications and medical therapy that should not be combined with taking vitamin A supplements to prevent adverse reactions in the body. 2. The B Vitamins This chapter discusses the medical conditions and medications that should not be combined with taking vitamin B supplements to prevent adverse reactions in the body. 3. Vitamin C This chapter discusses the medical conditions, medications and medical therapy...
	Optimization and validation of a high performance liquid chromatography method for the simultaneous determination of vitamins A and E in human serum ... [An article from: Analytica Chimica Acta] by L. Urbanek (Author), D. Solichova (Author), B. Melichar (Author), J. Dvorak (Author) This digital document is a journal article from Analytica Chimica Acta, published by Elsevier in 2006. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Media Library immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Description: In this study a novel, simple and rapid reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) procedure for simultaneous determination of vitamins A and E (retinol and alpha-tocopherol) in blood serum has been developed and validated using monolithic column and diode-array detection (DAD). The monolithic column Chromolith Performance RP-18e (100mmx4.6mm) was operated at ambient temperature. One hundred percent methanol at flow rate 2.5mlmin^-^1 was used as a mobile phase. Detection of both compounds was...
	A+ for almonds, abundant in vitamin E, minerals.(EN on Foods)(Recipe): An article from: Environmental Nutrition by Mindy Hermann (Author) This digital document is an article from Environmental Nutrition, published by Belvoir Media Group, LLC on December 1, 2008. The length of the article is 699 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: A+ for almonds, abundant in vitamin E, minerals.(EN on Foods)(Recipe) Author: Mindy Hermann Publication: Environmental Nutrition (Magazine/Journal) Date: December 1, 2008 Publisher: Belvoir Media Group, LLC Volume: 31 Issue: 12 Page: 8(1) Article Type: Recipe Distributed by Gale, a part of Cengage...
	Dr. Wilfrid E. Shute's Complete...Updated Vitamin E Book by Wilfrid E. Shute (Author)
	Tocotrienols: Vitamin E Beyond Tocopherols, Second Edition by Barrie Tan (Editor), Ronald Ross Watson (Editor), Victor R. Preedy (Editor) A New Avenue of Research Beyond Traditional Studies of Vitamin E The first 90 years of vitamin E research has produced prolific and notable discoveries. Until the last few decades, attention has been given mostly to the biological activities and underlying mechanisms of alpha-tocopherol, which we now know is one of more than eight vitamin E isomers. Tocotrienol discovery came much later, in 1965, but existed for almost 20 years as an obscure vitamin E. Explores Treatment Possibilities Tocotrienols have proven to contain some exceptional benefits that aren't shared by the better known tocopherols. Although both are antioxidants, today a bright spot for tocotrienol research is in cancer and heart disease, while emergent fields of tocotrienol research are on the rise with many covered in...
	The Vitamin C Connection by E. Cheraskin (Author)
	Vitamin E for ailing & healthy hearts by Wilfrid E. Shute (Author), Harald J. Taub (Author)