 |
|
Humanitarian assistance often lacks needs assessment
November 12, 2007The first academic thesis in Sweden on international health assistance in disaster zones is to be presented at the medical university Karolinska Institutet. In his thesis, Dr Johan von Schreeb shows that international assistance is often sent to disaster areas without any prior needs assessment having been made of the affected population.
Dr von Schreeb has carried out needs assessments in a number of disaster situations. He examined the need for international medical assistance after the terrorist action in a school in Beslan, Russia, in 2004, and the low-intensity conflict in the Palestinian territories in 2002. He also studied the use of Foreign Field Hospitals in the natural (sudden impact) disaster zones of Bam (Iran) in 2003, Haiti and Aceh (Indonesia) in 2004 and Pakistan (Kashmir) 2005). What he discovered was a lack of understanding of people's needs subsequent to the disaster and that international assistance takes inadequate account of existing resources. International field hospitals specialising in life-saving trauma care were dispatched to four areas of natural disaster. Not one arrived within the 48 hours in which lives could still be saved.
If appropriate assistance is to be provided, organisers need access to information about the disaster, the affected area, the size of the population, the socio-economic situation and the available local and regional resources. International donors of humanitarian assistance have jointly decided to distribute the money on the basis of local needs. There are well-described methods of making needs assessments, but the results are too rarely used. One of Dr von Schreeb's sub-studies examined the extent to which Sida took account of needs assessments in its decisions to fund humanitarian health projects in 2003. Only one third of these decisions contained information about the size of the population to be helped or other factors reflecting their health needs.
"My interpretation of this is that it's difficult to provide funding on the basis of needs," says Dr von Schreeb. "Other procedures are needed for having needs govern funding decisions."
During his time as medical coordinator for Medecins Sans Frontieres (Doctors without Borders) in Kashmir, Dr von Schreeb was able to test a new rapid method of gathering needs assessment data in a disaster area. After the 2005 earthquake in Kashmir, he interviewed people at health facilities. His interviewees were geographically representative of the studied population, and the early estimated death and injury toll compared well with the results of a later study in which everyone living in the area was interviewed.
"The interviews gave a good, immediate idea of what people needed - in this case to have their houses repaired before the winter," says Dr von Schreeb.
Karolinska Institutet
"My interpretation of this is that it's difficult to provide funding on the basis of needs," says Dr von Schreeb. "Other procedures are needed for having needs govern funding decisions."
During his time as medical coordinator for Medecins Sans Frontieres (Doctors without Borders) in Kashmir, Dr von Schreeb was able to test a new rapid method of gathering needs assessment data in a disaster area. After the 2005 earthquake in Kashmir, he interviewed people at health facilities. His interviewees were geographically representative of the studied population, and the early estimated death and injury toll compared well with the results of a later study in which everyone living in the area was interviewed.
"The interviews gave a good, immediate idea of what people needed - in this case to have their houses repaired before the winter," says Dr von Schreeb.
Karolinska Institutet
Humanitarian Assistance Current Events and Humanitarian Assistance News RSSNASA uses satellite to unearth innovation in crop forecasting
Soil moisture is essential for seeds to germinate and for crops to grow. But record droughts and scorching temperatures in certain parts of the globe in recent years have caused soil to dry up, crippling crop production.
Experts examine risk-pooling through insurance to help poor countries cope with climate change
Insurance solutions are pushed forward at the climate negotiations this week in Poznan. This is a critical juncture to build insurance mechanisms solidly into the architecture of the agreement that will emerge in Copenhagen next year.
Livestock interventions can protect lives, livelihoods
Pastoralist communities in dryland areas of Africa are reliant on livestock as sources of food, income and social support. However drought is common in sub-Saharan Africa, making these communities vulnerable to loss of livestock when rains fail.
AIDS, TB, malaria and bird flu spread unchecked in Burma
Government policies in Burma that restrict public health and humanitarian aid have created an environment where AIDS, drug-resistant tuberculosis, malaria and bird flu (H5N1) are spreading unchecked.
Health And Politics: Lessons Learned From The Iraq Conflict (p 1371)
A Viewpoint in this week's issue of THE LANCET discusses the complex issues concerning the provision of humanitarian relief in the Iraq conflict. The authors of the article comment that 'the US armed forces have increased engagement in humanitarian projects, such as community health and food programmes. Relief organisations believe that this engagement contributes to insecurity by blurring the lines between civilian and military function, and falsely associates them with the military forces'.
Health And Human Rights
Two Health and Human Rights articles in this week's issue of THE LANCET discuss the co-ordination of United Nations (UN), governmental, and non-governmental organisation (NGO) in response to emergency situations, focusing specifically on the relief effort in Angola, where civil war had raged for over two decades until a ceasefire was agreed in April this year. A recent editorial in THE LANCET (Lancet 2002; 359: 2125) was critical of UN agencies for not responding quickly enough to humanitarian emergencies. Responding to this, Erick de Mul from the UN Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs, Angola, comments: "Hundreds of individual agencies around the world are now working i
More Humanitarian Assistance Current Events and Humanitarian Assistance News Articles
 |
Humanitarian Logistics (INSEAD Business Press) by Rolando Tomasini (Author), Luk van Wassenhove (Author) Imagine planning an event like the Olympics. Now imagine planning the same event but not knowing when or where it will take place, or how many will attend. This is what humanitarian logisticians are up against. Oversights result in serious consequences for the victims of disasters. So they have to get it right, fast. This book comprehensively covers the problems of humanitarian logistics. |
 |
Charlie Rose with George Shultz; Jan Egeland (December 22, 2005) A conversation with former Secretary of State George Shultz about Iraq and other challenges facing the current administration. Then, Jan Egeland, U.N. Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief, discusses the new central emergency response fund and the U.N.'s goal to have predictable assistance for all by 2006. This product is manufactured on demand using DVD-R recordable media. Amazon.com's standard return policy will apply. |
 |
The Pulse of Humanitarian Assistance (International Humanitarian Affairs) by Kevin Cahill (Author) Understanding the complex nature of international humanitarian action—particularly following natural disasters or armed conflicts—has been the mission of this unique series. This book explores the cutting-edge concerns that will affect how assistance is offered in the future.Featuring twelve original essays by leading practitioners, policymakers, and scholars, the book is a state of the field report on problems, threats, and opportunities facing relief efforts in today’s world.With contributions from such authorities as Bernard Kouchner, founder of Doctors Without Borders, Charles McCormick, CEO of Save the Children, and physicians, military leaders, field workers, and others, the essaysconfront the most critical issues facing the delivery of effective relief.The issues... |
 |
Condemned to Repeat?: The Paradox of Humanitarian Action by Fiona Terry (Author) |
 |
Shaping the Humanitarian World (Routledge Global Institutions) by Peter Walker (Author), Daniel G. Maxwell (Author) Providing a critical introduction to the notion of humanitarianism in global politics, tracing the concept from its origins to the twenty-first century, this book examines how the so called international community works in response to humanitarian crises and the systems that bind and divide them. By tracing the history on international humanitarian action from its early roots through the birth of the Red Cross to the beginning of the UN, Peter Walker and Daniel G. Maxwell examine the challenges humanitarian agencies face, from working alongside armies and terrorists to witnessing genocide. They argue that humanitarianism has a vital future, but only if those practicing it choose to make it so. Topics covered include:
|
 |
Contemporary States of Emergency: The Politics of Military and Humanitarian Interventions by Didier Fassin (Editor), Mariella Pandolfi (Editor) From natural disaster areas to zones of political conflict around the world, a new logic of intervention combines military action and humanitarian aid, conflates moral imperatives and political arguments, and confuses the concepts of legitimacy and legality. The mandate to protect human lives—however and wherever endangered—has given rise to a new form of humanitarian government that moves from one crisis to the next, applying the same battery of technical expertise (from military logistics to epidemiological risk management to the latest social scientific tools for "good governance") and reducing people with particular histories and hopes to mere lives to be rescued. This book explores these contemporary states of emergency. Drawing on the critical insights of... |
 |
The Humanitarian Enterprise: Dilemmas and Discoveries by Larry Minear (Author) International humanitarian activities have grown enormously in scale over the past ten years. Alongside this greater experience, the complex links between humanitarian work and the worlds of politics and military engagement have become ever more contested. Through the lens of the Humanitarianism and War Project, Larry Minear explores what international humanitarians – from the UN and national governments, to the Red Cross and the many private relief and development agencies – have learned about how to do humanitarian work well, and the arguments which remain unresolved. With an epilogue on the issues highlighted by the international response to the terrorist attacks of 2001 and the war in Afghanistan, this book will be of interest to anyone wishing to understand the future of... |
|
Complex Humanitarian Emergencies: Lessons from Practitioners by Mark Janz (Author), Joann Slead (Editor) When certain indicators such as famine, civil unrest and economic collapse combine, the result is often a complex humanitarian emergency (CHE). It is in the midst of such chaos that releif and development practitioners live and work. In this volume, experienced practitioners address the question of how we can respond appropriately to CHEs by linking conceptual and theoretical thinking to practical application at the grassroots level. | |
 |
In the Shadow of "Just Wars": Violence, Politics, and Humanitarian Action by Medecins Sans Frontieres (Author), Doctors Without Borders (Author), Fabrice Weissman (Editor) Médecins sans Frontières; Fabrice Weissman (Editor) During the planning stages of military intervention in Iraq, humanitarian organizations were offered U.S. government funds to join the Coalition and operate under the umbrella of Operation Iraqi Freedom. Nongovernmental organizations had previously been asked to join in "just wars" in Kosovo, East Timor, Sierra Leone, and Afghanistan, wars initiated by Western powers against oppressive regimes or armed groups. Many aid organizations cooperated eagerly. Few Afghans regret the eclipse of the Taliban, or Sierra Leoneans the stabilization of their country after British military intervention in 2000. However, the incidental victims of these triumphs, those on the "wrong" side, are soon forgotten. Humanitarian organizations are... |
 |
A Framework for Survival: Health, Human Rights, and Humanitarian Assistance in Conflicts and Disasters by Kevin Cahill (Author) Wars and natural disasters--from the Balkans to the Sudan, and from Afghanistan to Central Africa--have increasingly placed humanitarian workers in the crossfire. Kevin M. Cahill has assembled an international team of renowned experts to offer a much-needed assessment of the moral, legal and political dilemmas and consequences of humanitarian assistance. Focusing on health issues, A Framework for Survival takes an unflinching look at the reality facing the nations and people involved, from refugees to relief organizations. In contrast to conventional military, economic and geopolitical strategies, it suggests rational and effective solutions and foreign policy recommendations. With the collapse of many government infrastructures since the end of the Cold War, the success or failure of... |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |