Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say
Slashdot It! Slashdot New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say
Submit to Reddit Submit New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say to Reddit
Reading: New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers SayTwitter This Reading: New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers SayTwitter New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say
Add to Facebook Add New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say to Facebook

New Research Tools Suggest Cancer And Other Diseases Are Too Complex For Easy Answers, Researchers Say

December 28, 2007

Washington, D.C. − Scientists who study cancer may be prone to drawing simplistic conclusions from the powerful molecular tools now available because they don't appreciate how complex the data is that is being generated, said a team of Georgetown University Medical Center (GUMC) researchers in the January issue of Nature Reviews Cancer.

In a review article summing up the state of the field, they said cancer investigators should endeavor to better understand the issues these genomic and proteomic technologies create or conclusions from their research may be misleading.




"These tools have allowed us to see that nature is more complex than we thought, and while we don't yet know what the overarching biological rules are − such as the interrelationship between multiple signaling pathways that can lead to cancer development − we are trying to play the game like we do," said the review's lead author, Robert Clarke, Ph.D., D.Sc., professor of oncology and physiology & biophysics at the Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center at GUMC, where he co-directs the Breast Cancer Program. Clarke is the interim director of GUMC's Biomedical Graduate Research Organization, which is home to more than 60 percent of the University's biomedical research funding.

"The answers to our questions are probably there in the data," he said, "but the issue is whether we can get them using these complex tools and, also, how we will know they are right when we see them."

Clarke led the analysis with six other scientists from Georgetown and from Virginia Polytechnic Institute. GUMC is pioneering a field of systems medicine study designed to understand the theory and properties of the data generated by these new tools and how they may affect data analysis and interpretation.

"This review addresses the challenges in reducing high-dimensional molecular data and making the output relevant to cancer treatment," said Howard Federoff, executive vice president for health sciences at GUMC. "There is no doubt that the integration of traditional clinical data alongside transcriptomic and proteomic data will result in a change in our understanding of disease mechanisms, likely drive a revision in nosology and have meaningful impact on patients with cancer. I place great value on this systems medicine approach because it heralds the future of medical practice and holds promise to transform healthcare."

The genomic and proteomic technologies used in cancer research help provide a snapshot of the molecular workings of cancer cells. Researchers hope to identify the genes that are active during cancer development and which transcribe the messenger RNA (mRNA) needed to produce the proteins that actually do the "work" of the cell. In theory, knowing the genes, mRNA, and proteins that are linked to specific cancers will help researchers build better predictive models of diagnosis, prognosis, and therapy.

But there are thousands of active molecules in a single slice of a tumor analyzed after surgical removal, Clarke said, and this produces "very high-dimensional data spaces." That means that a molecular snapshot could "have 10,000 or so dimensions if you consider a molecule working along a pathway as a dimension. Think of a box which is described as having a height, width and length, but if you add color and the box's fiber, you have two more dimensions. There are countless things going on in a cell that could describe it − this is the essence of multi-dimensionality and these tools tell you all of that, " said Clarke.

But there are perils in generating such large amounts of data, Clarke said, because the data being generated will not all be relevant to the question researchers are trying to ask since there are countless dynamic processes ongoing at one time within a tumor. "Some cells in a tumor are dying, some are not. Some are growing, others are not. Some are trying to spread and the rest aren't," Clarke said. "Everything is going on in a tumor at once, and all of these activities require coordination of different genes. So it may not be accurate to analyze these molecules as if they are all focused on performing a single function.

"We need to discover what specific genes perform which function. If we knew the rules - what genes are involved in which process - we should be able to understand some of the questions we have, but we are not there yet," he said.

Despite the lack of understanding, many studies have been published that link specific "biomarkers" −genes, mRNA or proteins − with an aspect of cancer development or treatment, and the results often appear to be statistically valid, Clarke said. "But it is not clear that that solution is complete or is necessarily correct. It may be partly right and may be intuitively pleasing because you are getting what you expected to see from an experiment. That could be a trap, a self-fulfilling prophecy."

And while the findings may "fit" in the tumor samples they are tested in, they may not if other tumor tissue is studied, and many times researchers don't take that extra step, the researchers said in their article. "The lack of rigorous validation is a problem that currently plagues cancer research, Clarke added.

Another pitfall in using the new technology is the "curse of multi-dimensionality," Clarke said. "You have a lot of measurements, and the statistical model gets very complicated. So sometimes you don't have enough computing power to derive the right answer or you get an answer that is only true for part of the data."

In other words, scientists don't always know what they don't know when looking at multi-dimensional data sets.

"We still don't always have enough knowledge to know whether we have the answers right or not."

Co-authors of the review include a multidisciplinary team of authors: Yue Wang, PhD and Jianhua Xuan, PhD, both computer scientists and engineers from Virginia Polytechnic Institute. From GUMC, co-authors included Habtom W. Ressom, PhD, a computer scientist; two biostatisticians, Antai Wang, PhD and Edmund A. Gehan, PhD, and Minetta C. Liu, MD, a medical oncologist.

The review was funded by the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Defense.

Georgetown University





Science News and Science Current Events Tag Cloud
This tag cloud is a visual representation of term frequencies of random science news topics with common terms grouped together and emphasized by their display size.
Antiretroviral   Ants   Carbon Footprint   Brain Cancer   Frogs   Superconductivity   Overweight   Bipolar   Galaxy   In-vitro Fertilization   Supercomputer   Zinc   Bioenergy   Hubble Space Telescope   Glaucoma   Melatonin   Bisphenol A   Gastric Bypass Surgery   Tsunami   Amphibian   Plant Growth   Immune Cells   Superconductor   Facial Expressions   Pacemaker  
Related Research Tool Current Events and Research Tool News Articles Research Tool Current Events and Research Tool News RSS Research Tool Current Events and Research Tool News RSS
Nonstick and laser-safe gold aids laser trapping of biomolecules
Biophysicists long for an ideal material-something more structured and less sticky than a standard glass surface-to anchor and position individual biomolecules.

A new mouse model provides insight into genetic neurological disorders
Neurosensory diseases are difficult to model in mice because their symptoms are complex and diverse. The genetic causes identified are often lethal when transferred to a mouse.

New Tool for Next-Generation Cancer Treatments using Nanodiamonds
A research team at Northwestern University has demonstrated a tool that can precisely deliver tiny doses of drug-carrying nanomaterials to individual cells.

An age-old story
Growing older is a fact of life, but people's hopes, fears, pre-conceptions and experiences surrounding the ageing process are richly diverse.

Origins of Pompeii-style artifacts examined at ISIS
Roman artefacts which are nearly two thousand years old with similarities to ancient remains found at Pompeii in Italy have been examined at the Science and Technology Facilities Council's ISIS neutron source (21-22 February).

A new gene silencing platform -- silence is golden
A team of researchers led by Rutgers' Samuel Gunderson has developed a novel gene silencing platform with very significant improvements over existing RNAi approaches.

Of Mice and Peanuts: A new mouse model for peanut allergy
Chicago researchers report the development of a new mouse model for food allergy that mimics symptoms generated during a human allergic reaction to peanuts.

Patient-derived induced stem cells retain disease traits
hen neurons started dying in Clive Svendsen's lab dishes, he couldn't have been more pleased. The dying cells - the same type lost in patients with the devastating neurological disease spinal muscular atrophy - confirmed that the University of Wisconsin-Madison stem cell biologist had recreated the hallmarks of a genetic disorder in the lab, using stem cells derived from a patient.

Chemist tames longstanding electron computation problem
When the University of Chicago's David Mazziotti talks about chemistry, perhaps he is thinking about how the behavior of all of the electrons in a molecule can be anticipated from the behavior of just two of its electrons.

Previous claims of siRNA therapeutic effects called into question by report in human gene therapy
The many recent reports documenting the therapeutic efficacy of short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) in animal models of human disease may actually be describing non-specific therapeutic effects related to the ability of siRNA to activate an immune response, according to a paper in the September 2008 issue (Volume 19, Number 9) of Human Gene Therapy, a peer-reviewed journal published by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
More Research Tool Current Events and Research Tool News Articles
Basic Legal Research: Tools And Strategies

Basic Legal Research: Tools And Strategies
by Amy E. Sloan (Author)



  Market Research Matters: Tools and Techniques for Aligning Your Business
by Wiley

When it comes to planning a winning corporate strategy, many business leaders fail to consider market research. This is a critical mistake. Done correctly and with creativity, market research can provide real value by serving as the radar that will alert your business to the perils and opportunities that lie ahead.

Excellent marketing insight is the edge that differentiates business winners from losers. It can help your company in its effort to make–not merely serve markets. Businesses that successfully anticipate major marketplace shifts such as e-commerce, PCs, or the demand for bottled water reap rewards of legendary proportions. Few do. Less dramatic but equally important is the opportunity to improve customer understanding and marketing, which can grow profits daily. Businesses...

Peake Research PR-R5-FCX-3-16 BMW Scan Tool 2001-2006

Peake Research PR-R5-FCX-3-16 BMW Scan Tool 2001-2006
by Peake Research

Displays all BMW-factory engine fault codes; allowing you to do your own engine diagnostic! A big step up from generic code readers. Resets the Engine light (Check Engine or Service Engine Soon) Resets the Oil service and Inspection lights, and service mileage. Very easy to use Low cost Includes instruction manual and code chart

Little Pink Tool Pouch & Belt

Little Pink Tool Pouch & Belt
by R&K Supply Company

Little Pink Tool Pouch & Belt includes 6 attractive pink and black hand tools which carry a lifetime guarantee. Includes 7oz. Claw Hammer, 10" Pump Plier, 6" Slip Joint Plier, Screwdriver 6 in 1, 25" Tape Measure and 8" Adjustable Wrench. FREE OPEN END WRENCH SET WITH PURCHASE!

Brush Research Mfg. Bc 1-3/8

Brush Research Mfg. Bc 1-3/8" 180g Flexhone Tool
by Brush Research

Bore Size (decimal equivalent): 1.375. Bore Size (mm): 35. Flex-Hone Model: BC - 1-3/8. Grit: 180. Description: Standard Duty Silicon Carbide Flex-Hone® Tool. Resilient, flexible honing tool with a soft cutting action. Unique construction allows the abrasive globules or "stones" to float, assuring the tool will be self-centering, self-aligning to the bore and self-compensating for wear.

Charmed Life Products The Pink Collection for Breast Cancer Research Grill Charms

Charmed Life Products The Pink Collection for Breast Cancer Research Grill Charms
by Charmed Life Products LLC

Grill Charms: The must have grilling accessory that is revolutionizing the American cook-out. Similar in concept to the wine charm these dime-sized solid stainless steel charms are placed in your food before grilling. The stems are serrated to hold securely while grilling, moving and flipping. The Pink Collection has six individual and unique designs such as a shoe, a wine glass, and a ribbon. If someone likes extra garlic, someone else likes extra pepper and someone else has health concerns with MSG, with Grill Charms each person chooses their own Grill Charm and they can season their food any way they wish, without fear of a mix up on the grill. Personalize your food prior to cooking to distinguish spices and flavors, to avoid health or allergy issues or any other OPTION you can dream...

Neuropathy Nutrition Rx 90 Capsules by Progressive Research Labs / 90 Capsules

Neuropathy Nutrition Rx 90 Capsules by Progressive Research Labs / 90 Capsules
by Progressive Research Labs

Neuropathy Nutrition Rx is formulated to support healthy nerves and circulation. Neuropathy causes peripheral nerve damage and can create extremely painful numbing in the extremities. Over time, Neuropathy can also lead to circulation blockage that often results in amputations or cardiovascular problems.

Statistics: A Tool for Social Research

Statistics: A Tool for Social Research
by Joseph F. Healey (Author)

STATISTICS: A TOOL FOR SOCIAL RESEARCH, Eighth Edition, is a comprehensive, reader-friendly text that uses real-world examples, engaging exercises, and special features in every chapter to help even the most math-averse students succeed in a required statistics course. At the same time, this versatile text is appropriate for more advanced students in diverse social science disciplines, providing an accessible, well-balanced introduction to fundamental concepts of statistics and their practical application to a wide variety of contemporary social issues. The text covers hand calculations and the use of computers, providing a solid grounding in both traditional formulas and the latest SPSS statistical software package. Healey effectively breaks down even complex material to help students...

Word by Word Aramaic / English Dictionary - Talmud Study & Research English Translation Tool

Word by Word Aramaic / English Dictionary - Talmud Study & Research English Translation Tool
by TES Inc

About - Word by Word Aramaic / English DictionaryFinally... a software program that improves the way you study Talmud. It used to be that if you did not know the meaning of a Talmudic or Aramaic word, you would turn to your Jastrow Dictionary and eventually find the meaning. Of course that was provided you knew the root of the word and where to look. The Jastrow which is the flag ship of Talmudic Aramaic Dictionaries is thousands of pages and anyone who ever used one, will appreciate Word by Word Aramaic Dictionary. Now with Word by Word Aramaic Dictionary, you have instant access to 166,895 words and definitions in Aramaic or English. Word by Word Aramaic Dictionary translates Aramaic and Talmudic words to English and vice versa. When there are multiple meanings of a word, it will show...

Outdoor Research Lightweight Pack Cover Dark Grey, L

Outdoor Research Lightweight Pack Cover Dark Grey, L
by Outdoor Research

Anyone who has ever hiked for a day after day in the pouring rain understands the necessity of the Outdoor Research Lightweight Pack Cover. This waterproof cover keeps your gear dry under coated HydroLite fabric and conforms to your packs shape thanks to an elastic drawstring.

Product FeaturesMaterial: HydroLiteDimensions: [M] 41.75 x 14 x 13in (106 x 36 x 33m); [L] 47 x 15 x 15in (119 x 38 x 38cm); [XL] 52.5 x 16 x 18in (132 x 41 x 43cm) Size Range: [M] 1800-3000cu in (28-50L); [L] 2800-5000cu in (45-80L); [XL] 5000+cu in (80+L)Weight: [M] 5.3oz (150g); [L] 6.4oz (181g); [XL] 7.8oz (221g)Recommended Use: Keeping your pack dryManufacturer Warranty:...

© 2009 BrightSurf.com