Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print How fairness is wired in the brain

How fairness is wired in the brain

May 29, 2008

PASADENA, Calif.--In the biblical story in which two women bring a baby to King Solomon, both claiming to be the mother, he suggests dividing the child so that each woman can have half. Solomon's proposed solution, meant to reveal the real mother, also illustrates an issue central to economics and moral philosophy: how to distribute goods fairly.

Now, researchers at the California Institute of Technology have discovered that reason struggles with emotion to find equitable solutions, and have pinpointed the region of the brain where this takes place. The concept of fairness, they found, is processed in the insular cortex, or insula, which is also the seat of emotional reactions.




"The fact that the brain has such a robust response to unfairness suggests that sensing unfairness is a basic evolved capacity," notes Steven Quartz, an associate professor of philosophy at Caltech and author of the study, voicing a sentiment that anyone who has seen children fight over a treat can relate to.

"The movement to look into the neural basis for ethical decision making is only about seven years old," Quartz says. "This is the first study where people made real decisions with real consequences."

The subjects in the study, 26 men and women between 28 and 55 years old, faced a real-world moral dilemma. They started their participation in the experiment by reading a short biography of each of the 60 orphans at the Canaan Children's Home in Uganda. The orphanage would receive a sum of money that would depend on decisions the subjects made. In the end, $2,279 was donated.

While a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) machine scanned their brains for peak activity regions, the participants each had about eight seconds to decide how to distribute meals among groups of children in different scenarios. In one, their choice would grant either four extra meals to each of two children or six extra meals to one child. The children they didn't choose would get nothing. In another scenario, the kids had been given extra meals and the subjects had to decide whether it was better to take six meals away from each of two kids, or ten meals away from one.

Ultimately the subjects' brains made a choice, and Quartz and his collaborators got to peek into where that calculation was made. "You wonder what is happening at different levels--is your brain's decision right or not""

When they got to give food to the children, the study participants' orbital frontal cortex, the reward region of the brain, lit up. When instead they had to take food away, the insula region--the emotional processor--was activated.

Quartz suggests that the insula was triggered by the inequity of the choices. The activity varied considerably across subjects, indicating that individual differences in moral sensitivity may be rooted in the strength of the biological responses, he adds.

"The emotional response to unfairness pushes people from extreme inequity and drives them to be fair," Quartz says. This observation, he adds, suggests that "our basic impulse to be fair isn't a complicated thing that we learn."

This study, which appears in the May 8 early online edition of the journal Science, is the first to examine "neuroethics"--the neural underpinnings of moral decision making--with real-world consequences. It may also help guide how to make policy decisions about distributing resources. And, adds Jonathan Katz, chair of Caltech's Division of the Humanities and Social Sciences, "It's one of the first studies to bridge humanities research with social science and biology," a central effort at Caltech.

California Institute of Technology



Related Fairness Current Events and Fairness News Articles Fairness Current Events and Fairness News RSS Fairness Current Events and Fairness News RSS
New theory on fairness in economics targets CEO pay
Chief executives in 35 of the top Fortune 500 companies were overpaid by about 129 times their "ideal salaries" in 2008, according to a new type of theoretical analysis proposed by a Purdue University researcher to determine fair CEO compensation.

Cleanliness IS next to godliness: new research shows clean smells unconsciously promote moral behavior
People are unconsciously fairer and more generous when they are in clean-smelling environments, according to a soon-to-be published study led by a Brigham Young University professor.

Medical ethics experts identify, address key issues in H1N1 pandemic
The anticipated onset of a second wave of the H1N1 influenza pandemic could present a host of thorny medical ethics issues best considered well in advance, according to the University of Toronto Joint Centre for Bioethics, which today released nine papers for public discussion.

Classroom behavior: Why it's hard to be good
Being seen as either well behaved or naughty at school is never entirely in the hands of the individual child, this study funded by the Economic and Social Research Council shows.

A combination of education methods could be the key for some students aiming for higher education
Dr Geoff Hayward from Oxford University funded by the Economic and Social Research Council, who led the research points out, a high proportion of those with combined academic and vocational qualifications gained their qualifications in state-school sixth forms and have importantly similar backgrounds to the traditional academic applicants.

Studies show that nice guys finish first in business world
When it comes to leading a team tasked with developing new products and bringing them to market, new research from North Carolina State University shows that being nice and playing well with others gives you a very real competitive advantage.

Work stress associated with adverse mental and physical health outcomes in police officers
Exposure to critical incidents, workplace discrimination, lack of cooperation among coworkers, and job dissatisfaction correlated significantly with perceived work stress among urban police officers, according to a study by researchers at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health.

Lack of strategies to manage MRI wait lists a key reason for excessive wait times
A new study headed by Dr. Tom Feasby, Dean of UCalgary's Faculty of Medicine, shows that while Canada lags behind other countries in the number of diagnostic imaging devices, more machines are not the only solution to long wait times. The study's authors say it is critical to prioritize MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) requests effectively.

Experts examine risk-pooling through insurance to help poor countries cope with climate change
Insurance solutions are pushed forward at the climate negotiations this week in Poznan. This is a critical juncture to build insurance mechanisms solidly into the architecture of the agreement that will emerge in Copenhagen next year.

Report offers options for negotiators seeking to craft critical accord on forests and climate change
The Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) today released a comprehensive analysis clarifying major challenges and offering an assortment of options that could help negotiators reach a global agreement on reducing carbon emissions tied to forest destruction and degradation.
More Fairness Current Events and Fairness News Articles
No Fair!: Kids Talk About Fairness

No Fair!: Kids Talk About Fairness
by Loewen (Author), Nancy (Author), Wesley (Illustrator), Omarr (Illustrator)

Life isn't always fair, or is it? Hear what Tina Truly has to say about fairness.

It's Not Fair!

It's Not Fair!
by Amy Krouse Rosenthal (Author), Tom Lichtenheld (Illustrator)

Why'd I get the smaller half? Why don't you yell at her? Why does my team always lose? Why can't we have a pet giraffe? Because that's life.

And life can't always go the way we want it to. But with this delightful and witty book, Amy Krouse Rosenthal and Tom Lichtenheld reassure us that everyone, including pigs, planets, and square pegs, sometimes thinks: It's not fair!



Justice as Fairness: A Restatement

Justice as Fairness: A Restatement
by John Rawls (Author), Erin Kelly (Editor)

This book originated as lectures for a course on political philosophy that Rawls taught regularly at Harvard in the 1980s. In time the lectures became a restatement of his theory of justice as fairness, revised in light of his more recent papers and his treatise Political Liberalism (1993). As Rawls writes in the preface, the restatement presents "in one place an account of justice as fairness as I now see it, drawing on all [my previous] works." He offers a broad overview of his main lines of thought and also explores specific issues never before addressed in any of his writings.

Rawls is well aware that since the publication of A Theory of Justice in 1971, American society has moved farther away from the idea of justice as fairness. Yet his ideas retain their power and...

Fair & Lovely Multivitamin Total Fairness Cream 80g

Fair & Lovely Multivitamin Total Fairness Cream 80g
by Hindustan Unilever

Fair & Lovely Multivitamin Fairness Cream contains four essential vitamins to nourish and hydrates skin with radiant fairness. Vitamin B3 works to restrict melanin, Vitamin C reduces discoloration for even toned skin, Vitamin A to enhance skin elasticity

  Quigley's Village ~Fairness ~The Wacky Watermelon Break-In ~VHS
by Cornerstone Video

A delightful place where children learn Christian values. Running time 30 min ... for ages 2-7

Cutting in Line Isn't Fair (Main Street School) (Main Street School)

Cutting in Line Isn't Fair (Main Street School) (Main Street School)
by Anastasia Suen (Author), Jeff Ebbeler (Illustrator)

The students in Miss K s class experience situations that occur in schools everywhere. Jessie's first-person narratives teach about fairness with brilliant illustrations and humorous text.

Fairness Doctrine [CD on Demand]

Fairness Doctrine [CD on Demand]
by Jimmy Joe K

Fairness Doctrine by Jimmy Joe K

This product is manufactured on demand using CD-R recordable media. Amazon.com's standard return policy will apply.



Character Education: Fairness Laminated Motivational Poster. Guidance Art Print

Character Education: Fairness Laminated Motivational Poster. Guidance Art Print
by Jaguar Educational

The pillars of good character presented graphically for educational settings Includes a quote from Knute Rockne.

  CENSORSHIP DOCTRINE / FAIRNESS DOCTRINE T-Shirt (BLACK), Adult 4XL
by Cool Custom Design



A Sense of Fairness

A Sense of Fairness
Band of Joes (Primary Contributor)



© 2009 BrightSurf.com