 |
|
Intimate examinations should not be performed without consent
June 20, 2008Editorial: Informed consent and intimate examinations
Intimate examinations, performed by medical students on anaesthetised patients, are often carried out without adequate consent from patients, but this violates their basic human rights and should not be allowed, claims an editorial in the July issue of Student BMJ.
Although the examination of patients under anaesthesia provides a unique opportunity for medical students to practice with minimal distress to patients, it is vital that students put their responsibility towards patients before any learning opportunity, write Ohad Oren and Gershon Grunfeld from the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology in Israel.
The issue was highlighted earlier this year when Israeli medical students refused to intimately examine anaesthetised women without obtaining their informed consent.
Yet despite these concerns, some specialists consider pelvic examinations to be an ordinary part of medical practice for which specific consent is not needed, say the authors, while others fear that requiring informed consent from the patient will radically reduce training opportunities for students. There is also the presumption that patients understand that medical students and junior doctors will be involved in their care because they are being treated at a teaching hospital.
But according to the authors, this misses the point of informed consent and deprives patients of their choice as independent decision makers about their own medical care.
Performing intimate examinations on patients without their explicit consent is "a gross violation of the principle of respect for patients' autonomy", they argue.
The authors conclude by calling for the development of responsible hospital policy conducive to ethical practice and new well organised processes for obtaining consent.
In an accompanying feature, Daniel Stott examines the role of chaperones in intimate examinations for the protection of both patients and doctors, and discusses how the new emphasis on chaperones creates pressure on already "hard pressed" resources.
BMJ-British Medical Journal
The issue was highlighted earlier this year when Israeli medical students refused to intimately examine anaesthetised women without obtaining their informed consent.
Yet despite these concerns, some specialists consider pelvic examinations to be an ordinary part of medical practice for which specific consent is not needed, say the authors, while others fear that requiring informed consent from the patient will radically reduce training opportunities for students. There is also the presumption that patients understand that medical students and junior doctors will be involved in their care because they are being treated at a teaching hospital.
But according to the authors, this misses the point of informed consent and deprives patients of their choice as independent decision makers about their own medical care.
Performing intimate examinations on patients without their explicit consent is "a gross violation of the principle of respect for patients' autonomy", they argue.
The authors conclude by calling for the development of responsible hospital policy conducive to ethical practice and new well organised processes for obtaining consent.
In an accompanying feature, Daniel Stott examines the role of chaperones in intimate examinations for the protection of both patients and doctors, and discusses how the new emphasis on chaperones creates pressure on already "hard pressed" resources.
BMJ-British Medical Journal
Informed Consent Current Events and Informed Consent News RSSGenetic test for spinal muscular atrophy should be offered to all couples, says the ACMG
Carrier screening for spinal muscular atrophy (SMA)-a serious genetic disease affecting approximately 1 in 10,000 infants that causes progressive muscle weakness and death-should be made available to all families, according to a new practice guideline issued by the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG).
Largest study of fertility patients shows concerns about embryo disposition
Fertility patients who are done having children feel responsible for the stored, frozen embryos left over from their treatment, yet more than half are against implanting the embryos in anyone else, according to a new study by researchers at Duke University Medical Center.
First comprehensive genomic study of common cold reveals new treatment targets
Today, scientists from Procter & Gamble (P&G), the University of Calgary and the University of Virginia announced results from the first study to examine the entire human genome's response to the most common cold virus, human rhinovirus.
Updated guidelines for stem cell research released
The National Academies today released amended guidelines for research involving human embryonic stem cells, revising those that were issued in 2005 and updated in 2007.
Research Ethics Committees identify and correct problems in applications to do cancer trials
Researchers running cancer trials are often critical of the Research Ethics Committee (REC) process they have to go through to get their trials approved, complaining that it's too complex, burdensome and sometimes unreasonable. In the UK only 17% of research study applications are given immediate favourable opinion by RECs.
Oil and gas projects in western Amazon threaten biodiversity and indigenous peoples
The western Amazon, home to the most biodiverse and intact rainforest left on Earth, may soon be covered with oil rigs and pipelines.
A virtual toothache helps student dentists
Masha is a dental patient. Her oral health problems continue to change as she meets new Case Western Reserve University student dentists in Second Life's virtual dental office.
Indigenous peoples hardest hit by climate change describe impacts
Indigenous peoples have contributed the least to world greenhouse gas emissions and have the smallest ecological footprints on Earth.
Angina drug potentially useful against heart rhythm disorders
A recently approved angina drug may also represent a powerful new treatment for a rare hereditary syndrome that places teens at risk for sudden cardiac death, according to research presented to today at the 57th Annual Scientific Sessions of the American College of Cardiology (ACC) in Chicago.
Toward the ethical treatment of whole genome research participants
Recent technological developments have made it possible for scientists to sequence an entire human genome, but these advances may be a mixed blessing.
More Informed Consent Current Events and Informed Consent News Articles
 | Informed Consent by Sandra Glahn Jeremy Cramer, M.D. is the next Einstein of infectious disease research. While working on a way to revive water submersion victims, he makes a breakthrough discovery in AIDS research that thrusts him into the center of a media frenzy. But the publicity turns negative and his marriage reaches the breaking point when he accidentally infects a colleague and his negligence allows his son to contract... |
 | A History and Theory of Informed Consent by Ruth R. Faden, Tom L. Beauchamp Clearly argued and written in nontechnical language, this book provides a definitive account of informed consent. It begins by presenting the analytic framework for reasoning about informed consent found in moral philosophy and law. The authors then review and interpret the history of informed consent in clinical medicine, research, and the courts. They argue that respect for autonomy has had... |
 | Agent GCP and the Bloody Consent Form Library Edition: Informed Consent and Institutional Review Boards in Clinical Trials, for Beginner to Advanced, for ... Also Relevant to Biomedical Ethics by Daniel Farb Agent GCP is THE way to learn FDA regulations. The exciting, suspenseful, and sometimes zany plot of a murder in a clinical trial is interweaved with interactivity and teaching of FDA regulations in an unforgettable manner. Subjects are modularized so that learners can take one subject out of sequence should they need to. At the completion, learners will have obtained a superb knowledge of... |
 | Informed Consent: Legal Theory and Clinical Practice by Jessica W. Berg, Paul S. Appelbaum, Lisa S. Parker, Charles W. Lidz Few issues affecting the therapeutic professions are as much discussed and as little understood as informed consent. This book, written from the combined perspectives of a physician, a lawyer, and a social scientist, is the first reference work to provide a concise overview of informed consent with particular emphasis on the practical issues facing professionals. After introducing the ethical... |
 | Agent GCP and The Bloody Consent form Guidebook: Informed Consent and Institutional Review Boards in Clinical Trials, For Beginner to Advanced, For Pharmaceutical ... Also Relevant to Biomedical Ethics by Daniel Farb; Bruce Gordon Agent GCP is THE way to learn FDA regulations. The exciting, suspenseful, and sometimes zany plot of a murder in a clinical trial is interweaved with interactivity and teaching of FDA regulations in an unforgettable manner. At the completion, learners will have obtained a superb knowledge of informed consent and IRB regulations. This course covers all the regulations on informed consent... |
| Transparency: informed consent in primary care.: An article from: The Hastings Center Report by Howard Brody This digital document is an article from The Hastings Center Report, published by Hastings Center on September 1, 1989. The length of the article is 4031 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.Citation... | |
 | Informed Consent by John A. Byrne From a distinguished Business Week journalist, an inside look at the silicon breast implant controversy as it played out inside Dow Corning and in the lives of one of their executives and his wife, whose own implants caused near-fatal... |
 | Informed Consent in Blood Transfusion and Cellular Therapies: Patients, Donors and Research Subjects by Christopher P. Stowell and Kathleen Sazama Facing consent issues for donors? Responsible for the organization and delivery of transfusion and cellular therapies to patients? Working with recipients of treatment that is considered research? This book is the only up-to-date, comprehensive publication that deals with the process of obtaining informed consent for patients, donors and research subjects. It is an invaluable reference resource... |
 | Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment: A Guide for Physicians and Other Health Professionals by Thomas Grisso, Paul S. Appelbaum Univ. of Massachusetts, Worcester. Practical handbook, with numerous case studies, explaining how assessments should be conducted and offering detailed guidelines to assist practitioners in this task. DNLM: Patient Acceptance of Health... |
 | Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics by Neil C. Manson, Onora O'Neill Informed consent is a central topic in contemporary biomedical ethics. Yet attempts to set defensible and feasible standards for consenting have led to persistent difficulties. In Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics Neil Manson and Onora O'Neill set debates about informed consent in medicine and research in a fresh light. They show why informed consent cannot be fully specific or fully... |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |