 |
|
Exercise Pill is No Replacement for Exercise
August 06, 2008COLUMBIA, Mo. - Recently, researchers at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies, a research organization focused on biology and its relation to health, published a study in the journal Cell on the results of a substance that increased exercise endurance without daily exertion when tested in mice. Media reports have described this substance as an "exercise pill," potentially eliminating the need for exercise. Frank Booth, a University of Missouri expert on the science of inactivity, says the "exercise pill" study did not test all of the commonly known benefits of exercise and taking the pill cannot be considered a replacement for exercise.
In the Cell paper "Exercise Mimetics" the researchers demonstrated that AMPK-PPARδ pathways, which is a cellular messenger system, can be targeted by orally active drugs to enhance training adaptation or even to increase endurance without exercise. However, Booth cautions that some of the commonly known benefits of exercise were not tested in the Cell paper including:
Decreased resting and submaximal exercise heart rate
Increased heart stroke volume at all exercise work loads
Increased maximal exercise cardiac output
Lower blood pressure and arterial stiffness
Increased aerobic capacity
A complete list of the 26 benefits not tested in the paper is included below.
The prevention of the increased risk of chronic disease produced by lifelong physical inactivity also was not tested in the Cell paper. According to Katzmarzyk & Janssen (Can J Appl Physiol 29:90, 2004), human physical activity decreases the risk of:
Coronary artery disease (decreases risk by 45 percent)
Stroke (decreases risk by 60 percent)
Hypertension (decreases risk by 30 percent)
Colon cancer (decreases risk by 41 percent)
Breast cancer (decreases risk by 30 percent)
Type 2 diabetes (decreases risk by 50 percent)
Osteoporosis (decreases risk by 59 percent)
Until targeting AMPK-PPARδ pathways by drugs is shown to have all the above listed exercise benefits in humans, it is premature to use the term "exercise mimetics" from the very limited observations of the Cell paper, Booth said. Booth's expectation, based upon his more than 40 years of research experience in exercise and physical inactivity adaptations, is that the drugs in the Cell paper will only partially imitate exercise. In order for any "exercise pill" to counter physical inactivity, the pill must be
polygenic, or control many genes at once; therefore the Cell drugs are not likely to provide all of the
benefits of comprehensive physical activity. In Booth's opinion, the drugs used in the Cell paper were not conclusively proven to mimic exercise, contrary to media reports.
Booth has more than 40 years of research experience in physiological, biochemical, molecular and genetic adaptations that occur during exercise. He is a professor in the MU College of Veterinary Medicine and the MU School of Medicine and a research investigator in the Dalton Cardiovascular Research Center. He is a member of the editorial boards of Journal of Applied Physiology, American Journal of Physiology: Cell Physiology, Physiological Genomics and CardioMetabolic Syndrome.
Commonly known benefits of exercise not tested in the Cell paper were:
Decreased resting and submaximal exercise heart rate
Increased heart stroke volume at all exercise work loads
Increased maximal exercise cardiac output
Lower blood pressure and arterial stiffness
Increased aerobic capacity
Increased strength and cross-sectional area of skeletal muscle
Delayed loss of muscle mass and strength with aging and physical frailty
Improved balance and coordination
Improved flexibility
Reduced osteoporosis
Reduced joint stress and back pain
Decreased gallstone disease
Improved endothelial function
Decreased incidence of myocardial ischemia
Less myocardial damage from ischemia
Decreased oxidative stress
Decreased inflammation
Improved immune function
Decreased liver steatosis and fatty liver disease
Improved insulin sensitivity and reduced risk of type 2 diabetes
Less likelihood of depression, anxiety, stress and poor psychological well-being
Ameliorating hyperlipidemia: lower total cholesterol, higher HDL, and decreased blood triglycerides
Improved cognitive function in the elderly
Increased blood flow and neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus of the hypothalamus
Prevention of the loss of brain volume in the elderly
Delay in decline of physiological reserve in organ systems with aging
University of Missouri
Increased heart stroke volume at all exercise work loads
Increased maximal exercise cardiac output
Lower blood pressure and arterial stiffness
Increased aerobic capacity
A complete list of the 26 benefits not tested in the paper is included below.
The prevention of the increased risk of chronic disease produced by lifelong physical inactivity also was not tested in the Cell paper. According to Katzmarzyk & Janssen (Can J Appl Physiol 29:90, 2004), human physical activity decreases the risk of:
Coronary artery disease (decreases risk by 45 percent)
Stroke (decreases risk by 60 percent)
Hypertension (decreases risk by 30 percent)
Colon cancer (decreases risk by 41 percent)
Breast cancer (decreases risk by 30 percent)
Type 2 diabetes (decreases risk by 50 percent)
Osteoporosis (decreases risk by 59 percent)
Until targeting AMPK-PPARδ pathways by drugs is shown to have all the above listed exercise benefits in humans, it is premature to use the term "exercise mimetics" from the very limited observations of the Cell paper, Booth said. Booth's expectation, based upon his more than 40 years of research experience in exercise and physical inactivity adaptations, is that the drugs in the Cell paper will only partially imitate exercise. In order for any "exercise pill" to counter physical inactivity, the pill must be
polygenic, or control many genes at once; therefore the Cell drugs are not likely to provide all of the
benefits of comprehensive physical activity. In Booth's opinion, the drugs used in the Cell paper were not conclusively proven to mimic exercise, contrary to media reports.
Booth has more than 40 years of research experience in physiological, biochemical, molecular and genetic adaptations that occur during exercise. He is a professor in the MU College of Veterinary Medicine and the MU School of Medicine and a research investigator in the Dalton Cardiovascular Research Center. He is a member of the editorial boards of Journal of Applied Physiology, American Journal of Physiology: Cell Physiology, Physiological Genomics and CardioMetabolic Syndrome.
Commonly known benefits of exercise not tested in the Cell paper were:
Decreased resting and submaximal exercise heart rate
Increased heart stroke volume at all exercise work loads
Increased maximal exercise cardiac output
Lower blood pressure and arterial stiffness
Increased aerobic capacity
Increased strength and cross-sectional area of skeletal muscle
Delayed loss of muscle mass and strength with aging and physical frailty
Improved balance and coordination
Improved flexibility
Reduced osteoporosis
Reduced joint stress and back pain
Decreased gallstone disease
Improved endothelial function
Decreased incidence of myocardial ischemia
Less myocardial damage from ischemia
Decreased oxidative stress
Decreased inflammation
Improved immune function
Decreased liver steatosis and fatty liver disease
Improved insulin sensitivity and reduced risk of type 2 diabetes
Less likelihood of depression, anxiety, stress and poor psychological well-being
Ameliorating hyperlipidemia: lower total cholesterol, higher HDL, and decreased blood triglycerides
Improved cognitive function in the elderly
Increased blood flow and neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus of the hypothalamus
Prevention of the loss of brain volume in the elderly
Delay in decline of physiological reserve in organ systems with aging
University of Missouri
Exercise Current Events and Exercise News RSSA Simple Blood Test for Colon Cancer
People are often reluctant to undergo a routine but painful colonoscopy ― but the consequences can be fatal. According to the American Cancer Society, colon cancer is the third most common cancer found in American men and women and kills about 50,000 Americans every year.
Track your fitness, environmental impact with new cell phone applications
Planning on gobbling a few extra treats this holiday season? Soon, your cell phone may be able to help you maintain your exercise routine and keep the pounds off over winter months, without your having to lift a finger to keep track.
Home-based diet and exercise intervention improves elderly cancer survivors' physical function
A home-based program to improve exercise and diet led to significant, clinically meaningful improvement in body weight and physical function among older long-term cancer survivors in preliminary findings from the RENEW (Reach-out to ENhancE Wellness) trial.
Science teams at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory identify 13 new tumor-suppressor genes in liver cancer
Over the years, hunting for cancer-related genes and understanding how they work has been an important, although time-consuming, exercise. At Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL), five different research groups have now combined their expertise to speed up the rate of discovering cancer-related genes and validating their function in living animals.
How often will you use that treadmill?
Why not buy that treadmill? You'll be exercising every day, right? A new study in the Journal of Consumer Research examines why our expectations of our behavior so often don't match reality.
Physical activity after bariatric surgery improves weight loss, quality of life
A new study by researchers from The Miriam Hospital's Centers for Behavioral and Preventive Medicine suggests increased physical activity after bariatric surgery can yield better postoperative outcomes.
Exercise increases brain growth factor and receptors, prevents stem cell drop in middle age
A new study confirms that exercise can reverse the age-related decline in the production of neural stem cells in the hippocampus of the mouse brain, and suggests that this happens because exercise restores a brain chemical which promotes the production and maturation of new stem cells.
UNC study: text messaging may help children fight off obesity
A new study from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill suggests that cell phone text messaging could be used to reduce children's chances of becoming overweight or obese later in life, by helping them monitor and modify their own behaviors now.
Brisk walk could help chocoholics stop snacking
Researchers at the University of Exeter have found that a walk of just fifteen minutes can reduce chocolate cravings. The benefits of exercise in helping people manage dependencies on nicotine and other drugs have previously been recognised. Now, for the first time, newly-published research shows that the same may be true for food cravings.
MSU researcher studies ties between cholesterol drugs, muscle problems
A Michigan State University researcher is studying whether the most popular class of cholesterol-lowering drugs may cause muscle problems in users.
More Exercise Current Events and Exercise News Articles
 | Diary of an Exercise Addict by Peach Friedman Friedman suffered from exercise bulimiaβa compulsion to purge calories through excessive exercise, and a rapidly growing eating disorder that affects some 400,000 American women. Β In Diary of an Exercise Addict Friedman recounts her descent into a life-threatening illness, her remarkable recovery, and the setbacks along the way. With refreshing candor she lays bare her relationships with... |
 | ACSM's Resource Manual for Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription (ACSM's Resource Manual for Guidelines for Exercise Testing a) Designed as a companion to ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription and as a textbook for ACSM certification candidates, this book covers all the major aspects of preventive rehabilitative and fitness programs and the main points from all position stands of the American College of Sports Medicine. It provides readers with the necessary background information to address the... |
 | Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations and Techniques (Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations & Techniques) by Carol Kisner, Lynn Allen Colby Thoroughly updated to highlight current evidence to support best practice, Kisner & Colby's new 5th edition offers the most up-to-date guidelines for managing musculoskeletal conditions. Now even more extensively illustrated, it provides principles of therapeutic exercise and manual therapy. It describes pathologic conditions and surgical procedures commonly encountered by therapists in the... |
 | Spark: The Revolutionary New Science of Exercise and the Brain by John J. Ratey A groundbreaking and fascinating investigation into the transformative effects of exercise on the brain, from the bestselling author and renowned psychiatrist John J. Ratey, MD.Did you know you can beat stress, lift your mood, fight memory loss, sharpen your intellect, and function better than ever simply by elevating your heart rate and breaking a sweat? The evidence is incontrovertible: Aerobic... |
 | The Calorie King Food & Exercise Journal by Alan Borushek (Author) - Pocket-sized, travels easily - 10-week, one day per page with weekly summary page - Space to record calories for food and exercise - Optional columns for carbohydrate, protein or fat intake - Water/fluid intake section on each page - Quick exercise guide - Tips on diet, exercise, changing eating... |
 | BodyMinder Workout and Exercise Journal (A Fitness Diary) by F. E. Wilkins The BODYMINDER is the ultimate physical fitness diary. With a focus on workouts, it can also be used to keep track of any and all other exercise. Each "day" consists of two pages with an organized, easy-to-use layout for recording workout details...from equipment & settings, to reps & sets, to difficulty level, to heart rate, to muscle groups, and more. There is also space for listing the... |
 | Physiology of Sport and Exercise, Fourth Edition by Jack H. Wilmore, David Costill, W. Larry Kenney "Physiology of Sport and Exercise, Fourth Edition", stands alone as the best, most comprehensive resource framing the latest research findings in a reader-friendly format. This winning combination makes it easier and more engaging than ever for students to develop their understanding of the body's marvelous abilities to perform various types and intensities of exercise and sport, to adapt to... |
 | Exercise Physiology: Energy, Nutrition, and Human Performance (Exercise Physiology ( MC Ardle)) by William D McArdle, Frank I Katch, Victor L Katch This textbook integrates basic concepts and relevant scientific information to provide a foundation for understanding nutrition, energy transfer, and exercise training. The new Sixth Edition continues to provide excellent coverage of exercise physiology, uniting the topics of human performance, nutrition, energy expenditure and capacity, molecular biology, and more. Every chapter has been fully... |
 | Smart Exercise: Burning Fat, Getting Fit by Covert Bailey Best-selling author Covert Bailey has revolutionized thinking about health and fitness. Smart Exercise is a comprehensive guide to exercise and a lucid explanation of how our bodies stay fit or fat. Most important, Smart Exercise reveals the world's best-kept secret about fitness: keep your muscles in peak form and everything else will follow. Using his famous sense of humor to great effect,... |
 | Treat Your Own Knees: Simple Exercises to Build Strength, Flexibility, Responsiveness and Endurance by Jim Johnson Treat Your Own Knees shows how to reduce or end knee pain by improving knee function. In easy-to-grasp language, author Jim Johnson covers the physiology of the knee and the kinds of pain that affect it, along with the psychological aspects. He offers a series of straightforward exercises based on current medical data and tested in his practice. Black-and-white drawings show exactly how to do the... |
| © 2008 BrightSurf.com |