Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print MSU study finds that not all hearing aids are created equal

MSU study finds that not all hearing aids are created equal

August 14, 2008

Consumers with hearing loss might think they are saving significantly more by purchasing over- the-counter hearing aids, but they most likely will be disappointed - or could be taking risks - when purchasing such aids, according to MSU research.

Professor Jerry Punch of the Department of Communicative Sciences and Disorders and Susanna Love Callaway, a lifelong education alumna and international student from Denmark, published their study on over-the-counter hearing aids in a recent issue of the American Journal of Audiology.

Through her work as a student in Punch's two online courses, Callaway began to wonder about the high cost variability of hearing aids and asked Punch to advise her on a potential project. Specifically, do hearing aids have to be expensive to work from a purely technical standpoint? Punch and Callaway set out to find the answer by subjecting 11 over-the-counter hearing aids to the same test protocol as traditional hearing aids.




Most consumers do not have or have only partial insurance coverage for hearing aids, leading to out-of-pocket expenses ranging from hundreds to thousands of dollars. Low-cost options are typically marketed on the Internet and in mail-order magazines as listening devices - often for bird watchers or deer hunters.

"These low-cost amplifying devices can look tempting to individuals with hearing impairment because of the significant cost differences," Punch said. "But our research found that the low-cost aids generally don't meet the fitting requirements to help a hearing-impaired person and could potentially damage a person's hearing."

The research is important to consumers, Callaway said. "Aside from being of extremely poor quality, very low-cost hearing aids - those under $100 - have the potential to damage your hearing because they send very loud sounds into the ear. The study's mid-range hearing aids ($100-500) were of higher quality and were not considered a safety hazard."

The authors state in their article that aids costing $100 to $500 often control the amount of sound sent into the ear better, but without a precise and knowledge-based fitting of the device by an audiologist, consumers can expect to experience hit-or-miss success, Punch said. "Based on the research, the best advice for consumers is to talk to an audiologist. Because hearing aids have complex technical features, they need to be fitted and customized to the individual."

The study measured how well the electronic features of the devices could compensate for commonly occurring types of hearing loss, employing methods that audiologists use to fit conventional hearing aids - a process audiologists call prescriptive fitting. Specifically, the researchers found that only a few of the aids they studied met the basic fitting requirements, and, for the few that did, that was true only for a specific degree of hearing loss.

"Currently, more than 32 million people have a hearing impairment, yet only about 25 percent of those use hearing aids," Punch said. "Meanwhile, the aging population is growing - and hearing loss becomes more common as we become older."

Although the Food and Drug Administration officially regulates hearing aids, those regulations are not enforced for low-cost amplifying devices that are sold through mail order and on the Internet, Punch said. He thinks that people with hearing loss should have more information about these devices.

The research was funded by the Oticon Foundation, and equipment was provided by Frye Electronics of Oregon for the duration of study.

Callaway is first author on the paper, which was part of her master's thesis for her degree in audiology at the University of Copenhagen. She is currently completing the requirements for a doctorate degree at Western Michigan University.

Michigan State University



Related Hearing Aids Current Events and Hearing Aids News Articles Hearing Aids Current Events and Hearing Aids News RSS Hearing Aids Current Events and Hearing Aids News RSS
New tool to assess speech development in infants, toddlers with hearing impairments
The number of hearing impaired infants and toddlers who are successfully aided by technological devices, such as hearing aids and cochlear implants, continues to grow, but there are still unknowns about these children's speaking abilities, according to a Purdue University expert.

National guidelines released for earwax removal
The American Academy of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery Foundation (AAO-HNSF) will issue the first comprehensive clinical guidelines to help health care practitioners identify patients with cerumen (commonly referred to as earwax) impaction. The guidelines emphasize evidence-based management of cerumen impaction by clinicians, and inform patients of the purpose of ear wax in hearing health.

New research offers insight into oral cancer, chronic pediatric ear infections, and hearing health
Three new studies published in the June 2008 edition of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery focus on what role gender plays in the prognosis of oral tongue cancer, chronic ear infections in children, and the success rates of hearing aid implants in the elderly.

Lend me your ears -- and the world will sound very different
Recognising people, objects or animals by the sound they make is an important survival skill and something most of us take for granted. But very similar objects can physically make very dissimilar sounds and we are able to pick up subtle clues about the identity and source of the sound.

How to imbue products with symbolic meaning
Many people pay silly money to wear a particular logo or a designer brand. Of course, a designer outfit doesn't keep you any warmer or dryer than an unbranded one, but functionality is only part of the story. Designer products say something about you - you are a trendy, sexy or sophisticated person. Brands help us to express who we think we are and who we want to be.

Researcher developing new method for hearing loss assessment
A Purdue University researcher is working on a new technique to diagnose hearing loss in a way that more accurately reflects real-world situations.

Ability to listen to 2 things at once is largely inherited, says twin study
Your ability to listen to a phone message in one ear while a friend is talking into your other ear-and comprehend what both are saying-is an important communication skill that's heavily influenced by your genes.

For First Time, Cochlear Implant Restores Hearing To Patient With Rare Genetic Disorder
Researchers at Georgetown University Medical Center and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) have, for the first time, used a "bionic" ear to restore hearing in a patient with von Hippel-Lindau disease. They say this advance offers new hope for individuals with the rare disorder, which can produce non-malignant tumors in ears, as well as in the eyes, brain, and kidneys.

Some children are born with 'temporary deafness' and do not require cochlear implant
Clinical research conducted in the Department of Communication Disorders at the University of Haifa revealed that some children who are born deaf "recover" from their deafness and do not require surgical intervention.

One membrane, many frequencies
Modern hearing aids, though quite sophisticated, still do not faithfully reproduce sound as hearing people perceive it. New findings at the Weizmann Institute of Science shed light on a crucial mechanism for discerning different sound frequencies and thus may have implications for the design of better hearing aids.
More Hearing Aids Current Events and Hearing Aids News Articles


The Consumer Handbook on Hearing Loss and Hearing Aids: A Bridge to Healing

Ideal for helping anyone who has a hearing deficiency to enjoy life to its fullest, this guide explores the causes and management of hearing loss and the corrective products and resources available. Readers will get professional advice on the choices of hearing devices as well as point-by-point explanations on types and care of aids and tips for extending the life of the mechanism. More than just...



Digital Hearing AIDS
by James M. Kates



The Hearing Aid Dispensers Business Development Guide: It's not how much you make; It's how much you keep
by MBA, PhD, Dr. Gerald DuBrino

Achieving a Return On Investment is not happenstance. It is a direct result of utilizing sound business practices. Dr. DuBrino has contributed 4 articles to Advance for Audiologists and Advance for Nurse Practitioners over the past 5 years that have presented the research and day to day experiences of consulting with various audiologists throughout the industry. Erecting a sign outside the...



The Hearing Aid Decision: Answers to Your Many Questions
by Randall D. Smith, Jerome G. Alpiner, Megan Mulvey



Hearing Aids
by Harvey Dillon

Up-to-date information on all aspects of hearing aids: their technology, how they alter sound, and how they are prescribed, selected, fitted, measured and evaluated. Comprehensive - Technologically oriented topics, people oriented topics, and many that fill the gap between these. Theoretically sound - Issues and findings explained rather than just discussed or reported. Recommended practices are...



Digital Hearing Aids
by Arthur Schaub

Digital Hearing Aids is an essential reference for information about the latest innovations in digital hearing aid technology. Concise descriptions and easy-to-reference tables and diagrams enable the reader to rapidly gian a solid understanding of digital signal processing, inclding such important topics as adaptive acoustic directionality, adaptive noise reduction, adaptive feed-back...



Understanding Digitally Programmable Hearing AIDS



2008-2009 Hearing Aid Handbook
by Jeffrey J. DiGiovanni

This unique desk reference on hearing aids gives unprecedented access to the major hearing aid manufacturers and their product lines, in a convenient “at-a-glance” format. Nine major manufacturers are profiled, with background information on each company including history, research and development, philanthropic activity, and warranty information. Following each profile is a comprehensive...



Hearing Instrument Technology for the Hearing Health Care Professional
by Andi Vonlanthen, Horst Arndt

Hearing Instrument Technology for the Hearing Healthcare Professional is designed to provide the reader with technical information about hearing aids and related technology in a simple and approachable manner. Written by hearing aid product researchers with over 40 years of combined experience, the text successfully covers the history and contemporary developments of hearing technology without...



Overcoming Hearing Aid Fears: The Road to Better Hearing
by John M. Burkey

There are dozens of misconceptions about hearing aids: "They make you look old," "They cause ear infections," "They increase hearing loss," "I can't afford one". The misinformation impairs a person's quality of life by discouraging him or her from pursuing help. Technological advances have enable hearing aids to address a greater range of hearing losses, while making them smaller, better designed...

© 2008 BrightSurf.com