Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Study finds a wide variety of errors in testing process at family medicine clinics

Study finds a wide variety of errors in testing process at family medicine clinics

August 15, 2008

Bad outcomes more common for minority patients

The largest study to date of testing errors reported by family physician offices in the United States found that problems occur throughout the testing process and disproportionately affect minority patients.




In the June 2008 issue of Quality & Safety in Health Care, the researchers report that medical testing errors led to lost time, lost money, delays in care, and pain and suffering for patients, with adverse consequences affecting minority patients far more often.

"I think everybody has had an occasion where their physician did a test, and they just didn't hear back," said John Hickner, MD, professor and vice chair of family medicine at the University of Chicago Medical Center. "People identify that as a common experience. The incident reports we received voluntarily from family physicians and their office staff detail what the problem areas are."

"There's a fair amount of risk and harm that results from testing mistakes and slips," he added. "This data provides a starting point for improvement."

The study took place at eight family physician offices--all part of the American Academy of Family Physicians National Research Network. Four of the doctors' offices were rural, three urban and one suburban.

During 32 weeks in 2004, 243 clinicians and office staff submitted 590 anonymous reports describing 966 medical-test-related errors. The tests included lab work, diagnostic imaging and other tests such as pulmonary function tests and electrocardiograms.

Errors were classified in one of 10 categories: test ordering, test implementation, reporting results to the clinician, clinician responding to results, notifying the patient of results, administrative, treatments, communications, other process errors, and knowledge and skills.

The most common errors involved failure to report results to the clinician, accounting for one out of four (24.6%) reported mistakes. Test implementation (17.9%) and administrative errors (17.6%) were the next most common.

Test implementation errors were nearly double for minority groups, at 32 percent versus 18 percent for non-Hispanic whites. The investigators believe this may reflect difficulties with transportation to the testing site or lack of insurance to pay for the test.

A quarter of the errors resulted in delays in care for patients, and 13 percent caused pain, suffering or a definite adverse clinical consequence. Eighteen percent resulted in harm.

"One of the most striking and disturbing findings was that minority patients were nearly three times more likely to experience adverse consequences," Hickner said, and twice as likely to experience physical harm from errors.

The researchers reported considerable variation in the types of errors reported from each practice. "While significant physical harm was rare, adverse consequences for patients were common," Hickner observed. "This study strongly supports the need for office-by-office improvements in the overall testing process within primary care."

Although this study was not designed to determine the true error rate, "testing-process errors appear to be common," the authors conclude. "Since many errors are undetected or unreported, we can assume this is an extreme lower bound."

An accompanying paper in the same journal from the same study looked at how often harm to patients was prevented or reduced by early detection and intervention. About 25 percent of the errors were discovered in time for an intervention, usually by physicians. "This demonstrates the continuing importance of people," the authors note, "and cautions against the over-reliance on current technological systems."

University of Chicago Medical Center



Related Medicine Clinics Current Events and Medicine Clinics News Articles
Flu surveillance boosts control, treatment options, says UAB travel-clinic chief
Because pandemics unfold in unpredictable ways, surveillance of travel-related illness is among the most powerful tools health officials and doctors can use to detect and respond to new pathogens like the novel H1N1 influenza, says the physician who heads the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) Travelers' Clinic.

New chlamydia test offers rapid, pain-free test for men
A new urine test developed with funding from the Wellcome Trust will allow doctors to diagnose Chlamydia infection in men within the hour, improving the ability to successfully treat the infection on the spot and prevent re-transmission.

Exposure to family violence compromises physical and mental health of older women
Older African American women exposed to high levels of family violence during their lifetimes are at significantly greater risk of poor health status, according to a report in the current issue of Journal of Women's Health, a peer-reviewed journal published by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.

Neglected tropical diseases burden those overseas, but travelers also at risk
Though little known to most Americans, lymphatic filariasis, trachoma, leishmaniasis, onchocerciasis, schistosomiasis and other so-called neglected tropical diseases are responsible for severe health burdens, especially among the world's poorest people.

Urgent need for new campaigns to combat soaring rates of sexually transmitted infections
Sexual health awareness campaigns really do work, and new ones are urgently needed to combat soaring rates of sexually transmitted infection (STI), reveals a study in Sexually Transmitted Infections. The research, principally from the Communicable Disease Surveillance Centre of the Public Health Laboratory Service, shows that HIV and AIDS awareness campaigns in the mid and late 1980s cut STI rates. They also probably helped prevent the kinds of levels of HIV infection of most of the rest of Europe, which are up to six times higher than those in the UK. But since the 1980s, HIV infection has remained high, while in the past five years bacterial infections, such as gonorrhoea and syphilis, ha
More Medicine Clinics Current Events and Medicine Clinics News Articles
Mayo Clinic Internal Medicine Review, Eighth Edition

Mayo Clinic Internal Medicine Review, Eighth Edition
by Amit K. Ghosh (Editor)

Written by experienced faculty at Mayo Clinic, this Eighth Edition is a completely revised and updated study tool that has proved invaluable for the American Board of Internal Medicine certification or maintenance of certification as well as general practice review by physicians around the world.



Using this source, physicians will access a virtual blueprint for exam preparation and acquire clear guidance on question format, types of questions, and hints on topics commonly encountered on the test.



Providing more than 350 MULTIPLE-CHOICE QUESTIONS that simulate the current exam format, this must-have guide will equip readers with the resources they need to anticipate testing challenges and pass the exam. Here are just a few of the great features...

Mayo Clinic Wellness Solutions for Heart Health

Mayo Clinic Wellness Solutions for Heart Health
Starring: Dr. Brent A. Bauer Mayo Clinic, Dr. Bijoy K. Khandheria Mayo Clinic, Rodney Yee
Directed By: Cathe Neukum

TAKE CHARGE OF YOUR HEALTH
Mayo Clinic, one of the top medical centers in the country, and GAIAM, the health and wellness experts, team up to bring you this groundbreaking, integrated health action plan designed specifically to to improve heart health. Changing the way you live can change the way you feel.
PART 1: UNDERSTANDING YOUR CONDITION
A 30-minute conversation with Mayo Clinic specialists. Dr. Brent Bauer introduces you to the integrative treatment approach, and Mayo Clinic doctors share everything you need to know about your condition and an array of conventional and alternative therapy options.
PART 2: EAT WELL TO FEEL WELL
Change your diet to feel better. Dr. Donald Hensrud, Chair, Preventive Medicine, Mayo Clinic, takes you grocery shopping and shares smart ways...

Hospice Pensioners Clinic Boules Medicine 1903 France

Hospice Pensioners Clinic Boules Medicine 1903 France
by old-print

A Page And Reverse Side As Shown Taken From The ILlustration Newspaper Of 1903. A Weekly Newspaper Published In Paris. It Was Founded By Edouard Charton; The First Issue Was Published On March 4Th 1843. Size Of Each Page Is Approx 15 X 11 Inches (380X280) All Are Genuine Prints And Not Reproductions. Please Check Image Carefully For The Condition Of These Prints.

Da Medicine Man

Da Medicine Man
New Orleans Musicians' Clinic (Primary Contributor)



  Mens Health Advisor - Cleveland Clinic
by Cleveland Clinic



  Colorectal Disease [VHS]
Starring: Florida Cleveland Clinic



Sinol "All Natural" Headache Nasal Spray with capsaicin. This new pain reliever is being used by migraine and cluster headache clinics. Relief medicine that works.

Sinol "All Natural" Headache Nasal Spray with capsaicin. This new pain reliever is being used by migraine and cluster headache clinics. Relief medicine that works.
by Sinol USA, Inc

Sinol "All Natural" Headache Nasal Spray with capsaicin. This new pain reliever is being used by migraine and cluster headache clinics. Relief medicine that works. 200 spray treatments.

Meet Dr. Christian

Meet Dr. Christian
Starring: Jean Hersholt, Dorothy Lovett, Robert Baldwin, Enid Barnett, Paul Harvey
Directed By: Bernard Vorham, Bernard Vorhaus
Also With: Monroe Shaff (Producer), William Stephens (Producer)



MedCity News

MedCity News
by MedCity News

MedCity News is a news service focusing on business, innovation and influence in health care. We don’t write about consumer health or the research in medical journals. Instead, MedCity News covers health care as the economic engine of major American cities.Our current focus is Ohio and the rest of the Midwest.Kindle blogs are fully downloaded onto your Kindle so you can read them even when you're not wirelessly connected. And unlike RSS readers which often only provide headlines, blogs on Kindle give you full text content and images, and are updated wirelessly throughout the day.

Mayo Clinic Book of Alternative Medicine: The New Approach to Using the Best of Natural Therapies and Conventional Medicine (Mayo Clinic, Book of Alternative Medicine)

Mayo Clinic Book of Alternative Medicine: The New Approach to Using the Best of Natural Therapies and Conventional Medicine (Mayo Clinic, Book of Alternative Medicine)
by Mayo Clinic (Author)

The Mayo Clinic Book of Alternative Medicine is an illustrated, accessible guide to understanding what works and what doesn’t in the world of complementary and alternative medicine, and how to put this information to use in your everyday life.

From acupuncture to yoga, Echinacea to St. John’s wort, and meditation to healing touch, Mayo Clinic provides answers to the most pressing questions people have about the effectiveness of complementary and alternative medicine, and when it’s appropriate to use natural remedies in place of or in conjunction with traditional medicine. This guide also offers practical advice for treating common ailments and incorporating alternative treatments into your — and your family’s — life.

© 2009 BrightSurf.com