Findings challenge common practice regarding glucose control for critically ill patients

August 27, 2008

An analysis of randomized trials indicates that for critically ill adults, tight glucose control is not associated with a significantly reduced risk of death in the hospital, but is associated with an increased risk of hypoglycemia, calling into question the recommendation by many professional societies for tight glucose control for these patients, according to an article in the August 27 issue of JAMA.

In 2001, a randomized controlled trial (van den Berghe et al) showed that tight glucose control for critically ill surgical patients reduced hospital mortality by one-third. "Because few interventions in critically ill adult patients reduce mortality to this extent, the results of this trial were enthusiastically received and rapidly incorporated into guidelines," the authors write. Numerous organizations, including the American Diabetes Association and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists now recommend tight glucose control in all critically ill adults. "These recommendations have led to worldwide adoption of tight glucose control in a variety of intensive care unit (ICU) settings." But some subsequent trials of tight glucose control in certain ICU settings have failed to show the mortality benefit, and have indicated an increased risk for hypoglycemia (abnormally low blood sugar level).

Renda Soylemez Wiener, M.D., M.P.H., of the Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, White River Junction, Vt., and Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, N.H., and colleagues conducted a meta-analysis of 29 randomized controlled trials, examining the risks and benefits of tight glucose control (glucose goal less than 150 mg/dL) as compared with usual care in critically ill adults. The meta-analysis included data for 8,432 patients.

The researchers found that among these trials, there was no significant difference in hospital mortality between tight glucose control and usual care strategies (21.6 percent vs. 23.3 percent) and no significant difference in hospital mortality when stratified by surgical, medical, and medical-surgical ICU setting. Tight glucose control was not associated with a significantly decreased risk for new need for dialysis (11.2 percent vs. 12.1 percent), but was associated with a significantly decreased risk of septicemia (10.9 percent vs. 13.4 percent; generalized illness due to bacteria in the bloodstream). The risk of hypoglycemia was increased about 5-fold (13.7 percent vs. 2.5 percent).

"Given the overall findings of this meta-analysis, it seems appropriate that the guidelines recommending tight glucose control in all critically ill patients should be re-evaluated until the results of larger, more definitive clinical trials are available," the authors write.

JAMA and Archives Journals

---

---

	Beyond Fingersticks: The art of control with continuous glucose monitoring by Red Blood Cell Books Everything you ever wanted to know about CGM (but didn’t know to ask)! Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM), the revolutionary technology that’s poised to completely change diabetes care, gives you a unique peak beneath your skin, revealing what your blood sugar is doing—day and night and night and day. Beyond Fingersticks covers the history, science, biology, and technical details behind these systems. The author has left no stone unturned in helping you cope with the nuts and bolts of daily living with CGM systems, from choosing alarm thresholds that really work, to successful calibration, to affording a system, to dealing with the volumes of data they create. How to wear, travel, sleep with, and think about CGM—it’s all here for you. Yep. Even sex wearing...
	Guidelines urge early in-hospital glucose control.(Clinical Rounds): An article from: OB GYN News by Miriam E. Tucker (Author) This digital document is an article from OB GYN News, published by Thomson Gale on April 15, 2006. The length of the article is 645 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Guidelines urge early in-hospital glucose control.(Clinical Rounds) Author: Miriam E. Tucker Publication: OB GYN News (Magazine/Journal) Date: April 15, 2006 Publisher: Thomson Gale Volume: 41 Issue: 8 Page: 24(1) Distributed by Thomson...
	PREVENTING DIABETIC FOOT COMPLICATIONS: Tight glucose control and patient education are the keys (Postgraduate Medicine) by JTE Multimedia The landmark Diabetes Control and Complications Trial proved that hyperglycemia is directly related to development of diabetic microvascular complications and that glucose control can reduce or even prevent retinopathy, neuropathy, and nephropathy. These findings have profound implications in prevention and care of foot ulcers, a common complication of diabetes. In this article, Dr Culleton summarizes how to help patients become part of a healthcare team working to avoid possible serious consequences of uncontrolled hyperglycemia. Culleton JL. Preventing diabetic foot complications: tight glucose control and patient education are the keys. Original Publication Date: July 1999
	The G-Index Diet: Control Your Glucose Level and Lose Weight Now by Richard Podell (Author), William Proctor (Author) The reason most diets fail is that many "diet foods" stimulate the appetite and trigger out-of-control eating. This startling, proven guide to eating indicates which foods turn the metabolism on to start burning fat. Includes a balanced weight-loss regimen and a satisfying maintenance plan.
	Diabetes on Your Own Terms: * Enjoy guilt-free blood glucose control * Enjoy the foods you love * Live a stress-free life with few compli (Marlowe Diabetes Library) by Janis Roszler R.D. C.D.E L.D.N. R.D. C.D.E L.D.N. (Author) Despite prevailing ideas about diabetes treatment, you can learn to control your diabetes, instead of feeling like it controls you. This is the first book to underscore that managing your condition doesn't have to be focused on deprivation. Leading diabetes educator/dietitian Janis Roszler breaks new ground in Diabetes on Your Own Terms with her insight into balancing real life with the distresses and strains of dealing with diabetes. Diabetes on Your Own Terms will provide you with treatment options and how to establish health goals that suit your lifestyle and personality; information about healthy practices — weight loss, diet, and exercise — and suggestions for incorporating new habits into your daily life; an explanation of common diabetic complications, and how to avoid and/or...
	Benefits of Lispro Insulin: Control of postprandial glucose levels is within reach (Postgraduate Medicine) by JTE Multimedia How well would the following fit into your schedule? You must know when you will eat throughout the day, and about an hour beforehand you must inject an appropriate amount of insulin to offset the amount of carbohydrate you intend to consume. For many diabetic patients who use regular insulin, these are the requirements. Dr Bohannon describes a newly approved insulin that goes into action and gets out of the body faster, more closely mimicking the body's natural insulin response to food. Original Publication Date: February 1997
	Complete Guide to Carb Counting: How to Take the Mystery Out of Carb Counting and Improve Your Blood Glucose Control by Hope S. Warshaw R.D. (Author), Karmeen Kulkarni M.S. (Author) The completely revised Complete Guide to Carb Counting, 3rd edition, by the American Diabetes Association, provides you with the knowledge and the tools to put carbohydrate counting into practice. Rewritten and reorganized to introduce and explain carb counting concepts as you'll need them in your diabetes care plan, you'll learn why carb counting helps you manage your blood sugar, the amount of carb to eat, how to count the carbohydrates in meals, and how to count carbs using food labels, restaurant menus, and your eyes, too. This is THE meal planning system every carb-counting person with diabetes needs to manage their blood glucose.
	New Mechanisms in Glucose Control by Anthony H. Barnett (Author), Jenny Grice (Author) New Mechanisms in Glucose Control presents a clear overview of the new drugs and treatment therapies that have been developed in recent years to help improve glycaemic  management for the diabetic patient, namely the incretin mimetics (GLP-1 agonists) and DPP-4 inhibitors. It also considers other drug classes currently in development and undergoing clinical trials including the SGLT2 inhibitors and other pipeline products. In addition to pharma cotherapeutic agents, the role of bariatric as a management tool for diabetes is covered as well as consideration of the organisation of diabetes care with a community focus.This indispensable pocketbook details the newer treatments and offers a comparison with more traditional agents including sulphonyureas, glitazones and insulin. The pros and...
	Closed-Loop Control of Blood Glucose (Lecture Notes in Control and Information Sciences) by Frederick Chee (Author), Tyrone Fernando (Author) This book presents closed-loop blood glucose control in a simple manner, which includes the hardware and "software" components that make up the control system. It provides examples on how mathematical models are formulated as well as the control algorithms that stem from mathematical exercises. The book also describes the basic physiology of blood glucose regulation during fasting and meal from a functional level.
	8 Weeks to Maximizing Diabetes Control: How to Improve Your Blood Glucose and Stay Healthy with Type 2 Diabetes by Laura Hieronymus C.D.E (Author), Christine Tobin RN (Author) In just 8 weeks, you can learn the tricks of the trade for managing your type 2 diabetes. Whether you've just been diagnosed or have bee living with diabetes for years, 8 Weeks to Maximizing Diabetes Control gives you the tools and resources you need to reach your treatment goals.