Un-total Recall: Amnesics Remember Grammar, but Not Meaning of New Sentences

September 24, 2008

Syntactic persistence is the tendency for speakers to produce sentences using similar grammatical patterns and rules of language as those they have used before. Although the way this occurs is not well understood, previous research has indicated that this effect may involve a specific aspect of memory function. Memory is made up of two components: declarative and procedural. Declarative memory is used in remembering events and facts. Procedural memory helps us to remember how to perform tasks, such as playing the piano or riding a bike. A recent study suggests that the common phrase, "it's so easy, it's like riding a bike" should perhaps be replaced with "it's so easy, it's like forming a sentence."

In this experiment, Victor S. Ferreira from the University of California San Diego along with Kathryn Bock, Michael P. Wilson and Neal J. Cohen from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, examined which type of memory function contributes to syntactic persistence by comparing amnesics with a group of control volunteers. The amnesics in this study experience anterograde amnesia and exhibit problems forming new memories-they cannot remember facts & events that occurred following their head injury. However, their procedural memory is still intact. For example, these patients will not remember that they received a new bike, but they will improve at riding the bike.

In this study, controls and amnesics heard a sentence containing a specific grammatical structure (a prime sentence) and were asked to repeat it aloud. Subjects were then shown a picture and had to describe it. This was followed by a memory test where subjects heard another sentence (a probe sentence) and were asked if it was identical to the prime sentence shown initially. Probe sentences sometimes were identical to the prime sentence, had the same meaning as the prime sentence but a different grammatical structure, had the same grammatical structure but different meaning as the prime sentence or differed from the prime sentence in both grammatical structure and meaning.

The results, reported in the September issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, indicate that both controls and amnesics exhibited syntactic persistence and to the same degree. That is, the sentences that they used to describe the pictures had similar grammatical structure to the prime sentence that they had seen at the start of the experiment.

However, the amnesics were worse than controls at recognizing the sentence they had seen before. During the memory test, control subjects rejected novel sentences more often when they differed from the prime sentence in meaning. When control subjects were presented with sentences which had a similar grammatical structure (although different meaning) as the prime sentence, they were more likely to say that they recognized them. The fact that amnesics did poorly throughout this entire section indicates that they had forgotten the meaning of the prime sentence. However, their descriptions of the pictures indicate that they still retained the grammatical structure of the prime sentence.

These results support the idea that there are two components of language function- one for content and another for structure. The results presented here indicate that the content aspect of language (meaning/semantics) is associated with declarative memory and that the structural aspect of language (grammar and syntax) is associated with procedural memory.

The researchers propose that syntactic knowledge is a specialized skill, akin to riding a bike. The authors conclude, "The core knowledge underlying the human syntactic ability-one of the most creative capacities known in nature, and one that is commonly thought to depend on advanced and flexible intelligent functioning- is shaped by a specialized system of basic memory mechanisms that are themselves found in even the simplest of organisms."

Association for Psychological Science

Part-of-speech persistence: The influence of part-of-speech information on lexical processes [An article from: Journal of Memory and Language]
by A. Melinger (Author), J.P. Koenig (Author)

This digital document is a journal article from Journal of Memory and Language, published by Elsevier in 2007. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Media Library immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

Description:
This paper presents three naming experiments designed to investigate whether the activation levels of syntactic features associated with lexical items, specifically part-of-speech information, can influence lexical processes. Naming preferences for orthographically ambiguous but phonologically distinct English nouns and verbs, such as convict (CONvict"n vs. conVICT"v) were compared. In Experiment 1, ambiguous target words were preceded by unambiguous noun, verb, and letter (control) primes. Experiments...

Morphosyntactic Persistence in Spoken English: A Corpus Study at the Intersection of Variationist Sociolinguistics, Psycholinguistics, and Discourse ... in Linguistics. Studies and Monographs)
by Benedikt Szmrecsanyi (Author)

Language users are creatures of habit with a tendency to re-use morphosyntactic material that they have produced or heard before. In other words, linguistic patterns and tokens, once used, persist in discourse. The present book is the first large-scale corpus analysis to explore the determinants of this persistence, drawing on regression analyses of a variety of functional, discourse-functional, cognitive, psycholinguistic, and external factors. The case studies investigated include the alternation between synthetic and analytic comparatives, between the s-genitive and the of-genitive, between gerundial and infinitival complementation, particle placement, and future marker choice in a number of corpora sampling different spoken registers and geographical varieties of English. Providing a...

Language Processing (Studies in Cognition)
by Simon Garrod (Editor), Martin Pickering (Editor)

Language Processing questions what happens when we process language - what mental operations occur during processing and how they are organised over time. The last decade has seen real advances in the study of language processing that have wide ranging implications for human cognition in general. Language Processing gives an account of these developments both as they relate to experimental studies of processing and as they relate to computational modelling of the processes. In addition to chapters covering core topics, such as lexical processing, syntactic parsing and the comprehension of discourse, special topics of recent interest are also included.

Hand and Mind: What Gestures Reveal about Thought
by David McNeill (Author)

Using data from more than ten years of research, David McNeill shows that gestures do not simply form a part of what is said and meant but have an impact on thought itself. Hand and Mind persuasively argues that because gestures directly transfer mental images to visible forms, conveying ideas that language cannot always express, we must examine language and gesture together to unveil the operations of the mind.

Talking the Talk: Language, Psychology and Science
by Trevor A. Harley (Author)

Language makes us human, but how do we use it and how do children learn it? Talking the Talk is an introduction to the psychology of language. Written for the reader with no background in the area or knowledge of psychology, it explains how we actually "do" language: how we speak, listen, and read. This book provides an accessible and comprehensive introduction to psycholinguistics, the study of the psychological processes involved in language. It shows how it’s possible to study language experimentally, and how psychologists use these experiments to build models of language processing. The book focuses on controversy in modern psycholinguistics, and covers the all the main topics, including how children acquire language, how language is related to the brain, and what can go wrong...

The On-line Study of Sentence Comprehension: Eyetracking, ERPs and Beyond
by Manuel Carreiras (Author), Charles Clifton Jr. (Author)

This book addresses important findings, assumptions, problems, hopes, and future guidelines on the use of advanced research techniques to study the moment-by-moment mental processes that occur while a reader or listener is understanding language. The core techniques are eye tracking and ERPs, with some extensions to others such as fMRI. The On-line Study of Sentence Comprehension has been written by top researchers in the field of psycholinguistics, who are also leading experts in the use of eye tracking and ERPs. This book combines comprehensive overviews of the state of the art on theoretical progress, the latest on assumptions behind the use of eye movements (reading and visual world) and ERPs methods with papers that address specific research questions. This work covers not only...

Speech Motor Control: In Normal and Disordered Speech
by Ben Maassen (Editor), Raymond Kent (Editor), Hermann Peters (Editor)

Speaking is one of the most complex skills that humans perform. In our everyday communication, we transfer sentences, concepts, thoughts, and ideas. How though, is the speaker able to convert these into movements of the speech apparatus? These speech movements are the observable end-product, but what neurological, psycholinguistic, and perceptual-motor processes lie behind their production? To fully understand speech disorders, such as stuttering, apraxia of speech, and Parkinsonian dysarthria, the disruptions in this complex interplay are highly relevant. Equally important is the question of how the infant develops from random babbling to precisely controlled production of words, syllables, and phonemes. This volume presents state of the art research in the science of speech motor...

Language as a Complex Adaptive System (The Language Learning Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics Cognitive Neuroscience Series)
by Nick C. Ellis (Author), Diane Larsen-Freeman (Author)

Explores a new approach to studying language as a complex adaptive system, illustrating its commonalities across many areas of language researchBrings together a team of leading researchers in linguistics, psychology, and complex systems to discuss the groundbreaking significance of this perspective for their workIllustrates its application across a variety of subfields, including languages usage, language evolution, language structure, and first and second language acquisition"What a breath of fresh air! As interesting a collection of papers as you are likely to find on the evolution, learning, and use of language from the point of view of both cognitive underpinnings and communicative functions." Michael Tomasello, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary...

Oxford Handbook of Psycholinguistics (Oxford Library of Psychology)
by Gareth Gaskell (Editor)

The ability to communicate through spoken and written language is one of the defining characteristics of the human race, yet it remains a deeply mysterious process. The young science of psycholinguistics attempts to uncover the mechanisms and representations underlying human language. This interdisciplinary field has seen massive developments over the past decade, with a broad expansion of the research base, and the incorporation of new experimental techniques such as brain imaging and computational modelling. The result is that real progress is being made in the understanding of the key components of language in the mind.

The Oxford Handbook of Psycholinguistics brings together the views of 75 leading researchers in psycholinguistics to provide a comprehensive and authoritative...

Aspects of Language Production (Studies in Cognition)
by Linda Wheeldon (Editor)

This volume represents major research issues in language production today, presenting readers with a picture of the breadth of current research in the field. Contributors have focused on models of visual word processing, aphasic speech, object recognition and language production in children. Many chapters highlight the need for psychological models of language production to learn from theoretical linguistics in order to become better informed about the structure of language itself. Therefore, this volume also includes chapters written by linguists for psychologists which serve to remind us of the complexity of structure and process in the languages of the world.