Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print New Study on Effects of Disclosing Financial Interests on Participation in Medical Research

New Study on Effects of Disclosing Financial Interests on Participation in Medical Research

October 06, 2008

Baltimore, MD. - Knowing how an investigator is paid for running a research study surprisingly plays a small role in patients' willingness to take part in clinical trials. However, according to a new Johns Hopkins University study more participants are troubled when they are told that the investigator could profit or lose money depending on the results.

In an effort to learn more about the effects of disclosing an investigator's financial interests on potential study participants, researchers from the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, Duke University Medical Center, and Wake Forest University surveyed 470 patients from an outpatient cardiology clinic. Each of these patients, who were diagnosed with coronary artery disease, agreed to go through a consent process over the phone for a hypothetical clinical trial.




The study, published in the October issue of the American Heart Journal, found that simply revealing an investigator's financial interest in a study does little to affect the patient's decisions to enroll in a hypothetical clinical trial. What the study did find was that patients were more concerned about certain types of financial interests, especially when the investigator owned stock in the company financing the study.

"Disclosure of investigators' financial interests in research does not substantially affect a person's willingness to participate," says Jeremy Sugarman, M.D., senior author of the study and Harvey M. Meyerhoff Professor of Bioethics and Medicine at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, however, "ethically it's important that the patient's 'right to know' is respected before they consent to enroll in research."

"What seems to be important in the decision-making process was the patients' pre-existing level of trust in medical research in general," says Dr. Kevin Weinfurt, a medical psychologist at Duke and the lead author of the study.

The team of researchers first assessed the patients' overall level of trust in medical research. Investigators then randomly assigned them to one of three disclosure groups: Members of one group were told the clinic involved in the study would receive per capita payments per enrollee that would be used to cover the costs of the trial, including the doctor's salary. Participants in a second group were told that the investigator held stock in the company sponsoring the research. There were no disclosure statements made to members of the third group.

When asked how likely they would be to join a clinical trial, members of all three groups expressed a moderate degree of willingness to do so. Still, there were some important differences between the groups.

Patients who heard about stock ownership were less willing than those in the other two groups to indicate that they would participate in the study. In addition, they spontaneously offered three times the number of negative comments about the relationship than participants in the other groups, using words like, "disingenuous," "unacceptable," and "unethical." In addition, ten members of the group that were told about stock ownership in the company sponsoring the trial, spontaneously said they would not take part in the trial compared with only one such comment from the other two groups.

In general, members of the per capita group felt that a financial arrangement that helped cover costs of the trial was acceptable, saying, "OK, that sounds more appropriate. So there's no payment to him, but through the university. OK, I'm good."

But some members in the group that was told about stock ownership found positive things to say about that arrangement, too. One person volunteered that "It looks like he'd have this real incentive for this thing to go real well, and I guess that's all to the good."

"The findings of this study make it clear that policy makers need to continue to address the issue of conflicts of interest in research conducted by investigators who stand to profit from the results of clinical trials," says Sugarman. When it comes to financial disclosure between investigators and research participants Sugarman says, "Policy makers may want to consider more restrictive policies for equity relationships than for other financial interests in research."

It's important to note that participants in the study were disproportionately middle-to higher income white men, and the researchers say lower income participants from other racial groups might feel differently about financial relationships between researchers and sponsoring companies.

The study was funded by a grant from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute.

Other researchers involved in the study include Joelle Friedman, Chantelle Hardy, Alice Fortune-Greely, Janice Lawlor, Jennifer Allsbrook, Li Lin and Kevin Schulman, of Duke, and Mark Hall, from Wake Forest University.

Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics



Related Medical Research Current Events and Medical Research News Articles Medical Research Current Events and Medical Research News RSS Medical Research Current Events and Medical Research News RSS
Physician-scientist proves stem cells heal lungs of newborn animals
Dr. Bernard Thébaud lives in two very different worlds. As a specialist in the Stollery Children's Hospital's Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at the Royal Alexandra Hospital, he cares for tiny babies, many of whom struggle for breath after being born weeks before they are due.

Hyperactivity associated with shorter nights for young boys
Hyperactive boys don't get enough sleep, which can worsen their condition according to new research. Published in the November issue of Pediatrics, the study is the first to examine a large sample of children and to study the link between lack of sleep and hyperactivity.

Researchers find potential treatment for Huntington's disease
Investigators at Burnham Institute for Medical Research (Burnham), the University of British Columbia's Centre for Molecular Medicine and Therapeutics and the University of California, San Diego have found that normal synaptic activity in nerve cells (the electrical activity in the brain that allows nerve cells to communicate with one another) protects the brain from the misfolded proteins associated with Huntington's disease.

Research reveals lipids' unexpected role in triggering death of brain cells
The lipid that accumulates in brain cells of individuals with an inherited enzyme disorder also drives the cell death that is a hallmark of the disease, according to new research led by St. Jude Children's Research Hospital investigators.

Novel mouse gene reduces major pathologies associated with Alzheimer's disease
A new study reveals that a previously undiscovered mouse gene reduces the two major pathological perturbations commonly associated with Alzheimer's disease (AD).

Mouse gene suppresses Alzheimer's plaques and tangles
Investigators at Burnham Institute for Medical Research (Burnham) and colleagues have identified a novel mouse gene (Rps23r1) that reduces the accumulation of two toxic proteins that are major players in Alzheimer's disease: amyloid beta and tau.

UT Southwestern aids national effort to recruit volunteers for medical research
A new national initiative involving UT Southwestern Medical Center will match volunteers who want to take part in medical research studies with the scientists who are leading those studies.

Initial Results Show Pregnant Women Mount Strong Immune Response To One Dose of 2009 H1N1 Flu Vaccine
Healthy pregnant women mount a robust immune response following just one dose of 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine, according to initial results from an ongoing clinical trial sponsored by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) of the National Institutes of Health.

Fighting Sleep, Penn Researchers Reverse the Cognitive Impairment Caused By Sleep Deprivation
A research collaboration led by biologists and neuroscientists at the University of Pennsylvania has found a molecular pathway in the brain that is the cause of cognitive impairment due to sleep deprivation.

OMRF scientists discover promising new path for treating traumas
A discovery by scientists at the Oklahoma Medical Research Foundation could help save lives threatened by traumatic injuries like those sustained in car crashes or on the battlefield. The work also holds potential for treating severe infectious diseases and diabetes.
More Medical Research Current Events and Medical Research News Articles
Research Methodology in the Medical and Biological Sciences

Research Methodology in the Medical and Biological Sciences
by Petter Laake (Author), Haakon Breien Benestad (Author), Bjorn Reino Olsen (Editor)

Providing easy-to-access information, this unique sourcebook covers the wide range of topics that a researcher must be familiar with in order to become a successful experimental scientist. Perfect for aspiring as well as practicing professionals in the medical and biological sciences it discusses a broad range of topics that are common, yet not traditionally considered part of formal curricula. The information presented also facilitates communication across conventional disciplinary boundaries, in line with the increasingly multidisciplinary nature of modern research projects.

· Perfect for students with various professional backgrounds providing a broad scientific perspective
· Easily accessible, concise material makes learning about...

The Design of Studies for Medical Research

The Design of Studies for Medical Research
by David Machin (Author), Michael J. Campbell (Author)

The same careful rigour imposed on the design of phase III randomised controlled trials is not always applied to medical research in other areas such as trials conducted at earlier stages of drug development. 

With the emphasis that is now placed on evidence-based medicine, such care and rigour will inevitably impact on these areas with increasing attention turned to the quality of design. 

This title describes what principles can be used to structure research effectively allowing for the required degree of accuracy.

Written by two best selling authors, this book includes many examples from medical literature and will be of great value to all groups conducting studies at the interface of clinical and laboratory research.



Medical Statistics from Scratch (Bowers, Medical Statistics from Scratch: An Introduction for Health Professionals)

Medical Statistics from Scratch (Bowers, Medical Statistics from Scratch: An Introduction for Health Professionals)
by David Bowers (Author)

This long awaited second edition of this bestseller continues to provide a comprehensive, user friendly, down-to-earth guide to elementary statistics. The book presents a detailed account of the most important procedures for the analysis of data, from the calculation of simple proportions, to a variety of statistical tests, and the use of regression models for modeling of clinical outcomes.

The level of mathematics is kept to a minimum to make the material easily accessible to the novice, and a multitude of illustrative cases are included in every chapter, drawn from the current research literature. The new edition has been completely revised and updated and includes new chapters on basic quantitative methods, measuring survival, measurement scales, diagnostic testing,...

Physician Assistant's Guide to Research And Medical Literature

Physician Assistant's Guide to Research And Medical Literature
by J. Dennis Blessing (Editor)

Scientific research is the basis of all modern health care, so physician assistant students and PAs in practice must be able to interpret medical literature and apply it to their own situation. In addition, managed care demands that PAs be able to demonstrate the quality and cost-effectiveness of the care they provide. And rising expectations are leading more and more PA students and educators to perform research for a master's degree or career advancement.

New! Chapters covering evidence-based medicine, clinical research and grant writing

Designing Clinical Research: An Epidemiologic Approach

Designing Clinical Research: An Epidemiologic Approach
by Stephen B Hulley (Author), Steven R Cummings (Author), Warren S Browner (Author), Deborah G Grady (Author), Thomas B Newman (Author)

Designing Clinical Research sets the standard for providing a practical guide to planning, tabulating, formulating, and implementing clinical research, with an easy-to-read, uncomplicated presentation. This edition incorporates current research methodology--including molecular and genetic clinical research--and offers an updated syllabus for conducting a clinical research workshop. Emphasis is on common sense as the main ingredient of good science. The book explains how to choose well-focused research questions and details the steps through all the elements of study design, data collection, quality assurance, and basic grant-writing. All chapters have been thoroughly revised, updated, and made more user-friendly. "Doody's Core Titles™ 2009."

Essentials of Writing Biomedical Research Papers

Essentials of Writing Biomedical Research Papers
by Mimi Zeiger (Author)

Provides immediate help for anyone preparing a biomedical paper by givin specific advice on organizing the components of the paper, effective writing techniques, writing an effective results sections, documentation issues, sentence structure and much more. The new edition includes new examples from the current literature including many involving molecular biology, expanded exercises at the end of the book, revised explanations on linking key terms, transition clauses, uses of subheads, and emphases. If you plan to do any medical writing, read this book first and get an immediate advantage.

  Research in Medical Education
by Aamc

The Association's publications provide comprehensive information about member institutions and their missions. AAMC also offers publications geared to medical school applicants.

Super Booster Softgels 60 Softgels with Advanced K2 Complex From the Life Extension Foundation. LEF Has a 27 Year History of Introducing Life Saving Medical Discoveries and Funding Scientific Research.

Super Booster Softgels 60 Softgels with Advanced K2 Complex From the Life Extension Foundation. LEF Has a 27 Year History of Introducing Life Saving Medical Discoveries and Funding Scientific Research.
by Life Extension Foundation

Ginkgo - The most popular flavonoid supplement is Ginkgo biloba. Hundreds of studies substantiate its multifaceted effects in the promotion of healthy circulatory and neurologic functions. Chlorophyllin - The pigment chlorophyllin is vividly seen in green vegetables. Scientific studies indicate that chlorophyllin may be the most potent nutrient to protect against environmental DNA damage. Selenium - The FDA states that some scientific evidence suggests consumption of selenium may reduce the risk of certain forms of cancer. However, the FDA has determined this evidence is limited and not conclusive. The ability of selenium to boost glutathione is well established, but most people don't know that there are several different forms of selenium that provide diverse biological benefits.

Medical Research Institute - No2 Platinum, 300 caplets

Medical Research Institute - No2 Platinum, 300 caplets
by Medical Research Institute

The product that started it all. "Perpetual Pumps." Hemodilation. "Flash Recoveries". NO2 introduced a whole new vocabulary within the sports nutrition world. NO2 broke all the sales record at the worlds #1 vitamin retailer. NO2 created an entire category of nitric oxide knock-offs. In fact, most people refer to nitric oxide as "NO2" products. The accolades go on and on. Why? Because NO2 works. And it always has. You see, the difference between NO2 and every other product that came before it (and the copycats that came after) is the patented pHylex9 extended-release delivery technology that Ed Byrd (MRI Founder) applied to Arginine - AKG (not just L-arginine). It took Ed years to perfect the original Platinum formula. Pumps that last all day. Muscle recovery that begins the same day you...

Non-Clinical Medical Jobs, Careers, and Opportunities

Non-Clinical Medical Jobs, Careers, and Opportunities
by Joseph Kim, MD, MPH

For physicians and other healthcare professionals who wish to learn about non-clinical medical opportunities ranging from medical writing, healthcare administration, public health, consulting, health information technology, managed care, pharma/biotech, medical education, market research, finance, venture capital, and more.Kindle blogs are fully downloaded onto your Kindle so you can read them even when you're not wirelessly connected. And unlike RSS readers which often only provide headlines, blogs on Kindle give you full text content and images, and are updated wirelessly throughout the day.

© 2009 BrightSurf.com