Scientists trace molecular origin of proportional development

October 14, 2008

Cincinnati Children's study shows a little molecular messiness leads to enhanced precision

CINCINNATI - When it comes to embryo formation in the lowly fruit fly, a little molecular messiness actually leads to enhanced developmental precision, according to a study in the Oct. 14 Developmental Cell from Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center.

While the fundamentals of this tiny bug's reproductive biology may seem insignificant, one day they could matter quite a bit to humans. That's because the study provides new information about how cells choose their own fates, especially in maintaining the size relationship and proportionality of body parts during embryonic development, said Jun Ma, Ph.D., a researcher in the divisions of Biomedical Informatics and Developmental Biology at Cincinnati Children's and the study's corresponding author.

"We used the fruit fly in our study to trace the molecular origin of where body proportionality comes from, directly affecting how we think about precision control mechanisms during development," Dr. Ma said. "This new information is a basic, but very important, step. Although humans are far more complex, this could one day help us understand how two different-sized babies - with different mothers providing varied environmental and genetic influences - are born alike, with properly sized heads and limbs."

Besides discovering a scientific platform that will advance studies into precise, or normal, development, Dr. Ma and colleagues hope their knowledge will facilitate research into abnormal development, like certain types of birth defects.

Although fruit flies have miniscule brains and dine on rotten fruit, genetically the species has quite a bit in common with humans - a concept known as evolutionary conservation. This relationship has long made the insect a model for studying body patterning in animals.

Dr. Ma's team probed how a gene transcription regulatory protein called Bicoid turns on another gene, known as Hunchback. Hunchback instructs the embryo's anterior to begin formation of proportional body parts in the fruit fly's head and thoracic regions. Hunchback is switched on in the anterior half of the embryo, where the level of Bicoid is high. In normal (wild-type) embryos, the process begins when Bicoid diffuses from the anterior toward the posterior end, a principal already established in existing research literature. Bicoid, which comes from the mother, then forms a gradient along this body axis.

Dr. Ma and his colleagues discovered the amount of Bicoid in early embryos depends on the size of the egg. Larger embryos in the study showed higher Bicoid levels in the anterior region, while smaller embryos showed lower levels. This relationship between embryo size and Bicoid amount helps Bicoid establish a gradient scaled precisely according to each embryo's length, which is necessary for Hunchback to respond precisely, they said.

One area of messiness in the system is that the precision levels of Bicoid and Hunchback are different. The research team reported that imaging analyses of 28 wild-type embryos showed even a precise Bicoid gradient still has positional errors that go beyond the boundaries set up by its target Hunchback. Dr. Ma's team suggests that Bicoid can self correct its positional errors through a coupling that develops between Bicoid's forming gradient and the protein's activation of target genes. The correction essentially fine tunes the mechanism to achieve further developmental precision.

Other studies have suggested Bicoid level differences among individual embryos play little or no role in the precision of fruit fly embryo development. Bicoid gradient, they say, is inherently so precise at switching on its target genes that it approaches the limits set by basic physical principles. While offering important new insights into how Bicoid establishes a precise gradient along the embryo's length, Dr. Ma said the previous research also begged the questions: What then makes the Bicoid gradient so precise, or is it really so precise?

"Instead of discounting the variability of the Bicoid gradient among different embryos, we found this noise to be an advantage of the system," said Dr. Ma, also a professor of pediatrics at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine. "The amount of Bicoid going to small and large embryos all self corrects, so the system is built to be very robust and precise so different cells can be told to become part of the head, or part of something else, in a proportionate manner."

Besides conducting staining and imaging tests on normal wild-type embryos to test their hypothesis, Dr.Ma's team also studied Bicoid and Hunchback expression in embryos from genetically altered, mutant (staufen) female fruit flies. They found Bicoid could not form a precise and scaled gradient in embryos from these mutant females, which, they concluded, contributed to additional Hunchback variations and disproportionate development.

Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center

---

---

	bicoid mRNA localization in Drosophila late oogenesis and early embryogenesis. by Timothy Thomas Weil (Author) Asymmetric protein distribution is required to achieve polarization within a cell. Intracellular RNA localization is a conserved mechanism for spatial regulation of gene expression, targeting protein synthesis to specific subcellular domains. In Drosophila, axial polarity is established in oogenesis via localization of maternal determinant mRNAs. Localization of bicoid (bcd) mRNA (RNA), the anterior determinant, is required to establish a morphogenetic gradient of Bcd protein in the early embryo, which is in turn required to pattern the anterior-posterior body axis. Previous studies have characterized a microtubule-dependent pathway for bcd RNA localization during mid-oogenesis, when bcd first accumulates at the anterior. Through live imaging of fluorescently tagged endogenous bcd mRNA,...
	The Art of Genes: How Organisms Make Themselves by Enrico Coen (Author) Over the past twenty years there has been a revolution in biology--for the first time scientists have been able to unravel the details of how organisms make themselves. The mechanisms by which a fertilized egg develops into an adult can now be grasped in a way that was unimaginable a few decades ago. The Art of Genes is the first account of these exciting new findings, and of their broader significance in how we view ourselves. Through a highly original synthesis of sciece and art, Enrico Coen vividly describes this revolution in our understanding of how plants and animals develop. Drawing on a wide range of material--from flowers growing petals instead of sex organs, and flies that develop an extra pair of wings, to works of art by Leonardo and Magritte--he explains in lively...
	From DNA to Diversity: Molecular Genetics and the Evolution of Animal Design by Sean B. Carroll (Author), Jennifer Grenier (Author), Scott Weatherbee (Author) In this landmark work, the author team led by Dr. Sean Carroll presents the general principles of the genetic basis of morphological change through a synthesis of evolutionary biology with genetics and embryology. In this extensively revised second edition, the authors delve into the latest discoveries, incorporating new coverage of comparative genomics, molecular evolution of regulatory proteins and elements, and microevolution of animal development. An accessible text, focusing on the most well-known genes, developmental processes and taxa. Builds logically from developmental genetics and regulatory mechanisms to evolution at different genetic morphological levels. Adds major insights from recent genome studies, new evo-devo biology research findings, and a new chapter on...
	BIOS Instant Notes in Developmental Biology by Dr Richard Twyman (Author) Coverage of the field in Instant Notes in Developmental Biology is current and focuses largely on the principles of embryonic development. It is designed to provide a clear summary of the principles of developmental biology in a compact and easily manageable structure.
	Wie Gene die Entwicklung steuern: Die Geschichte des Homeobox (German Edition) by Walter J. Gehring (Author) Als Forscher und Autor zugleich beschreibt Walter Gehring eine packende Reise, an deren vorläufigem Ende schließlich die Entdeckung der Homeobox steht. Die Homeobox ist ein kleiner Abschnitt unserer Erbsubstanz, der für diese homeotischen Gene, die die Entwicklung vom Ei bis zum erwachsenen Organismus steuern, charakteristisch ist. Die Bestimmung der dreidimensionalen Struktur der Homeodomäne im Protein führt den Leser vom molekularen in den atomaren Bereich, ohne jemals die biologischen Aspekte außer Acht zu lassen. Der Autor zeigt, dass ein einzelnes Gen für die Bildung eines Auges verantwortlich ist, indem es die Aktivität von hunderten von anderen Genen steuert - eine Erkenntnis, die völlig neue Perspektiven für das Verständnis der Entwicklungs- und Evolutionsvorgänge...
	Cells to Civilizations: The Principles of Change That Shape Life by Enrico Coen (Author) Cells to Civilizations is the first unified account of how life transforms itself--from the production of bacteria to the emergence of complex civilizations. What are the connections between evolving microbes, an egg that develops into an infant, and a child who learns to walk and talk? Award-winning scientist Enrico Coen synthesizes the growth of living systems and creative processes, and he reveals that the four great life transformations--evolution, development, learning, and human culture--while typically understood separately, actually all revolve around shared core principles and manifest the same fundamental recipe. Coen blends provocative discussion, the latest scientific research, and colorful examples to demonstrate the links between these critical stages in the history of...
	Entwicklungsbiologie und Reproduktionsbiologie von Mensch und Tieren: Ein einführendes Lehrbuch (Springer-Lehrbuch) (German Edition) by Werner A. Müller (Author), Monika Hassel (Author) Von der befruchteten Eizelle zum Organismus - ein Geheimnis der Natur? Über die dahinter liegenden faszinierenden Vorgänge und die neuesten Erkenntnisse in der Entwicklungsbiologie informiert dieses Lehrbuch. Einzigartig ist der Überblick über die Entwicklung der bedeutendsten Modellorganismen sowie die Embryonalentwicklung des Menschen. Vergleichende Ausführungen zu Aspekten der Evolution, Entwicklungsgenetik oder Sexualentwicklung vervollständigen das Bild. Topaktuelle Themen werden berücksichtigt: Stammzellforschung, therapeutisches Klonen, Erzeugung transgener Tiere, Gentherapie von Erbkrankheiten, Krebsentstehung. Die 3. Aufl. gibt erstmals auch eine Einführung in die allgemeine Reproduktionsbiologie und berücksichtigt verstärkt medizinische und rechtliche Aspekte....
	Molecular Embryology: How Molecules Give Birth to Animals by J. Michael Barry (Author) Molecular Embryology explains in simple terms the molecular interactions that transform an egg to a complex embryo that in the end gives rise to a fully-formed animal. In doing so, the book covers one hundred and fifty years of experiments that have led to our present understanding of these molecular interactions. As the text progresses, the reader will gain a sense of the developmental similarities and differences between organisms. Students studying developmental biology and embryology will find this book an extremely useful introduction to the subject and will also appeal to anyone with an interest in the most recent advances in this largely undiscovered territory.
	Modularity in Development and Evolution by Gerhard Schlosser (Editor), Gunter P. Wagner (Editor) Modularity in Development and Evolution offers the first sustained exploration of modules from developmental and evolutionary perspectives. Contributors discuss what modularity is, how it can be identified and modeled, how it originated and evolved, and its biological significance. Covering modules at levels ranging from genes to colonies, the book focuses on their roles not just in structures but also in processes such as gene regulation. Among many exciting findings, the contributors demonstrate how modules can highlight key constraints on evolutionary processes. A timely synthesis of a crucial topic, Modularity in Development and Evolution shows the invaluable insights modules can give into both developmental complexities and their evolutionary origins....
	Master Control Genes in Development and Evolution: The Homeobox Story (The Terry Lectures Series) by Dr. Walter J. Gehring (Author) In this text one of the world's most eminent developmental biologists discusses some of the new insights into how genes control development. Walter Gehring describes in detail his contributions to the landmark discovery of the homeobox, a characterisitc DNA segment found in the genes of all higher organisms from the frutifly to humans, and he explains how this has provided the key to our modern understanding of development and evolution. The book thus becomes not only a discussion of genetics but also a description of the art of scientific investigation. Gehring begins his story by looking at the work of the many researchers who laid the foundation for the fields of molecular, cellular and developmental biology, providing vignettes of past and present investigators. He then describes his...