Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Hospital rankings: More than meets the eye

Hospital rankings: More than meets the eye

October 22, 2008

DURHAM, N.C., -- Medicare's pay-for-performance program ranks and rewards hospitals according to how well they meet certain guidelines for clinical care. But researchers at Duke Clinical Research Institute say the program penalizes hospitals that care for the greatest numbers of the poor and needy by not taking into account their greater clinical burden.

Studies show that age, race and severity of disease can influence which patients get certain treatments and how they fare, and these factors vary significantly from hospital to hospital. "That means that hospitals serving large groups of the elderly, women, poor, uninsured or African American patients might have problems competing with institutions whose patients are younger, wealthy, insured, and white," says Dr. Eric Peterson, a cardiologist at Duke and the senior author of the study. "Hospitals are simply not starting out on the same playing field."




Under the current pay-for-performance system, hospitals in the top 20 percent of the rankings receive financial reward; those in the middle 60 percent receive nothing, and those at the bottom stand to loose Medicare reimbursement money. Currently, Medicare does not consider demographic variables and patients' existing health problems in figuring hospital rankings.

Peterson and colleagues in the American Heart Association's Get With the Guidelines program wanted to find out if those rankings would change if patient mix was included in the calculations. They examined Medicare beneficiary records of 148,472 heart attack patients in 449 hospitals across the country from 2000 to 2006. They analyzed the hospitals' process performance on eight measures of clinical care taken from guidelines established by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The measures included appropriate use of certain drugs, like aspirin, beta-blockers, ACE inhibitors and anti-clotting medications; and procedures, like angioplasty and counseling to support smoking cessation.

Investigators ranked the hospitals according to crude composite process performance scores and then grouped them according to Medicare's current system. Next, they ranked the same hospitals again, but this time taking into account the patients' demographic variables, their clinical characteristics and eligibility for certain procedures.

They found that the hospitals with the lowest crude composite scores tended to be smaller, non-academic institutions that treated a higher percentage of older, sicker and minority patients than those in the top group.

While there was general agreement on performance between the two ranking systems, researchers found that when taking into account patient characteristics and treatment opportunity, 16.5 percent, or 74 of the hospitals would fall into a different financial status category.

So why doesn't Medicare consider patient mix in tallying rankings? "On the surface, it may well seem to be the right thing to do, but some feel such a move would 'legitimize' less-than-optimal care," says Peterson. "At the same time, not taking these factors into consideration is like comparing apples to oranges."

Peterson says one solution might be to reward hospitals for improvement in adherence to evidence-based treatment, rather than rewarding a single score or ranking. Another option might involve separately reporting adherence data for older patients, women, or minorities. "That would surely draw more attention to any gaps in care, and might prompt better compliance."

Duke University Medical Center



Related Clinical Care Current Events and Clinical Care News Articles Clinical Care Current Events and Clinical Care News RSS Clinical Care Current Events and Clinical Care News RSS
New study links vitamin D deficiency to cardiovascular disease and death
While mothers have known that feeding their kids milk builds strong bones, a new study by researchers at the Heart Institute at Intermountain Medical Center in Salt Lake City suggests that Vitamin D contributes to a strong and healthy heart as well - and that inadequate levels of the vitamin may significantly increase a person's risk of stroke, heart disease, and death, even among people who've never had heart disease.

For young boys with cancer, testicular tissue banking may be option to preserve fertility
For parents of children with cancer, the hopeful news is that pediatric survival rates have steadily improved for decades. Among the bad news-treatments that enable survival often cause infertility.

Autism Consortium symposium draws record number of researchers, advocates, parents for autism update
The Autism Consortium, an innovative collaboration of researchers, clinicians, funders and families dedicated to catalyzing research and enhancing clinical care for autism spectrum disorders (ASDs), held its fourth annual symposium on October 28th, 2009, at Harvard Medical School in Boston.

Childhood cancer survivors experience suicidal thoughts decades after diagnosis
Adult survivors of childhood cancer have an increased risk for suicidal thoughts, even decades after their cancer treatments ended, according to a study led by Dana-Farber Cancer Institute scientists.

Feelings of stigmatization may discourage HIV patients from proper care
The feeling of stigmatization that people living with HIV often experience doesn't only exact a psychological toll -new UCLA research suggests it can also lead to quantifiably negative health outcomes.

Genes signal late-stage laryngeal cancer, poorer outcome
Researchers at Henry Ford Hospital have identified tumor-suppressing genes that may provide a more accurate diagnosis of disease stage and survival for laryngeal cancer patients than current standards.

Study looks at using the immune system to reduce prostate cancer risk
Immune therapies have been explored as a way to treat cancer after it develops.

Anemic Patients With MDS Gain Long-Term Benefits From Erythropoietin and Myeloid Growth Factor Hormones
Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS), a group of blood disorders that can lead to acute myeloid leukemia (AML) in some patients, often cause severe anemia (when the body lacks a sufficient number of functional red blood cells).

Intensive management can improve blood pressure in non-adherent hypertensive patients
Researchers from Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) have shown that patients with uncontrolled hypertension respond to treatment intensification regardless of their degree of adherence to antihypertensive medications.

Participants in antidepressant drug trials are atypical patients, UT Southwestern researchers report
One reason antidepressant medication treatments do not work as well in real life as they do in clinical studies could be the limited type of study participants selected, researchers at UT Southwestern Medical Center have found.
More Clinical Care Current Events and Clinical Care News Articles
Family Medicine: Ambulatory Care and Prevention, Fifth Edition (LANGE Clinical Medicine)

Family Medicine: Ambulatory Care and Prevention, Fifth Edition (LANGE Clinical Medicine)
by Mark Mengel (Author), L. Schwiebert (Author)

The most convenient and easy-to-use clinical manual available for outpatient medicine and family practice

A Doody's Core Title ESSENTIAL PURCHASE

"the book is informative and well written. This will be a welcome addition to the library at the Family Medicine Center and a great resource in preparing teaching pearls for residents and medical students."--Doody's Review Service

Family Medicine is the ultimate at-a-glance guide to the diagnosis and treatment of common primary care problems. The book spans the full scope of ambulatory medicine, and is organized according to the flow of patient care--starting with insights into signs and symptoms, followed by expert disease management recommendations.

The information is presented in a manner that...

Dove  Clinical Protection Cool Essentials, 1.7-Ounce Stick (Pack of 2)

Dove Clinical Protection Cool Essentials, 1.7-Ounce Stick (Pack of 2)
by Dove

Dove's Clinical Protection. The strength you need, infused with the beauty and care you expect from Dove. Who is Dove Clinical Protection For? Women seeking prescription strength protection from wetness, but without the irritation.

IS Clinical Cleansing Complex 6 oz

IS Clinical Cleansing Complex 6 oz
by IS Clinical

iS CLINICALÕs ultimate cleansing formula, CLEANSING COMPLEX is a clear gel that is both powerful and gentle at the same time. A balanced formulation of bio-nutrients, antioxidants, soothing and healing ingredients combined with Sugar Cane Extract (a source of Glycolic Acid) and Willow Bark Extract (a source of Salicylic Acid), which act together to deep clean your pores. CLEANSING COMPLEX is excellent for removing dirt and oils on the skinÕs surface without stripping the essential natural oils that enhance the skinÕs integrity. This formulation is designed for both men and women of all skin types, and is excellent for removing makeup. CLEANSING COMPLEX is also an important first step when preparing the skin for treatment and protective products. Many skincare professionals use...

  Ambulatory Care Clinical Skill Program : Core Module Package
by Amer Soc Health System Pharm



Sustaining Appropriate Clinical Boundaries in Home and Community-Based Care

Sustaining Appropriate Clinical Boundaries in Home and Community-Based Care
Directed By: Kelly Gregory and Thom Pancella
Also With: Thom Pancella and Kelly Gregory Joel Epstein (Producer), Jan Heumann (Writer)

Due to the home and community-based location of their work, community support staff and other in-home care providers have unique challenges in maintaining appropriate clinical boundaries with their clients. In this session participants will explore numerous potential pitfalls that can ensnare well-meaning professionals. The Code of Ethics for Psychiatric Rehabilitation Practitioners will be used to demonstrate how an ethics code can be beneficial in guiding practice. Jan Heumann holds a Bachelors degree in Recreational Therapy and Masters degree in Counseling Psychology. As a 28-year veteran in mental health, her experience includes work as a Recreational Therapist, a Psychosocial Rehabilitation Program Supervisor, Community Support Supervisor, Program Director at a Community Mental...

iS Clinical Body Complex 6oz

iS Clinical Body Complex 6oz
by iS Clinical

This body moisturizer has been shown to help soothe even the most compromised skin conditions with natural acids, Retinol, Vitamin B5 and other soothing antioxidants.

  Lumex Deluxe Clinical Care Recliner
by GF Health

The Lumex Deluxe Clinical Care Recliner sets a new standard of comfort for the patient and ease of use for the caregiver. The Lumex Deluxe Clinical Care Recliner is EXTRAordinary in many ways: * The unique, patent pending recliner mechanism enables the patient to position the back infinitely from TV position to full recline. The wide, contoured seat and back, along with an integrated footrest provide an enhanced level of comfort. Built-in arm pads in the back give improved support for the arms while in Trendelenburg. Wall saver armrest caps increase durability of the armrests and protect walls from marring * Easy to achieve Trendelenburg position. No more cables or handles, Trendelenburg position can be actuated from either side of recliner by a convenient foot pedal. Higher floor to back...

  Living with ALS ~ Clinical Care Management - Discussion Among ALS Experts
Also With: ALS Association (Producer)



iS Clinical Sunscreen TUBE SPF 25

iS Clinical Sunscreen TUBE SPF 25
by iS Clinical

This revolutionary lightweight cream combines powerful antioxidants and sunscreen actives without destroying the efficacy of the delicate botanicals. Clinically proven to reduce UV-induced erythema by more than 53 percent within 24 hours (compared to untreated skin), this remarkable product actually treats sunburn as well as protects against it. SPF 25 TREATMENT SUNSCREEN also comes in PerfecTint®, for an instant, safe, and natural-looking tan for any skin type. Both versions come in tubes and individual-dose foil packets that are excellent for travel.

Clinical Guide: Skin and Wound Care (Clinical Guide: Skin & Wound Care)

Clinical Guide: Skin and Wound Care (Clinical Guide: Skin & Wound Care)
by Cathy Thomas Hess (Author)

This handy-sized, completely updated edition will help both clinicians and institutions deliver appropriate, cost-efficient wound care. Clinical Guide: Skin and Wound Care, Sixth Edition provides new content on skin care, incontinence, and regulations while providing an overview of wound care and prevention and more than 650 wound care products for every type of wound. The appendices provide assessment tools and multiple treatment algorithms. "Doody's Core Titles™ 2009."

© 2009 BrightSurf.com