Our Cheatin' Brain: The Brain's Clever Way of Showing Us the World as a Whole

October 30, 2008

Whether we choose to admit it or not, we all experience memory errors from time to time. Research has suggested that false memory may be a result of having too many other things to remember or perhaps if too much time has passed. However, previous studies have indicated that a specific type of false memory known as "boundary extension" occurs for different reasons. Boundary extension is a mistake that we often make when recalling a view of a scene-we will insist that the boundaries of an image stretched out farther than what we actually saw. Although this error is very common and occurs in people of all ages (from young children to the elderly), few studies have been done examining how quickly boundary extension occurs. That is, it was unknown how long a scene needs to be interrupted before the viewer experiences boundary extension and is convinced they saw more than they actually did.

Psychologists Helene Intraub and Christopher A. Dickinson from the University of Delaware were interested in this effect and wanted to test how quickly boundary extension can occur in a group of volunteers. The researchers created two versions of a photograph- the photographs depicted the same scene but one had a wider view, showing more of the background. In the first experiment, volunteers were shown one view, interrupted very briefly by a "mask" (an unrelated display of lines and curves with a small "happy face" in the center) followed by the same photograph or the other version of the photograph, which remained on the screen. Volunteers were then asked to report whether the picture they were looking at was the same, or showed more or less of the view compared to the first photograph. The second experiment had a similar set up except that the first and second photographs were shown on opposite sides of the monitor forcing the volunteers to shift their eyes from one image to the other so that the interruption included an eye movement.

The results, reported in the October issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, showed that boundary extension occurred in both experiments-although the volunteers knew exactly what would be tested and their view of the scene was disrupted for as little as 42 milliseconds, when the view was identical, they rated the second photograph as being "closer up" compared to the first. They were positive that they saw more of the scene in the first photograph, even when the interruption lasted quicker than an eye blink! The results of the second experiment (requiring an eye movement) indicate that boundary extension also occurs during visual scanning and not just during more simple tasks that use a mask alone (as in Experiment 1).

Based on these results, the authors suggest a new concept of scene perception, one that is not based solely on visual input. Rather, they suggest that other inputs are also involved, including amodal perception (the ability of the brain to automatically "fill in" blank spaces for us) and spatial perception (providing the viewer with a sense of space beyond the image). Therefore in this study, during the interruption, although the visual input was missing the other inputs were still available, giving the volunteers a general sense of what they saw.

The researchers suggest that errors in boundary judgment may actually be beneficial because the end goal is a logical view of the world as a whole. The authors conclude, "The rapidity of this error would be advantageous rather than harmful, because the goal of the visual system is not to represent the spurious boundaries of each fleeting view, but to incorporate those views into a coherent, continuous representation of a surrounding world."

Association for Psychological Science

The Boundaries of the Campus: A History of the University of Wisconsin Extension Division, 1885-1945
by Frederick M. Rosentreter (Author)

Extension problems in complex and CR-geometry (Publications of the Scuola Normale Superiore / Theses (Scuola Normale Superiore))
by Alberto Saracco (Author)

This book is both a survey of some aspects of extension problems in Complex Analysis and Geometry and a collection of results by the author. After recalling the preliminary and necessary notions of complex analysis, the survey focuses on extension of holomorphic functions (filling both compact and non-compact holes), on the reflection principle, on extension results via cohomology vanishing, and on the boundary problem. The last two subjects include detailed results by the author on non-compact extension: the cohomology of semi q-coronae and the unbounded boundary problem.

Being Human: The Technological Extensions of the Boundaries of the Body
by Paola Mieli (Author)

New technologies, from Virtual Reality to Artificially Aided Reproduction, are rapidly altering the scope of the human subject. This collection of essays and interviews--based on a research project initiated by the Apres-Coup Psychoanalytic Group of New York--addresses how these changes may be affecting the structure and character of the mind, as well as the representation of the body.

The Countries of South Asia: Boundaries, Extensions, and Interrelations (Proceedings of the South Asia Seminar, 3)
by Peter Gaeffke (Author), David A. Utz (Editor)

Springfield OKs larger urban district.(Government)(City councilors approve a boundary extension to 23rd Street after voters passed an improvement plan ... article from: The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR)
by Gale Reference Team (Author)

This digital document is an article from The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR), published by Thomson Gale on November 27, 2007. The length of the article is 461 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

Citation Details
Title: Springfield OKs larger urban district.(Government)(City councilors approve a boundary extension to 23rd Street after voters passed an improvement plan on the ballot)
Author: Gale Reference Team
Publication: The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR) (Newspaper)
Date: November 27, 2007
Publisher: Thomson Gale
Page: E35

Distributed by Thomson...

Case for the Extension of the Municipal Boundary of Edinburgh, and the Transference of the Powers of the Police and Paving Boards to the Town Council
by John Sinclair (Author)

This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923. This book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages, poor pictures, errant marks, etc. that were either part of the original artifact, or were introduced by the scanning process. We believe this work is culturally important, and despite the imperfections, have elected to bring it back into print as part of our continuing commitment to the preservation of printed works worldwide. We appreciate your understanding of the imperfections in the preservation process, and hope you enjoy this valuable book.

Boundary-Layer Theory
by H. Schlichting (Author), K. Gersten (Author)

A new edition of the almost legendary textbook by Schlichting completely revised by Klaus Gersten is now available. This book presents a comprehensive overview of boundary-layer theory and its application to all areas of fluid mechanics, with emphasis on the flow past bodies (e.g. aircraft aerodynamics). It contains the latest knowledge of the subject based on a thorough review of the literature over the past 15 years. Yet again, it will be an indispensable source of inexhaustible information for students of fluid mechanics and engineers alike.

Minnesotas Boundary with Canada: Its Evolution Since 1783 (Publications - Minnesota Historical Society, Public Affairs Center)
by William E. Lass (Author)

The boundary between the U.S. and Canada is far more than a line on a map or a demarcation on the ground. In a broad sense, it represents the aspirations, successes, frustrations, failures, and compromises of the two largest countries on the North American continent. Behind this unfortified boundary lie the negotiations, surveys, and intrigue leading to the final establishment of this international border that had its beginnings in the eighteenth century.

Moral Boundaries: A Political Argument for an Ethic of Care
by Joan Tronto (Author)

In this work the author aims to provide an original response to the controversial questions surrounding women and caring. She demonstrates that feminist thinkers have failed to realize the political context which has shaped their debates about care. It is her belief that care cannot be a useful moral and political concept until its traditional and ideological associations as a "women's morality" are challenged. Tronto contests the association of care with women alone as empirically and historically inaccurate, as well as politically unwise. She goes on to illustrate the ways in which society degrades the importance of caring in order to maintain the power of those who are privileged.

Neighbor Law: Fences, Trees, Boundaries, & Noise
by Cora Jordan Attorney Attorney Attorney Attorney Attorney Attorney Attorney Atto (Author), Emily Doskow Attorney (Author)

Learn your rights and responsibilities with this clear-cut, comprehensive guide to the laws concerning common neighbor disputes. The popular bestseller covers: fences; trees and other greenery that crosses the property line; boundaries; blocked views; noise; water runoff and flooding; interference from nearby businesses; dangers to children ("attractive nuisances")...and more! In plain English, Neighbor Law explains how to find applicable laws and resolve disputes without going to court, and explains when the law is on your side and how to deal with your neighbors without creating enemies. And, if you must go to small claims court, you'll find all the facts and stragegies you need.