Surgical Removal of Small Colon Polyps is Costly and Unnecessary

November 04, 2008

Polypectomy (the surgical removal of polyps by colonoscopy) of small polyps found during CT colonography is costly and unnecessary according to a study performed at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health in Madison, WI.

A decision analysis model was constructed to represent the clinical and economic consequences of performing three year colorectal cancer surveillance, immediate colonoscopy with polypectomy, or neither on patients who have 6-9 mm polyps found on CT colonography (CTC). The analysis model was accompanied by a hypothetical population of 100,000 60-year-old adults with 6- to 9-mm polyps detected at CTC screening. Results showed that, "by excluding large polyps and masses, CTC screening can place a patient in a very low risk category making colonoscopy for small polyps probably not warranted," said Perry J. Pickhardt, MD, lead author of the study. "Approximately 10,000 colonoscopy referrals would be needed for each theoretical cancer death prevented at a cost of nearly $400,000 per life-year gained. We would also expect an additional 10 perforations and probably one death related to these extra colonoscopies. There may be no net gain in terms of lives-just extra costs," said Dr. Pickhardt.

"The clinical management of small polyps detected at colorectal cancer screening has provoked controversy between radiologists and gastroenterologists. Patients should be allowed to have the choice between immediate colonoscopy and imaging surveillance for one or two isolated small polyps detected at colorectal cancer screening," said Dr. Pickhardt.

CT colonography is now a recommended test for colorectal cancer screening by the American Cancer Society. "If patients with small polyps are monitored, only five percent of adults undergoing CTC screening will need to undergo immediate invasive colonoscopy," said Dr. Pickhardt.

American Roentgen Ray Society

---

---

	How to learn colonoscopy by Umbrella Network Wondering how this little book became the best selling colonoscopy book on Amazon? It may have something to do with the fact that it is 1/20th the price of every other medical book. It may have something to do with the fact that most medical textbooks are badly written, with arcane references to out of date evidence. We'd like to think it is because this book contains the best distillation of the optimal method of learning the technique of safe, efficient colonoscopy. If you need to learn a set of heuristics to advance your endoscopy skills quickly, then this 10,000 word text aims to present them to you simply and concisely. The second addition has been updated, with diagrams and photos added where necessary to improve clarity.
	Colonoscopy: Principles and Practice by Jerome D. Waye (Editor), Douglas K. Rex (Editor), Christopher B. Williams (Editor) First Edition - Winner of 2004 BMA Medical Book Competition in GastroenterologyThe second edition of this prize winning book is written by some of the world’s foremost experts in the field of colonoscopy and colonic imaging. Every chapter has been updated and 5 new chapters have been added to include the latest information and advances in the field of colonoscopy:Capsule Colonoscopy Narrow Band ImagingConfocal EndomicroscopyEndoscopic Submucosal Dissection in the ColonNew Colonoscopes and Assist DevicesDrawing on the vast experience of the authors it covers every area of medicine that impacts on colonoscopy, including virtual colonography, pathology, techniques for pediatric and adult procedures, and legal aspects concerning colonoscopy. The book is focused on patient care, and...
	Atlas of Colonoscopy: Examination Techniques and Diagnosis by H. Messmann (Author) A complete guide to colonoscopy featuring more than 1,000 superb illustrations!In recent decades, colonoscopy has developed into one of the most essential techniques for early screening, detection, and diagnosis of colorectal cancer, inflammatory bowel disease, and other disorders. And rapid advances in interventional endoscopy offer doctors and patients an ever-increasing array of treatment possibilities. For newcomers to the technique and advanced practitioners alike, this lavishly illustrated atlas is a state-of-the-art guide to total colonoscopy. Atlas of Colonoscopy is...Accessible:Expert authors present all of the necessary instruments and examination techniques, as well as guidelines on preparation, related medications, complications, and more. Tips and tricks for instrument...
	Colonoscopy: It'll Crack U Up by Patricia L. Raymond (Author) Are you the proud owner of a vintage posterior? Were you born on or before January 1, 1954? Well,then, "Colonoscopy: It’ll Crack U Up" is just up your alley! Crack U Up is the latest publication from Dr. Patricia Raymond and Rx For Sanity…a compilation of bottom humor for anyone with a tail approaching 50. Find out your risks for colon cancer, what you can do to prevent it, take the Cheek Check Challenge. Show your support for your friends and relatives post-colonoscopy – congratulate them with a great gift copy of Crack U Up! We prescribe a copy of "Crack U Up" for your personal use….and suggest you dose two of your friends or business associates with a copy. Resolve to take better care of yourself, urge those closest you to do the same, and Celebrate your vertical...
	Colonoscopy: Principles and Practice by Jerome D. Waye (Editor), Douglas K. Rex (Editor), Christopher B. Williams (Editor) First Edition - Winner of 2004 BMA Medical Book Competition in GastroenterologyA state-of-the-art reference guide covering all aspects of the performance, technical and clinical background to colonoscopyThe second edition of this prize winning book is written by some of the world’s foremost experts in the field of colonoscopy and colonic imaging. Every chapter has been updated and 5 new chapters have been added to include the latest information and advances in the field of colonoscopy:Capsule Colonoscopy Narrow Band ImagingConfocal EndomicroscopyEndoscopic Submucosal Dissection in the ColonNew Colonoscopes and Assist DevicesDrawing on the vast experience of the authors it covers every area of medicine that impacts on colonoscopy, including virtual colonography, pathology, techniques...
	CT Colonography: Principles and Practice of Virtual Colonoscopy, 1e by Perry J. Pickhardt MD (Author), David H. Kim MD (Author) In CT Colonography, Perry Pickhardt and David Kim present techniques for quicker evaluation and diagnosis of colon cancer through the pioneering, specialty-changing imaging technique of virtual colonoscopy (VC). This combination of sophisticated X-rays and CT scans of the abdomen offers patients an alternative to colonoscopy that is cost effective and reduces the need for unnecessary polyp removal. Abundantly illustrated in full color, this pioneering book describes CT colonography from pathogenesis, staging and treatment through indications, technique, and interpretation for the most common pathologies. You'll have the full spectrum of VC technique and be able to see procedures performed through video clips on the included DVD.Covers principles, techniques, and interpretations for the...
	Virtual Colonoscopy by Judy Yee (Author) This text is a complete and practical guide to performing virtual colonoscopy examinations and interpreting the results. The book provides precise instructions on how to prepare the patient and specific protocols for the various CT scanners currently in use. Detailed chapters on interpretation demonstrate normal anatomy, anatomic variants, CT appearances of polyps and cancer, and pitfalls of interpretation on two-dimensional and three-dimensional views. Additional chapters cover extracolonic findings, reporting, and fecal and fluid tagging. More than 700 illustrations show examination techniques and normal and pathologic findings. A companion Website will offer teaching cases to further refine the reader's interpretive skills.
	Quality Colonoscopy, An Issue of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy Clinics, 1e (The Clinics: Internal Medicine) by John I. Allen MD MBA (Author) Dr. Allen's issue focuses on how gastroenterologists can maximize the "value” of colonoscopy - where value is defined as quality/cost. Clinical issues are covered, like sedation issues, complications of colonoscopy, and infection risk, but the majority of the articles deal with the discussions that surround quality colonoscopy-articles like: Risk Management and Legal Issues for Colonoscopy; Cost effectiveness of Colonoscopy in Prevention of Colon Cancer; Efficacy and Effectiveness of Colonoscopy: How Do We Bridge the Gap?; Current State of Colonoscopy Performance Measures; Use of Databases and Registries to Enhance Quality; and Maximizing the Value of Colonoscopy in Community, to name a few. In preparation of the changing landscape of healthcare, this issue will be an important one for...
	Atlas of Virtual Colonoscopy by Abraham H. Dachman (Editor), Andrea Laghi (Editor) Atlas of Virtual Colonoscopy thoroughly revises and updates Abraham Dachman’s bestselling first edition. Joined in this edition by co-editor Andrea Laghi, Dr. Dachman has expanded the focus of the text to cover fundamental topics of this rapidly evolving technology, including the history of virtual colonoscopy, a review of clinical trial data from throughout the world, and a presentation of clinical background information. Also included are chapters covering patient preparation and tagging, performing and reporting virtual colonoscopy, viewing methods, MR colonography, and computer aided detection. The second part of the text presents an atlas of high-resolution images with detailed explanations of teaching points, covering normal anatomy; sessile, pedunculated, diminutive and flat...
	Virtual Colonoscopy: A Practical Guide (Medical Radiology / Diagnostic Imaging) by Philippe Lefere (Editor), Stefàan Gryspeerdt (Editor), Albert L. Baert (Editor) Virtual colonoscopy is a rapidly evolving technique for the detection of tumoral lesions in the colon. It is now accepted by the American Cancer Society as a valuable screening tool for both colorectal cancer and its adenomatous precursor. With contributions from leaders in the field, this book addresses all the important issues relating to virtual colonoscopy. There is a particular focus on practical aspects, such as how to start virtual colonoscopy in a department, the regular preparation, and the correct scanning parameters. Imaging characteristics and pitfalls are considered in detail, with an extensive pictorial review of difficult lesions; the importance of computer-aided diagnosis is also discussed. In this second edition the text has been updated with the latest study results and...