Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer
Slashdot It! Slashdot Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer
Submit to Reddit Submit Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer to Reddit
Reading: Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast CancerTwitter This Reading: Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast CancerTwitter Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer
Add to Facebook Add Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer to Facebook

Mayo Clinic Study Finds Risk Assessment Tool Not Reliable Predictor for Some Women at High Risk of Breast Cancer

November 06, 2008

ROCHESTER, Minn. - A statistical model commonly used to predict the risk of breast cancer in women was not accurate when used to evaluate women with atypical hyperplasia, according to a new Mayo Clinic study published in the Oct. 14, 2008, issue of the Journal of Clinical Oncology. Atypical hyperplasia (atypia) describes breast tissue with an increased growth of abnormal cells that might become cancerous.

The Gail model calculates probabilities that a woman will develop invasive breast cancer during the next five years, and by age 90. The model has come to be called by the name of its developer, National Cancer Institute researcher Mitchell Gail, M.D., Ph.D. Its original purpose was to identify groups of high-risk women for participation in breast cancer chemoprevention studies. But the model has since been used in clinical settings to counsel individuals about their risk of developing breast cancer. Predicting risk at an individual level is much more challenging than when risks can be averaged across groups.




"The assumption has always been that this model works well in women with atypia, but this had never been validated," says Shane Pankratz, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic statistician and a lead investigator in the study. "We found that, for the group of women with atypia, the model predicted significantly fewer invasive breast cancers than were actually observed, and we also observed that the model was not able to reliably identify the women who were actually at higher risk of developing breast cancer."

The Gail model considers the woman's family history of breast cancer, her age, and her ages at the onset of menstruation and at first live birth, as well as the number of breast biopsies undergone and presence of atypical hyperplasia found in biopsies. About 5 percent of women who undergo biopsies for suspicious lumps or other breast concerns have atypia. About 25 percent of those with atypia will develop cancer within 25 years.

Mayo Clinic researchers tested the Gail model in 331 women with atypia who had benign breast biopsies at Mayo Clinic between 1967 and 1991. Of these women, 58 developed cancer during an average of 13.7 years of follow-up. In contrast, the model predicted that 34.9 women would develop breast cancer in that period.

Using these and other data, researchers also calculated the model's performance for individuals using the concordance statistic (c-statistic), which reflects how closely the actual timing of breast cancer events aligned with model predictions. A c-statistic of 0.5 is observed if the predictions are no better than random chance; a c-statistic of 1.0 is observed if the predictions are perfectly concordant with the actual outcomes. In this study, the c-statistic was 0.5, reflecting that the Gail model worked no better than a coin flip in predicting which of the women with atypia would develop invasive breast cancer.

When assessed across other groups of women without respect to the presence of atypia, the Gail model typically performs better. In that setting, it has been shown to predict approximately the same number of breast cancers that later occur.

Lynn Hartmann, M.D., Mayo Clinic oncologist and co-investigator on the study, says that there is strong interest in predicting breast cancer risk. For example, the Gail model, posted on the National Cancer Institute's Web site, attracts 25,000 viewers each month.

"Doctors counsel women at high risk to have more frequent or intensive surveillance or to consider chemoprevention strategies such as tamoxifen or raloxifene," says Dr. Hartmann. "When making such decisions, women and their physicians must have highly reliable risk estimates."

Researchers are pursuing other avenues to better predict individual risk. Previously, Mayo Clinic researchers found that women with multiple sites of cellular atypia in a breast biopsy have significantly increased risk of developing breast cancer. In a study published earlier this year, Mayo researchers found that women whose atypia tissues express COX-2 enzymes were more likely to develop breast cancer, and the higher the COX-2 levels, the higher the risk.

Other Mayo Clinic researchers involved in this study were Judy Boughey, M.D.; Amy Degnim, M.D.; Robert Vierkant; Karthik Ghosh, M.D.; Celine Vachon, Ph.D.: Marlene Frost, Ph.D.; Shaun Maloney and Carol Reynolds, M.D.

Mayo Clinic





Science News and Science Current Events Tag Cloud
This tag cloud is a visual representation of term frequencies of random science news topics with common terms grouped together and emphasized by their display size.
Prion   Acupuncture   Smart-1   Mammograms   Climate   Hepatitis C   Mathematics   Saturns Rings   Earth-like Planets   Antioxidant   Chlamydia   Children   Amino Acids   Circadian Rhythms   Gecko   Psychotherapy   Miscarriage   Rett Syndrome   Inflammatory Bowel Disease   Eating Disorders   Viscosity   Wireless sensor   Drug-resistant Bacteria   Butterflies   Infectious Disease  
Related Breast Cancer Current Events and Breast Cancer News Articles Breast Cancer Current Events and Breast Cancer News RSS Breast Cancer Current Events and Breast Cancer News RSS
Newly appreciated membrane estrogen receptor important therapeutic target for breast cancer
New research at Rhode Island Hospital has uncovered the biological effects of a novel membrane estrogen receptor, a finding that has potential implications for hormonal therapy for breast cancer.

Study shows PET can measure effectiveness of novel breast cancer treatment
A new study published in the July issue of The Journal of Nuclear Medicine shows that positron emission tomography (PET) scans in mice can be used to determine whether a novel type of breast cancer treatment is working as intended.

New MRI technique could mean fewer breast biopsies in high-risk women
A University of Wisconsin-Madison biomedical engineer and colleagues have developed a method that, applied in MRI scans of the breast, could spare some women with increased breast cancer risk the pain and stress of having to endure a biopsy of a questionable lump or lesion.

Researchers pinpoint a new enemy for tumor-suppressor p53
Researchers at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center have identified a protein that marks the tumor suppressor p53 for destruction, providing a potential new avenue for restoring p53 in cancer cells.

What should a teenage girl do if she finds a lump in her breast?
If a lump is found in the breast of an adolescent girl, she often will undergo an excisional biopsy.

Study challenges routine use of MRI scans to evaluate breast cancer
Reviewing the records of 577 breast cancer patients, Fox Chase Cancer Center researchers found that women with newly diagnosed breast cancer who receive a breast MRI are more likely to receive a mastectomy after their diagnosis and may face delays in starting treatment.

A new take on growth factor signaling in tamoxifen resistance
Differences in growth factor (GF) signaling may cause the poor prognosis in some breast cancer cases. A new study, published in the open access journal BMC Medical Genomics, suggests that some estrogen receptor-positive breast cancers respond poorly to tamoxifen because of increased GF signaling.

Study finds cancer is the second most frequent cause of death in individuals with schizophrenia
People with schizophrenia die from cancer four times as often as people in the general population.

Green tea may affect prostate cancer progression
According to results of a study published in Cancer Prevention Research, a journal of the American Association for Cancer Research, men with prostate cancer who consumed the active compounds in green tea demonstrated a significant reduction in serum markers predictive of prostate cancer progression.

Novel light-sensitive compounds show promise for cancer therapy
Chemists at the University of California, Santa Cruz, have developed novel compounds that show promise for photodynamic cancer therapy, which uses light-activated drugs to kill tumor cells.
More Breast Cancer Current Events and Breast Cancer News Articles
PINK RIBBON BREAST CANCER BEADED KEY CHAIN Purse Charm

PINK RIBBON BREAST CANCER BEADED KEY CHAIN Purse Charm

Beaded Pink Ribbon Breast Cancer Awareness Keychains. A mix of 4 styles! BEADS GALORE! Great for keychains, purse charms and more! Great for fund raisers! Meaures approx. 5" long!

Breast Cancer Survival Manual, Fourth Edition: A Step-by-Step Guide for the Woman With Newly Diagnosed Breast Cancer

Breast Cancer Survival Manual, Fourth Edition: A Step-by-Step Guide for the Woman With Newly Diagnosed Breast Cancer
by John Link (Author)

A completely updated edition of the definitive guide for patients with breast cancer
The new fourth edition of The Breast Cancer Survival Manual provides essential updates on treatment and care, enhancing the basic information that has made this the most trusted guide for women diagnosed with breast cancer for the past decade. This edition includes the most current advice on • getting a second opinion: why it’s important, what questions    to ask, and how to decide which team of doctors is best for you
• updates on genetic testing and how doctors are using
   the results to tailor care for each patient
• navigating new types of radiation, the herceptin
   breakthrough, and improved reconstruction surgeries
Conscious of the rapidly evolving spectrum of...

Fox Run Breast Cancer Awareness Baking Set

Fox Run Breast Cancer Awareness Baking Set
by Fox Run

Support Breast Cancer awareness in a sweet way with this five piece set. Bake cookies using the ribbon cookie cutters or cupcakes using the white paper bake cups with the pattern of pink ribbons. Decorate both with the included 4 in 1 sprinke assortement jar. The set also includes a pink silicone spoon spatula to help mix up your favorite batch of cookie dough.

Avon Breast Cancer Crusade Tennis Bracelet

Avon Breast Cancer Crusade Tennis Bracelet
by Avon

Silvertone with light rose crystals and pink enamel-look ribbon motif. 7" L with 1" extender.100% of the profits ($3.46) will be donated to the Avon Breast Cancer Crusade. ...

Please note that in your shipping confirmation you will be asked to let us know if you are currently receiving service from an Avon Representative. If you are, please follow the link provided in the confirmation so that s/he can receive proper credit for your Avon order placed through Amazon.com.

24 PINK Ribbon BREAST CANCER Awareness Rubber Bracelets/HOPE/Strength/SURVIVOR/FAITH/New in Package/EXCELLENT for FUND RAISING

24 PINK Ribbon BREAST CANCER Awareness Rubber Bracelets/HOPE/Strength/SURVIVOR/FAITH/New in Package/EXCELLENT for FUND RAISING
by Oriental Trading Co

24 Brand new in package PINK 8" Rubber Bracelets imprinted with an assortment of different inspirations; COURAGE, DREAM, LOVE, HOPE, FAITH and STRENGTH.

MAGLITE K3AMW6 National Breast Cancer Solitaire Flashlight, Pink

MAGLITE K3AMW6 National Breast Cancer Solitaire Flashlight, Pink
by MAGLITE

Weighing less than one ounce (with battery) and about three inches in length, the Mag-Lite Solitaire Single Cell AAA flashlight offers the same precision engineering and craftsmanship found in every Mag-Lite flashlight. With its unique shape, the Mag-Lite Solitaire flashlight fits conveniently into pockets, purses, attache cases, etc. The distinctive shapes, styles and overall appearances of all Mag flashlights, and the circumferential inscriptions extending around the heads of all Mag flashlights are trademarks of Mag Instrument, Inc. The circumferential inscription on the head of every flashlight signifies that it is an original Mag flashlight and part of the Mag family of flashlights. U.S. Trademark Registrations for the shape, style and overall appearance trademarks of Mag flashlights...

Conair CS3B Ceramic 1

Conair CS3B Ceramic 1" Straightener, Breast Cancer Awareness, Power of Pink
by Conair

Conair raises breast cancer awareness with the "Power of Pink" ionic styler. Featuring ionic technology that helps promote shiny, healthy hair, 3 heat/speed settings for precision styling and a removable filter for easy cleaning, this 1875 watt unit is the perfect blend of power and versatility. As an added value, a $1.00 of the proceeds from the sale of this product will be donated directly to Breast Cancer Research foundation.

Thorlo Women's Pink Pad Breast Cancer Sock, White/Pink, Large

Thorlo Women's Pink Pad Breast Cancer Sock, White/Pink, Large
by Thorlo

These socks were designed for women who prefer a lighter weight product for performance walking or just taking a stroll. You should always wear your Thorlos when fitting new footwear. An improper fit can reduce circulation (footwear too tight= footwear too hot/cold).

Chicken Soup for the Breast Cancer Survivor's Soul: Stories to Inspire, Support and Heal (Chicken Soup for the Soul)

Chicken Soup for the Breast Cancer Survivor's Soul: Stories to Inspire, Support and Heal (Chicken Soup for the Soul)
by Jack Canfield (Author), Mark Victor Hansen (Author), Mary Olsen Kelly (Author)

Your support group in a book, filled with boundless strength and profound hope - until the fight is won.

Along with the shock, fear and loss many women face upon a breast cancer diagnosis comes unexpected strength, wisdom, and strong networks of sharing, support and healing. In Chicken Soup for the Breast Cancer Survivor's Soul, survivors and their family members talk openly about how difficult their fight with breast cancer has been and how they made it through the dark times with a belief in a higher power and the support of those closest to them.

Find strength in the encouraging stories of how family members confront their fears and show genuine affection for one another through gestures such as a granddaughter cutting the hair off of all her dolls so that they will...

Breast Cancer Awareness Ribbon Promise of a Cure Cuff Bracelet

Breast Cancer Awareness Ribbon Promise of a Cure Cuff Bracelet

This Cuff Bracelet Will Fit up to a 8" Wrist and is 3/8" Wide Crafted of a Silver Toned Base Metal and Brought to High Polish Shine Set with a Bright Pink Breast Cancer Awareness Ribbon and Inscribed With The Phrase "Promise of a Cure"

© 2009 BrightSurf.com