Drop in cancer deaths tied primarily to gains in behavior and screening

December 03, 2008

Improvements in behavior and screening have contributed greatly to the 13 percent decline in cancer mortality since 1990, with better cancer treatments playing a supporting role, according to new research from David Cutler of Harvard University.

While not the first to report a long-term decline in cancer mortality, Cutler's is the first study to examine the reasons for this decline. Published in the fall edition of the Journal of Economic Perspectives, Cutler's paper, titled "Are We Finally Winning the War on Cancer?", looks at data for lung, colorectal, breast and prostate cancer.

"The decline in cancer is much larger than we commonly understand," says Cutler, who is Otto Eckstein Professor of Applied Economics in Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences, "and thus the benefits to society from reduced cancer mortality are even bigger than previously thought."

Cutler added that it had been unclear which of the many steps that have been taken to fight cancer have been most effective. In this research, he found that while reasons for the decline vary by type of cancer, screening and behavioral changes have contributed both equally and substantially.

Behavioral changes have had the greatest effect on lung cancer, Cutler says, where smoking cessation has had a tremendous impact. Other types of cancer have not been similarly impacted by the reduction in smoking. "The immense effort put into reducing smoking the past few decades has really paid off," Cutler noted.

In contrast, screening has proven especially effective in early detection of colorectal and breast cancer, but less so in identifying lung or prostate cancer. Colonoscopies also have a preventive value in removing polyps, and so preventing the formation of colon cancer.

"Among types of cancer where screening is valuable," Cutler says, "the question becomes: How can we increase the number of people who are being screened? Although costly, many types of screening are an enormous value."

Cutler found that treatment of cancer after its detection has been the least decisive of the three factors in cutting the cancer mortality rate.

"Drugs that are quite expensive have been shown to extend life by only a few months among patients with metastatic cancer, which raises questions about the relative value of such costly treatments," he says. "In contrast, while screening can be expensive, increased screening has led to significantly longer life expectancy for those diagnosed early with colorectal or breast cancer."

Cutler examined these four types of cancer because they are the most common, with abundant data on patient outcomes. Data was examined from population registries of individuals with cancer, as well as clinical literature about the effectiveness of behavioral changes, screenings and treatment.

"We typically think of the war on cancer as developing a new cure," says Cutler. "An equally important question is figuring out how we can take what we know and make it work for more people. We should think about the war as not just developing the next weapon, but using what we have in a smarter way. A health care system working for cancer would prevent people from getting it, catch it early, and then treat people accordingly. If our healthcare sys-tem was focused in this way, there could be a huge benefit."

Harvard University

A Cancer Source Book for Nurses, 8th Edition
by AMERICAN CANCER (Author)

A Cancer Source Book For Nurses, Eighth Edition Is Intended For Nurses In Every Practice Setting Who Are Involved With Providing Care For Cancer Survivors, Individuals With Cancer, And Those At Risk For Cancer. The Book Covers The Most Common Cancers And Strategies For Nursing Care. Several New Chapters Have Been Added, Including Chapters On Sexuality, Alternative Therapies, Vascular Access Devices, Clinical Trials, And Special Populations; Other Chapters Have Been Revised Extensively To Reflect Current Knowledge And Trends, And Include How To Manage Symptoms, The Latest On Cancer Prevention And Detection, Childhood Cancers, And Survivorship Issues. Chapters On The Most Common Cancers Include Information On Incidence, Risk Factors, Early Detection, Diagnostic Evaluation And Staging,...

Mortality
by Christopher Hitchens (Author)

On June 8, 2010, while on a book tour for his bestselling memoir, Hitch-22, Christopher Hitchens was stricken in his New York hotel room with excruciating pain in his chest and thorax. As he would later write in the first of a series of award-winning columns for Vanity Fair, he suddenly found himself being deported "from the country of the well across the stark frontier that marks off the land of malady." Over the next eighteen months, until his death in Houston on December 15, 2011, he wrote constantly and brilliantly on politics and culture, astonishing readers with his capacity for superior work even in extremis.

Throughout the course of his ordeal battling esophageal cancer, Hitchens adamantly and bravely refused the solace of religion, preferring to confront...

Seeds of Mortality: The Public and Private Worlds of Cancer
by Stewart Justman (Author)

According to the publicity of cancer, we are at last emerging from the time when the disease was surrounded by the unhealthy silence of denial. Stewart Justman is less certain about our so-called progress. A cancer patient himself, in Seeds of Mortality he separates the experience of cancer from the publicity and disputes the liberation rhetoric that has somehow established itself in the cancer world. He questions whether in fact the past was an age of darkness, whether silence is necessarily harmful (or conspiratorial), whether the openness of publicity is our best personal defense against cancer. He argues that cancer is a much more enigmatic disease than the publicity would suggest, that to those who stand in its presence the traditions of humility may still have something to say. Mr....

Recovering From Mortality: Essays From A Cancer Limbo Time
by Deborah Cumming (Author)

At the time that Deborah Cumming wrote Recovering from Mortality, she was living in a situation not widely recognized but shared by many people. She knew that she might die soon, yet she was not dying now. What is a person to think in this limbo time? How is a person to act? Rather than accept formulaic answers to these questions, she decided to discover her own path. She didn't want to pass on her answers to others; she didn't believe she knew universal answers. Nor was she interested in adding another story of a cancer patient who survived heroically or died movingly. She did want to commune with others in limbo, with people who might find it a lonely or mysterious condition. And she felt increasingly that she was talking about the human condition in general, for whether we...

American Cancer Society's Complete Guide to Colorectal Cancer
by American Cancer Society (Author), Bernard Levin (Editor), Terri Ades (Editor), Katie Couric (Editor)

Created by a prestigious panel of experts, this new book offers comprehensive coverage of colorectal cancer, the second most prevalent form of cancer in the world, which, with proper screening, is almost entirely preventable. It provides up-to-date, essential information about the disease, including prevention, detection, diagnosis, treatment options, complementary and alternative therapies, coping, living well with cancer, caregiving, and much more. Throughout the text real cancer survivors offer their experience dealing with this disease, from diagnosis to treatment and beyond.

Cancer Mortality and Morbidity Patterns in the U.S. Population: An Interdisciplinary Approach (Statistics for Biology and Health)
by K.G. Manton (Author), Igor Akushevich (Author), Julia Kravchenko (Author)

The purpose of this book is to examine the etiology of cancer in large human populations using mathematical models developed from an inter-disciplinary perspective of the population epidemiological, biodemographic, genetic and physiological basis of the mechanisms of cancer initiation and progression. In addition an investigation of how the basic mechanism of tumor initiation relates to general processes of senescence and to other major chronic diseases (e.g., heart disease and stroke) will be conducted.

Cancer Incidence and Mortality in England and Wales: Trends and Risk Factors (Oxford Medical Publications)
by Anthony Swerdlow (Author), Isabel Dos Santos Silva (Author), Richard Doll (Author)

Cancer causes a quarter of all deaths in England and Wales. There is great professional and public interest in cancer trends, but no satisfactory source to which to turn to find information about these trends and explanation of them. It is even more difficult to know where to turn for information on trends in factors causing cancer. This book presents new analyses that bring together for the first time, data on cancer trends in the country since 1868. Detailed consideration is given to the reasons for changes in rates of cancer, in relation to a wide range of risk factors and preventive factors. Data are presented with figures and tables describing long-term trends in more than 50 factors that may affect the risk of cancer, including AIDS, asbestos exposure, cancer screening,...

Urbanization and Cancer Mortality: The United States Experience 1950-1975 (Monographs in Epidemiology & Biostatistics)
by Michael R. Greenberg (Author)

Quality of Life in American Neighborhoods: Levels of Affluence, Toxic Waste, and Cancer Mortality in Residential Zip Code Areas
by Jay Gould (Author)

Trends in Cancer Incidence and Mortality (Combined Vols 19/20) (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Course Manual)
by R. Doll (Author), Richard Doll (Editor), Joseph F. Fraumeni (Editor)

Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford, U.K. Cancer Surveys Series: Advances and Prospects in Clinical Epidemiological and Laboratory Oncology, Volume 19/20. Advanced epidemiological cancer research in all types of cancer, with an international perspective. 46 contributors, 16 U.S.