Is one diet as good as another? U of I study says no and tells you why

March 05, 2009

Any diet will do? Not if you want to lose fat instead of muscle. Not if you want to lower your triglyceride levels so you'll be less likely to develop diabetes and heart disease. Not if you want to avoid cravings that tempt you to cheat on your diet. And not if you want to keep the weight off long-term.

"Our latest study shows you have a better chance of achieving all these goals if you follow a diet that is moderately high in protein," said Donald Layman, a University of Illinois professor emeritus of nutrition. The research was published in the March Journal of Nutrition.

Layman's new study followed the weight-loss efforts of 130 persons at two sites, the U of I and Penn State University, during 4 months of active weight loss and 8 months of maintenance.

Two previous studies had looked at short-term weight loss; this one was designed to look at long-term effects, he said.

Although both plans were equal in calories, half the group followed a moderate-protein diet (40% carbohydrates, 30% protein, 30% fat) while the other followed a diet based on USDA's food-guide pyramid (55% carbohydrates, 15% protein, 15% fat).

"Persons in the first group ate twice the amount of protein as the second group," said Layman.

And the difference in protein made all the difference in improved body composition and body lipids, he said.

Although the amount of weight lost in both groups was similar, at 4 months participants in the protein group had lost 22 percent more body fat than members of the food-pyramid group. At 12 months, the moderate-protein dieters had lost 38 percent more body fat.

"The additional protein helped dieters preserve muscle. That's important for long-term weight loss because muscle burns calories-if you lose muscle, and you used to be able to consume 2,000 calories without gaining weight, you'll find that now you can only eat, say, 1,800 calories without weight gain," he said.

What were the effects on lipids? Although at 4 months the food-guide pyramid appeared to be more effective in lowering LDL and total cholesterol levels, at 12 months LDL levels came back up until both diets were equally effective, Layman said.

"This is the first study to show that short-term changes in LDL cholesterol are not maintained with long-term weight loss. Most scientists believe that high cholesterol is more a factor of genetics than of diet," he said.

But the moderate-protein diet had by far the bigger effect on lowering triglycerides, and that lasted as long as individuals remained on the diet, he said.

"Of the two types of lipid problems, high triglycerides pose a greater risk for heart disease. Approximately twice as many people have high triglycerides, and people with this condition are approximately four times more likely to die from heart disease," the scientist said.

To ensure compliance, participants met every week for weigh-ins and nutrition instruction. "We taught participants how to follow their diet, how to grocery shop, and how to prepare the meals. They also measured everything they ate three days a week," he said.

"Studies that report there is no difference among diets also report that subjects were not carefully following the diets," said Layman. "It's very important to realize the difference between diet compliance and diet effectiveness."

The protein diet was easier to follow and maintain long-term, with 64 percent of the moderate-protein dieters completing the study compared to 45 percent of dieters using the high-carbohydrate diet, Layman said.

"Subjects on the moderate-protein diet reported that they weren't as interested in snacks or desserts, and they didn't have food cravings. When you eat protein, you feel full longer," he said.

Average weight loss for the protein group was 23 percent higher than the food-pyramid group, with 31 percent of "completers" in the protein group losing more of than 10 percent of their initial body weight versus 21 percent of the food-pyramid group.

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

---

---

	Running SUCKS! How to Run for Fast Weight Loss - For Busy Women Who HATE Running by MakeRight Publishing If you want to lose at least one clothing size in the next 2 weeks using simple running techniques that take LESS than 5 minutes of running per day... then this new book by Jennifer Jolan (America's #1 Weight Loss Queen) will show you how. The book is called: "Running SUCKS! How to Run for Fast Weight Loss - For Busy Women Who HATE Running" However, unlike most books about running, this one is short and all "meat" (with no fluff or filler). In fact, you'll read it in less than 15 minutes. And it's perfect for busy women who want to lose weight fast, but who hate running and consider it a "necessary evil." There is no suffering involved with these running secrets. No grueling long distance jogging (jogging and...
	How To Lose Weight and Get Healthy Even If You're Lazy - 115 Painless Weight Loss Tips by Lazy Girl Enterprises Diet advice has been around for so long, I bet they've found cave paintings showing proper portion sizes when eating a whooly mammoth. Trust me when I tell you there is not a lot of new weight loss info out there. The information doesn't change, but we do. We're all in different places in our weight loss journey and education. "How To Lose Weight and Get Healthy Even If You're Lazy" offers 115 ideas you may not have heard before, or that you may see in a new light now that you're further along in your journey. Of course, if you already know and practice common-sense ideas and your weight is under control, then this probably isn't the book for you which absolutely delights me. I'm all about celebrating success! But for me, and maybe you, it's taken many years of...
	Lose Weight WITHOUT Dieting: The Animal KIngdom Way by David Nordmark (Author) Diets don't work. Studies have shown that only 5 percent of people who go on a diet are able to keep the weight off for more than a year. Yet even with this 95 percent failure rate the weight loss industry continues to flood the market with new diets and useless gimmicks. What's the secret to true, long lasting weight loss? The key is to focus on your habits as they are related to food, not dieting. Unlike animals in nature human beings acquire a whole host of unnatural habits related to food without even realizing it. By changing these habits, most of whom you are probably not even aware off, you can start to lose weight naturally and easily. Get off the Diet roller coaster and start losing weight WITHOUT dieting today! To learn more about this course as well as others related to natural...
	The Permanent Weight Loss Solution by Integrated Fitness Solutions, LLC Imagine losing weight and then having the power to keep it off forever. That is what most people who embark on a weight loss journey are missing - the power to keep the weight loss - lost. Permanent weight loss is not found in what we've been brainwashed to believe - quick fix weight loss diets and extreme fat burning exercise routines. Instead its simply rooted in discovering your compelling reason "why," aligning yourself with the Laws of Nature, and mastering your motivation. You didn't gain weight fast, so expecting to lose weight fast is not only unrealistic, but one of the false expectations and distractions keeping you from achieving what you really want all along- permanent weight loss. You'll learn why this faulty belief in the "Magic...
	Rapid Weight Loss System: How to Lose 10 Pounds in a Week...A Simple Weight Loss Plan That Works by Platinum Internet RAVE REVIEWS FOR THIS BOOK: "This is an excellent book. If you want a book that would help you lose 10 pounds in a week, I would highly recommend this book." "A good plan for rapid weight loss - sensible yet effective. If you follow the plan day by day, you can very reasonably expect to lose weight." "This worked for me. I needed to lose 10 pounds for a wedding, and this got the job done. A good book that delivers what it promises." WHY CHOOSE THIS BOOK? Because it offers you a fast, easy plan that genuinely help you lose 10 pounds in a week. Part of a million-selling series, this book focuses on action you can take today to get real results. WHAT YOU GET So you want to lose weight fast? Now you can. This...
	The Spark: The 28-Day Breakthrough Plan for Losing Weight, Getting Fit, and Transforming Your Life by Chris Downie (Author) From the experts who created SparkPeople.com, America’s #1 diet and fitness site, comes The Spark. This groundbreaking book outlines the best of what has worked for millions of members who have lost weight, kept it off, and reached other goals. Driven by positive energy and proven results, The Spark outlines a breakthrough formula that combines nutrition, exercise, goal setting, motivation, and community, which has helped people change their lives beyond the scale. •          Discover the 27 Secrets of Success—the best action steps, foods, and proven medical advice that have helped tens of thousands of members lose from 2 to 200 pounds. •          Special tips from people who lost 100 pounds or more—see what these people had in common and what they did and...
	The 10/60 Diet: How to lose 10% of your body weight in 60 days. With all of the diet books on the market today, where is a person to turn? Pages upon pages of fluff with doctored before and after pictures; indiscernible scientific mumbo-jumbo; diet and exercise regimens that are impossible to follow and maintain. What if someone trimmed the fat from diet book and provided a simple plan to lose ten percent of your body weight within sixty days? Here it is. It costs under $1, it's under twenty pages, and it's all you need to find your beautiful new body, which has been hiding within you all along. The author used this diet to go from 194 pounds to 172 pounds between January 28, 2011 and March 28, 2011. How many authors can show results from the diets they recommend? Invest $0.99 and a few minutes of your time...
	The 5-Second Flat Belly Secret - Lose 2-3 Inches from Your Belly in Less Than 1 Month by MakeRight Publishing Can you really get a flat belly without hard exercise and eating like a health nut? Jennifer Jolan, best-selling author and America's Weight Loss Queen proves you can in her new book, The 5-Second Flat Belly Secret. And, believe it or not... you can do it in just 5 seconds per day! The secret science (used for thousands of years) makes this possible. And many women have lost as much as 2-3 inches of belly fat in one month or less following these ancient secrets hardly anyone in the diet or "fitness" industry knows about today. It's short and to the point. No fluff. No mindless filler like many weight loss books. In fact, you can read this book in less than 15 minutes, apply the secrets right away, and literally see results in the...
	100 Days of Weight Loss: The Secret to Being Successful on Any Diet Plan by Linda Spangle (Author) This personal growth diet companion encourages dieters--no matter what diet plan they are on--to stick to it by giving them the tools to address the issues behind their eating habits and to make the right choices.Going on a diet is easy, staying on a diet is hard and it is the consistent, long-term lifestyle change that results in real success. This book is not a diet but a diet companion. There are 100 short lessons that provide coping skills, behavioral tools, and personal growth ideas that serve as a companion and encourager and give dieters the daily strength to stick with their resolution. Spangle tackles the emotional and psychological issues of weight loss, which is missing from most diet plans. They tell you what to eat. 100 Days of Weight Loss gives you the personal tools to make...
	Hypothyroidism Diet Tips & Tricks for Women - Fix Your Thyroid & Lose Weight Fast by MakeRight Publishing If you are interested in a hypothyroidism diet that can help you lose weight and feel like a teenager again in as little as 1-2 months, then this new book by Jen Jolan (America's #1 weight loss queen) will show you how. This book is short, and to the point. There is no filler. And no needless "fluff" just to fill up pages. In fact, you can read this book in one sitting. And just by making a few simple changes with her unique hypothyroidism diet, you can gain more energy, lose more fat, and eliminate the usual under active thyroid symptoms in women (feeling cold all the time, fatigue, dry brittle nails, hair loss, depression, aches & pains, etc) you may be feeling now. Here are some of the secrets found inside: A secret...