Early family ties: No sponge in the human family tree

April 03, 2009

Since the days of Charles Darwin, researchers are interested in reconstructing the "Tree of Life", and in understanding the development of animal and plant species during their evolutionary history. In the case of vertebrates, this research has already come quite a long way. But there is still much debate about the relationships between the animal groups that made their apparation very early in evolutionary history, probably in the late Precambrian, some 650 million years ago. An international research group led by LMU Munich Geobiology Professor Gert Wörheide and colleagues from France and Canada has now managed to explain the relationships between some of these very early animal groups with a high degree of confidence. In the most comprehensive study of its kind, the researchers show that all sponges descended from a unique sponge ancestor, who in turn was not the ancestor of all other animals. That means that humans did not descend from a sponge - like organism either, as some scientists have put forward. Moreover, the results also suggest that the nervous system only evolved once in animal history.

The most ancient animal groups (phyla) include the Porifera (sponges), Placozoa, Cnidaria, and Ctenophora (comb jellies). The sponges are extremely simply built, and have no organs. The placozoans also have a very simple structure. They have a flat, disk-shaped body, and no organs either. Comb jellies, the ctenophores, are life forms that resemble jellyfish. The true jellyfish, however, are part of the cnidarians, a phylum that also includes corals and sea anemones. The exact relationships among these early animal groups are still controversial, as different research groups have often obtained conflicting results. In particular, results from morphological studies, which look for structural similarities between different organisms, frequently contradict the results from molecular biological studies. The latter explore the functions of genes, and deduce phylogenetic relationships from gene sequences.

Aiming to resolve these controversies, a group of international scientists led by Hervé Philippe (Université de Montréal, Canada), Gert Wörheide (LMU Munich, Germany) and Michael Manuel (University of Paris, France) performed the most comprehensive study to date and investigated 128 genes from a total of 55 species - including nine poriferans, eight cnidarians, three ctenophores and the single known species of placozoans. Their analyses were based on a relatively new approach called phylogenomics, which determines the evolutionary relationships of life forms by comparing large datasets of gene sequences. Together with biochemists, evolutionary and computational biologists from Germany, France and Canada, the team analyzed more than 30,000 amino acid positions. Using computer analyses, the researchers then estimated a phylogenetic tree that displays how related the studied animals are.

One of the most significant outcomes of this study is new evidence that all species of sponges are descendants of a single ancestor. On the other hand, Bilateria, which include worms, mollusks, insects, and vertebrates, did not descend directly from this "spongy" ancestor. "If the ancestral animal would have had a sponge-like organization or body, as some earlier molecular studies repeatedly claimed, then we would all be descendents of such sponge-like organisms," explains Wörheide. "This proposition generated a lot of attention in the past. But our results clearly disagree with it." The analyses also revealed that ctenophores and cnidarians most likely belong to a common group. "This group, the "coelenterates", is most closely related to the bilaterians," explains Wörheide. "Our results support, after much controversy, a hypothesis that was already formulated back in 1848."

The investigation also provides new insights into the development of individual organ systems. "Both coelenterates and bilaterians already have nerve cells. Their now corroborated close relationship also suggests that the nervous system developed only once in animal history," Wörheide states. And yet, another recent and less comprehensive study concerning the non-bilaterians proposed the unorthodox hypothesis that the comb jellies had already diverged from all other species even before the sponges. "Since the comb jellies already have nerve and muscle cells, this would suggest that these features developed several times independently in animal history, or that they were lost in sponges and placozoans," explains the LMU researcher.

This new study, which compared more evolutionarily ancient life forms than ever before, presents a stimulating framework for future studies. "Our results can now be used to explore how certain key features evolved among animals," says Wörheide. There is evidence, for example, that part of the genetic toolkit responsible for building the nervous system in other animals was already present in sponges. Similarly, eye-like sensory organs can already be detected in box jellyfish. "One of the goals of future studies will now be to find out how and when the genetic toolkit for the nervous system, muscles and sensory organs evolved in animal history," Wörheide concludes.

Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München

---

---

	Design*Sponge at Home, Signed by Grace Bonney by Grace Bonney (Author) The long-awaited home décor bible by the beloved design blogger“Thank you,” wrote a reader to Design*Sponge creator Grace Bonney, “for teaching me that houses don’t have to be frumpy and formal. They don’t have to be matchy-matchy or rigidly modern.” They can just be comfy and unique and reflect who you are, no matter how small your budget or space.That reader is one of the 75,000 unique daily visitors to Design*Sponge, who make it the most popular design site on the web. The site receives 250,000 pageviews every day and has 150,000 RSS subscribers and 280,000 followers on Twitter. Design*Sponge fans have been yearning for the ultimate design manual from their guru, Grace, and she has finally delivered with this definitive guide, which includes:• Home tours of 70...
	SpongeBob Goes to the Doctor (Spongebob Squarepants) by Steven Banks (Author), Zina Saunders (Illustrator) SpongeBob has come down with a bad case of the suds and he's afraid to go to the doctor. But when being sick means having to miss a day of work at the Krusty Krab, SpongeBob must face his fear.
	Camp Spongebob (Spongebob Squarepants (Pb Numbered)) by Molly Reisner (Author), Kim Ostrow (Author), Heather Martinez (Illustrator) Sandy decides to open Bikini Bottom's very first summer camp and asks SpongeBob to be her assistant. But Spongebob goes overboard trying to make sure that their camp is the best camp ever!
	Happy Birthday, SpongeBob! (Spongebob Squarepants Ready-to-Read) by J-P Chanda (Author), Heather Martinez (Illustrator) It’s SpongeBob’s party, and he can celebrate if he wants to! But where are the balloons, the cake, . . . or his friends? Like SpongeBob, young readers are in for a surprise as they join their favorite yellow sponge in this Level 1 reader with rebus icons.
	SpongeBob's Box of Books (Spongebob Squarepants) by Various (Author) Ahoy there, mateys! Here's a boxful of treasure: six (count them, six!) rip-roaring 8 x 8 storybooks that you can take with you on all your seafaring -- and landlubbing -- adventures. And they're all ready to go in this handy carrying case with a handle. Included in this boxed set are: Hands Off! And the Winner Is... SpongeBob and the Princess Ice-Cream Dreams Bubble Blowers, Beware! The Great Snail Race
	SpongeBob, Soccer Star! (Spongebob Squarepants) by David Lewman (Author), Stephen Reed (Illustrator) Gooaal! Soccer fans everywhere will cheer on SpongeBob and his friends in this funny soccer adventure.
	For the Love of Bubbles (Spongebob Squarepants Chapter Book, No. 12) by Steven Banks (Author), The Artifact Group (Author) SpongeBob was out bubble blowing one morning when suddenly he tripped over some kelp, bumped his head, and blacked out! When he awoke, he couldn't remember his name or where he lived! While SpongeBob searches for his lost identity, Patrick and Sandy set out to find their best friend. Imagine their shock when they discover he's been elected mayor of New Kelp City!
	SpongeBob DetectivePants in the Case of the Vanished Squirrel (Spongebob Squarepants) by David Lewman (Author), Harry Moore (Illustrator) SpongeBob DetectivePants and his faithful assistant Patrick PatrickPants are back! When Sandy suddenly goes missing, they are soon on the case to hunt down the evil squirrel-napper who stole their friend. With only a mysterious note and a trail of acorns to guide them, the investigators set off combing the town for more clues. And one thing’s for sure – they won’t rest until Sandy is safely back in Bikini Bottom – case closed! This hilarious mystery also contains one page of holographic stickers!
	The Rise of the Sponge Cake Moon (Gheras The Wise) by Chris Irving/C.p.Singleton The story starts with Mr and Mrs God in their little cottage. Mr God has been playing with the idea of creating a universe for so long that Mrs God is at the end of her tether. She advises him, after getting him to whisk the Yorkshire pudding batter, to drop cubic planets and go with spherical ones instead. She promises to help him if she can call the planet, with the little people, Earth, after their cat. With all the kerfuffle of making the dinner, the universe and the little people they forget to make a moon. This makes for a lot of dark nights and bored wolves. The story moves on to a cave-man called Atam, who is Chief Mula-Moon’s head chef and the man responsible for making the Chief’s anniversary dinner. Each year Atam makes the most...
	SpongeBob DetectivePants: The Case of the Missing Spatula (Spongebob Squarepants) by David Lewman (Author), Harry Moore (Illustrator) SpongeBob SquarePants is excited to start another glorious day at his wonderful job, frying Krabby Patties at the Krusty Krab. But when SpongeBob discovers that his favorite spatula, Flipper, is missing, he resolves never to fry again until he finds out who stole it! Will SpongeBob ever make Krabby Patties again? Have fun with the holographic stickers while SpongeBob solves this mystery!