Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Evidence of the 'Lost World' -- did dinosaurs survive the end Cretaceous extinctions?

Evidence of the 'Lost World' -- did dinosaurs survive the end Cretaceous extinctions?

April 28, 2009

The Lost World, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's account of an isolated community of dinosaurs that survived the catastrophic extinction event 65 million years ago, has no less appeal now than it did when it was written a century ago. Various Hollywood versions have tried to recreate the lost world of dinosaurs, but today the fiction seems just a little closer to reality. New scientific evidence suggests that dinosaur bones from the Ojo Alamo Sandstone in the San Juan Basin, USA, date from after the extinction, and that dinosaurs may have survived in a remote area of what is now New Mexico and Colorado for up to half a million years. This controversial new research, published today in the journal Palaeontologia Electronica, is based on detailed chemical investigations of the dinosaur bones, and evidence for the age of the rocks in which they are found.

"The great difficulty with this hypothesis - that these are the remains of dinosaurs that survived - is ruling out the possibility that the bones date from before the extinction" says Jim Fassett, author of the research. "After being killed and deposited in sands and muds, it is possible for bones to be exhumed by rivers and then incorporated into younger rocks" he explains. This is not the usual way in which fossil deposits of this kind form, but it has been shown to explain some other post-extinction dinosaur bones. Fassett has amassed a range of evidence that indicates that these fossils from the Ojo Alamo Sandstone were not exhumed and redeposited and that these dinosaurs really did live after the end Cretaceous extinction event.




The first step must be to demonstrate that the rocks containing the bones are younger than the extinction event. Fassett has analysed the magnetic polarity of the rocks, and the pollen grains they contain, different approaches to finding the age of rocks which, he concludes "independently indicate that they do indeed post-date the extinction". Fassett also found that "the dinosaur bones from the Ojo Alamo Sandstone have distinctly different concentrations of rare earth metal elements to the bones in the underlying Cretaceous rocks" and this, he argues "makes it very unlikely that the post-extinction bones were exhumed from the underlying sediments." This is supported by a find of 34 hadrosaur bones together - "these are not literally an articulated skeleton, but the bones are doubtless from a single animal" - if the bones had been exhumed by a river, they would have been scattered.

So does this provide conclusive proof that dinosaurs survived the Cretaceous extinctions? According to David Polly, one of the editors of the journal in which the research is published "this is a controversial conclusion, and many palaeontologists will remain sceptical", but we already know that flying theropod dinosaurs (more generally referred to as birds) and crocodiles survived, so the possibility of pockets of survivors of other types of dinosaur is not quite as far fetched as it might sound. Finding conclusive evidence, however, is a difficult matter when the crime scene is 65 million years old. "One thing is certain" continues Polly, "if dinosaurs did survive, they were not as widespread as they were before the end of the Cretaceous and did not persist for long." The 'Lost World scenario' of humans and dinosaurs existing at the same time, still belongs firmly in the realms of pure fantasy.

The Palaeontological Association



Related Dinosaurs Current Events and Dinosaurs News Articles Dinosaurs Current Events and Dinosaurs News RSS Dinosaurs Current Events and Dinosaurs News RSS
Warm-blooded dinosaurs worked up a sweat
Were dinosaurs "warm-blooded" like present-day mammals and birds, or "cold-blooded" like present day lizards? The implications of this simple-sounding question go beyond deciding whether or not you'd snuggle up to a dinosaur on a cold winter's evening.

A motley collection of boneworms
It sounds like a classic horror story-eyeless, mouthless worms lurk in the dark, settling onto dead animals and sending out green "roots" to devour their bones.

Central Africa's tropical Congo Basin was arid, treeless in Late Jurassic
The Congo Basin - with its massive, lush tropical rain forest - was far different 150 million to 200 million years ago. At that time Africa and South America were part of the single continent Gondwana.

The last European hadrosaurs lived in the Iberian Peninsula
Spanish researchers have studied the fossil record of hadrosaurs, the so-called 'duck-billed' dinosaurs, in the Iberian Peninsula for the purpose of determining that they were the last of their kind to inhabit the European continent before disappearing during the K/T extinction event that occurred 65.5 million years ago.

The humble beginnings of a king
Tyrannosaurus rex and related large carnivorous dinosaurs together form the family Tyrannosauridae. A long forgotten fossil skull in the collections of the Natural History Museum in London has now provided crucial clues to the early stages of the lengthy evolutionary history of these fearsome predators.

New dinosaur species from Montana
A husband and wife team of American paleontologists has discovered a new species of dinosaur that lived 112 million years ago during the early Cretaceous of central Montana.

New analyses of dinosaur growth may wipe out one-third of species
Paleontologists from the University of California, Berkeley, and the Museum of the Rockies have wiped out two species of dome-headed dinosaur, one of them named three years ago - with great fanfare - after Hogwarts, the school attended by Harry Potter.

Galaxy cluster smashes distance record
The most distant galaxy cluster yet has been discovered by combining data from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory and optical and infrared telescopes.

Clemson researchers say algae key to mass extinctionss
Algae, not asteroids, were the key to the end of the dinosaurs, say two Clemson University researchers. Geologist James W. Castle and ecotoxicologist John H. Rodgers have published findings that toxin producing algae were a deadly factor in mass extinctions millions of years ago.

Do 3 meals a day keep fungi away?
The fact that they eat a lot - and often - may explain why most people and other mammals are protected from the majority of fungal pathogens, according to research from Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University.
More Dinosaurs Current Events and Dinosaurs News Articles
Dozen Jumbo Dinosaurs up to 6 inches long

Dozen Jumbo Dinosaurs up to 6 inches long
by Toy C

Set of 12 realistic toy dinosaur figures. Dinos are made from slightly flexible plastic, are hollow inside. Set includes: Ceratosaurus, Pachycephalosaurus, Stegosaurus, Parasaurolophus, Tyrannosaurus, Spinosaurus, Brachiosaurus, Velociraptor, Apatosaurus, Euoplocephalus, Triceratops, Styracosaurus.

ZipBin Dinosaur Playset

ZipBin Dinosaur Playset
by Neat Oh

ZipBin is more than great-looking storage. It's a portable play world that unzips to reveal space to play, create and imagine. And it's easy to clean up... in a zip!

The Dinosaur storage bin's dramatic exterior theme identifies the contents and will look great in your child's room. When the bin is unzipped, it becomes a dinosaur island play mat, complete with a colorful island, a volcano, and oozing tar pit and a mysterious cave. When play is done, the play mat becomes the storage bin in a zip, capturing the toys inside. Includes four dinosaurs: Tyrannosaurus Rex, Saurolophus, Triceratops, and Compsognathus, 4-5" long. ZipBin measures approximately 16" x 13" x 9".

My Big Dinosaur Book (My Big Board Books)

My Big Dinosaur Book (My Big Board Books)
by Roger Priddy (Author)



Scientific Explorer's My First Dinosaur Science Kit

Scientific Explorer's My First Dinosaur Science Kit
by Scientific Explorer

With My First Dino Kit, You're a real paleontologist! Use excavation tools to dig up a dinosaur skeleton and then classify and display your findings. Build a glow in the dark model, or grow and shrink some giant dinos, all while you learn about the prehistoric past. Did some dinosaurs have feathers? Are crocodiles as ancient as the dinosaurs? You'll find out. Ages 4+ adult supervision required.



Mattel SCREATURE Interactive Dinosaur

Mattel SCREATURE Interactive Dinosaur
by Mattel

Your own prehistoric pal! Dare pet his head? More bite than roar! Can you master Screature, or will you be his prey? Lifelike and realistic with ferocious sounds, Screature uses an infrared sensor to sense and attack his prey with your help. If you can control Screature, he will respond loyally to your petting, but if you pet him in the wrong place, Screature attacks! Set him in room guard mode and Screaturewill guard all your prized treasures! Screature is a mean little predator with a big appetite. Try me, open tray package. 3x 'AA' batteries included, with minor assembly required.

Animal Planet's Big Tub of Dinosaurs

Animal Planet's Big Tub of Dinosaurs
by Hasbro

It

First Dinosaur Encyclopedia

First Dinosaur Encyclopedia
by DK Publishing (Author)

From the first sea mammals to fierce dinosaurs, this inspiring reference book takes children on a fantastic journey into the prehistoric world.

Dinosaurs - The Complete First and Second Seasons

Dinosaurs - The Complete First and Second Seasons
Starring: Bill Barretta, Kevin Clash, Tom Fisher, Dave Goelz, David Greenaway
Directed By: Bruce Bilson, Jay Dubin, Mark Brull, Michael Jacobs, Patrick Johnson

Meet the Sinclairs -- the funniest family in 60 million years! They're just your average family with one BIG difference. They're dinosaurs living the good life in sixty million and three B.C.! Daddy Earl his wife Fran their kids Robbie Charlene and the Baby and feisty Grandma Ethyl bring a hilarious Jurassic twist to daily life as they eat drink make merry and get their kicks watching cavemen rub rocks together. Based on an idea by Jim Henson the award-winning comedy series features state-of-the-art puppetry and audioanimatronics. For the first time you can enjoy the complete first two seasons and rediscover the pre-hysterical fun all over again.Bonus Features:Pre-Hysterical Times: The Making Of DINOSAURS -- Get a first-ever behind-the-scenes look at how Jim Henson's Creature Shop brought...

Melissa & Doug Dinosaur Stamp Set

Melissa & Doug Dinosaur Stamp Set
by Melissa and Doug

Mix and match the 8-9 playfully detailed stamps to create hundreds of beautiful scenes, and then color in the pictures with the 5 colored pencils! Each themed set includes 2 colored inkpads. Ages 4+. Each set 8.75" x 8" x 2".

RoomMates RMK1043SCS Dinosaurs Peel & Stick Appliques

RoomMates RMK1043SCS Dinosaurs Peel & Stick Appliques
by RoomMates

DINOSAURS Decorative Wall Stickers (set of 4 sheets - 16 Jumbo stickers) . Self-stick, removable, and reusable Jumbo Wall Stickers are the easy way to decorate and won't damage your walls! It's so quick and amazing , just peel and stick! Jumbo Size: 4 sheets , 16 precut stickers. Decorate in minutes!! Easy to apply. Works best on clean, smoth, dust-free surfaces. Apply even pressure to entire sticker surface. 16 pieces of Peel & Stick technology will adhere to any smooth surface. Easily removable and repositionable. Washable with mild soap and sponge. Safe for use in all rooms including the bathroom. Decorating has never been so easy! Clamshell Packaging.

© 2009 BrightSurf.com