 |
|
Unstated assumptions color Arctic sovereignty claims
May 29, 2009Parties need to understand each other's assumptions if issues are to be resolved
Settling the growing debate over ownership of Arctic Ocean resources is complicated by the fact that the various countries involved have different understandings of the geography of the place.
Phil Steinberg, an associate professor in the Department of Geography at Florida State University in Tallahassee, says coming to terms with those divergent views is the first necessary step to resolving what is becoming a prickly international issue as global warming opens up more of the Arctic Ocean.
In a presentation at the Congress of the Humanities and Social Sciences taking place at Ottawa's Carleton University, Dr. Steinberg says that people make unstated assumptions about geography when they talk about places. In the case of the Arctic Ocean, there are two opposing concepts: Is the Arctic Ocean just water that you pass over, or is it land with water on top of it - land that belongs to a country?
He says that when countries such as Russia talk of resource extraction, they are thinking of the Arctic as land with water on top of it. Canada makes the same assumption when it talks of the Northwest Passage as belonging to Canada. The U.S., however, views the Northwest Passage as just water - water that people pass over to travel from one place to another.
"In the U.S. national imaginary, I don't think there's the idea that the space up there is divided into territories that belong to anybody," says Dr. Steinberg. He adds that some of those assumptions are built right into our maps.
Look at a map of the world, says Dr. Steinberg: Land areas are divided into countries, each in a different colour. That reinforces the idea of ownership. But on a map the sea is a coloured a uniform blue - a graphic representation of the oceans being freely accessible to all.
The same idea applies to Antarctica, which is generally coloured white on maps and not marked by firm territorial divisions. In the Arctic, there is one further complicating factor: When the ocean is covered by ice, it can be walked on and to some extent used like land; but when the ice melts, the Arctic is water.
"In trying to understand the debate, it's always helpful to understand the implicit references each side is making," says Dr. Steinberg. "Often, the disagreements are over unspoken assumptions.
"In the case of the Northwest Passage, a whole lot of what is going on from the U.S. side is fear of setting a precedent.
"Small issues become big issues when states become fearful of setting precedents."
Organized by the Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences, Congress 2009 brings together over 8,000 researchers from Canada and around the world.
Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences
In a presentation at the Congress of the Humanities and Social Sciences taking place at Ottawa's Carleton University, Dr. Steinberg says that people make unstated assumptions about geography when they talk about places. In the case of the Arctic Ocean, there are two opposing concepts: Is the Arctic Ocean just water that you pass over, or is it land with water on top of it - land that belongs to a country?
He says that when countries such as Russia talk of resource extraction, they are thinking of the Arctic as land with water on top of it. Canada makes the same assumption when it talks of the Northwest Passage as belonging to Canada. The U.S., however, views the Northwest Passage as just water - water that people pass over to travel from one place to another.
"In the U.S. national imaginary, I don't think there's the idea that the space up there is divided into territories that belong to anybody," says Dr. Steinberg. He adds that some of those assumptions are built right into our maps.
Look at a map of the world, says Dr. Steinberg: Land areas are divided into countries, each in a different colour. That reinforces the idea of ownership. But on a map the sea is a coloured a uniform blue - a graphic representation of the oceans being freely accessible to all.
The same idea applies to Antarctica, which is generally coloured white on maps and not marked by firm territorial divisions. In the Arctic, there is one further complicating factor: When the ocean is covered by ice, it can be walked on and to some extent used like land; but when the ice melts, the Arctic is water.
"In trying to understand the debate, it's always helpful to understand the implicit references each side is making," says Dr. Steinberg. "Often, the disagreements are over unspoken assumptions.
"In the case of the Northwest Passage, a whole lot of what is going on from the U.S. side is fear of setting a precedent.
"Small issues become big issues when states become fearful of setting precedents."
Organized by the Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences, Congress 2009 brings together over 8,000 researchers from Canada and around the world.
Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences
Arctic Ocean Current Events and Arctic Ocean News RSSLast time carbon dioxide levels were this high: 15 million years ago, scientists report
You would have to go back at least 15 million years to find carbon dioxide levels on Earth as high as they are today, a UCLA scientist and colleagues report Oct. 8 in the online edition of the journal Science.
NASA flies to Antarctica for largest airborne polar ice survey
NASA begins a series of flights Oct. 15 to study changes to Antarctica's sea ice, glaciers and ice sheets. The flights are part of Operation Ice Bridge, a six-year campaign that is the largest airborne survey ever made of ice at Earth's polar regions.
Arctic Sea ice extent is third lowest on record
U.S. satellite measurements show Arctic sea ice extent in 2009 - the area of the Arctic Ocean covered by floating ice - was the third lowest since satellite measurements were first made in 1979.
Satellites and submarines give the skinny on sea ice thickness
This summer, a group of scientists and students - as well as a Canadian senator, a writer, and a filmmaker - set out from Resolute Bay, Canada, on the icebreaker Louis S. St-Laurent.
NASA, CU-Boulder airborne expedition chases Arctic sea ice questions
A small NASA aircraft completed its first successful science flight Thursday in partnership with the University of Colorado at Boulder as part of an expedition to study the receding Arctic sea ice and improve understanding of its life cycle and the long-term stability of the Arctic ice cover.
Arctic climate under greenhouse conditions in the Late Cretaceous
New evidence for ice-free summers with intermittent winter sea ice in the Arctic Ocean during the Late Cretaceous - a period of greenhouse conditions - gives a glimpse of how the Arctic is likely to respond to future global warming.
Mercury in Mackenzie River delta dramatically higher than previously believed
University of Alberta researchers conducting a water study in the Mackenzie River Delta have found a dramatically higher delivery of mercury from the Mackenzie River to the Arctic Ocean than determined in previous studies.
New cleaning protocol for future 'search for life' missions
Scientists have developed a new cleaning protocol for space hardware, such as the scoops of Mars rovers, which could be used on future "Search for Life" missions on other planets.
As world warms, water levels dropping in major rivers
Rivers in some of the world's most populous regions are losing water, according to a comprehensive study of global stream flows.
New Arctic satellite data shows Arctic literally on thin ice
The latest data from NASA and the University of Colorado at Boulder's National Snow and Ice Data Center show the continuation of a decade-long trend of shrinking sea ice extent in the Arctic, including new evidence for thinning ice as well.
More Arctic Ocean Current Events and Arctic Ocean News Articles
 |
The Four Oceans (Rookie Read-About Geography) by Wil Mara (Author) The popular Rookie Books expand their horizons - to all corners of the globe! With this series all about geography, emergent readers will take off on adventures to cities, nations, waterways, and habitats around the worldÂ…and right in their own backyards. |
 |
We Swim The Arctic Ocean Perfuma (Primary Contributor) |
 |
Long Sleeve T-shirt with iceberg, ocean, sea, arctic, glacier, winter Large White by Shop Zeus |
 |
Call of the Killer Whale (Orcas), Parts 1 and 2 Also With: PBS (Producer) |
 |
Polar Bears of Arctic Alaska Starring: n/a Directed By: Arthur C. Smith III Also With: Arthur C. Smith III (Producer), Arthur C. Smith III & Jennifer Smith (van den Berg) (Writer) These are Alaskan polar bears. While Churchill and other locations have been a staple of traditional polar bear programming, this is the first film to document American polar bears in the Alaskan arctic. Polar Bears of Arctic Alaska is a cinematic family portrait of polar bears on the scenic Beaufort Sea coast. Without a word of narration, Alaskan filmmaker Arthur C. Smith III reveals fuzzy cubs as playful students, their sows tender teachers. A gentle musical score enhances the beauty of this endearing documentary of the wild and beautiful North American polar bear. Polar Bears of Arctic Alaska was filmed and produced from the Inupiaq Eskimo village of Kaktovik, which lies within the boundaries of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge on Alaska's Barter Island in the Arctic Ocean.... |
 |
Blue Moods Arctic Ocean Motivational White Wood-Mounted Art Poster Print - 20" X 16" by Adam Hersh Posters |
 |
Arctic Ocean Paradise Scene Kit by Buy Seasons |
 |
Source Naturals ArcticPure EFA Fish Oil 325mg, 120 softgels by Source Naturals Dietary supplement. Arctic Pure uses oil from fish caught in the cleanest and coldest body of water, the Arctic Ocean. A series of advanced distillation processes concentrates and extracts beneficial fatty acids, while guaranteeing the absence of heavy metals and PCB's. Natural flavors give our ArcticPure oils a taste that is pleasing to both children and adults. ArcticPure EFA combines omega-3 (fish oil) and omega-6 (borage oil) fatty acids. These fatty acids (EPA, DHA, and GLA) are important for proper cell signaling and membrane integrity. ArcticPure EFA is enhanced with advanced lipid-stabilizing antioxidants for extended freshness (These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any... |
 |
Decorated Mouse Pad with iceberg, ocean, sea, arctic, glacier, winter by SHOPZEUS Professional "Brite White" fabric mouse pads are among the most versatile and durable, providing brilliant graphic reproduction for spot color or full color imprints. This durable polyester surface is above industry standards and provides a superior product value overall. Designed to reproduce vibrant detailed images. Our mouse pads have white fabric top with the 100% genuine black rubber base (not the cheap foam your seen on other advertisements). |
 |
Gösta Nystroem: Arctic Ocean; Sinfonia Breve; Sinfonia Seria Gosta Nystroem (Composer), Jukka-Pekka Saraste (Composer), Peter Eros (Composer), Sixten Ehrling (Composer), Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra (Composer), Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra (Composer) |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |