 |
|
'Shortcuts' of the mind lead to miscalculations of weight and caloric intake, says Penn study
June 16, 2009PHILADELPHIA -- Psychologists at the University of Pennsylvania have identified a cognitive shortcut, or heuristic, they call "Unit Bias," which causes people to ignore vital, obvious information in their decision-making process, points to a fundamental flaw in the modern, evolved mind and may also play a role in the American population's 30 years of weight gain.
Researchers who focus on the cognitive aspects that contribute to obesity conducted several studies with college-age participants in which the subjects were asked to estimate the weight of adult women from either photographs or a live presentation by models. Other student participants were asked to estimate the calories in one of two actual meals. Both meals contained the same foods, but one had larger portion sizes than the other.
The results demonstrated that when estimating the body weight of women, participants apparently disregard or ignore the provided height information and focus solely on the width of the model. In certain instances, researchers would inflate the provided height information of the models as much as 10 inches, though that did not alter participants' estimates of the models' weights.
When estimating calories, study participants assumed portion sizes were culturally typical and guessed no caloric differences between small and large portions.
The findings are akin to asking a room full of people to calculate the volume of a box when given only the height and width and no one asks for the length. Or, more accurately, the length is provided and no one pays attention to that one, crucial dimension, thereby making it impossible to arrive at the correct answer.
The study suggests that there are situations where critical dimensions to understanding are devalued or ignored. The paper examines different circumstances discovered by researchers where single dimensions dominate multidimensional judgments. In these studies specifically, participants estimated body weight based on the model's shape even though height information was provided in the photographs or directly available with live models. Meanwhile, participants devalued or completely ignored other parameters critical to an accurate judgment.
Penn psychologists point to the study as a novel example of the negative artifacts packaged within the evolved way the human brain processes information. The mind has evolved to develop a capacity to free up our conscious thinking for dangerous and reproductive situations. For example, a driver at a green light doesn't need to cycle through a series of decisions. Green simply means go. The brain has evolved to remove common or repetitive situations or tasks from our awareness because the capacity of our consciousness is quite limited.
What ties these studies together is that missing information was literally thrust in the face of participants, and yet they didn't use it.
"We have heuristics in our brain - simple mechanistic shortcuts that have evolved over hundreds of thousands of years, which free up precious space in our consciousness," said Andrew Geier, lead author in the Department of Psychology in Penn's School of Arts and Sciences. "In these atypical instances, however, it's the shortcut that hurts us."
The researchers believe that the negative artifacts of the evolved mind may be directly connected with America's obesity epidemic.
"We have evolved in a very different environment," Geier said. "It used to be that food was scarce, and you ate what was available because you didn't know where your next meal would come from. That is not the case anymore. Although we have yet to prove this, we believe that the ecology of eating in the current food environment has become an example of the atypical situations demonstrated in this new article, which may be an explanation for why almost 70 percent of American adults are either overweight or obese. This represents a cognitive explanation for why America is gaining so much weight. The eating environment has morphed into an atypical scenario where our usually helpful mental mechanisms betray us."
University of Pennsylvania
When estimating calories, study participants assumed portion sizes were culturally typical and guessed no caloric differences between small and large portions.
The findings are akin to asking a room full of people to calculate the volume of a box when given only the height and width and no one asks for the length. Or, more accurately, the length is provided and no one pays attention to that one, crucial dimension, thereby making it impossible to arrive at the correct answer.
The study suggests that there are situations where critical dimensions to understanding are devalued or ignored. The paper examines different circumstances discovered by researchers where single dimensions dominate multidimensional judgments. In these studies specifically, participants estimated body weight based on the model's shape even though height information was provided in the photographs or directly available with live models. Meanwhile, participants devalued or completely ignored other parameters critical to an accurate judgment.
Penn psychologists point to the study as a novel example of the negative artifacts packaged within the evolved way the human brain processes information. The mind has evolved to develop a capacity to free up our conscious thinking for dangerous and reproductive situations. For example, a driver at a green light doesn't need to cycle through a series of decisions. Green simply means go. The brain has evolved to remove common or repetitive situations or tasks from our awareness because the capacity of our consciousness is quite limited.
What ties these studies together is that missing information was literally thrust in the face of participants, and yet they didn't use it.
"We have heuristics in our brain - simple mechanistic shortcuts that have evolved over hundreds of thousands of years, which free up precious space in our consciousness," said Andrew Geier, lead author in the Department of Psychology in Penn's School of Arts and Sciences. "In these atypical instances, however, it's the shortcut that hurts us."
The researchers believe that the negative artifacts of the evolved mind may be directly connected with America's obesity epidemic.
"We have evolved in a very different environment," Geier said. "It used to be that food was scarce, and you ate what was available because you didn't know where your next meal would come from. That is not the case anymore. Although we have yet to prove this, we believe that the ecology of eating in the current food environment has become an example of the atypical situations demonstrated in this new article, which may be an explanation for why almost 70 percent of American adults are either overweight or obese. This represents a cognitive explanation for why America is gaining so much weight. The eating environment has morphed into an atypical scenario where our usually helpful mental mechanisms betray us."
University of Pennsylvania
Weight Current Events and Weight News RSSPhysical education key to improving health in low-income adolescents
School-based physical education plays a key role in curbing obesity and improving fitness among adolescents from low-income communities, according to a new study led by researchers at the University of California, San Francisco and UC Berkeley.
Energy gap useful tool for successful weight loss maintenance strategy
Americans continue to get heavier. Most weight control methods short of bariatric surgery are generally considered ineffective in preventing obesity or reducing weight.
Tension on the grapevine
Predictions of grape yields are extremely important to juice processors and wineries; timely and precise yield forecasts allow producers to plan for harvest and move the highly perishable grape crop from vine to processing efficiently.
Health-centered weight control method shows promise
Most weight-control strategies emphasize energy-restricted diets and increased physical activity - and most are not effective over the long term.
New study further disputes notion that amputee runners gain advantage from protheses
A study by six researchers, including a University of Colorado at Boulder associate professor and his former doctoral student, shows that amputees who use running-specific prosthetic legs have no performance advantage over counterparts who use their biological legs.
American Dietetic Association Releases Updated Position Paper Promoting and Supporting Breastfeeding
The American Dietetic Association has released an updated position paper on breastfeeding that details health benefits for both infants and mothers and encourages promotion of breastfeeding whenever possible.
Addressing obesity via the 'energy gap'
The November issue of the Journal of the American Dietetic Association features a commentary by James O. Hill, an honorary ADA member, professor of pediatrics and medicine and director of the Center for Human Nutrition at the University of Colorado-Denver.
MSU researcher: Obesity significantly cuts odds of successful pregnancy
Obese women are as much as 28 percent less likely to become pregnant and have a successful pregnancy, according to research that earned a Michigan State University professor a national award.
Weight Training Boosts Breast Cancer Survivors' Body Image and Satisfaction with Intimate Relationships, Penn Study Shows
In addition to building muscle, weightlifting is also a prescription for self-esteem among breast cancer survivors, according to new University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine research.
Study: Lap band surgery effective for morbidly obese children
A surgeon at Children's National Medical Center and his colleagues from New York University have found laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding (Lap band) to improve the health of morbidly obese adolescents.
More Weight Current Events and Weight News Articles
 |
Valeo HW5 5-Pound Neoprene Hand Weights by Valeo Neoprene coated hand weights come complete with 2 weights and an exercise wall chart. The neoprene coating provides a comfortable non-slip grip. Weights help improve muscle tone and core strength and they enhance all aerobic exercise and fitness training. |
 |
Valeo AW10 10-Pound Adjustable Ankle / Wrist Weights by Valeo Valeo's 10 pound adjustable ankle/wrist weights have removable weight packs for adjustment from 2-10 pounds. Adjustable metal d-ring closure system allows weights to be worn on either ankles or wrists. Soft padding provides extra comfort. Double strap closure allows for a secure fit. Packaged in pairs. |
 |
Valeo HW10 10-Pound Neoprene Hand Weights by Valeo Neoprene coated hand weights come complete with 2 weights and an exercise wall chart. The neoprene coating provides a comfortable non-slip grip. Weights help improve muscle tone and core strength and they enhance all aerobic exercise and fitness training. |
 |
EatSmart Digital Bathroom Scale w/ Extra Large Backlit 3.5" Display and Oversize Platform by EatSmart Nutrition Scales The EatSmart Bathroom Scale is the ideal way to track your weight loss quickly and easily. Simply tap the scale and step on, and in seconds you'll have an accurate readout to the nearest .2 lbs on the EatSmart's oversized 3.5" LCD display. The LCD display also contains a cool-blue backlight, allowing for easy viewing even in the most low light areas of the bathroom or home.
The EatSmart Digital Bathroom Scale is also not only easy to use but also extremely accurate, engineered to the highest precision standards. The four high-gauge EatSmart precision sensors ensure that you will get an accurate measurement every time (just read our reviews!). Additionally the slim, tempered glass design fits perfectly into any surroundings and large non-slip platform safely allows weights to 330 lbs.... |
 |
Valeo HW3 3-Pound Neoprene Hand Weights by Valeo Neoprene coated hand weights come complete with 2 weights and an exercise wall chart. The neoprene coating provides a comfortable non-slip grip. Weights help improve muscle tone and core strength and they enhance all aerobic exercise and fitness training. |
 |
Valeo AW20 Adjustable Ankle / Wrist Weights (10-Pounds Each, 20-Pound Total) by Valeo Weights are padded for comfort with removable weight packs for adjustment from 4-20 lbs. Self-gripping closure for easy removal of weight packs and an adjustable metal D-ring double strap closure system. |
 |
Omron HBF-400 Body Fat Monitor and Scale by Omron measures body fat percentage, body mass index (BMI), and body weight, 4 person profile, easy on/off switch at base, large LCD display |
 |
Valeo HW8 8-Pound Neoprene Hand Weights by Valeo Neoprene coated hand weights come complete with 2 weights and an exercise wall chart. The neoprene coating provides a comfortable non-slip grip. Weights help improve muscle tone and core strength and they enhance all aerobic exercise and fitness training. |
 |
Valeo HW2 2-Pound Neoprene Hand Weights by Valeo Neoprene coated hand weights come complete with 2 weights and an exercise wall chart. The neoprene coating provides a comfortable non-slip grip. Weights help improve muscle tone and core strength and they enhance all aerobic exercise and fitness training. |
 |
Bowflex SelectTech 552 Dumbbells by Bowflex Dial up results! The power of 30 standard dumbbells is in these redesigned SelectTech Dumbbells by Bowflex. Each dumbbell adjusts from 5 to 52.5 lbs., allowing you to build strength, loose weight and feel great! Compact and durable. |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |