Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Calculate benefit before dialysis for frail elders

Calculate benefit before dialysis for frail elders

October 15, 2009

BOSTON - Kidney specialists should weigh the potential quality of life for frail elders with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) in opting for dialysis over more conservative therapies, a nephrologist and a palliative care specialist suggest in an editorial in the New England Journal of Medicine.

Acknowledging a lack of data from randomized trials evaluating the benefit of dialysis in the elderly, authors Mark L. Zeidel MD, and Robert M. Arnold MD, believe that "to care effectively for these persons, we must now learn much more - we must define who among this population will benefit most from dialysis and who will benefit most from conservative therapy."




Zeidel is a nephrologist, Chairman of the Department of Medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and a Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School. Arnold is the Director of the Palliative Care Service at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center and Dr. Leo H. Criep Chair in Patient Care and Professor of Medicine at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine.

The editorial accompanies a NEJM study on outcomes involving all nursing home residents in the United States who began to undergo dialysis between June 1998 and October 2000 and for whom predialysis status was available. The study found poor overall outcomes, in the first year after initiation of dialysis with 58 percent of residents dying and 29 percent having a decrease in functional status. Only 13 percent maintained functional status.

Dialysis provides artificial replacement of lost kidney function, passing a patient's blood through a machine that filters out impurities normally captured in the organ. The treatment can be lengthy and physically challenging for patients.

Conservative treatment, which does not involve dialysis, focus on medicines to decrease the symptoms of the kidney failure places less physical stress on patients and can result in a better quality of life, particularly for patients in ESRD. This care draws on knowledge in nephrology, geriatrics and palliative care.

Zeidel and Arnold note that small studies that examine the outcome of patients who elect conservative therapy over dialysis suggest that mortality and quality-of-life outcomes do not differ very much among selected patients who undergo dialysis and those who do not. They believe it is critical that larger studies be designed to determine the actual benefit of dialysis for frail elders.

In the meantime, "optimal care requires clear, informed conversations about the patient's goals, given his or her disease and the ability of various treatments to achieve these goals.

"Conservative therapy should be discussed, not as a last resort where there is 'nothing left to do' but as a clear option that might be most effective in promoting patient goals."

The authors also believe nephrologists need to become more aware of national guidelines on shared decision making regarding the initiation and withdrawal of dialysis, citing the fact that 30 percent of the patients older than 75 withdraw from dialysis indicate "the ability to counsel patients about potentially foregoing dialysis should be a core competency for nephrologists."

Arnold and Zeidel note than elderly patients with ESRD have multiple functional impairments, physical symptoms and a high rate of depression, facts that require an integrated, holistic approach to the care. There are also increased rates of frailty, cognitive dysfunction and geriatric syndromes such as falls and hospitalization involving elders undergoing dialysis.

Despite the fact that palliative care consultations for patients with cancer have shown decreases in symptoms and improved satisfaction, the authors note ESRD patients are less likely to receive comprehensive palliative care consultations. They recommend routine inclusion of palliative care specialists for these patients.

"In persons who will benefit, we must determine when we should initiate dialysis; this may differ substantially from initiation of dialysis in younger, healthier patients with ESRD," they note. "We must learn much more about how to ensure that we obtain truly informed consent from our patients, how to support them optimally in their therapeutic decisions and how to relieve their symptoms most effectively.

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center



Related Dialysis Current Events and Dialysis News Articles Dialysis Current Events and Dialysis News RSS Dialysis Current Events and Dialysis News RSS
Brain injured athletes may benefit from hypothermia research
NFL players and other athletes who suffer serious or multiple concussions may benefit from ground-breaking research being conducted by scientists at Barrow Neurological Institute at St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center. The scientists are developing a surgical technique that involves hypothermia in specific regions of the brain.

The cost of improving dialysis care
Improving survival among dialysis patients may increase treatment costs significantly, according to a paper being presented at the American Society of Nephrology's 42nd Annual Meeting and Scientific Exposition in San Diego, CA.

Women with chronic kidney disease more likely than men to go undiagnosed
Woman are at particular risk of their primary care physicians delaying diagnosis of chronic kidney disease (CKD), according to a paper being presented at the American Society of Nephrology's 42nd Annual Meeting and Scientific Exposition in San Diego, California.

For dialysis patients, skinny is dangerous
Dialysis patients with low body fat are at increased risk of death-even compared to patients at the highest level of body fat percentage, according to research being presented at the American Society of Nephrology's 42nd Annual Meeting and Scientific Exposition in San Diego.

Kidney transplants generally safe for lupus patients
Individuals with a history of lupus who receive a kidney transplant rarely develop the serious inflammatory condition lupus nephritis in their new organ, according to a paper being presented at the American Society of Nephrology's 42nd Annual Meeting and Scientific Exposition in San Diego, CA.

Muscle weakness a common side effect of long stays in intensive care units
After decades of focusing on the management of respiratory failure, circulatory shock and severe infections that lead to extended stays in hospital intensive care units, critical care researchers are increasingly turning attention to what they believe is a treatable complication developed by many who spend days or weeks confined to an ICU bed: debilitating muscle weakness that can linger long after hospital discharge.

Kidneys from deceased donors with acute renal failure expand donor pool
Kidneys recovered from deceased donors with acute renal failure (ARF) - once deemed unusable for transplant - appear to work just as well as kidneys transplanted from deceased donors who do not develop kidney problems prior to organ donation.

Few complications 1 year after aortic valve implantation
Research presented at the 21st annual Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics (TCT) scientific symposium, sponsored by the Cardiovascular Research Foundation (CRF), demonstrated an "exceptionally low" rate of complications one year after implantation of transcatheter aortic valve prostheses.

Link between depression, early stages of chronic kidney disease found by researchers
One in five patients with chronic kidney disease is depressed, even before beginning long-term dialysis therapy or developing end-stage renal disease, UT Southwestern Medical Center researchers have found.

Results from the Kyoto heart study
The KYOTO HEART Study, which took place in Japan between January 2004 and January 2009, shows that the addition of valsartan to conventional antihypertensive treatment to improve blood pressure control is associated with an improved cardiovascular outcome in Japanese hypertensive patients at high risk of CVD events.
More Dialysis Current Events and Dialysis News Articles
Dialysis without Fear: A Guide to Living Well on Dialysis for Patients and Their Families

Dialysis without Fear: A Guide to Living Well on Dialysis for Patients and Their Families
by Daniel Offer (Author), Susan Offer Szafir (Author), Marjorie Kaiz Offer (Author)

More than 400,000 people in the United States undergo kidney dialysis. If you or a member of your family are one of them, then the prospect of a regular appointment with a dialysis machine may seem like the end of life itself. But that reaction couldn't be more wrong.

In Dialysis Without Fear, psychiatrist and dialysis patient Dr. Daniel Offer joins with his wife, Marjorie Kaiz Offer, and daughter, Susan Offer Szafir, to reveal how life can be lived--and lived well--on dialysis. Drawing on his long medical career and more than seven years of personal experience with dialysis, Dr. Offer dispels many misconceptions surrounding this treatment, explaining how you can adapt to the new diet, travel, work and continue to partake in life's joys and celebrations. But the fears and...

Handbook of Dialysis

Handbook of Dialysis
by John T. Daugirdas (Editor), Peter G. Blake (Editor), Todd S. Ing (Editor)

The revised, updated Fourth Edition of this popular handbook provides practical, accessible information on all aspects of dialysis, with emphasis on day-to-day management of patients. Chapters provide complete coverage of hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, special problems in dialysis patients, and problems pertaining to various organ systems. This edition reflects the latest guidelines of the National Kidney Foundation's Kidney Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative (KDOQI) on hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis adequacy and on nutrition. New chapters cover chronic kidney disease management in predialysis patients, frequent daily or nocturnal hemodialysis, and hemodiafiltration. Chapters on venous and arteriovenous access have been completely revised. Each chapter provides references to...

Review of Hemodialysis for Nurses and Dialysis Personnel (Review of Hemodialysis for Nurses & Dialysis Personnel)

Review of Hemodialysis for Nurses and Dialysis Personnel (Review of Hemodialysis for Nurses & Dialysis Personnel)
by Judith Z. Kallenbach (Author), Charles Gutch (Author), Martha Stoner (Author), Anna Corea (Author)

This practical, straightforward introduction to dialysis takes an interdisciplinary approach, providing an overview of dialysis technology and the relationship of dialysis to nursing, nutrition, and medicine. Using its hallmark question-and-answer format, the content starts with the basics, including a review of fluids and electrolytes and the renal system, and prepares the reader for more advanced discussions as they are introduced. And with its lifespan coverage and useful quick reference content, it’s no wonder it’s considered the premier resource for educating health professionals on the essentials of dialysis and the related patient care. * Focuses on the roles of the multidisciplinary dialysis team, including the patient and the patient’s family, to provide a comprehensive...

Dialysis Membrane Tubing 10'

Dialysis Membrane Tubing 10'
by Nasco Scientific

Made of seamless, regenerated cellulose. An excellent membrane designed for laboratory dialysis and routine osmosis/diffusion experiments. Flat Width 1-3/4" 10' long

Principles and Practice of Dialysis (Principles & Practice of Dialysis)

Principles and Practice of Dialysis (Principles & Practice of Dialysis)
by William L Henrich (Author)

This book is an evidence-based review of the practical challenges of dealing with patients receiving dialysis. The first section covers technical and procedural considerations such as choosing the hemodialysis membrane and choosing the best dialysis option. The second section covers clinical considerations such as infection and the treatment of specific renal disease complications. The book includes numerous illustrations and tables and drug charts for dialysis patients. This edition's current outcomes chapter has been expanded to include patient depression and improving quality of care. New chapters cover dialysis in the ICU, valvular heart disease, and pre-emptive renal transplantation.

Nepro Liquid Nutrition, Homemade Vanilla, 8-Ounce Plastic Bottles (Pack of 24)

Nepro Liquid Nutrition, Homemade Vanilla, 8-Ounce Plastic Bottles (Pack of 24)
by Nepro

Nepro Liquid Nutrition in Homemade Vanilla is intended for people requiring electrolyte and fluid restrictions. This improved formula provides specialized complete, balanced nutrition, specifically designed to meet the dietary needs of people on dialysis. High in calories, moderate protein, low electrolytes, and with 1900 calories (1 quart), it provides at least 100-percent of the RDI for 18 key vitamins and minerals. It is a high calcium, low phosphorus, lactose free, supplement or sole source of nutrition, while being low in vitamins A and D, and high in folic acid and vitamin B6, because of the altered metabolism of people on dialysis. Ready to use. For adults and children 4 or more years of age.

That Damn Dialysis

That Damn Dialysis
by Cindy Barclay (Author)

Cledus is an attractive, hardworking, 50-year-old man with a sense of humor and whose world is turned upside down when he becomes one of 20.6 million Americans who are diagnosed with chronic kidney disease each year. His girlfriend leaves him, his mother tries to take over his life, and his financial security is severely compromised as his world shrinks down to monitoring the buzzing sound of his ""lifeline"" that confirms he is alive. Cledus’ story is told with compassion and humor that encompasses the uncertainty, fears, and frustration of day-to-day living while coping with this disease. Readers will share the journey with Cledus as he faces his challenges, and relates his frustration, his feelings of isolation and his courage as he deals with the life-sustaining confinement of a...

The Guide to Nutrition and diet for Dialysis Patients

The Guide to Nutrition and diet for Dialysis Patients
by M.D. R.H. (AHG) Shuang Chen (Author)

Specifically written for patients undergoing dialysis treatment, this guide provides important nutritional and dietary information to improve the patients' quality of life during dialysis and to prolong their lives. Presented in a concise, easy to read format, complete with food analyses and charts, The Guide To Nutrition and Diet for Dialysis Patients addresses thirty-eight of the most commonly asked questions on diet and nutrition, offering essential knowledge for dialysis patients and their families. This book also includes a series of lists for patients to use in identifying foods with high calcium, potassium, sodium and phosphorous contents. This guide is relevant for all people concerned with dietary consumption.

Manual of Clinical Dialysis

Manual of Clinical Dialysis
by Suhail Ahmad (Author)

This second edition of the Manual of Clinical Dialysis is a concise and well-illustrated guide to all aspects of dialysis. All chapters have been revised and present a complete overview of the techniques, processes and equipment involved in clinical dialysis as well as an overview of the complications of dialysis. The manual also provides an overview of common clinical problems related to renal failure such as hypertension, anemia and renal osteodystrophy.



Cooking for David: A Culinary Dialysis Cookbook

Cooking for David: A Culinary Dialysis Cookbook
by Sara Colman (Author), Dorothy Gordon (Author)

Cookbook facts: Published September 2000: the newest, most up-to-date dialysis cookbook available.

272 pages

12 chapters with dividers.

Top-quality padded, laminated linen spill proof cover.

3-Ring loose leaf binder that opens so you can add new upcoming recipes from our website.

Pre-planned daily menus for breakfast, lunch and dinner with nutrient totals and National Renal Diet Food Choice totals. Guidelines for food selection, preparation and portioning for the dialysis diet.

Renal Dialysis Food Pyramid pull-out included with every book.

A handy "E-Zel" cookbook stand included with every book.

160 tested recipes.

A complete nutrient analysis for each recipe includes: Sodium Potassium Phosphorus Protein Fat ...

© 2009 BrightSurf.com