 |
|
Benefit of memantine in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease not proven
October 29, 2009Not all data from studies carried out to date have been made available
There is no scientific proof that patients with moderate or severe Alzheimer's disease benefit from drugs containing the agent memantine. This is the conclusion in the final report that the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) published in September 2009.
The report is part of a broader commission awarded by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) to assess both drug and non-drug therapy options for Alzheimer's disease. In addition to memantine, IQWiG has investigated cholinesterase inhibitors, Ginkgo biloba and non-drug therapy alternatives.
Memantine is intended to regulate excess glutamate
Memantine is approved for moderate to severe Alzheimer's disease, but not for the mild stage of the disease. In Germany memantine is sold under the tradenames "Axura" (Merz) and "Ebixa" (Lundbeck).
Memantine is intended to prevent an excess of glutamate from damaging the brain. Glutamate is a neurotransmitter, in other words a substance that transmits neural signals. Animal experiments have shown that patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease might have a permanent excess of glutamate, which leads to neural cells dying. Memantine is intended to prevent this without affecting the normal transmission of neural signals.
The substance was developed several decades ago and prescribed for other diseases such as Parkinson's. Memantine has been used in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease since 2002.
Studies with nearly 2000 participants included in the assessment
The scientists searched for studies which investigated outcomes that were relevant to patients and their families: this includes cognitive function (e.g. memory capacity) and activities of daily living (e.g. personal hygiene) as well as mental concomitant symptoms (e.g. depression, agitation), quality of life and avoiding being put in a nursing home.
IQWiG was able to include in its assessment 7 studies, in which a total of 1913 patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease were treated with memantine over a period of 16 to 28 weeks. In 5 of these studies, the subjects received only memantine (monotherapy), in the remaining 2 the substance was administered as an add-on to an existing therapy with a cholinesterase inhibitor. Each study had a comparator control group, in which the patients took a placebo. Up till now, there have not been any usable studies comparing memantine with another dementia drug or with a non-drug therapy.
There are 2 other relevant manufacturer's studies, but they could not be included in the assessment as not all the necessary data were made available.
Only minimal differences in cognition and activities of daily living
Point scales were used in order to measure activities of daily living and cognitive function. The values were determined on each scale, for example, by giving the patients observation tests or asking the patients and their families about changes in the disease symptoms and how they managed with activities of daily living. However, not every change on such a scale means that the patient's disease stage actually improves or deteriorates. As the analysis of the study results shows, there are differences between the groups for these 2 outcomes, but these are minimal. Moreover, they are debatable due to the incompleteness of the data. It is therefore doubtful whether patients and their families can in fact see these differences as an advantage.
However, the manufacturer could also have provided evidence of benefit by means of a responder analysis. This investigates whether more patients in the memantine group notice a perceptible improvement in their symptoms than in the placebo group. However, the manufacturer did not provide a reliable responder analysis. Consequently, IQWiG did not find any overall proof of benefit from memantine in the activities of daily living and in cognitive function.
No reliable data on quality of life and necessity of inpatient care
The included studies did not provide reliable information on all outcomes. There are no data on the health-related quality of life of patients because they were not collected in the studies. However, there have been very few suitable instruments for displaying quality of life with this disease.
Although some studies did record whether patients had to be institutionalized, the results are not reliable. Consequently, it remains unclear whether memantine has an influence on how long persons with dementia can be cared for at home.
Data on concomitant symptoms do not reveal any differences
Information on concomitant psychopathological symptoms, such as depression, sleep disorders or severe agitation, was collected and reported. However, the studies do not document any difference between those patients treated with memantine and those given a placebo.
Nor did the scientists find a difference with regard to mortality. However, there is not much information on this as the studies were not designed to address this research question.
Memantine does not have any noticeable drug risks
Participants in the memantine group did not withdraw from the trial on account of adverse effects any more frequently than those in the placebo group. Nor was there any difference in the number of patients with (severe) adverse effects. Thus, there were no noticeable drug risks associated with memantine. However, the longest study only ran for 28 weeks, so it is not possible to draw conclusions on long-term effects. In addition, the number of subjects was altogether too low for potential rare side effects to be recorded.
Other family members do not appear to benefit either
IQWiG did not only consider the patients but also their families. However, the study results did not provide any proof that taking memantine reduces their burden, for instance, by lessening the amount of care required or the emotional burden. None of the included studies defined quality of life of the family caregivers as an outcome. The amount of care required was collected in most of the studies, but the majority of the data was not made available by the manufacturers. Consequently, the present results cannot be reliably interpreted.
Final report takes account of additional, previously unpublished data
IQWiG and its external experts had considerably more data available for the final report than for the preliminary report, in which only 4 studies with a total of 1263 patients could be included. In the course of the submission of comments procedure, the manufacturers submitted previously unpublished study analyses. For the final report, Merz provided subgroup analyses of participants with moderate and severe Alzheimer's disease because in some studies memantine had also been given to patients with mild severity, which was not in compliance with approval when viewed from today's perspective.
Nevertheless, the data pool for the final report is still incomplete. Relevant information is still lacking on 2 more clinical trials with a total of 580 participants. In contrast to the preliminary report, IQWiG has not placed a caveat on the final report because the small amount of information published on these 2 studies, including that disseminated at conferences, suggests that the minimal effects on cognition and activities of daily living would be even less if the missing data were included. There would be no change to the overall result - the lack of proof of benefit.
More research is needed
According to the scientists, the study pool for memantine is still insufficient overall. There is a lack of studies of longer duration that enable the long-term effects of therapy with memantine to be estimated. There is also a lack of research on patients living in nursing homes who suffer from the concomitant diseases typical in this age group. It cannot be excluded that memantine has a better effect in some patient groups.
"As long as it is not proven that therapies give patients or caregivers a perceptible advantage, it is very difficult to justify continuing to prescribe them when their costs are carried by the general public," comments Peter Sawicki, Director of IQWiG. "The number of elderly people is growing and so are the medical and social problems associated with Alzheimer's disease. I don't think that we will find a simple solution to this problem in the near future. That's why it is important at this stage to provide better social and medical care to patients and to relieve the burden for family caregivers. And it is surely better to 'invest' in this rather than in drugs, where we don't know whether they actually provide a benefit."
Report preparation procedure
IQWiG published the preliminary results in the form of the preliminary report in August 2008 and interested parties were invited to submit comments. When the comments stage ended, the preliminary report was revised and sent as a final report to the contracting agency, the Federal Joint Committee, in July 2009. Documentation of the written comments and minutes of the oral debate are published in a separate document simultaneously with the final report. The report was produced in collaboration with external experts.
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care
Memantine is intended to regulate excess glutamate
Memantine is approved for moderate to severe Alzheimer's disease, but not for the mild stage of the disease. In Germany memantine is sold under the tradenames "Axura" (Merz) and "Ebixa" (Lundbeck).
Memantine is intended to prevent an excess of glutamate from damaging the brain. Glutamate is a neurotransmitter, in other words a substance that transmits neural signals. Animal experiments have shown that patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease might have a permanent excess of glutamate, which leads to neural cells dying. Memantine is intended to prevent this without affecting the normal transmission of neural signals.
The substance was developed several decades ago and prescribed for other diseases such as Parkinson's. Memantine has been used in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease since 2002.
Studies with nearly 2000 participants included in the assessment
The scientists searched for studies which investigated outcomes that were relevant to patients and their families: this includes cognitive function (e.g. memory capacity) and activities of daily living (e.g. personal hygiene) as well as mental concomitant symptoms (e.g. depression, agitation), quality of life and avoiding being put in a nursing home.
IQWiG was able to include in its assessment 7 studies, in which a total of 1913 patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease were treated with memantine over a period of 16 to 28 weeks. In 5 of these studies, the subjects received only memantine (monotherapy), in the remaining 2 the substance was administered as an add-on to an existing therapy with a cholinesterase inhibitor. Each study had a comparator control group, in which the patients took a placebo. Up till now, there have not been any usable studies comparing memantine with another dementia drug or with a non-drug therapy.
There are 2 other relevant manufacturer's studies, but they could not be included in the assessment as not all the necessary data were made available.
Only minimal differences in cognition and activities of daily living
Point scales were used in order to measure activities of daily living and cognitive function. The values were determined on each scale, for example, by giving the patients observation tests or asking the patients and their families about changes in the disease symptoms and how they managed with activities of daily living. However, not every change on such a scale means that the patient's disease stage actually improves or deteriorates. As the analysis of the study results shows, there are differences between the groups for these 2 outcomes, but these are minimal. Moreover, they are debatable due to the incompleteness of the data. It is therefore doubtful whether patients and their families can in fact see these differences as an advantage.
However, the manufacturer could also have provided evidence of benefit by means of a responder analysis. This investigates whether more patients in the memantine group notice a perceptible improvement in their symptoms than in the placebo group. However, the manufacturer did not provide a reliable responder analysis. Consequently, IQWiG did not find any overall proof of benefit from memantine in the activities of daily living and in cognitive function.
No reliable data on quality of life and necessity of inpatient care
The included studies did not provide reliable information on all outcomes. There are no data on the health-related quality of life of patients because they were not collected in the studies. However, there have been very few suitable instruments for displaying quality of life with this disease.
Although some studies did record whether patients had to be institutionalized, the results are not reliable. Consequently, it remains unclear whether memantine has an influence on how long persons with dementia can be cared for at home.
Data on concomitant symptoms do not reveal any differences
Information on concomitant psychopathological symptoms, such as depression, sleep disorders or severe agitation, was collected and reported. However, the studies do not document any difference between those patients treated with memantine and those given a placebo.
Nor did the scientists find a difference with regard to mortality. However, there is not much information on this as the studies were not designed to address this research question.
Memantine does not have any noticeable drug risks
Participants in the memantine group did not withdraw from the trial on account of adverse effects any more frequently than those in the placebo group. Nor was there any difference in the number of patients with (severe) adverse effects. Thus, there were no noticeable drug risks associated with memantine. However, the longest study only ran for 28 weeks, so it is not possible to draw conclusions on long-term effects. In addition, the number of subjects was altogether too low for potential rare side effects to be recorded.
Other family members do not appear to benefit either
IQWiG did not only consider the patients but also their families. However, the study results did not provide any proof that taking memantine reduces their burden, for instance, by lessening the amount of care required or the emotional burden. None of the included studies defined quality of life of the family caregivers as an outcome. The amount of care required was collected in most of the studies, but the majority of the data was not made available by the manufacturers. Consequently, the present results cannot be reliably interpreted.
Final report takes account of additional, previously unpublished data
IQWiG and its external experts had considerably more data available for the final report than for the preliminary report, in which only 4 studies with a total of 1263 patients could be included. In the course of the submission of comments procedure, the manufacturers submitted previously unpublished study analyses. For the final report, Merz provided subgroup analyses of participants with moderate and severe Alzheimer's disease because in some studies memantine had also been given to patients with mild severity, which was not in compliance with approval when viewed from today's perspective.
Nevertheless, the data pool for the final report is still incomplete. Relevant information is still lacking on 2 more clinical trials with a total of 580 participants. In contrast to the preliminary report, IQWiG has not placed a caveat on the final report because the small amount of information published on these 2 studies, including that disseminated at conferences, suggests that the minimal effects on cognition and activities of daily living would be even less if the missing data were included. There would be no change to the overall result - the lack of proof of benefit.
More research is needed
According to the scientists, the study pool for memantine is still insufficient overall. There is a lack of studies of longer duration that enable the long-term effects of therapy with memantine to be estimated. There is also a lack of research on patients living in nursing homes who suffer from the concomitant diseases typical in this age group. It cannot be excluded that memantine has a better effect in some patient groups.
"As long as it is not proven that therapies give patients or caregivers a perceptible advantage, it is very difficult to justify continuing to prescribe them when their costs are carried by the general public," comments Peter Sawicki, Director of IQWiG. "The number of elderly people is growing and so are the medical and social problems associated with Alzheimer's disease. I don't think that we will find a simple solution to this problem in the near future. That's why it is important at this stage to provide better social and medical care to patients and to relieve the burden for family caregivers. And it is surely better to 'invest' in this rather than in drugs, where we don't know whether they actually provide a benefit."
Report preparation procedure
IQWiG published the preliminary results in the form of the preliminary report in August 2008 and interested parties were invited to submit comments. When the comments stage ended, the preliminary report was revised and sent as a final report to the contracting agency, the Federal Joint Committee, in July 2009. Documentation of the written comments and minutes of the oral debate are published in a separate document simultaneously with the final report. The report was produced in collaboration with external experts.
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care
Memantine Current Events and Memantine News RSSResearchers find potential treatment for Huntington's disease
Investigators at Burnham Institute for Medical Research (Burnham), the University of British Columbia's Centre for Molecular Medicine and Therapeutics and the University of California, San Diego have found that normal synaptic activity in nerve cells (the electrical activity in the brain that allows nerve cells to communicate with one another) protects the brain from the misfolded proteins associated with Huntington's disease.
CSHL team solves structure of NMDA receptor unit that could be drug target for neurological diseases
A team of scientists at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) reports on Thursday their success in solving the molecular structure of a key portion of a cellular receptor implicated in Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, and other serious illnesses.
Preventative brain radiation for lung cancer patients: Benefits and risks
A new study is taking a closer look at the benefits versus risks for lung cancer patients to undergo preventative brain radiation therapy as a means to stop cancer from spreading to the brain.
Phase 3 Alzheimer's drug increases toxic beta amyloid in the brain -- but still provides benefits
New insights into how a Phase III Alzheimer's drug might work were among the advances in potential therapies targeting two abnormal brain proteins - beta amyloid and phosphorylated tau - that were reported today at the Alzheimer's Association 2009 International Conference on Alzheimer's Disease (ICAD 2009) in Vienna.
Migraine prevention by targeting glutamate receptors?
When migraine strikes, because of severe pain, often accompanied by nausea and sensitivity to light and sound, sufferers are effectively disabled for up to 72 hours.
Study confirms benefit of combination therapy for Alzheimer's disease
Extended treatment with Alzheimer's disease drugs can significantly slow the rate at which the disorder advances, and combination therapy with two different classes of drugs is even better at helping patients maintain their ability to perform daily activities.
Halting retrieval of drug-associated memories may prevent addiction relapse
Disrupting the brain's retrieval of drug-associated memories may prevent relapse in drug addiction, according to new research in the August 13 issue of The Journal of Neuroscience.
Memantine and Alzheimer's disease
In a study published this month in the Journal of Alzheimer's Disease, researchers from the University of Aberdeen report that the drug memantine, used for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease and praised as "the first and only representative of a new class of Alzheimer drugs" works in fact similar to other existing compounds, and is beneficial only in a narrow concentration range.
Test reveals effectiveness of potential Huntington's disease drugs
A test using cultured cells provides an effective way to screen drugs against Huntington's disease and shows that two compounds-memantine and riluzole - are most effective at keeping cells alive under conditions that mimic the disorder, UT Southwestern Medical Center researchers report.
Hope remains for Alzheimer's sufferers
The National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE), who last week rejected appeals to allow patients with mild Alzheimer's to receive the life-changing medication donepezil (Aricept®), will hopefully re-appraise their decision in three-years time.
More Memantine Current Events and Memantine News Articles
|
Memantine also effective in mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease.(Geriatric Psychiatry): An article from: Clinical Psychiatry News by Bruce Jancin (Author) This digital document is an article from Clinical Psychiatry News, published by International Medical News Group on July 1, 2004. The length of the article is 465 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine also effective in mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease.(Geriatric Psychiatry) Author: Bruce Jancin Publication: Clinical Psychiatry News (Magazine/Journal) Date: July 1, 2004 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 32 Issue: 7 Page: 41(1) Distributed by Thomson... | |
 |
Memory Lane Family Also With: Sponsored by Namenda Memantine HCI (Primary Contributor) |
 |
The NewsHour Reports on Alzheimer's Disease Starring: Charlayne Hunter-Gault, Jim Lehrer, Susan Dentzer, Steven DeKosky, Ray Suarez Also With: MacNeil / Lehrer Productions (Producer) According to the Alzheimer's Association, as many as eight million Americans will be suffering from Alzheimer's by 2030 and 16 million by 2050. The NewsHour reports on treatments, vaccine development, research, the impact on caregivers and the growing incidence of early-onset Alzheimer's disease. This product is manufactured on demand using DVD-R recordable media. Amazon.com's standard return policy will apply. |
|
FDA panel approves memantine for moderate to severe Alzheimer's: NMDA receptor antagonist.(Rx): An article from: Internal Medicine News by Elizabeth Mechcatie (Author) This digital document is an article from Internal Medicine News, published by International Medical News Group on November 1, 2003. The length of the article is 578 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: FDA panel approves memantine for moderate to severe Alzheimer's: NMDA receptor antagonist.(Rx) Author: Elizabeth Mechcatie Publication: Internal Medicine News (Magazine/Journal) Date: November 1, 2003 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 36 Issue: 21 Page: 27(1) Distributed by Thomson... | |
|
Memantine may reduce agitation in AD patients: the investigators were surprised by the magnitude and consistency of the drug's effect on behavior.(Geriatrics)(Alzheimer's ... An article from: Internal Medicine News by Doug Brunk (Author) This digital document is an article from Internal Medicine News, published by International Medical News Group on April 1, 2005. The length of the article is 449 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine may reduce agitation in AD patients: the investigators were surprised by the magnitude and consistency of the drug's effect on behavior.(Geriatrics)(Alzheimer's disease) Author: Doug Brunk Publication: Internal Medicine News (Magazine/Journal) Date: April 1, 2005 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 38 Issue: 7 Page:... | |
|
U.S. approval sought for memantine to slow severe cognitive decline. (New Class of Drugs).: An article from: Internal Medicine News by Miriam E. Tucker (Author) This digital document is an article from Internal Medicine News, published by International Medical News Group on September 15, 2002. The length of the article is 709 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: U.S. approval sought for memantine to slow severe cognitive decline. (New Class of Drugs). Author: Miriam E. Tucker Publication: Internal Medicine News (Magazine/Journal) Date: September 15, 2002 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 35 Issue: 18 Page: 5(1) Distributed by Thomson... | |
|
Memantine improved cognition in Alzheimer's.(Geriatrics): An article from: Internal Medicine News by Robert Finn (Author) This digital document is an article from Internal Medicine News, published by International Medical News Group on August 1, 2004. The length of the article is 645 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine improved cognition in Alzheimer's.(Geriatrics) Author: Robert Finn Publication: Internal Medicine News (Magazine/Journal) Date: August 1, 2004 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 37 Issue: 15 Page: 22(1) Distributed by Thomson... | |
|
Memantine can cut Alzheimer's-related costs. (FDA Approval Expected by Year-End).: An article from: Clinical Psychiatry News by Norra MacReady (Author) This digital document is an article from Clinical Psychiatry News, published by International Medical News Group on May 1, 2003. The length of the article is 553 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine can cut Alzheimer's-related costs. (FDA Approval Expected by Year-End). Author: Norra MacReady Publication: Clinical Psychiatry News (Magazine/Journal) Date: May 1, 2003 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 31 Issue: 5 Page: 30(1) Distributed by Thomson... | |
|
Memantine may reduce agitation in AD patients: patients taking the drug showed improvements on the Neuropsychiatric Inventory agitation domain.(Geriatric ... An article from: Clinical Psychiatry News by Doug Brunk (Author) This digital document is an article from Clinical Psychiatry News, published by International Medical News Group on April 1, 2005. The length of the article is 489 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine may reduce agitation in AD patients: patients taking the drug showed improvements on the Neuropsychiatric Inventory agitation domain.(Geriatric Psychiatry)(Alzheimer's disease) Author: Doug Brunk Publication: Clinical Psychiatry News (Magazine/Journal) Date: April 1, 2005 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 33 Issue: 4 Page:... | |
|
Memantine also effective in mild to moderate Alzheimer's.(Geriatric Medicine): An article from: Family Practice News by Bruce Jancin (Author) This digital document is an article from Family Practice News, published by International Medical News Group on December 1, 2004. The length of the article is 440 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser. Citation Details Title: Memantine also effective in mild to moderate Alzheimer's.(Geriatric Medicine) Author: Bruce Jancin Publication: Family Practice News (Magazine/Journal) Date: December 1, 2004 Publisher: International Medical News Group Volume: 34 Issue: 23 Page: 54(1) Distributed by Thomson... |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |