 |
|
Chart junk? How pictures may help make graphs better
November 05, 2009Those oft-maligned, and highly embellished, graphs and charts in USA Today and other media outlets may actually help people understand data more effectively than traditional graphs, according to new research from North Carolina State University.
Newspapers and magazines often embellish charts or graphs to draw attention to them or to highlight information. Some experts describe these graphic embellishments as "chart junk," which they argue detracts from a graph or chart's effectiveness. So, can those graphics be too distracting, making it more difficult or time-consuming to read a graph accurately?
Researchers from NC State and the University of Idaho show that the answer is yes, and no.
When people look at charts or graphs, two things happen. In the first stage, a person quickly (and unconsciously) takes in all the elements of the image at the same time. In this stage any contrasting features "pop out" at the viewer, explains Dr. Doug Gillan, co-author of the study and professor and head of psychology at NC State. In the second stage, which is slower and requires some focused attention, the viewer examines each component of the graph or chart separately.
"Imagine a bar graph showing the number of ACC championships won by each school's basketball team," Gillan says. "In the second stage the viewer is examining each bar in the graph to see which team has won the most championships."
To determine whether design elements - such as background pictures - affect a viewer's ability to read a graph, the researchers ran an experiment using rectangular bar graphs. They tested how accurately people could read the bar graph when it was presented against three different backgrounds: a blank background, a background filled with rectangles, and a background filled with circles.
The researchers found that people were most accurate when reading the bar graph against a background filled with circles - the contrast between the rectangular bars and the circles made the graph pop out during that first stage. People performed worse when the background was blank, and worst when the bar graph was displayed against a background that contained rectangular shapes.
In other words, background images can actually enhance one's ability to read a chart or graph - as long as the images contrast with the chart or graph itself. If the background image is too similar, it can actually make it more difficult to read the chart or graph accurately.
Are you listening, USA Today?
North Carolina State University
When people look at charts or graphs, two things happen. In the first stage, a person quickly (and unconsciously) takes in all the elements of the image at the same time. In this stage any contrasting features "pop out" at the viewer, explains Dr. Doug Gillan, co-author of the study and professor and head of psychology at NC State. In the second stage, which is slower and requires some focused attention, the viewer examines each component of the graph or chart separately.
"Imagine a bar graph showing the number of ACC championships won by each school's basketball team," Gillan says. "In the second stage the viewer is examining each bar in the graph to see which team has won the most championships."
To determine whether design elements - such as background pictures - affect a viewer's ability to read a graph, the researchers ran an experiment using rectangular bar graphs. They tested how accurately people could read the bar graph when it was presented against three different backgrounds: a blank background, a background filled with rectangles, and a background filled with circles.
The researchers found that people were most accurate when reading the bar graph against a background filled with circles - the contrast between the rectangular bars and the circles made the graph pop out during that first stage. People performed worse when the background was blank, and worst when the bar graph was displayed against a background that contained rectangular shapes.
In other words, background images can actually enhance one's ability to read a chart or graph - as long as the images contrast with the chart or graph itself. If the background image is too similar, it can actually make it more difficult to read the chart or graph accurately.
Are you listening, USA Today?
North Carolina State University
Graphs Current Events and Graphs News RSSNew tools for sustainable farming
Environmentalists are just as fond of talking about it as are politicians, economists or marketing experts - "sustainability" has become a buzzword.
Students least informed about environmental science are most optimistic
Will problems associated with environmental issues improve in the next two decades? According to an analysis of student performance on PISA 2006--an international assessment of 15-year-olds--students who are the best informed about environmental science and the geosciences are also the most realistic about the environmental challenges facing the world in the next 20 years.
People's misperceptions cloud their understanding of rainy weather forecasts
If Mark Twain were alive today he might rephrase his frequently cited observation about everyone talking about the weather but not doing anything about it to say, "Everyone reads or watches weather forecasts, but many people don't understand them."
Wristbands ease nausea with cancer treatment
Cancer patients who wore acupressure wristbands had much less nausea while receiving radiation treatment, making the bands a safe, low-cost addition to anti-nausea medication.
Case Western Reserve professor helps control infectious diseases with models and math
Can an algebraic equation hold the secret to eradicating malaria or schistosomiasis? A Case Western Reserve University mathematics professor is utilizing the combination of algorithms and models in an effort to assist his medical colleagues in the fight against infectious diseases.
Dream of quantum computing closer to reality as mathematicians chase key breakthrough
The ability to exploit the extraordinary properties of quantum mechanics in novel applications, such as a new generation of super-fast computers, has come closer following recent progress with some of the remaining underlying mathematical problems.
Pinning down the fleeting Internet: Web crawler archives historical data for easy searching
The Internet contains vast amounts of information, much of it unorganized. But what you see online at any given moment is just a snapshot of the Web as a whole -- many pages change rapidly or disappear completely, and the old data gets lost forever.
DOE/Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Latin American nations could become important suppliers of ethanol for world markets in coming decades, according to an Oak Ridge National Laboratory study released recently.
A crystal that nature may have missed
For centuries, human beings have been entranced by the captivating glimmer of the diamond. What accounts for the stunning beauty of this most precious gem? As mathematician Toshikazu Sunada explains in an article appearing today in the Notices of the American Mathematical Society, some secrets of the diamond's beauty can be uncovered by a mathematical analysis of its microscopic crystal structure.
New smartpen and paper to help teach blind college students
Subjects like physics, calculus and biology are challenging for most students, but imagine tackling these topics without being able to see the graphs and figures used to teach them. A new smartpen and paper technology that works with touch and records classroom audio aims to bring these subjects to life for blind students.
More Graphs Current Events and Graphs News Articles
 |
Graphs (All Aboard Math Reader) by Bonnie Bader (Author), Mernie Gallagher Cole (Illustrator) Gary Graff doesn't want to go to his family's boring reunion, but when he surveys his family members to finish his math homework-a graphing assignment-Gary learns a lot about graphing and his family-and has a lot of fun, too! Illustrated by Mernie Gallagher Cole |
 |
The Great Graph Contest by Loreen Leedy (Author) Two comical creatures go crazy with graphs in an imaginative look at organizing information. Young readers can learn about bar graphs, pie charts, Venn diagrams, and more. |
 |
Introductory Graph Theory by Gary Chartrand (Author) Clear, lively style covers all basics of theory and application, including Mathematical Models, Elementary Concepts of Graph Theory, Transportation Problems, Connection Problems, Party Problems, Diagraphs and Mathematical Models, Games and Puzzles, Graphs and Social Psychology, Planar Graphs and Coloring Problems, and Graphs and Other Mathematics. |
 |
Scholastic Success With Charts, Tables, and Graphs: Grades 5-6 by Michael Priestley (Author) Prepares kids for standardized tests! Give your students the practice they need to read and interpret bar graphs, line graphs, tables, charts, pictographs, time lines, and more with these fun, ready-to-reproduce activity pages. This time-saving resource is organized by subject area so you can find the perfect page for your math, reading/language arts, social studies, and science lesson. A great way to provide your students with the independent practice they need to understand the charts, graph, and charts they encounter in the real-world--and on standardized tests. |
 |
Show Me the Numbers: Designing Tables and Graphs to Enlighten by Stephen Few (Author) Tables and graphs can more adequately communicate important business information when they reflect the good design practices discussed in this practical guide to effective table and graph design. Information is provided on the fundamental concepts of table and graph design, the numbers and knowledge most suitable for display in a graphic form, the best tabular means to communicate certain ideas, and the component-level aspects of design. Analysts, technicians, and managers will appreciate the solid theory behind this outline for ensuring that tables and graphs present quantitative business information in a truthful, attractive format that facilitates better decision making. |
 |
GRAPHING SLOPE & LINEAR EQUATIONS by MCDONALD PUBLISHING These informative posters help teach students about coordinate planes, equations of lines, slope, and methods for graphing linear equations. Package includes 4 posters, 4 reproducible activity sheets, and a teacher's guide. |
 |
Pentel Graph Gear 1000 Automatic Drafting Pencil, 0.5mm Lead Size, Black Barrel, 1 Each (PG1015A) by Pentel Finely chiseled metallic grip inlaid with soft latex-free pads. Dual-function pocket clip releases heavy spring mechanism to retract tip. Sophisticated brushed metal barrel. Writes crisp, .5mm fine lines of consistent density. Refillable with Pentel Super Hi-Polymer Lead and Z2-1 refill eraser. |
 |
Creating More Effective Graphs by Naomi B. Robbins (Author) A succinct and highly readable guide to creating effective graphs The right graph can be a powerful tool for communicating information, improving a presentation, or conveying your point in print. If your professional endeavors call for you to present data graphically, here's a book that can help you do it more effectively. Creating More Effective Graphs gives you the basic knowledge and techniques required to choose and create appropriate graphs for a broad range of applications. Using real-world examples everyone can relate to, the author draws on her years of experience in graphical data analysis and presentation to highlight some of today's most effective methods. In clear, concise language, the author answers such common questions as: What constitutes an... |
 |
Gotta Have Graphs Grades 1-6 by Denine Carter (Author) Create meaningful math experiences with fun, easy-to-implement graphing activities! Covering 13 different types of graphs including object graphs, picture graphs, bar graphs, glyphs, and more, each unit provides step-by-step instructions for introducing the activity as well as for collecting, displaying, analyzing, and discussing the data. Grades 1-6. Activities in each unit Use practical and easy-to-obtain data Are arranged in order of difficulty for easy planning Offer extension ideas |
 |
Casio Men's Moon Phase Tide Graph Sport Watch #W753D-1AV by Casio Featuring an innovative moon phase display, the Casio Men's Sport Moon Phase Tide Graph Watch #W753D-1AV keeps you in touch with Mother Nature. The digital-gray dial face is protected by a durable mineral dial window. Embellishing the dial are an easy-to-read time display, a day-date-and-month calendar, and other high-tech details including a countdown timer, a stopwatch, and an hourly time signal. Its sleek look is achieved with a silver-tone, stainless steel band, equipped with a sturdy fold-over-clasp, and other a matching 42-millimeter stainless steel case and stationary silver-tone stainless steel bezel. Presenting a sporty design, this functional timepiece encourages your celestial fascinations. Powered by quartz movement, this watch is also water resistant to 330 feet. |
| © 2009 BrightSurf.com |