Email a Friend
Printer Friendly
Slashdot It!
Submit to Reddit
Add to Facebook

Using magnetic toys as inspiration, researchers tease out structures of self-assembled clusters

January 29, 2010

Cambridge, MA - Scientists have long studied how atoms and molecules structure themselves into intricate clusters. Unlocking the design secrets of Nature offers lessons in engineering artificial systems that could self-assemble into any desired form.

In the January 29th issue of Science, a team from Harvard led by Vinothan Manoharan and Michael Brenner, presents additional clues to how and why groups of atoms and molecules may favor less symmetrical and more complex, flexible geometric patterns.

The answer relates to a familiar concept in physics-entropy. The researchers literally first caught sight of the link by using magnetic "stick and ball" construction toys.

Manoharan, Associate Professor of Chemical Engineering and Physics in Harvard's School of Engineering and Applied Science (SEAS) and Department of Physics, and his colleagues used colloidal particles, a suspended chemical mixture seen in semi-solid foods like mayonnaise, to simulate the clustering behavior of atoms and molecules.

"To allow clusters to form, we put a few tiny polystyrene spheres in microscopic cylindrical wells filled with water. The particles act as 'sticky' hard spheres and naturally cluster together just like groups of nearby interacting atoms and molecules do," says Manoharan.

The researchers expected that simple, highly symmetric shapes would arise most often. Instead, two surprising, related, and scalable phenomena arose when the number of particles used in their experiments reached six or rose above nine.

Six particles can form into a symmetrical octahedron and into a more complex tri-tetrahedron shape. In terms of chemical structure, each shape results in 12 bonds, and hence, has the same amount of potential energy.

With the potential energy being equal, Manoharan and colleagues thought that both shapes would occur in equal proportion. They found, however, that the tri-tetrahedron occurs 20 times more often than the octahedron.

"The only possible explanation was entropy," says Manoharan. "Most people are familiar with entropy as a measure of 'disorder', but the most useful definition of entropy is simply the number of different ways a bunch of particles can arrange themselves."

Natalie Arkus, a former applied mathematics graduate student who worked with Brenner, Glover Professor of Applied Mathematics and Applied Physics, provided a hint to solving the puzzle, as she discovered a method to calculate all the possible structures that could be formed using geometric magnetic toys (composed of magnetic metal rods and silver ball bearings).

As there are more ways for the complicated tri-tetrahedron structure to form (something that can be directly seen by labeling the toy spheres and counting the ways they can be put together) the shape appears far more frequently than the octahedron. In general, among clusters with the same potential energy, highly symmetric structures are less likely to arise.

The researchers also found that when the number of particles reaches nine or higher, entropy plays another important role.

Because the number of possible structures with nine or more particles is vast, the team focused on what are called non-rigid, or flexible structures. Non-rigidity occurs when a cluster has half-octahedra that share at least one vertex, allowing the cluster to twist without breaking or forming another bond (something also easily seen with the toys).

"Because they can move flexibly, the non-rigid clusters have high vibrational entropy," explains Manohran. "In cases with nine or more particles, symmetric clusters do not appear as often due to rotational entropy. The ability to rotate is useful, as it allows clusters to have extra bonds."

As a general rule, the team found that for all clusters up to 8 particles and a select number of structures with up to 12, the most symmetric structures occurred the least often due to entropy.

"Our findings illustrate, in a tangible way, what the concept of entropy means," says Manohran.

Looking ahead, the researchers are interested in using their results to understand the emergence of bulk crystallization, or how particles come together in the early stages of forming a crystal.

###

Manoharan and Brenner's co-authors included Guangnan Meng, a research associate in the Department of Physics at Harvard University, and Natalie Arkus, a graduate of SEAS and now a postdoctoral fellow at The Rockefeller University. The authors acknowledge support from the National Science Foundation and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency.

Harvard University

Related Atoms Molecules Current Events and Atoms Molecules News Articles

First Results from the LCLS: Unpeeling Atoms and Molecules from the Inside Out
The first published scientific results from the world's most powerful hard X-ray laser, located at the Department of Energy's SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, show its unique ability to control the behaviors of individual electrons within simple atoms and molecules by stripping them away, one by one-in some cases creating hollow atoms.

Ultrashort light pulse blazes new paths for science, industry
Researchers in Italy have created an ultrashort light pulse-a single isolated burst of extreme-ultraviolet light that lasts for only 130 attoseconds (billionths of a billionth of a second).

New method edges closer to holy grail of modern chemistry
University of Chicago chemist David Mazziotti has developed a new method for determining the behavior of electrons in atoms and molecules, a key ingredient in predicting chemical properties and reactions.

'Frequency comb' spectroscopy proves to be powerful chemical analysis tool
Physicists at JILA have designed and demonstrated a highly sensitive new tool for real-time analysis of the quantity, structure and dynamics of a variety of atoms and molecules simultaneously, even in minuscule gas samples.

More Atoms Molecules Current Events and Atoms Molecules News Articles

	Adventures With Atoms and Molecules: Chemistry Experiments for Young People (Adventures With Science) by Robert C. Mebane (Author), Thomas R. Rybolt (Author) Chemistry experiments for home or school demonstrate the properties and behavior of various kinds of atoms and molecules.
	Quantum Physics of Atoms, Molecules, Solids, Nuclei, and Particles by Robert Eisberg (Author), Robert Resnick (Author) A revision of a successful junior/senior level text, this introduction to elementary quantum mechanics clearly explains the properties of the most important quantum systems. Emphasizes the applications of theory, and contains new material on particle physics, electron-positron annihilation in solids and the Mossbauer effect. Includes new appendices on such topics as crystallography, Fourier Integral Description of a Wave Group, and Time-Independent Perturbation Theory.
	Theoretical Femtosecond Physics: Atoms and Molecules in Strong Laser Fields by Springer Theoretical femtosecond physics is a new field of research. Theoretical investigations of atoms and molecules interacting with pulsed or continuous wave lasers of up to atomic field strengths are leading to an understanding of many challenging experimental discoveries. Laser-Matter interaction is treated on a nonperturbative level in the book using approximate and numerical solutions of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. The light field is treated classically. Physical phenomena, ranging from ionization of atoms to the ionization and dissociation of molecules and the control of chemical reactions are presented and discussed. Theoretical background for experiments with strong and short laser pulses is given. Several exercises are included in the main text. Some detailed...
	2 Atoms In A Molecule Noah and the Whale (Primary Contributor)
	Atom Molecules - Men's Silk Necktie by Josh Bach The perfect necktie for the scientist, and the retro-hipster in all of us. 100% silk. Hand finished in the USA.
	ATOMS ELEMENTS MOLECULES COMPOUNDS by MCDONALD PUBLISHING Turn your young scientists into experts on these basic science concepts. Students learn the parts of an atom, the arrangement of elements on the periodic table, the structure of molecules, the characteristics of compounds, and more. Package includes 4 posters, 4 reproducible activity sheets, and a helpful teacher's guide.
	How about Atoms and Molecules? DVD Starring: Artist Not Provided The composition of atoms and how they share, borrow, or steal electrons to form molecules is explained in this basic view of atomic structure.
	Understanding Atoms and Molecules [VHS] Atoms and molecules are the basic foundation of everything that exists. An atom is the smallest unit of matter that is recognizable as a chemical element, but atoms themselves may be broken up into smaller parts. Become acquainted with the inner structure of an atom and understand how each part of the atom has an essential function. Learn that molecules are groups of atoms that are held together by amazing chemical bonds. How these chemical bonds are formed will be explored, as students get a solid introduction to the building blocks of all matter.
	Atoms and Molecules: An Introduction for Students of Physical Chemistry by Martin Karplus (Author)
	Men and Women of Science: Atoms and Molecules: John Dalton DVD (Interest Grade Levels 4-12 & Adult) by EDCON Publishing Group Atoms and Molecules: John Dalton. The use of theories to explain many of the "wonders" we observe. *May not play properly on DVD players manufactured before 2002. This DVD, like the others in the series "Men and Women of Science", is made up of intriguing stories that trace the development of important science discoveries. This DVD depicts the life and work of a scientist of note in a way that will interest your students. The lessons convey a sense of the history and sociology of science and helps students develop informed attitudes toward the scientific enterprise. Each lesson includes a teacher's guide with background information on the scientist, "What to watch for" questions, discussion topics, and suggestions for follow-up activities. Complete with reproducible activity sheets in a...