Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 

Why do consumers dislike corporate brands that get too familiar?

May 17, 2012
Although it is tempting to use the word "we" to make consumers feel like part of the family, people react negatively when brands overstep their boundaries, according to a new study in the Journal of Consumer Research.

"Marketers often desire to promote consumers' feelings of being in a close relationship with the brands they market, and they frequently craft their communications using language that portrays brands as close partners with consumers," write authors Aner Sela (University of Florida), S. Christian Wheeler (Stanford University), and Gülen Sarial-Abi (Koç University).

"Our research shows that seemingly inconsequential changes, as subtle as using 'we' versus 'you and the brand,' can have both positive and negative effects on people's evaluations of real-world brands with which they have working relationships," the authors write.

Because "we" seems to represent more closeness and shared identity, it would seems that using "we" would increase people's feelings of closeness and loyalty to the brand. But the authors found that that depended on how close consumers felt to the brand in the first place.

In one study, participants read an excerpt supposedly taken from an ad for Wells Fargo, a prominent banking brand, or Aetna, a prominent health insurance company. The authors first discovered that people tend to feel closer to their bank than to their insurance company. The excerpts were identical except for the use of the pronoun "we" versus "you and [the brand]."

Real Wells Fargo customers had more positive attitudes toward the banking company after reading the "we" version; but actual Aetna customers had more positive attitudes toward the brand when they read "you and Aetna." Interestingly, people who were not customers of either brand had more positive feelings about both companies when the ads used "you and [the brand]." "People who are not brand customers expect brands with which they are not affiliated to communicate with them using less intimate language-just as people generally expect strangers to interact with them using less intimate language," the authors conclude.

University of Chicago Press Journals



More Corporate Brands Current Events and Corporate Brands News Articles

Corporate Director's Guidebook

Corporate Director's Guidebook
by ABA Business Law Section Corporate Law Committee (Author)


The Sixth Edition is being published in the wake of the 2007-2010 financial crisis and the resulting legislation, the Dodd-Frank wall street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act). As a result, this edition emphasizes themes arising out of the crisis and important to all directors, particularly those in public companies.

Taking Brand Initiative: How Companies Can Align Strategy, Culture, and Identity Through Corporate Branding

Taking Brand Initiative: How Companies Can Align Strategy, Culture, and Identity Through Corporate Branding
by Mary Jo Hatch (Author), Majken Schultz (Author)


Taking Brand Initiative offers a revolutionary approach to corporate branding that looks beyond the marketing value of brands company-to-customer and the HR significance of brands company-to-employee. It places the management of brands at the senior level of management as it radiates throughout the organization. In this groundbreaking book, international branding thought leaders, Mary Jo Hatch and Make Schultz explain how a company's brand is just as important to OoutsidersONpoliticians, suppliers, and analysts as it is to company insiders. They show how only the corporate brand can integrate all the company's staff functions and provide a vision for competition and globalization.

Brand Psychology: Consumer Perceptions, Corporate Reputations

Brand Psychology: Consumer Perceptions, Corporate Reputations
by Jonathan Gabay (Author)


Revealing the hidden processes behind why certain brands command our loyalty and trust, Brand Psychology looks at how to build up a positive brand image through Corporate Social Responsibility and ethical transparency.Reputation management authority Jonathan Gabay takes readers on a tour of the corporate, political and personal brands whose understanding of consumer psychology has either built or broken them.  He answers key questions about brand and reputation management, including:
--Why do we trust some brands more than others?
--How important is integrity for a brand's survival?
--How can brand confidence be rebuilt during a crisis?Using case studies and tips from respected neuropsychologists, economists, and IT, advertising, PR, and industry leaders, Brand Psychology turns...

Corporate Brand Personality: Re-focus Your Organization's Culture to Build Trust, Respect and Authenticity

Corporate Brand Personality: Re-focus Your Organization's Culture to Build Trust, Respect and Authenticity
by Lesley Everett (Author)


Personal and corporate branding expert Lesley Everett addresses the need for a re-focus and a re-alignment of corporate culture in order to compete in a business world that demands trust, respect, and strong values. In Corporate Brand Personality, Everett helps leaders ensure that organizational culture aligns with long term objectives, and she explains how to lead and engage employees at all levels within a company so that their behavior reflects the attitude and direction of the company. Informed by the collapse of several prominent corporations in recent years, the book taps into the move of putting people back into the heart of business to ensure that trust is at the core of any organization.

Using case studies and real life examples based on her own experience, Everett...

Packaging the Brand: The Relationship Between Packaging Design and Brand Identity (Required Reading Range)

Packaging the Brand: The Relationship Between Packaging Design and Brand Identity (Required Reading Range)
by Gavin Ambrose (Author)


Packaging the Brand is a detailed discussion of the most overtly commercial area of graphic design. Packaging represents the largest overlap between the disciplines of graphic design and branding. While many other areas of design may be commercial to an extent, the success of a piece of packaging design is inextricably linked with its ability to sell a product.   This book discusses the implications of this commercial function for a designer. It explores methods of visually communicating the value of a product to its target audience, and examines the entire lifespan of a piece of packaging: from its manufacture and construction, its display in various retail environments, to its eventual disposal and the associated environmental concerns....

Corporate Reputation: Brand and Communication

Corporate Reputation: Brand and Communication
by Stuart Roper (Author), Chris Fill (Author)


Why should and how can organisations manage their reputations? All organisations, the executives who direct them, the employees who create value and their stakeholders who influence them, all interact and can impact corporate reputation. In a 24/7 media environment, where even a tweet can shape impressions, the importance of reputation management has never been higher. Every single move, decision taken and each isolated event that involves a company or public figure, is scrutinised, documented and publicised globally, compounding the task of reputation managers. Just ask BP, Toyota or Tiger Woods.

The Brand Flip: Why customers now run companies and how to profit from it (Voices That Matter)

The Brand Flip: Why customers now run companies and how to profit from it (Voices That Matter)
by Marty Neumeier (Author)


Best-selling brand expert Marty Neumeier shows you how to make the leap from a company-driven past to the consumer-driven future. You’ll learn how to flip your brand from offering products to offering meaning, from value protection to value creation, from cost-based pricing to relationship pricing, from market segments to brand tribes, and from customer satisfaction to customer empowerment.  ...

Brand Against the Machine: How to Build Your Brand, Cut Through the Marketing Noise, and Stand Out from the Competition

Brand Against the Machine: How to Build Your Brand, Cut Through the Marketing Noise, and Stand Out from the Competition
by John Michael Morgan (Author)


The machine blasts messages at the world and it does not care who you are or what you have to say or whether its message is relevant to you at all. The machine is a moron. You, however, are not. Which is why your brand needs to rage against the traditional forces of advertising. You must engage your audience and win their business by giving more and selling less. Yours must be a Brand Against the Machine.

Brand Against the Machine offers proven and actionable steps for companies and entrepreneurs to increase their visibility and credibility, and create an indispensable brand that consumers can relate to, creating lifelong customers. Discover the aspirational currency that makes your brand one that people want to be or want to be friends with. Learn how to be real with your...

Designing B2B Brands: Lessons from Deloitte and 195,000 Brand Managers

Designing B2B Brands: Lessons from Deloitte and 195,000 Brand Managers
by Carlos Martinez Onaindia (Author), Brian Resnick (Author)


As an in-depth explanation of one organisation s brand strategy, this guide is both fascinating and full of useful insights. The CA magazine (UK) Get tactical insight from the top business-to-business branding experts and gain a global presence This comprehensive manual lays out the steps necessary for creating an iconic global identity. It uses the lessons and inside knowledge of Deloitte, the world's largest professional services organization, to help other business-to-business operations deliver a high-impact, value-added brand experience. This book will illustrate all the components of an integrated brand identity system, and how they can be crafted and implemented for optimal effect. Here, the speculative is replaced by the proven: a seamless framework for global brand success,...

What Great Brands Do: The Seven Brand-Building Principles that Separate the Best from the Rest

What Great Brands Do: The Seven Brand-Building Principles that Separate the Best from the Rest
by Denise Lee Yohn (Author)


Discover proven strategies for building powerful, world-class brands in this 800CEOREAD bestseller    It's tempting to believe that brands like Apple, Nike, and Zappos achieved their iconic statuses because of serendipity, an unattainable magic formula, or even the genius of a single visionary leader. However, these companies all adopted specific approaches and principles that transformed their ordinary brands into industry leaders. In other words, great brands can be built--and Denise Lee Yohn knows exactly how to do it. Delivering a fresh perspective, Yohn's What Great Brands Do teaches an innovative brand-as-business strategy that enhances brand identity while boosting profit margins, improving company culture, and creating stronger stakeholder relationships. Drawing from...

© 2015 BrightSurf.com