Science Current Events | Science News |

Period drama! Pop culture makes menstruation 'overly traumatic'.

July 12, 2012

A study by the University of Melbourne has raised concerns about Hollywood's treatment of menstruation, and whether it's frightening girls into believing it is worse than the reality.

Researcher Dr Lauren Rosewarne, from the University's School of Social and Political Sciences, has analyzed hundreds of representations of menstruation in film and television.

"The presentation of menstruation on screen is an overwhelmingly negative one," she said.

The analysis included jokes, plotlines and references from popular TV shows such as The Big Bang Theory, Mad Men, Friends and Grey's Anatomy, and blockbuster films like Annie Hall, Anchorman and Monty Python's The Meaning of Life.

"The regularity, normalcy and uneventfulness of real life menstruation is rarely portrayed on screen. Instead, it's treated as traumatic, embarrassing, distressing, offensive, comedic or thoroughly catastrophic," she said.

"There are numerous portrayals where menstruation is considered as evil, disgusting and as the root of all female evil."

Dr Rosewarne said these negative representations affected how women approached their own experiences.

"Girls in real life are viewing menstruation as a hassle, women are happily filling prescriptions to make it go away, men are mocking it, loathing it and rarely understanding it," she said.

"On screen presentations likely have some complicity."'

The research identified the representation of menstruation in Carrie (1976) as perhaps the most traumatizing.

"The fusion of a naked girl, shower stream, screaming and blood harked back to cinema's most famous shower horror scene from Psycho. Even though the audience presumably recognized Carrie was only menstruating, the character's terror was contagious."

Dr Rosearne's full analysis will appear in her upcoming book, Periods in Pop Culture, to be published by Lexington Books.

The University of Melbourne

Related Menstruation Current Events and Menstruation News Articles

Female smokers more likely to kick the habit by 'timing' their quit date with their menstrual cycle
Women who want to quit smoking may have better success by carefully timing their quit date with optimal days within their menstrual cycle, according to a new study from researchers at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania.

Women with epilepsy just as likely to get pregnant as healthy women of childbearing age
Women with epilepsy are just as likely to achieve a successful pregnancy as women without the neurological disorder, according to a new study led by research teams at multiple centers, including NYU Langone Medical Center.

Higher dietary fiber intake in young women may reduce breast cancer risk
Women who eat more high-fiber foods during adolescence and young adulthood--especially lots of fruits and vegetables--may have significantly lower breast cancer risk than those who eat less dietary fiber when young, according to a new large-scale study led by researchers at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

Researchers identify association between reproductive factors and risk of death
Reproductive factors in women, such as a later starting age of menstruation, having children, breastfeeding and use of oral contraceptives, are associated with a reduced risk of death.

Early maturing girls at great risk of alcohol abuse without close parental supervision
Inadequate supervision by parents during early adolescence forecasts a host of behavior problems, including problem drinking.

Women's faces get redder at ovulation, but human eyes can't pick up on it
Previous studies have shown that men find female faces more attractive when the women are ovulating, but the visual clues that allow this are unclear.

Women's faces get redder at ovulation, but human eyes can't pick up on it
Previous studies have shown that men find female faces more attractive when the women are ovulating, but the visual clues that allow this are unclear.

Population Council progesterone contraceptive vaginal ring on WHO essential medicines list
The World Health Organization released its 2015 updated essential medicines list and for the first time included the progesterone contraceptive vaginal ring (CVR), a contraceptive safe and effective for lactating women in the postpartum period.

First live birth after transplantation of ovarian tissue frozen during childhood
A young woman has become the first in the world to give birth to a healthy child after doctors restored her fertility by transplanting ovarian tissue that had been removed and frozen while she was a child.

Stop blaming the moon, says UCLA scientist
"It must be a full moon" is a common refrain when things appear more hectic than usual.
More Menstruation Current Events and Menstruation News Articles

Blood Magic: The Anthropology of Menstruation

Blood Magic: The Anthropology of Menstruation
by Thomas Buckley (Editor), Alma Gottlieb (Editor)

Examining cultures as diverse as long-house dwellers in North Borneo, African farmers, Welsh housewives, and postindustrial American workers, this volume dramatically redefines the anthropological study of menstrual customs. It challenges the widespread image of a universal "menstrual taboo" as well as the common assumption of universal female subordination which underlies it. Contributing important new material and perspectives to our understanding of comparative gender politics and symbolism, it is of particular importance to those interested in anthropology, women's studies, religion, and comparative health systems.

Flow: The Cultural Story of Menstruation

Flow: The Cultural Story of Menstruation
by Elissa Stein (Author), Susan Kim (Author)

In this hip, hilarious and truly eye-opening cultural history, menstruation is talked about as never before. Flow spans its fascinating, occasionally wacky and sometimes downright scary story: from mikvahs (ritual cleansing baths) to menopause, hysteria to hysterectomies—not to mention the Pill, cramps, the history of underwear, and the movie about puberty they showed you in 5th grade. Flow answers such questions as: What’s the point of getting a period? What did women do before pads and tampons? What about new drugs that promise to end periods—a hot idea or not? Sex during your period: gross or a turn-on? And what’s normal, anyway?  With color reproductions of (campy) historical ads and early (excruciating) femcare devices, it also provides a fascinating (and mind-boggling)...

The Period Book: A Girl's Guide to Growing Up

The Period Book: A Girl's Guide to Growing Up
by Karen Gravelle (Author), Jennifer Gravelle (Author), Debbie Palen (Illustrator)

The essential guidebook for every girl.The Period Book is a reassuring must-read for every girl about to have her period, and every parent wishing to prepare a daughter for this important milestone. With more than 300,000 copies sold, The Period Book stands out from the pack by specifically addressing younger girls. And with eleven now the average age at which girls get their period, this supportive and practical approach, providing clear and sensitive answers to common questions, is evern more welcome today.The revised edition includes a new introduction for parents and an additional chapter about body image.

New Blood: Third-Wave Feminism and the Politics of Menstruation

New Blood: Third-Wave Feminism and the Politics of Menstruation
by Professor Chris Bobel (Author), Professor Judith Lorber (Foreword)

New Blood offers a fresh interdisciplinary look at feminism-in-flux. For over three decades, menstrual activists have questioned the safety and necessity of feminine care products while contesting menstruation as a deeply entrenched taboo. Chris Bobel shows how a little-known yet enduring force in the feminist health, environmental, and consumer rights movements lays bare tensions between second- and third-wave feminisms and reveals a complicated story of continuity and change within the women's movement.

Through her critical ethnographic lens, Bobel focuses on debates central to feminist thought (including the utility of the category "gender") and challenges to building an inclusive feminist movement. Filled with personal narratives, playful visuals, and original humor, New Blood...

Moon Time: Harness the ever-changing energy of your menstrual cycle

Moon Time: Harness the ever-changing energy of your menstrual cycle
by Lucy H. Pearce (Author)

This fully updated second edition of the #1 Amazon bestseller in menstruation contains 45 pages of additional material including:

· Fertility charting

· Creating ceremonies: menarche, mother blessing, menopause ...

· Moon phases

· Expanded and fully-updated resource section

Hailed as 'life-changing' by women around the world, Moon Time shares a fully embodied understanding of your menstrual cycle. Full of practical insight, empowering resources, creative activities and passion, this book will put you back in touch with your body's wisdom.

Whether you are coming off the pill, wanting to understand your fertility, struggling with PMS, healing from womb issues, are coming back to your cycles after childbirth or just want...

Girls Only! All About Periods and Growing-Up Stuff

Girls Only! All About Periods and Growing-Up Stuff
by Victoria Parker (Author)

Girls Only! focuses on the practicalities of periods, the social and personal implications of starting your period, and the physical and emotional developments in puberty. It tells you what happens and when, what you need to know and how to prepare. It answers all the questions girls are dying to ask, but daren't, in a clear, friendly way, using real-life examples.

It's the perfect first book about periods for girls of primary school age as it provides information at the right level. The tone is positive and reassuring and complemented by quirky illustrations throughout.

The Curse : A Cultural History of Menstruation

The Curse : A Cultural History of Menstruation
by Janice Delaney (Author), Mary Jane Lupton (Author), Emily Toth (Author)

Aims to explore a range of hidden assumptions and attitudes about menstruation.

Period.: A Girl's Guide

Period.: A Girl's Guide
by JoAnn Loulan (Author), Bonnie Worthen (Author), Marcia Quackenbush (Illustrator), Chris Wold Dyrud (Illustrator)

For parents who do not know how or where to begin this discussion, here are ideas to get them started. A detachable Parent's Guide will lead them through the learning process for themselves and their daughters—and even their sons. The Parent's Guide can also be found in its entirety on the Book Peddlers website at In it you will find:
• Talking About Menstruation • What's The Right Age To Share Information? • Who Begins?
• What About The Boys? • Creating Your Own Right-of-Passage.

The Care and Keeping of You: The Body Book for Younger Girls, Revised Edition

The Care and Keeping of You: The Body Book for Younger Girls, Revised Edition
by Valorie Schaefer (Author), Josee Masse (Illustrator)

Our best-selling body book for girls just got even better! With all-new illustrations and updated content for girls ages 8 and up, it features tips, how-tos, and facts from the experts. (Medical consultant: Cara Natterson, MD.) You'll find answers to questions about your changing body, from hair care to healthy eating, bad breath to bras, periods to pimples, and everything in between. Once you feel comfortable with what's happening, you'll be ready to move on to the The Care & Keeping of You 2!

The Wise Wound: menstruation and everywoman

The Wise Wound: menstruation and everywoman
by Penelope Shuttle (Author), Peter Redgrove (Author)

“The first accessible book about menstruation as a human reality . . . entirely praiseworthy.”—The Sunday TimesThis is a book of many questions and some answers. What is this menstruation that half the world undergoes? Has it any use, or any purpose? Which is it, blessing or curse?This groundbreaking study of the facts, fantasies, and taboos surrounding menstruation has helped bring about a profound shift in attitudes toward a natural phenomenon that has been reviled and denigrated over the centuries. Thoroughly researched yet highly readable, combining psychology, anthropology, and poetry, Shuttle and Redgrove illustrate their theories using examples ranging from the Bible to such modern-day pop horrors as vampire movies and the cult film The...

© 2016