GPs using unreliable websites for tinnitus information, study finds
September 13, 2012
GPs are not always using the most comprehensive and reliable online resources to support them in treating patients with the debilitating hearing condition tinnitus, researchers have found.
The study looked at the 10 main websites used by GPs to get information on clinical practice and found that the two best websites for assessing or managing tinnitus - Map of Medicine and the British Tinnitus Association (BTA) - were rarely used by family doctors, with only two per cent logging on to access their pages.
The research, which involved a team of experts from The University of Nottingham, Nottingham Trent University and the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) National Biomedical Research Unit in Hearing, is published in the latest edition of the journal BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.
Dr Derek Hoare, Senior Research Fellow at The University of Nottingham and the NIHR National Biomedical Research Unit in Hearing, said: "We found that there are better options for sources of online information than those currently used by most GPs. Map of Medicine in particular used a rigorous and explicit approach to reporting making its sources of information very transparent and reliable, while The British Tinnitus Association website came out top for the quality of information it currently provides on treatment choice. Despite this, these two websites are rarely used by GPs.
"However, when we analysed the content of the group of websites we found that all were lacking a number of details relating to either assessing or managing tinnitus and so GPs may have to use a combination of websites to be fully informed. Our report also offers a range of recommendations that will help providers of online tinnitus websites to improve their resources."
Tinnitus, a condition in which patients hear a persistent ringing, hissing or buzzing sound in their ears, affects around 10 per cent of the population and is often associated with other illnesses including stress, anxiety, insomnia, depression and communication difficulties.
Patients usually access NHS services such as neurotology or audiological rehabilitation through their GPs. However, a recent national survey of GPs by the research team highlighted that many feel their knowledge of tinnitus is limited and they need better guidelines on how to effectively assess, diagnose and refer their patients.
In addition, patients with hearing problems expressed concern of poor GP awareness of the condition and other healthcare professionals such as audiologists highlighted inappropriate referrals received from GPs.
As tinnitus is seen to affect a relatively low number of patients at GP surgeries, many doctors are turning to the internet for information on the condition rather than spending resource on specialist training.
However, while the internet can provide instant access to a diverse range of sources, the volume of information available can often make it difficult for GPs to discern between the sites offering sound advice on the management of the condition and those which are inaccurate and unreliable - a Google search of 'tinnitus treatment' generates 11 million results alone.
The research analysed the content of 10 of the sites most commonly used by GPs - which included commercial, charity and Government-run websites - and used a specialist healthcare information score called DISCERN to rate the quality of the information they offered and their usability.
The study found that the Map of Medicine, ranked highest overall for quality and reliability despite achieving a low score for information on the management of tinnitus. Conversely, the BTA site, which was ranked in second place, had one of the highest scores on information on management choices.
The results indicate that GPs would have to visit at least two websites to gather all the information recommended by the Department of Health for good practice in tinnitus care, which is unlikely to happen in a busy practice.
Ironically, the lowest rated website was the NHS patient health information site NHS Choices. Both the highest and the lowest websites were accredited by The Information Standard.
The report recommends that GPs use both the Map of Medicine and the BTA sites as education tools on tinnitus, or more simply, to use the good practice guide on tinnitus produced by the Department of Health.
The research will also offer valuable information for websites providing information on tinnitus on how they can improve their service and Action on Hearing Loss has already gathered the preliminary findings to be incorporated into a forthcoming overhaul of its website.
The research was conducted by Miss Kathryn Fackrell (Nottingham Trent University), Dr Derek Hoare, Mrs Sandra Smith and Dr Abby McCormack (The University of Nottingham and the NIHR National Biomedical Research Unit in Hearing) and Professor Deborah Hall (Nottingham Trent University and the NIHR National Biomedical Research Unit in Hearing).
Support and funding for the research came from Action on Hearing Loss and the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Biomedical Research Unit Programme.
A copy of the paper is available to view online at www.biomedcentral.com/content/pdf/1472-6947-12-70.pdf
The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)
Related Tinnitus Current Events and Tinnitus News ArticlesCU researchers may have discovered a plan to disable Meniere's disease
Researchers at University of Colorado School of Medicine may have figured out what causes Meniere's disease and how to attack it.Researchers Find Early Success in New Treatment for Stroke Recovery
Researchers at The University of Texas at Dallas have taken a step toward developing a new treatment to aid the recovery of limb function after strokes.Now hear this: Scientists discover compound to prevent noise-related hearing loss
Your mother was right when she warned you that loud music could damage your hearing, but now scientists have discovered exactly what gets damaged and how.Study identifies a simple way to reduce healthcare costs
A study led by a Loyola University Medical Center ENT physician provides a case study of a simple action that can reduce healthcare costs without compromising care. Pitt team finds mechanism that causes noise-induced tinnitus and drug that can prevent it
An epilepsy drug shows promise in an animal model at preventing tinnitus from developing after exposure to loud noise, according to a new study by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine.Rapid hearing loss may be a symptom of rare Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease
Rapid hearing loss in both ears may be a symptom of the rare but always-fatal Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease and should be considered a reason for clinicians to test for the disorder.Nasty noises: Why do we recoil at unpleasant sounds
Heightened activity between the emotional and auditory parts of the brain explains why the sound of chalk on a blackboard or a knife on a bottle is so unpleasant.Report: Strategies to prevent noise-induced hearing loss, tinnitus in soldiers
Antioxidants, dietary supplements and high-tech brain imaging are among some of the novel strategies that may help detect, treat and even prevent noise-induced hearing loss and tinnitus among American troops, according to researchers at Henry Ford Hospital.Research Shows Nerve Stimulation Can Help Reorganize Brain
UT Dallas researchers recently demonstrated how nerve stimulation paired with specific experiences, such as movements or sounds, can reorganize the brain. Jeffrey W. Olin, DO, authors study that describes symptoms and severity of fibromuscular dysplasia
A patient registry is proving invaluable in cataloging the clinical features, symptoms, severity, and outcomes of fibromuscular dysplasia (FMD), a non-inflammatory vascular disease that can cause narrowing of arteries in the carotid (neck) and renal (kidney) arteries, which can result in headache, strokes, and aneurysms.
More Tinnitus Current Events and Tinnitus News Articles
Tinnitus No More: The Complete Guide On Tinnitus Symptoms, Causes, Treatments, & Natural Tinnitus Remedies to Get Rid of Ringing in Ears Once and for All|
You may be surprised to know that it is estimated over 36 million Americans suffer from “ringing in the ears,” or tinnitus. People who have this condition may hear the ringing in one or both ears. It may be a constant sound or it might just come and go from time to time. The volume of the sound ranges from a whine to a squeal. For some people, the condition is so serious that it affects their daily lives.
If you are one of the people suffering from ringing in the ears, you probably want to know what causes the ringing sound and desperately needed a way to stop it.
Tinnitus is triggered by multiple internal factors and therefore can only be treated by tackling all of those internal elements responsible for tinnitus. Treating tinnitus is not easy. It may be...
Tinnitus: Turning the Volume Down (Revised & Expanded)|
by Kevin Hogan (Author), Jennifer Battaglino (Author)
Over 50 million Americans experience some form of tinnitus and there are those who don't realize that the ringing in their ears has a name. Of those 50 million, 12 million are estimated to have severe tinnitus where they seek medical treatment. Approximately two million people are suffering so severely that they cannot make it through their daily activities.
Kevin Hogan has a positive approach to health as a definite goal worthy of determination. Kevin experienced tinnitus, and partly because of this, he treats those who suffer from it with respect!
He heard the usual, You have to live with it, and he does NOT live with it. In addition he has remolded his profession to help those with tinnitus. This book is a positive example, a helping hand, a light in the darkness....
Tinnitus STOP! - The Complete Guide On Ringing In The Ears, Natural Tinnitus Remedies, And A Holistic System For Permanent Tinnitus Relief|
Are you suffering from ringing in the ears, or a medical term called Tinnitus? Do you know what causes the ringing sound? And are you desperately needed a way to stop it?
Tinnitus is triggered by multiple internal factors and therefore can only be treated by tackling all of those internal elements responsible for tinnitus. It can only be cured by correctly diagnosing your condition from within, not by masking the noise or by calming the muscles or nerves of the outer ear (as with laser treatments for tinnitus, for example).
In this information jam-packed ebook, you will learn:
- EVERYTHING you need to know about tinnitus, EXACTLY what causes the noise in your head (Take a closer look at two most recent tinnitus surveys, the results might shock you)
The Consumer Handbook on Tinnitus|
by Richard S. Tyler (Editor)
This book is THE handbook for those suffering from tinnitus. Written by professionals, the text begins with the epidemiology of tinnitus, including classification, incidence in populations, and causes, as well as reviews of different studies. It then addresses the psychological profile of a tinnitus patients, how tinnitus affects a patient's lifestyle, work, relationships, and communications, and the patient's relationship to others around them. Other sections include tinnitus and insomnia, physiological mechanisms and neural models, medical and surgical evaluation and management, tinnitus in children, and finally a history of tinnitus. Sections pertaining to therapy and treatment for the patient include hearing aids, maskers, habituation therapy, counseling, and biofeedback.
Tinnitus Alleviation Therapy: A Self-Help Program for Gentle and Lasting Recovery|
by Maria Holl (Author), Cheryl Hirsch (Editor)
Ringing in your ears isn't fun. But as people age and begin to lose hearing, the chances of tinnitus increase. The Mayo Clinic estimates that one in five people have the condition. But there's no definitive cure for it. Part of the problem is that it results from a range of very different physical, environmental, and emotional causes, everything from bad circulation, high blood pressure, and wax build up to persistent loud noise and stress. Some people have found relief from acupuncture and hypnosis, antibiotics and antidepressants, and transcranial magnetic stimulation, but certain antibiotics and antidepressants have also been know to cause tinnitus. For readers who've tried all sorts of current remedies and still haven't found relief, it's time to read Tinnitus Alleviation Therapy...
Tinnitus Cure: Natural and Traditional Treatment for Tinnitus|
Tinnitus Cure: Natural and Traditional Treatment for Tinnitus
While several Tinnitus relief books are available, few provide as much comprehensive information to help Tinnitus sufferers understand and alleviate the disturbing symptoms. The remedies and treatments provided in this book range from traditional methods used by most physicians to more natural methods that are gaining more recognition in the medical field.
Dr. Giron provides detailed information in easy to understand language to help those suffering from this common condition.
* Characteristics of Tinnitus
* Causes and Risk Factors
* Tests and Diagnosis
* Treatment and Management
* Complementary and Alternative Treatments
Tinnitus Retraining Therapy: Implementing the Neurophysiological Model|
by Pawel J. Jastreboff (Author), Jonathan W. P. Hazell (Author)
Tinnitus and oversensitivity to sound are common and hitherto incurable, distressing conditions that affect a substantial number of the population. Pawel Jastreboff's discovery of the mechanisms by which tinnitus and decreased sound tolerance occur has led to a new and effective treatment called Tinnitus Retraining Therapy (TRT). Audiologists, ENT specialists, psychologists and counsellors around the world currently practise this technique, with very high success rates. TRT, the treatment developed by the authors from the model, has already proved to be the most effective and most widely practised worldwide. This book presents a definitive description and justification for the Jastreboff neurophysiological model of tinnitus, outlining the essentials of TRT, reviewing the research...
Tinnitus: Questions and Answers|
by Jack A. Vernon (Author), Barbara Tabachnick Sanders (Author)
A brief book in question and answer format that answers readers' questions regarding ringing in their ears. The book covers causes, treatments, and other topics with a format similar to the column written by the author in “Tinnitus Today” magazine. Other topics will include such things as drug treatments, dental issues relating to tinnitus, hearing loss and tinnitus, and other related ear disorders. The book has an optimistic tone and an appealing format with questions grouped by general topic. Anyone interested in learning more about hearing disorders.
The Tinnitus Handbook|
by United Research Publishers (Author), Bill Habets (Author), L. E. Mills (Illustrator)
only this book contains natural and alternative treatments that helped get rid of the agonizing ringing and other sounds in my ears. For example, one sugested remedy in the book is the herb gingo biloba. I started taking this herb daily and within a few weeks a miracle happend. For the first time in years the ringing in my ears stopped. I understand gingo stimulates the circulation in the ears and alleviates the tinnitus symtoms. I would recommend this bood to anyone suffering from tinnitus symptoms
Tinnitus Treatment: Clinical Protocols|
by Richard Tyler (Editor)
Most clinicians have little experience with tinnitus treatments, and are unsure of how to help a patient suffering from the condition. Filling a significant gap in literature, this book offers a variety of in-depth protocols to treat tinnitus. Beginning with a review of several neurophysiological and psychological models of tinnitus, the book goes on to cover evaluation tools; counseling options and methods; treatment with hearing aids, wearable and non-wearable noise generators, and music; tinnitus-related insomnia; quality-of-life issues; and much more. Highly experienced clinicians give you the practical strategies to apply such therapeutic modalities as cognitive-behavioral therapy, individual and group sessions, sound therapy, habituation therapy, and narrative therapy. You will also...