Science Current Events | Science News | Brightsurf.com
 
Email a Friend Send to a friend
Printer Friendly Print Fundamental facts about environmental hormones: text of speech by Dr Susan Jobling at the BA Festival of Science 2004

Fundamental facts about environmental hormones: text of speech by Dr Susan Jobling at the BA Festival of Science 2004

September 07, 2004

Fundamental facts about environmental hormones

Cancer may not be the only long-term health threat that we (and the other animals we share our planet with) face. Some researchers have suggested that minute amounts of certain environmental pollutants may adversely change the way wildlife (and possibly also humans) develop and reproduce. Researchers have been investigating these "environmental hormones" for several years and media coverage has highlighted concerns about the potential impacts of these so called environmental hormones on wildlife and on the human population. The scientific community is deeply divided about the questions being raised by the research findings. As with most new and complex fields, the issues surrounding environmental hormones are rife with debate, inconsistencies and controversy.




This presentation will provide an introduction to what environmental hormones are, what we know about what they do, what is not known and what is being done. It hopes to illustrate that the answers to these questions, and other mysteries surrounding environmental hormones, can only be provided by conducting both fundamental and applied scientific research. Unlike applied research, fundamental research may not always be of obvious benefit to society, but it may become so as the results of this research are utilised in more applied studies and there may be a gap spanning several years between the fundamental research result and its utilisation.

What are environmental hormones?
The term environmental hormone is commonly used to describe environmental agents that can alter the endocrine system of humans and wildlife. Fundamental research has taught us that the endocrine system is made up of specialised cells and glands under the control of a network of chemical signals or hormones. This communication network responds to stimuli by releasing hormones, the chemical messengers that carry instructions about essential bodily functions to target "receiver" cells throughout the body. The instructions are read by receptors within or on the surface of the "receiver" cell. Some hormonal instructions cause short term temporary changes, such as a faster heart beat. Others dictate more long-term development, such as initiation of the menstrual cycle or even bone or muscle growth, or development of the reproductive organs (ovaries and testes) in the developing foetus.

Our laboratory, like other laboratories working in this emerging field of environmental endocrine research have looked at chemical pollutants that mimic or block the action of natural hormones and hence fool the body into thinking that they are hormones or anti-hormones. Communication is the one essential property of life and hence chemicals that alter this information flow can have consequences that may be deleterious to individuals and/or populations. Environmental chemicals known to do this do so most often by interacting with receptors in a family called the steroid family, particularly the oestrogen and androgen receptors. They include ubiquitous and persistent pesticides, plasticizers, pharmaceuticals and natural hormones, many of which end up down our drains and in our rivers in which fish and other aquatic organisms reside. In recent years, the increased interest in these contaminants has led to an increasing amount of studies on the levels of drugs in wastewater. An early study in 1977 reported that 8.5kg/day of a metabolite of aspirin was found in waste water in Kansas City in the USA. This prompted speculation that "with millions of women taking oral contraceptives, some environmental contamination with estrogenic chemicals is a distinct possibility". More than 20 years later a component of the contraceptive pill 17a-ethinylestradiol was found in trace amounts in waste water in the U.K. and it is only now that we are beginning to understand the biological significance of the presence of this hormone in rivers. Whilst many environmental hormones are weakly active compared with natural hormones, ethynylestradiol may be many times potent than the hormones which our bodies produce. In order to understand its effects, let us consider what fundamental research has taught us about how oestrogen acts:

How do hormones and environmental hormones act?
Estrogens control the female reproductive cycle and the development of the female (and male) reproductive organs. They also influence bone density, can stimulate the growth of some breast tumours. Fundamental research into hormone action led to the discovery that small amounts of the hormone oestrogen given early in development could cause acute feminisation of the male in animals from fish through to humans. In fish, oestrogen exposure during early life can cause the development of intersex (with both male and female reproductive organs) in adult fish and hence, when these types of fish were found in UK rivers downstream from sewage treatment works, oestrogen was suspected to be contaminating our waters. Further research of a more applied nature has shown that this is indeed the case and has also led to the discovery that many other chemicals (apart from natural hormones contraceptive pill hormones), which were previously thought to be harmless, possess hormonal or anti-hormonal activity. Included in this list of chemicals are breakdown products of detergents, and plasticizers, all of which are commonly used industrial chemicals.

Intersex fish are less fertile than normal fish and a recent survey of UK Rivers by the Environment Agency and Brunel and Exeter Universities has shown that this phenomenon is extremely widespread, affecting fish at over 40 sites around the UK. This is a clear example of how fundamental research has helped to explain abnormalities found in wildlife populations. Moreover, recognition of these patterns of disruption in fish populations and its association with contamination of rivers by particular environmental hormones at particular concentrations is also enabling us to anticipate where we might be expected to see the effects of environmental hormones. If we can predict, then theoretically, we should also be able to prevent and hence, areas where the effects of environmental hormones are expected to cause problems for fish could be targeted for remediation.

The research on fish suggests that very low concentrations of environmental hormones can affect reproductive form and (in extreme cases) function in fish. The research also suggests that intersex could be a progressive condition that worsens with age. Could the same be true of humans and so could minute amounts of these environmental hormones that we are exposed to daily affect human health in the long term? The answer to this question remains elusive although patterns of reproductive and developmental disruption that could be caused by environmental hormones are present in the human population. These patterns have been discerned through fundamental research on the actions of hormones and this is why more fundamental research is necessary to further our understanding of hormone action.

Researchers are also researching at what threshold amounts and during what stages of development, chemicals can produce harmful effects via effects on the endocrine system. Toxicology teaches us that the dose of a pollutant or stressor makes the poison and hence the more of a chemical you are exposed to the more likely you are to be poisoned.essentially, when we find a poisonous dose of a chemical, we assume that all doses below this dose are safe. Fundamental research on hormones has, however, taught us that, unlike toxicants, hormones (and therefore possibly also environmental hormones) act by feedback loops so a little hormone may stimulate a target organ and induce a response (which might be adverse or beneficial). Conversely, a lot of hormone may trigger the endocrine system to send a message to the target organ telling it to switch off the response (which might also be adverse or beneficial). This is the way in which the body regulates the production of its own hormones. The problem with environmental hormones is that the body cannot control when it is exposed to these molecules and hence it may be forced to receive these signals at the wrong time. If this happens, it could lead to hormonal imbalances.

The low dose issue (as it has become known) is one of the most controversial areas of the environmental hormone field. It has revealed some very unexpected findings. Perhaps the most important of these is that a hormonally active chemical called bisphenol-A, produced in enormous quantities by the chemical industry, can cause sexual disruption in the tropical snail called Marisa cornuarietis at very low environmentally relevant, concentrations. The effects include a massive stimulation of egg production by the female snails, leading (in some cases) to rupture of the oviducts and death. These findings were reported by a German ecotoxicology laboratory researching suitable methods and test organisms for investigating environmental hormones. They have sparked huge controversy. The controversy was mainly because bisphenol-A had hitherto been shown to have only weak hormonal activity in the animals in which it had been tested. Conversely, these studies suggested that the chemical was exquisitely potent, at least to snails. Further studies by the same investigators and in our laboratories have shown that reproduction in some snails is also sensitive hormones, such as ethynyloestradiol, the contraceptive pill hormone. These results are also interesting from a fundamental scientific point of view as prior to these publications, although the signalling molecule oestradiol was known to be present in many invertebrates from corals on the reef to starfish, the signalling recognition system, or oestrogen receptor, had not been found in any of the invertebrates and in fact was thought to have arisen with the evolution of the vertebrates.

What happened next provides us with an example of how applied toxicological research can spark new areas of fundamental research. Following this publication, many laboratories (including our own) began the search for oestrogen receptors in snails in an effort to understand how chemicals such as bisphenol-A can cause effects in these animals. As a result of this research, the Japanese discovered the first oestrogen-receptor like molecule in a marine snail and the Americans discovered a similar molecule in a sea slug. In our own laboratory, we have discovered that Marisa cornuarietis, the snail in the original study in which BPA was shown to be so potent, also has an oestrogen receptor. These findings suggest that oestrogen was the first hormone to evolve and that the oestrogen signalling system must date back more than 600 million years rather than only 400 million years as was previously thought. Studies are now underway to try to understand how this receptor works in the snail as the information published to date suggests that the receptor is not regulated by oestrogen, at least in the sea slug, suggesting that this receptor may have lost its function here. If this is also correct in snails, then what is the explanation for the profound effects that estrogens have in Marisa? It is possible that estrogens act via non-receptor mediated mechanisms as these mechanisms have been documented to exist in higher organisms. Further research by our research group will hopefully provide the answers to these (and other) questions.

Remaining questions:
To further understand how environmental hormones work and if they threaten wildlife and human health, there are several additional questions that need to be asked and answered:
1.Can wildlife data be applied to humans when it is clear that some compounds have different effects in different kinds of animals?
2.Can laboratory tests on cells explain and predict effects in living organisms, especially since chemicals can affect more than one organ?
3.How do mixtures react and interact with the endocrine system and with one another?
4.How many more chemicals are likely to act like hormones?
5.What levels of exposure over what time frames cause adverse effects?
6.Does exposure to environmental hormones pose a greater threat to developing embryos than to adults and thus impact future generations?
7.How do variables such as profession, age, and genetics etc influence susceptibility and does exposure to one chemical predispose or sensitize an animal to a subsequent exposure?
8.How important are environmental hormones compared with other major issues affecting human and wildlife health?

What is being done?
People who are concerned about health usually want answers today, rather than tomorrow. The issue of environmental hormones, however, involves complex biological systems and diverse health responses and hence, cause and effect data are hard to find. Getting ahead of science could lead to wrong or misleading answers, although the lack of answers is frustrating for policy makers who are pressurised to act now and ask questions later. Notwithstanding this, even without hard evidence, the potential health threat and social and economic risks posed by the environmental hormone issue has forced governments and the public to take notice. We are now relying on scientific, political and public debate to weigh the evidence for and against the endocrine disruptor hypothesis and decide how to deal with it. Governments around the world are gathering information, funding research and developing screening and testing programmes and setting up new policies. Individuals are becoming informed through the media attention that this issue has received. The endocrine disruption/environmental hormone hypothesis deserves full investigation and this will require quite significant research, both fundamental and applied for the foreseeable future.

Brunel University



Related Estrogen Current Events and Estrogen News Articles Estrogen Current Events and Estrogen News RSS Estrogen Current Events and Estrogen News RSS
Menopause-cardiology consensus statement on cardiovascular disease and on HRT
A menopause-cardiology consensus statement has called for direct action to prevent cardiovascular disease (CVD) in menopausal women. The statement also concludes that there is little evidence of increased CVD risk in taking HRT.

Heart and bone damage from low vitamin D tied to declines in sex hormones
Researchers at Johns Hopkins are reporting what is believed to be the first conclusive evidence in men that the long-term ill effects of vitamin D deficiency are amplified by lower levels of the key sex hormone estrogen, but not testosterone.

Fertility procedures need not delay breast cancer treatment for younger women
A new study published in the November issue of the Journal of the American College of Surgeons shows that breast cancer patients under 40 years old who undergo fertility preservation do not face a significant delay in the treatment of their disease when their care is coordinated in a timely fashion.

Coffee break: Compound brewing new research in colon, breast cancer
A compound in coffee has been found to be estrogenic in studies by Texas AgriLife Research scientists.

Mayo researchers find robotic repair for vaginal prolapse has significant benefits
New Mayo Clinic research has found that robotic surgery for vaginal prolapse dramatically reduces patient hospital stay and recovery time.

Estrogen therapy likely must be given soon after menopause to provide stroke protection
For estrogen replacement to provide stroke protection, it likely must be given soon after levels drop because of menopause or surgical removal of the ovaries, scientists report in the Journal of Neuroscience.

Oral contraceptives may benefit women with asthma
New research shows that during natural menstrual cycles, women with asthma who were not taking oral contraceptives (OC) had lower exhaled nitric oxide levels (eNO), a marker of airway inflammation associated with asthma, than women who were taking OC.

Study shows hormone replacement therapy decreases mortality in younger postmenopausal woman
Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) to treat menopausal estrogen deficiency has been in widespread use for over 60 years. Several observational studies over the years showed that HRT use by younger postmenopausal women was associated with a significant reduction in total mortality; available evidence supported the routine use of HRT to increase longevity in postmenopausal women.

Hormone mix could cut breast cancer risk and treat symptoms of menopause
The right combination of estrogen and a selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM), which blocks the effects of estrogen in breast tissue, could relieve menopause symptoms and cut breast cancer risk.

Breast tenderness during hormone replacement therapy linked to elevated cancer risk
Women who developed new-onset breast tenderness after starting estrogen plus progestin hormone replacement therapy were at significantly higher risk for developing breast cancer than women on the combination therapy who didn't experience such tenderness, according to a new UCLA study.
More Estrogen Current Events and Estrogen News Articles
  Source Naturals Phyto-Estrogen Cream, 4 oz (113.4 g)
by Source Naturals

Advanced liposomal delivery. Non-GMO soy. Phyto-Estrogen Cream offers some of the finest phytoestregens, renowned for use during menopause. Each ounce contains 60 mg of isoflavone phytoestrogens, along with 150 mg of pomegranate juice extract, and 100 mg of red clover extract. Micro-penetrating liposomes pass through skin layers more easily than non-liposomal creams.

Natural Estrogen with Pomegranate Extract, 60 caplets

Natural Estrogen with Pomegranate Extract, 60 caplets
by Life Extension

Natural Estrogen with Pomegranate Extract60 caplets Item Catalog Number: 712 In an attempt to provide aging women with the multiple health effects of the bodies’ estrogen without side effects, scientists have discovered plant extracts with estrogenic activity (phytoestrogens). Natural Estrogen with Pomegranate Extract is one answer to the concerns of maintaining healthy hormone function. A review of the published literature reveals some interesting findings about how plant-derived estrogens can provide safe and effective support for such menopausal symptoms as hot flashes. Derived from organically-grown fruit, the pomegranate extract in this formula has the same ratio of polyphenols found in the whole fruit and all the benefits one would get from the juice without the sugar, calories,...

Estrogen/Estriol (Bio-Identical) Fragrance Free Cream 2 oz. Pump Bottle

Estrogen/Estriol (Bio-Identical) Fragrance Free Cream 2 oz. Pump Bottle
by Radiant Laboratories - Made In USA

Paraben-Free and Unscented. Menopausal Hot Flashes? Night Sweats? Trouble Sleeping? Replenish Your Estrogen Naturally and Safely. Get your life back! Estriol Has Been Used in Europe for Years. Bio-identical Hormones Are Safe and Effective. Non Prescription Bio-identical Natural Estrogen (Estriol Usp) Not to Be Confused with Phyto-estrogens. Bio-identical Hormones Are Safe for Women Help Relieve Menopause Symptoms. Estriol is not a phyto estrogen. Don't confuse phyto estrogens with pure natural estriol USP. The natural estrogen, estriol USP, is made the same way natural progesterone USP is made. Sterol analogues found in many varieties of plants are combined with specific bacteria and the resulting hormone is bio identical in chemical structure to the hormone produced by the human body....

Emerita Phytoestrogen Body Cream with Black Cohosh, 2-Ounce Tube

Emerita Phytoestrogen Body Cream with Black Cohosh, 2-Ounce Tube
by Emerita

Peri/Menopause support. Paraben-free. Who knew a little tube of cream could change the world? In 1978 we had a revolutionary idea: that there was not enough real choice when it came to peri / menopause. So we created Pro-Gest, Phytoestrogen Cream and Pers

Estrogen Revisited: Lifelong & Fearless

Estrogen Revisited: Lifelong & Fearless
by Donna Walters (Author)

Estrogen is essential for good health and well being in women of all ages throughout their lives. I have written this book because I want to encourage women who have been on hormone replacement, like me, to consider remaining on it for life as I plan to do. For women who have been scared or hesitant to take estrogen because they are afraid of contracting breast cancer as predicted by the incorrect conclusions of the Women's Health Initiative in 2002, read this book and save your life. My doctor told me that I should stop taking estrogen because it is recommended for the shortest amount of time to control symptoms only. I have researched this issue for over a year because I want to make the right decision for me. I have decided to share my findings and experience of long term estrogen use...

Phyto-Estrogen 60 Capsules

Phyto-Estrogen 60 Capsules
by Gaia Herbs

Provides a Natural Hormonal Balance During the Onset of Menopause Rich Natural Source of Phytoestrogens Support for the Peri-Menopause and Menopausal Years

Estroven Maximum Strength - 98 Caplets

Estroven Maximum Strength - 98 Caplets
by Amerifit

Estroven Maximum Strength is clinically shown to reduce hot flashes and night sweats. It contains a higher level of the key black cohosh and soy isoflavones ingredients found in Estroven Regular Strength, plus additional vitamins and minerals for women's health.

Alternative Health & Herbs Remedies Female Estrogen W, progesterone, 1-Ounce Bottle

Alternative Health & Herbs Remedies Female Estrogen W, progesterone, 1-Ounce Bottle
by Alternative Health & Herbs Remedies

Alternative Health & Herbs Remedies Female Estrogen W, progesterone, promotes hormonal balance, effective for women who are experiencing menopause and it does not contain hormones.

TestroPlex - 90 Capsules Anti-Estrogen & Anti-Aromatase Complex Testosterone Booster Tribulus Chrysin

TestroPlex - 90 Capsules Anti-Estrogen & Anti-Aromatase Complex Testosterone Booster Tribulus Chrysin
by Bionutricals

The amount of free testosterone can be altered (increased) by the use of aromatase inhibitors such as TestroPlexTM. The less testosterone that is synthesized [aromatized] into estrogen, the more total testosterone) or inhibitors of the plasma proteins that bind into testosterone. Manipulating the tendency of a testosterone to exist in an unbound state is an effective way to alter the overall activity and potency of ones overall testosterone levels. Higher levels of testosterone produce an enhanced anti-glucocorticoid effect, which yields an anti-catabolic, or more precisely, anti-proteoolytic, effect on muscle cells. This indirect effect is the result of testosterones high affinity for binding with glucocorticoid receptors, thus blocking the normal messenger pathway that triggers protein...

The Anti-Estrogenic Diet: How Estrogenic Foods and Chemicals Are Making You Fat and Sick

The Anti-Estrogenic Diet: How Estrogenic Foods and Chemicals Are Making You Fat and Sick
by Ori Hofmekler (Author), Rick Osborn (Contributor)

• Lower your risk of metabolic disorders, disease, and chronic weight gain
• Protect yourself against the estrogenic substances in the environment, products, water, and food

Learn how certain foods and herbs can protect you!

Estrogenic chemicals—known for causing the near extinction of various living species—are found in some of the most common foods we eat.

In this revolutionary diet book, Ori Hofmekler addresses the millions of overweight and obese individuals who have failed or are disappointed with other diets—those who suffer from yoyo dieting, weight gain rebounds, or accumulation of stubborn fat in the belly and other estrogen-sensitive areas. Focusing on our current over-exposure to estrogenic chemicals in the environment, foods, and water, The...

© 2009 BrightSurf.com