Reassuring Our Trust In Technology

January 06, 1999

ITHACA, N.Y. -- Much of the world of technology, says Trevor Pinch, is built on trust: Trust that the engineers have done their job responsibly, trust that they have the right expertise to do the job properly. "We can never escape the need for trust," he says. "We trust computers. We trust flying in Boeing 747s." Pinch's seemingly benign view of technology is based not on certainty but on fallibility: The notion that even the best intentions go awry, that even well-designed technology can go wrong occasionally. Trust, he says, is based on the curiously reassuring fact that because technology is fabricated by human hands "it is messy and uncertain."

Pinch, a Cornell University professor of science and technology studies, has enlarged and illustrated his ideas -- which can hardly be a surprise to any engineer -- in his latest book The Golem at Large (Cambridge University Press, 1998), co-authored by Harry Collins, professor of sociology at Cardiff University. The two collaborated on an earlier book, The Golem: What Everyone Should Know About Science (Cambridge University Press, 1993), which caused some resentment in the scientific community for its message that science is no guarantor of truth because it is subject to the same messy process of human-directed experiment.

The choice again of the Golem, the stumbling giant of East European Jewish mythology, as a metaphor is particularly apt for the two authors' latest book, because the seven case studies presented show exactly the often inchoate nature of technological progress. "We shouldn't over-mythologize technological certainty in the same way we shouldn't over-mythologize scientific certainty," says Pinch. "That message might have been shocking to some scientists, but I don't think any engineer would be shocked."

The examples range from the disputed effectiveness of Patriot missiles in the Gulf War and the assigning of blame for the crash of the Challenger shuttle mission, to the role of lay experts in making "vital contributions to technical decisions" about the fallout from the Chernobyl nuclear disaster and AIDS treatment.

In cases of technological failure, such as the space shuttle, Pinch says, invariably humans are accused of causing the failure rather than the failure being recognized as one of a complex technology. "We tend always to go for the more human explanation when technologies go wrong; that's our point," he says.

In the cases of the Chernobyl nuclear fallout, where British farmers quickly saw the effects on their animals, and of AIDS, where victims offered often-ignored advice, the book makes the powerful point that expertise is where the local knowledge is. "Lay people can have expertise," says Pinch. "That doesn't mean that one voice is as good as another, but that people can contribute and gain expertise. Scientists shouldn't reject that."

The message, he says, is that no one should reject expertise, wherever gained. Particularly, he believes, there should be trust in the work of scientists and technologists "because they are trustworthy people -- they are experts, just like your dentist, and you should trust them in the same way."

That message was too much for sociologist Barry Barnes of Exeter University to accept. Writing in the journal Nature, he argued that "it is worth asking whether a book designed to attack claims of certainty and omniscience would not be better entitled 'what you should know about propaganda.'"

However, reviewer Roy Porter noted in New Scientist that the authors' tone "is reassuring, calling for dialogues, not duels, between science and the humanities." And a review in Publishers Weekly commented: "Their book is worthy of note not only for its clear analysis of how science can come up short when applied outside of the laboratory but for its honest appraisal of technology's gatekeepers."
-end-


Cornell University

Related Technology Articles from Brightsurf:

December issue SLAS Technology features 'advances in technology to address COVID-19'
The December issue of SLAS Technology is a special collection featuring the cover article, ''Advances in Technology to Address COVID-19'' by editors Edward Kai-Hua Chow, Ph.D., (National University of Singapore), Pak Kin Wong, Ph.D., (The Pennsylvania State University, PA, USA) and Xianting Ding, Ph.D., (Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China).

October issue SLAS Technology now available
The October issue of SLAS Technology features the cover article, 'Role of Digital Microfl-uidics in Enabling Access to Laboratory Automation and Making Biology Programmable' by Varun B.

Robot technology for everyone or only for the average person?
Robot technology is being used more and more in health rehabilitation and in working life.

Novel biomarker technology for cancer diagnostics
A new way of identifying cancer biomarkers has been developed by researchers at Lund University in Sweden.

Technology innovation for neurology
TU Graz researcher Francesco Greco has developed ultra-light tattoo electrodes that are hardly noticeable on the skin and make long-term measurements of brain activity cheaper and easier.

April's SLAS Technology is now available
April's Edition of SLAS Technology Features Cover Article, 'CURATE.AI: Optimizing Personalized Medicine with Artificial Intelligence'.

Technology in higher education: learning with it instead of from it
Technology has shifted the way that professors teach students in higher education.

Post-lithium technology
Next-generation batteries will probably see the replacement of lithium ions by more abundant and environmentally benign alkali metal or multivalent ions.

Rethinking the role of technology in the classroom
Introducing tablets and laptops to the classroom has certain educational virtues, according to Annahita Ball, an assistant professor in the University at Buffalo School of Social Work, but her research suggests that tech has its limitations as well.

The science and technology of FAST
The Five hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST), located in a radio quiet zone, with the targets (e.g., radio pulsars and neutron stars, galactic and extragalactic 21-cm HI emission).

Read More: Technology News and Technology Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.