# UMass Amherst Researchers offer new physics rule to find mechanical strain

January 08, 2019AMHERST, Mass. - Addressing a physics problem that dates back to Galileo, three University of Massachusetts Amherst researchers this week propose a new approach to the theory of how thin sheets can be forced to conform to "geometrically incompatible" shapes - think gift-wrapping a basketball - that relies on weaving together two fundamental ideas of geometry and mechanics that were long thought to be irreconcilable.

Theoretical physicist Benny Davidovitch, polymer scientist Greg Grason and doctoral student Yiwei Sun, writing in

*Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences*, suggest and demonstrate via numerical simulations that naturally flat sheets forced to change their curvature can accommodate geometrically-required strain by developing microscopic wrinkles that bend the sheet instead of stretching it to the breaking point, a solution that costs less energy, as well.

This advance is important as biotechnologists increasingly attempt to control the level of strain encountered in thin films conforming to complex, curving and 3D shapes of the human body, for example, in flexible and wearable sensors for personalized health monitoring, they explain. Many of these devices rely on electrical properties of the film which is shown to be highly vulnerable to stretching, but which can tolerate some bending.

The new concept is one of "close enough," Davidovitch says - noncomformities that come with bending are so small that in practical terms, they cost almost no energy. "By offering efficient strategies to manage the strain, predict it and control it, we offer a new quantitative tool that's useful for people predicting the forces required to emboss or wrap nanoscopic thin sheets and shells onto substrates of different shapes," they state.

He adds, "Our work shows that by allowing tiny wrinkles in the wrapper, the necessary amount of stretching drops dramatically. For an extremely thin wrapper such as available today in laboratories, the stretching can be eliminated almost entirely."

Grason points out, "Our theoretical framework provides a simple and adaptable tool for understanding how to control and manipulate, and ideally to optimize, the level of strain that a given geometry imposes on such a device, and thereby improve its performance."

Davidovitch says there are two types of scientist interested in this long-standing problem, one less motivated by practicality than by how the laws of Nature apply. These thinkers are familiar with "Galileo's beam," a mechanics/physics problem that imagined a beam sticking out of a stone wall that will bend or deform when weight is added to it, he notes. Predicting the forces and strain on it posed a long-standing puzzle.

Galileo did not solve how much the beam will deform or how to predict that, he notes, but this problem related to strain was later explored and defined through new approaches to the geometry of continuous objects by German mathematician and physicist Carl Friedrich Gauss. Physicists and mathematicians "have focused a lot of intellectual activity over the centuries on it," Davidovitch says.

After Galileo, Davidovitch say, Swiss mathematician Leonhard Euler developed the "elastica theory," which argues that confined objects buckle in order to avoid strain, that is, any change in length. Euler showed that a situation in which absolutely no stretching takes place can occur under special circumstances, but not in the general type of confinement defined by Gauss's geometrical constraints, he adds.

The UMass Amherst team's new tool shows - when a constraint cannot be perfectly satisfied but almost satisfied - how to find the physical state or shape that's the best fit. "It's a new branch of variational calculus," Davidovitch says. "All I need to do is minimize the curvature that nearly eliminates all stretching, and it lets me find the one with the smallest possible bending energy."

They propose a new principle, the Gauss-Euler elastica, that reconciles the two cornerstones of classical mechanics and geometry defined previously by the works of Euler and Gauss. They invoke a new regime of solutions of the complex morphologies of thin bodies, a problem of intense recent interest from biophysics and materials engineering to applied mathematics, Grason points out.

He recalls, "When we first started this line of research, we didn't imagine how it would turn out. We were not trying to solve this problem." But doctoral student Sun, running some computer simulations, came up with results that defied naïve assumptions that confinement requires more energy to stretch than to bend the sheet. Formulas that he and Grason proposed were "impossible," Davidovitch says, "they appeared to be violating fundamental geometrical theorems."

They were stuck for two years, until they remembered Galileo's beam, what Davidovitch calls a "thought contradiction," that re-framed the question. It has been "very satisfying" to bring a new conceptual tool to the problem that wasn't available before, he says. Grason adds, "It's great to have an answer to why our initial simulations behaved so weirdly, of course. But eventually it leads us to understand the question better, and how it addresses a much broader class of problems in a new way. Yes, this has a good feeling."

-end-

University of Massachusetts at Amherst

**Related Geometry Articles:**

Mathematicians deliver formal proof of Kepler Conjecture

A mathematical problem more than 300 years old gets a formal proof with the help of computer formal verification.

A mathematical problem more than 300 years old gets a formal proof with the help of computer formal verification.

New study describes how surface texture can help or hinder formation of ice crystals

A new study examining how ice forms from pure water found that the geometry of the surface that water is on can have an effect on whether or not it freezes, suggesting that surface geometry plays an important role in ice formation.

A new study examining how ice forms from pure water found that the geometry of the surface that water is on can have an effect on whether or not it freezes, suggesting that surface geometry plays an important role in ice formation.

Self-assembled nanostructures can be selectively controlled

Plasmonic nanoparticles exhibit properties based on their geometries and relative positions.

Plasmonic nanoparticles exhibit properties based on their geometries and relative positions.

A tale of two pulsars' tails: Plumes offer geometry lessons to astronomers

Like cosmic lighthouses sweeping the universe with bursts of energy, pulsars have fascinated and baffled astronomers since they were first discovered 50 years ago.

Like cosmic lighthouses sweeping the universe with bursts of energy, pulsars have fascinated and baffled astronomers since they were first discovered 50 years ago.

David H. Yang to receive 2017 AMS-MAA-SIAM Morgan Prize

David H. Yang, a senior at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, is the recipient of the 2017 AMS-MAA-SIAM Frank and Brennie Morgan Prize for Outstanding Research in Mathematics by an Undergraduate Student.

David H. Yang, a senior at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, is the recipient of the 2017 AMS-MAA-SIAM Frank and Brennie Morgan Prize for Outstanding Research in Mathematics by an Undergraduate Student.

Dusa McDuff and Dietmar Salamon to receive 2017 AMS Steele Prize for Exposition

Dusa McDuff and Dietmar Salamon will receive the 2017 AMS Leroy P.

Dusa McDuff and Dietmar Salamon will receive the 2017 AMS Leroy P.

Leon Simon to receive 2017 AMS Steele Prize for seminal contribution to research

Leon Simon of Stanford University will receive the 2017 AMS Leroy P.

Leon Simon of Stanford University will receive the 2017 AMS Leroy P.

Application of the mathematics of harmony -- Golden non-Euclidean geometry in modern math

A masterful exploration of history and the essence of mathematical reasoning to the future development of modern science and mathematics.

A masterful exploration of history and the essence of mathematical reasoning to the future development of modern science and mathematics.

New theory -- embryo geometry -- proposes explanation for how vertebrates evolved

A new theory aims to explain how the complex vertebrate body, with its skeleton, muscles, nervous and cardiovascular systems, arises from a single cell during development and how these systems evolved over time.

A new theory aims to explain how the complex vertebrate body, with its skeleton, muscles, nervous and cardiovascular systems, arises from a single cell during development and how these systems evolved over time.

A collection of practical algorithms for polynomial inequality proving and discovering

'Automated Inequality Proving and Discovering' is the first book that focuses on practical algorithms for polynomial inequality proving and discovering.

'Automated Inequality Proving and Discovering' is the first book that focuses on practical algorithms for polynomial inequality proving and discovering.

**Related Geometry Reading:**

## Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the**best science podcasts**for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.

**Now Playing: TED Radio Hour**

**Setbacks**

Failure can feel lonely and final. But can we learn from failure, even reframe it, to feel more like a temporary setback? This hour, TED speakers on changing a crushing defeat into a stepping stone. Guests include entrepreneur Leticia Gasca, psychology professor Alison Ledgerwood, astronomer Phil Plait, former professional athlete Charly Haversat, and UPS training manager Jon Bowers.

**Now Playing: Science for the People**

**#524 The Human Network**

What does a network of humans look like and how does it work? How does information spread? How do decisions and opinions spread? What gets distorted as it moves through the network and why? This week we dig into the ins and outs of human networks with Matthew Jackson, Professor of Economics at Stanford University and author of the book "The Human Network: How Your Social Position Determines Your Power, Beliefs, and Behaviours".