Police shootings linked to inaccurate dispatch information

January 21, 2020

A new University of Colorado Denver study examined how information provided in a dispatched call for service influences a police officer's decision to use deadly force.

The findings show a relationship between inaccurate dispatched information about the presence of a weapon and police shooting errors, especially shootings of unarmed subjects.

Paul Taylor, PhD, assistant professor of criminology in the School of Public Affairs at CU Denver, created a simulation for officers armed with laser guns in which they heard recorded dispatch calls and responded by engaging with a big-screen video of the situation. More than 300 active law enforcement officers participated in this randomized controlled experiment.

"Pre-event information about the presence of a weapon before an officer arrives on scene can have an enormous impact on officer decision-making, and consequently their actions," said Taylor. "If the information they receive is incorrect, by even the slightest amount, it can drastically increase the likelihood for an error."

All of the officers listened to a simulated dispatch call for a potential trespass in progress with a description of the subject involved.This is the first study to examine the role of dispatched information in the context of increases in "perception" shooting errors, sometimes called "cellphone shootings," where officers mistakenly believe the subject involved has a weapon (which generally turns out to be a cellphone or other unharmful object).

Officers shot the subject more than twice as often when the dispatch call stated that the subject "appeared to be holding a gun." Taylor attributed this to confirmation bias. In the face of uncertainty and time compression, people tend to cling to their initial interpretation or understanding of an event. They actively seek information that confirms that understanding while ignoring disconfirming information at a subconscious level.

"Others have hypothesized that officers will always err on the side of personal safety, but that is not what this research found," said Taylor. "Instead, officers tended to err on the side of not making an error. When the dispatched information suggested the subject might be armed, they interpreted behavioral cues in that light, but when dispatched information was correct, officer decision-making significantly improved. For these officers, context and pre-event information played a significant role in how they interpreted the subjects' behavior."

We need more time

"Having enough time to evaluate a situation before being forced to make split-second decisions is absolutely critical in these sorts of situations," said Taylor. "Understanding that officers will rely heavily on pre-event information to make decisions and knowing that when that information is incorrect, it will increase the risk of error, is key--it should encourage agencies and officers to use tactics that, when possible and it is not always possible, allow officers more time."

Taylor's hope is that by better understanding these processes we can gain insight into underlying weaknesses found in everyday police practice and search for more effective solutions that increase both the safety of officers and the public they serve.

"These are clues, key pieces to the puzzle, about how to make us more resilient against future errors and, ultimately, save innocent lives," Taylor said.

University of Colorado Denver

Related Cellphone Articles from Brightsurf:

A multishot lensless camera in development could aid disease diagnosis
A new type of imaging that does not require a lens and uses reconfigurable particle-based masks to take multiple shots of an object is being developed by researchers at Penn State.

US cellphone data uncovers 'hotspots' where COVID-19 social distancing levels are low
US cellphone data analysis finds 'hotspots' where COVID-19 social distancing levels are low, as well as revealing how demographics and governmental restrictions interact.

COVID-19, digital technologies, and the future of disease surveillance
Several data-driven epidemiological approaches that have been proposed or trialed for COVID-19 are justified if implemented through transparent processes that involve oversight, write Michelle M.

'Surfing attack' hacks Siri, Google with ultrasonic waves
Using ultrasound waves propagating through a solid surface, researchers at Washington University in St.

Police shootings linked to inaccurate dispatch information
306 law enforcement officers from 18 agencies were involved in a simulation examining impact of dispatch information on an officer's decision to fire their weapon.

Cellphone distraction linked to increase in head injuries
Head and neck injuries incurred while driving or walking with a cellphone are on the rise -- and correlates with the launch of the iPhone in 2007 and release of Pokémon Go in 2016, a Rutgers study found.

New paper-based technology allows reliable, low-cost sensing of iron levels in fortified foods
A team of University of Illinois researchers has developed an affordable, reliable paper-based sensor that works with a cellphone app -- also developed at U of I -- to detect levels of iron in fortified food products.

Need a mental break? Avoid your cellphone, Rutgers researchers say
Using a cellphone to take a break during mentally challenging tasks does not allow the brain to recharge effectively and may result in poorer performance, Rutgers researchers found.

Spinning lightwaves on a one-way street
Researchers at Purdue University have created a quantum spin wave for light.

Penn engineers can detect ultra rare proteins in blood using a cellphone camera
Commercial approaches to ultrasensitive protein detection are starting to become available, but they are based on expensive optics and fluid handlers, which make them relatively bulky and expensive.

Read More: Cellphone News and Cellphone Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.