Research Describes Human Origins Debate Before Darwin

January 23, 1999

ANAHEIM -- Common wisdom holds that Charles Darwin's Origin of Species was the spark that ignited the debate -- often cast as religion versus science -- about human origins. But when Darwin's revolutionary work was first published in 1859, the intellectual and spiritual controversy that colors nearly any discussion of where humans come from was already a two-decade-old phenomenon in the United States.

G. Blair Nelson, a University of Wisconsin-Madison graduate student in the history of science, speaking here this week at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, describes a rich pre-Darwinian tradition of controversy over human origins that included such notions as different races having different origins, and the belief that, if you read the Bible correctly, Adam and Eve were not necessarily the first humans, but the first Jews or Caucasians, leaving the door open for the existence of pre-Biblical humanity.

"There were many different versions of these ideas," said Nelson, and some were used to prop up notions of white supremacy after the Civil War. Others, proto-fundamentalists, for example, used these ideas to reconcile their beliefs with an emerging fossil evidence that suggested a prehistoric, prebiblical lineage for humans.

After the Civil War, Darwin's theory exerted an influence that tended to shut many of these debates down, but some carried over into the early 20th century, said Nelson.

"The point is that American's had been talking about origins for two decades before the Civil War. It was a very important debate" that, in some quarters, was slow to die out after Darwin's seminal idea raised prevailing new theory.

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Related Phenomenon Articles from Brightsurf:

Mysterious molecular phenomenon could boost precision of targeted drug delivery
Scientists have shown how a type of cellular binding could help pave the way for highly targeted therapies against diseases like cancer.

How Steak-umm became a social media phenomenon during the pandemic
A new study outlines how a brand of frozen meat products took social media by storm - and what other brands can learn from the phenomenon.

Microbes living on air a global phenomenon
UNSW researchers have found their previous discovery of bacteria living on air in Antarctica is likely a process that occurs globally, further supporting the potential existence of microbial life on alien planets.

Behind the dead-water phenomenon
What makes ships mysteriously slow down or even stop as they travel, even though their engines are working properly?

Cartwheeling light reveals new optical phenomenon
Researchers at Rice University have discovered details about a novel type of polarized-light matter interaction with light that literally turns end over end as it propagates from a source.

Quantum phenomenon governs organic solar cells
Researchers at Linköping University have discovered a quantum phenomenon that influences the formation of free charges in organic solar cells.

Indian Ocean phenomenon spells climate trouble for Australia
New international research has found a worrying change in the Indian Ocean's surface temperatures that puts southeast Australia on course for increasingly hot and dry conditions.

Paving the way for spintronic RAMs: A deeper look into a powerful spin phenomenon
Scientists at Tokyo Institute of Technology explore a new material combination that sets the stage for magnetic random access memories, which rely on spin -- an intrinsic property of electrons -- and could outperform current storage devices.

Daylight not rain most important for Africa 'green-up' phenomenon
Contrary to popular belief, seasonal rains are not the most important factor for starting the growth cycle of plants across Africa.

Daily rainfall over Sumatra linked to larger atmospheric phenomenon
In a new study led by atmospheric scientist Giuseppe Torri at the University of Hawai'i (UH) at Mānoa School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology (SOEST), researchers revealed details of the connection between a larger atmospheric phenomenon, termed the Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO), and the daily patterns of rainfall in the Maritime Continent.

Read More: Phenomenon News and Phenomenon Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to